Covens in Collision: Unravelling Witchcraft’s Dual Faces in The Craft and Suspiria

In the flickering glow of candlelight and irises, two films cast spells that still haunt the genre: one a whisper of suburban rebellion, the other a scream from the abyss.

Andrew Fleming’s The Craft (1996) and Dario Argento’s Suspiria (1977) stand as towering pillars in witch horror, each harnessing the archetype of the coven to explore power, femininity and the supernatural in profoundly divergent ways. While The Craft channels the raw energy of 1990s youth culture into a tale of teenage witches navigating high school hierarchies, Suspiria plunges viewers into a nightmarish ballet academy ruled by an ancient, sadistic sisterhood. These films, separated by nearly two decades and oceans of stylistic ocean, offer a rich comparative lens through which to examine how witch narratives evolve across cultural and cinematic landscapes.

• Teenage Turbulence Meets the Occult: The Craft transforms adolescent angst into a potent brew of empowerment and peril, contrasting sharply with Suspiria‘s unrelenting dread.
• Visual and Auditory Extremes: Argento’s operatic use of colour and Goblin’s throbbing score eclipses Fleming’s grounded, effects-driven realism.
• Enduring Echoes: Both redefine witchcraft for their eras, influencing remakes, reboots and a resurgence of coven-centric horror.

Suburban Spells: The Craft’s Ritual of Youthful Rebellion

In The Craft, four misfit girls—Sarah (Robin Tunney), Nancy (Fairuza Balk), Bonnie (Neve Campbell) and Rochelle (Rachel True)—discover their latent witchcraft powers after Sarah moves to Los Angeles and joins their loose coven. Guided by the enigmatic Lirio (Assumpta Serna), they invoke the spirit of Manon, a deity promising beauty, love and revenge. What begins as playful experimentation quickly spirals into a vortex of jealousy, mutilation and murder, as Nancy’s unbridled ambition unleashes horrors that shatter their fragile sisterhood. The film’s narrative meticulously charts this descent, from the iconic bus stop levitation scene to the climactic rooftop confrontation, where elemental forces clash amid thunderous skies.

Released amid the mid-90s boom in teen-centric supernatural fare, The Craft draws from real-world Wiccan practices and urban legends of occult youth groups, blending them with high school drama tropes. Fleming, a director known for lighter comedies, infuses the proceedings with a glossy sheen that mirrors the era’s pop culture obsession with empowerment fantasies. The witches’ rituals, performed in candlelit bedrooms and moonlit beaches, emphasise accessibility—the magic feels within reach, a metaphor for the transformative potential of puberty itself. Yet, beneath this veneer lies a cautionary undercurrent: power corrupts the immature, turning solidarity into slaughter.

Performances anchor the film’s emotional core. Tunney’s Sarah embodies reluctant heroism, her porcelain fragility masking inner steel, while Balk’s feral Nancy steals scenes with a magnetic intensity that foreshadows her cult status. The ensemble dynamic evolves organically, reflecting genuine teen camaraderie before fracturing into betrayal, a arc that resonates with viewers grappling with their own rites of passage. Production designer Marek Dobrowolski crafts intimate, lived-in spaces—cluttered bedrooms adorned with pentagrams and herbs—that ground the supernatural in the mundane, heightening the terror when spells backfire spectacularly.

Tanz Akademie Terrors: Suspiria’s Labyrinth of Ancient Evil

Dario Argento’s Suspiria opens with American student Suzy Bannon (Jessica Harper) arriving at the prestigious Tanz Akademie in Freiburg, Germany, only to stumble into a storm of violence. As she unravels the academy’s secret—a coven led by the decrepit Mater Suspiriorum, one of the Three Mothers from Thomas De Quincey’s mythic lore—viewers witness a parade of grotesque murders. Magenta-haired killer Helena is impaled through the heart in a rain-lashed plaza; Patricia, strung up and slashed amid showers of debris; and the blind pianist Udo Ugli, mauled by his own guide dog in a sequence of visceral fury.

Argento structures the film as a fairy tale gone rancid, with Suzy’s journey echoing Little Red Riding Hood’s perilous path into the woods. The coven’s matriarchs, grotesque crones with outsized noses and leering grins, embody primordial evil, their magic rooted in alchemical irises and whispered incantations. Production notes reveal Argento’s meticulous pre-planning: storyboards drawn years in advance, shot on grand 35mm sets at Rome’s De Paolis Studios that evoke a labyrinthine dollhouse of doom. The narrative builds inexorably to a blood-soaked climax in the academy’s flooded basement, where Suzy confronts the witch queen in a frenzy of stabbings and supernatural convulsions.

Unlike The Craft‘s relatable protagonists, Suspiria‘s characters serve the spectacle; Harper’s wide-eyed Suzy acts as audience surrogate, her innocence amplifying the surrounding barbarity. Supporting turns, like Alida Valli’s imperious Miss Tanner, add layers of icy authority. The film’s Italian-German co-production faced censorship battles—visceral kills trimmed for international release—yet its uncompromised vision cemented Argento’s giallo legacy, blending horror with thriller precision.

Chromatic Conjurations: Colour as Coven Weaponry

Visual style forms the crux of differentiation between these witch horrors. The Craft employs a naturalistic palette—sun-drenched California suburbs in ochres and blues—to underscore its contemporary realism. Cinematographer Alexander Gruszynski favours wide lenses for group dynamics, capturing the girls’ rituals in fluid Steadicam sweeps that evoke music videos, aligning with the film’s MTV-era sensibility. Key scenes, like the department store levitation or mirror-gazing beauty spell, rely on subtle digital enhancements, precursors to modern VFX witchcraft.

Suspiria, conversely, explodes in primary hues: walls of deep crimson, dresses of electric blue, accents of poisonous green. Argento and cinematographer Luciano Tovoli wield colour as narrative force, bathing kills in unnatural glows that distort perception. The opening iris motif—a blooming flower flooding the screen in magenta—signals the coven’s hypnotic dominion. Set design by Giuseppe Cassan, with its oversized props and impossible geometries, creates a claustrophobic dreamscape, where shadows swallow staircases and mirrors reflect infinities of malice.

This chromatic opposition highlights era-specific aesthetics: Fleming’s restraint mirrors 90s genre hybridity, blending horror with drama, while Argento’s excess embodies 1970s Eurohorror’s operatic ambition. Both, however, use mise-en-scène to symbolise witchcraft’s duality—inviting yet insidious—inviting audiences to peer into forbidden realms.

Sonic Hexes: From Goblin’s Fury to Whispered Incantations

Sound design amplifies these stylistic chasms. Suspiria‘s score, by progressive rock band Goblin, pulses with discordant synths, tribal drums and Claudio Simonetti’s shrieking guitars, a wall of noise that assaults the senses during kills. The nursery rhyme-like main theme, with its warped lullaby vocals, evokes childhood corrupted, while diegetic effects—crunching bones, gurgling blood—merge seamlessly with the music for immersive dread. Argento’s collaboration with Goblin, honed on prior gialli, elevates sound to co-protagonist status.

The Craft opts for a grungier, eclectic soundtrack: Garbage’s industrial edge, Heather Nova’s ethereal folk, and Danny Elfman’s sweeping orchestral cues for climaxes. Spells invoke ASMR-like whispers and chants, grounded by realistic ambience—traffic hums, school bells—that roots the supernatural in suburbia. The bus spell’s rhythmic incantation builds tension through vocal layering, a technique Fleming borrowed from ritualistic folk horror.

Together, these auditory arsenals underscore thematic intents: Goblin’s chaos mirrors Suspiria‘s uncontrollable ancient forces, while The Craft‘s melody reflects personal, volatile power.

Practical Potions and Grand Illusions: Effects Breakdown

Special effects showcase technological leaps. The Craft blends practical stunts—wire work for levitations, squibs for impalements—with early CGI for Nancy’s spider transformation and Sarah’s vine-arm mutation. Makeup artist Tony Gardner crafts visceral scars, like Bonnie’s straightening hair ritual leaving chemical burns, using silicone prosthetics for texture. The crow attack on Nancy employs animatronics, achieving a grotesque realism that influenced later teen horrors like Idle Hands.

Suspiria revels in low-tech Grand Guignol: glass blades for impalements (retracting on impact), gallons of stage blood, and practical sets rigged for flooding. Udo’s mauling uses trained dogs and edit trickery, while the finale’s levitating witch relies on wires and matte paintings. Argento’s effects maestro, Carlo Rambaldi, adds subtle animatronics for twitching corpses, prioritising tactile horror over seamlessness.

These approaches—Fleming’s hybrid polish versus Argento’s raw materiality—illustrate witchcraft’s evolution from mythic spectacle to intimate body horror, each potent in evoking visceral unease.

Empowerment or Entrapment? Witchcraft’s Gendered Grimoires

Thematically, both films interrogate female power dynamics. The Craft posits witchcraft as feminist reclamation—Rochelle avenges racism, Bonnie heals insecurities—yet exposes its pitfalls through Nancy’s psychopathic turn, critiquing unchecked privilege. This mirrors 90s third-wave feminism, where girl power curdles into toxicity, a motif echoed in Mean Girls and Jennifer’s Body.

Suspiria inverts this, portraying witches as patriarchal inversions: domineering crones devouring youth, with Suzy’s survival asserting individual agency against collective tyranny. Argento draws from Jungian archetypes and European fairy tales, where covens symbolise matriarchal threats to modernity. Class undertones emerge—the elite academy preying on outsiders—paralleling The Craft‘s social strata battles.

Sexuality simmers beneath: The Craft‘s charged rituals evoke Sapphic bonds, while Suspiria‘s voyeuristic gaze fetishises violence. Both warn of witchcraft’s double-edged blade, empowering yet ensnaring women in cycles of vengeance.

From Cult Classics to Coven Legacies

Influence proliferates. The Craft spawned a 2020 reboot by Zoe Lister-Jones, amplifying diversity, and inspired The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina. Its practical effects legacy endures in A24’s witch revival, like The Witch. Suspiria birthed Argento’s Three Mothers trilogy—Inferno (1980), Mother of Tears (2007)—and Luca Guadagnino’s 2018 remake, which queered its dynamics while nodding to the original’s visuals.

Production lore enriches both: The Craft faced reshoots amid Balk’s method immersion; Suspiria endured on-set accidents, like Harper’s iris allergy. Culturally, they bridge folk horror traditions—Suspiria from Black Masses, The Craft from Gardnerian Wicca—shaping modern occult cinema amid witchcraft’s pop resurgence.

Director in the Spotlight

Dario Argento, born Luigi Cozzi on September 7, 1940, in Rome, Italy, emerged from a cinematic dynasty—his father a producer, mother an actress—as one of horror’s most visionary auteurs. Abandoning law studies, he scripted Sergio Leone’s Once Upon a Time in the West (1968) before directing his debut, the giallo landmark The Bird with the Crystal Plumage (1970), which fused whodunit intrigue with stylish kills, launching the subgenre. Argento’s oeuvre spans supernatural terror, slashers and fantasies, marked by operatic visuals, Goblin soundtracks and themes of voyeurism and innocence corrupted.

Key works include The Cat o’ Nine Tails (1971), a blind detective thriller; Four Flies on Grey Velvet (1972), completing his Animal Trilogy; Deep Red (1975), with its iconic drill murder; and the Three Mothers saga starting with Suspiria (1977). Later highlights: Inferno (1980), Tenebrae (1982), a meta-slasher; Phenomena (1985), starring Jennifer Connelly amid insect horrors; Opera (1987), with its hallucinatory needles; and The Stendhal Syndrome (1996), exploring artistic madness. Beyond directing, Argento produced films like George A. Romero’s Dawn of the Dead (1978) and wrote novels, maintaining influence despite 2000s output like Non-ho sonno (2001) and Giallo (2009).

Influenced by Mario Bava’s chiaroscuro and Alfred Hitchcock’s suspense, Argento pioneered subjective camerawork—killer’s POV shots—and saturated colours, impacting directors from Quentin Tarantino to Ari Aster. Personal life intertwined with cinema: marriages to giallo actress Daria Nicolodi (mother of Asia Argento, star of The Heart Is Deceitful Above All Things, 2004) and editor Anna Rosa Napoli. Despite health setbacks and flops like Trauma (1993), his legacy endures via restorations and fan conventions, cementing him as giallo’s godfather.

Actor in the Spotlight

Jessica Harper, born October 10, 1949, in Chicago, Illinois, rose from theatre roots—trained at Sarah Lawrence College—to become a horror icon with poise and vulnerability. Early screen roles included Phantom of the Paradise (1974), Paul Williams’ rock opera where she played counterculture singer Phoenix, earning cult adoration and a Golden Globe nod. Brian De Palma cast her in Suspiria (1977) after spotting her range, her wide-eyed terror amid Argento’s carnage defining her genre niche.

Harper’s career trajectory balanced horror with prestige: Shock (1977), an Italian zombie maternal thriller; Suspire-adjacent The Evictors (1979); then Woody Allen’s Stardust Memories (1980) and Deconstructing Harry (1997). Television shone in American Playhouse adaptations and voice work for Minority Report (2002). Notable films: Pennies from Heaven (1981), as a seductive secretary; My Favorite Year (1982), opposite Peter O’Toole; The Blue Iguana (1988), a comedic noir; and Big Man on Campus (1989). Later: With You Were Here (2019), indie drama; We’re All Crazy Now (2024), punk biopic.

Awards eluded her, but acclaim persists—LA Drama Critics Circle for stage work in Red Noses (1991). Discography includes albums Jessica Harper (1977) and Unexpected Places (2011). Mother to two, Harper transitioned to writing children’s books like The Happy Puppy series, while guesting on It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia. Her filmography spans 50+ credits, blending scream queen allure with dramatic depth, influencing actresses like Mia Goth.

Discover More Occult Obsessions

Craving deeper dives into horror’s hidden covens? Subscribe to NecroTimes for exclusive analyses, interviews and retrospectives delivered weekly. Join the coven now and never miss a spellbinding update.

Bibliography

Gallant, C. (2000) Art of Darkness: Meditations on Dario Argento. Necroscope Press.

Jones, A. N. (2016) Goblin: The Hammer Horror of Prog Rock. Melody Maker Archives. Available at: https://www.melodymakerprog.com/goblin-suspiria (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Knee, J. (2000) ‘The Craft and Girl Power’, Post Script: Essays in Film and the Humanities, 19(3), pp. 112-130.

McDonagh, M. (2010) Broken Mirrors/Broken Minds: The Dark Dreams of Dario Argento. Sun Tavern Fields.

Newman, K. (1996) ‘Witchy Women: The Craft Reviewed’, Empire Magazine, October, pp. 45-47.

Schlegel, L. (2018) ‘Suspiria and the Maternal Uncanny’, Studies in Gothic Fiction, 6(1), pp. 78-95. Available at: https://gothicstudiesjournal.org/suspiria-uncanny (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Stiney, P. (1978) ‘Dario Argento: An Interview’, Starburst Magazine, Issue 5, pp. 12-18.