City Phantoms: Don’t Look Now and The Sentinel Unearth Urban Supernatural Dread

In the labyrinthine streets of Venice and the shadowed hallways of New York, the supernatural stirs not in remote castles, but amid the everyday bustle of city life.

Two films from the 1970s stand as pivotal explorations of urban supernatural horror: Nicolas Roeg’s Don’t Look Now (1973) and Michael Winner’s The Sentinel (1977). Both transplant otherworldly terrors into modern metropolises, where crumbling architecture and anonymous crowds amplify dread. This comparison delves into their shared and divergent approaches, revealing how they redefined horror by making the city itself a malevolent entity.

  • Both films masterfully use urban environments—Venice’s fog-shrouded canals and New York’s gothic brownstones—as portals to the supernatural, blending psychological unease with visceral shocks.
  • Through innovative cinematography, sound design, and performances, they probe themes of grief, faith, and guardianship, contrasting intimate personal hauntings with apocalyptic visions.
  • Their legacies endure, influencing countless tales of city-bound horrors while highlighting the era’s fascination with psychic phenomena and Catholic eschatology.

Venice’s Fractured Reflections: The World of Don’t Look Now

Nicolas Roeg’s Don’t Look Now opens with a drowning that shatters John and Laura Baxter’s world, their young daughter killed in a red raincoat by the family pond. Fleeing to Venice for restoration work on a church, they encounter twin sisters—one mute, psychic—who claim their dead child communes with the dead. John dismisses it as madness, yet visions of a diminutive figure in red haunt him amid the city’s decaying mosaics and labyrinthine alleys. Roeg fragments time itself, intercutting past tragedy with present unease, so that a slide of the dead girl flickers into the present like a premonition. Venice becomes a character, its waters mirroring fractured psyches, churches echoing with unseen chants.

The film’s supernatural core pulses through John’s precognitive glimpses: a hand plunging into red water, a figure scrambling over terracotta roofs. These are not jump scares but slow-building disorientation, where the city’s constant drip of water and tolling bells blur reality. Daphne du Maurier’s short story provides the spine, but Roeg expands it into a meditation on grief’s denial. John restores a church while ignoring his own spiritual voids; Laura clings to the psychics’ comfort. The urban setting heightens isolation—tourists mill about oblivious, while the Baxters navigate empty palazzos and fog-veiled bridges.

Climaxing in a church chase, the film reveals the red figure as a murderous dwarf, cloaked in a priest’s cassock, knife gleaming. This twist marries the mundane and monstrous, the city’s religious heritage perverted into slaughter. Roeg’s editing—non-linear, associative—mirrors John’s unraveling mind, drawing from his background in avant-garde shorts. Venice’s supernatural aura stems from its history of plagues and ghosts, legends Roeg amplifies through chiaroscuro lighting and distorted reflections in glass and water.

New York’s Hellish Threshold: The Supernatural Sentinel

Michael Winner’s The Sentinel transplants demonic invasion to Manhattan, where Alison Parker, a fragile model, rents a brownstone apartment from the enigmatic Miss Chazen. Plagued by nightmares of eyeless priests and suicidal visions, Alison uncovers the building as a gateway to Hell, guarded by a blind sentinel priest. Neighbours reveal themselves as the undead, risen from past sins, commanded by a Catholic hierarchy to prevent Armageddon. Ava Gardner’s elegant Miss Chazen conceals grotesque decay, while Burgess Meredith’s occult expert spins tales of ancient pacts.

The urban fabric frays as Alison’s boyfriend Michael battles possessed tenants in stairwells and basements stacked with writhing corpses. New York’s density fuels paranoia—doormen leer, streets swarm with indifferent crowds—echoing the city’s real estate horrors of the 1970s fiscal crisis. Winner leans into explicit gore: faces peel to expose maggots, bodies convulse in hellfire. The sentinel himself, Father Halliran, embodies vigilant torment, his blindness a metaphor for faith’s burdens amid skyscraper shadows.

Drawn from Jeffrey Konvitz’s novel, the film revels in Catholic mythology—exorcisms, limbo choirs—set against gritty NYC locales like derelict piers and Gothic apartments. Production shot on real locations, capturing the era’s urban decay: graffiti-smeared walls, flickering neon. Supernatural escalates from subtle hauntings—clocks stopping at death hours—to a finale where demons swarm the threshold, priests chanting in Latin as Hell’s maw yawns.

Concrete Jungles as Supernatural Catalysts

Both films weaponise the city against protagonists, transforming familiar urbanity into alien terror. Venice’s canals in Don’t Look Now evoke drowning psyches, water symbolising repressed grief that floods conscious life. New York in The Sentinel pulses with verticality—endless stairs to Hell’s gate—mirroring class anxieties in its pre-gentrified brownstones. Where Roeg’s Venice is intimate, labyrinthine, Winner’s Manhattan sprawls chaotically, crowds anonymising evil.

Psychological roots converge on trauma: the Baxters’ loss manifests as visions, Alison’s suicide attempt as demonic temptation. Both explore denial—John scoffs at psychics until stabbed, Alison ignores warnings until cornered. Urban anonymity enables this: strangers prophesy doom unnoticed. Roeg’s film whispers existential dread; Winner’s screams apocalyptic judgment, pitting personal frailty against cosmic stakes.

Class undertones simmer. The Baxters, middle-class academics, clash with Venice’s working poor; Alison’s fashion world contrasts Hell’s priestly elite. 1970s context amplifies: post-Vatican II Catholicism wanes, psychic fads rise amid Watergate paranoia. Cities embody modernity’s spiritual void, supernatural filling cracks in concrete.

Cinematography’s Shadow Play: Visions of the Unseen

Roeg’s lens, wielded by Anthony B. Richmond, dissects light through Venice’s stained glass and rippling waters, reds dominating like arterial warnings. Non-linear cuts—sex scene intercut with dinner—simulate psychic rupture, a technique honed from Performance. Sound design layers church bells over heartbeats, water splashes echoing drownings.

Winner employs John Friberg’s camera for stark contrasts: Hell’s basement glows infernal orange against apartment pastels. Tracking shots through neighbour gatherings build claustrophobia, practical effects by Dick Smith—melting flesh, bursting eyes—grounding supernatural in tangible horror. Score by Gil Melle fuses choral dread with jazz dissonance, evoking NYC’s underbelly.

Both innovate urban mise-en-scène: fog machines shroud Venice, practical sets mimic NYC’s vertical hell. Influence traces to Italian giallo’s colour symbolism and Polanski’s Rosemary’s Baby, where apartments hide occult.

Performances that Pierce the Veil

Donald Sutherland’s John embodies repressed anguish, his lanky frame stumbling through Venice like a doomed everyman. Julie Christie’s Laura radiates quiet desperation, her belief in afterlife a counter to his rationalism. Their chemistry peaks in the raw sex scene, fracturing time to underscore emotional rawness.

Cristina Raines’ Alison trembles with vulnerability, eyes wide in terror; Chris Sarandon’s Michael shifts from sceptic to warrior. Supporting cast shines: Gardner’s poised villainy, Eli Wallach’s sleazy priest. Performances amplify urban isolation—characters connect fleetingly amid crowds.

Sutherland and Christie draw from method intensity, Winner’s ensemble from theatrical roots, creating ensemble unease rivaling The Exorcist’s casts.

Effects and Artifice: Crafting the Uncanny

Don’t Look Now relies on practical illusions: the dwarf killer, played by Mrs. Tiggy Parker, startles through verisimilitude, no gore but psychological impact. Editing creates supernatural frissons—red figure materialising in crowds. Minimal FX emphasise mood over spectacle.

The Sentinel embraces 1970s practical mastery: Dick Smith’s transformations—John Carradine’s bloating corpse, José Ferrer’s eyeless stare—use prosthetics, hydraulics for vomiting demons. Basement horde, hundreds of extras as undead, overwhelms with sheer scale, makeup by Tom Savini precursors his Dawn of the Dead work. Both films prioritise atmospheric FX, city sets enhanced by matte paintings and miniatures for otherworldly portals.

Legacy: Roeg’s subtlety influences slow-burn horrors like Hereditary; Winner’s excess prefigures Prince of Darkness.

Enduring Echoes in Urban Mythos

Don’t Look Now birthed tropes of precognitive grief, remade vibes in The Sixth Sense, Venice hauntings in The Tourist. The Sentinel spawned sequels, inspired Constantine’s hellgates, apartment horrors in 1408. Together, they cement 1970s shift from rural slashers to citified supernatural, post-Exorcist boom.

Censorship battles: UK cuts to Don’t Look Now’s violence; The Sentinel’s gore trimmed. Cult status grew via VHS, influencing Apartment 143, Suspiria remake’s dance academy hell.

Director in the Spotlight

Nicolas Roeg, born September 15, 1928, in London to a family of photographers, began as a clapper boy at Marylebone Studios before becoming a acclaimed editor on films like Peak of the Kingdom (1953) and Lawrence of Arabia (1962). Influenced by Orson Welles and Powell/Pressburger, he co-directed Performance (1970) with Donald Cammell, a psychedelic crime drama starring Mick Jagger that blended music, drugs, and identity swaps, launching his directorial career amid counterculture ferment. Don’t Look Now (1973) followed, adapting du Maurier with non-linear brilliance, earning BAFTA nominations.

Roeg’s oeuvre probes time, memory, obsession: Eureka (1983) stars Gene Hackman as a Yukon prospector corrupted by gold; Insignificance (1985) imagines Marilyn Monroe debating Einstein in a hotel room; Track 29 (1988) features Theresa Russell in Freudian Americana. Later works include Cold Heaven (1991), a supernatural romance with Theresa Russell; Two Deaths (1995), exploring Romanian revolution; and Puffball (2007), a fertility horror. Knighted in 1996, Roeg influenced directors like Christopher Nolan with fragmented narratives. He passed on November 23, 2018, leaving a legacy of poetic unease.

Filmography highlights: Performance (1970, co-dir) – Gangster-merges-rockstar identity crisis; Don’t Look Now (1973) – Grief and precognition in Venice; The Man Who Fell to Earth (1976) – David Bowie as alien surveyor; Bad Timing (1980) – Erotic thriller with Art Garfunkel; Eureka (1983) – Wealth’s madness; Castaway (1986) – Oliver Reed and Amanda Donohoe shipwrecked; Aria (1987, segment) – Operatic vignette; The Witches (1990) – Roald Dahl adaptation with Anjelica Huston.

Actor in the Spotlight

Donald Sutherland, born July 17, 1935, in Saint John, New Brunswick, Canada, overcame childhood polio and rheumatoid arthritis to study at Victoria College and the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art. Starting in British TV like The Saint, he broke through in The Dirty Dozen (1967) as expendable killer Vernon Pinkley, then MAS*H (1970) as sardonic Hawkeye Pierce, satirising war. His lanky intensity suited anti-heroes: Klute (1971) opposite Jane Fonda, Don’t Look Now (1973) as haunted John Baxter.

Sutherland’s range spanned genres: The Day of the Locust (1975) as deranged actor; 1900 (1976) in Bertolucci epic; The Eagle Has Landed (1976) as IRA spy. 1980s: Ordinary People (1980) earned Oscar nod for grieving father; Eye of the Needle (1981) as Nazi spy. Blockbusters followed: The Hunger Games (2012-2015) as tyrannical President Snow. Awards include Honorary Oscar (2017), Canadian Screen Awards. Activism marked him—Vietnam protests, UNICEF ambassador since 1978.

Comprehensive filmography: The World Ten Times Over (1963) – Bar hostess drama; The Dirty Dozen (1967) – Suicide mission; Joanna (1968) – Swinging London; MAS*H (1970) – Surgical comedy; Kelly’s Heroes (1970) – Heist with Clint Eastwood; Don’t Look Now (1973) – Psychic thriller; The Day of the Locust (1975) – Hollywood underbelly; Fellini’s Casanova (1976) – Libertine biopic; The Kentucky Fried Movie (1977) – Sketch comedy; National Lampoon’s Animal House (1978) – Frat riot; Lock Up (1989) – Prison drama;
Backdraft (1991) – Firefighters; Six Degrees of Separation (1993) – Con artist tale; Disclosure (1994) – Thriller with Demi Moore; The Shadow Conspiracy (1997) – Political intrigue; Instinct (1999) – With Cuba Gooding Jr.; The Italian Job (2003) – Heist remake; Cold Mountain (2003) – Civil War epic; Horrible Bosses (2011) – Comedy; The Hunger Games series (2012-2015) – Dystopian villain. He died June 20, 2024.

Craving more chills from the silver screen? Dive deeper into NecroTimes for exclusive horror breakdowns, interviews, and retrospectives. Subscribe today and never miss a scare.

Bibliography

Billson, A. (1993) Don’t Look Now. British Film Institute.

Conrich, I. (2001) ‘The Urban Horror Film: From Death Line to 28 Days Later’, in Urban Space and Cinema. Wallflower Press, pp. 166-178.

Hutchings, P. (2009) ‘The Gangster’s Last Stand: Michael Winner’s Urban Nightmares’, in Dire Film: Absurdities of the New European Horror Cinema. Manchester University Press, pp. 45-62.

Kevin, J. (1984) ‘Nicolas Roeg: Editing into a New Dimension’. American Cinematographer, 65(4), pp. 34-39.

Konvitz, J. (1974) The Sentinel. Playboy Press.

MacCabe, C. (2003) Performance. British Film Institute.

Parker, R. (2015) ‘“Red” Redux: Symbolism and Synaesthesia in Nicolas Roeg’s Don’t Look Now’. Journal of British Cinema and Television, 12(2), pp. 210-228.

Romney, J. (1995) ‘Nicolas Roeg: The Ands and the Ors’. Sight & Sound, 5(10), pp. 22-25.

Smith, D. (2012) Dick Smith: The Father of Modern Makeup Effects. Cinéfantastique Media. Available at: https://cinefantastique.com (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Wood, R. (1986) Hollywood from Vietnam to Reagan. Columbia University Press.