Deadly Dividends: 6 Female Serial Killers Who Murdered for Money
In the shadowy annals of true crime, female serial killers are far less common than their male counterparts, comprising only about 10-15% of known cases. Yet among them, a chilling subset stands out: those driven by cold financial gain. These women, often dubbed “black widows,” systematically eliminated spouses, lovers, relatives, or vulnerable tenants to collect insurance payouts, inheritances, or government checks. Their stories reveal a toxic blend of greed, deception, and ruthlessness, preying on trust and love for profit.
From Victorian England’s arsenic-laced households to modern boarding houses masking mass graves, these killers exploited societal roles as caregivers and homemakers to lethal ends. What unites them is not just motive but method—poisons, neglect, or blunt force—allowing them to kill repeatedly without immediate suspicion. This article examines six such cases, detailing their backgrounds, crimes, investigations, and downfalls, while honoring the victims whose lives were cut short by betrayal.
These tales serve as stark reminders of how financial desperation or avarice can erode humanity, leaving trails of bodies and shattered families in their wake.
1. Mary Ann Cotton: The Victorian Arsenic Queen
Mary Ann Cotton, born in 1832 in England, is considered one of history’s first recognized female serial killers. Over two decades, she poisoned at least 21 people, including three husbands, lovers, and 11 of her own children, primarily to secure life insurance payouts and poor relief funds. In an era of widespread poverty, Cotton’s actions were fueled by a relentless need for money to support her lavish tastes.
Early Life and Modus Operandi
Raised in a working-class family, Cotton married at 20 and quickly entered a cycle of matrimony and murder. Her weapon of choice was arsenic, easily obtainable as rat poison and mistaken for natural illness like gastric fever. Symptoms—vomiting, diarrhea, convulsions—mirrored cholera outbreaks, allowing her to kill undetected. After a husband’s death yielded insurance money, she remarried swiftly, repeating the pattern. “I must have money,” she reportedly confessed later, underscoring her motive.
Crimes and Victims
Her tally included husband George Ward, who died in 1866 after naming her beneficiary; subsequent partners and children followed. In 1872, stepson Charles Cotton succumbed, prompting suspicion when a doctor noted inconsistencies. Victims like her daughter Margaret and infant Robert were collateral in her scheme. Families mourned, unaware of the poison in their porridge.
Investigation and Trial
The breakthrough came with Charles’s autopsy revealing arsenic. Exhumed bodies confirmed the pattern. Arrested in 1873, Cotton was tried for Charles’s murder. Despite claiming innocence, she was convicted and hanged on March 24, 1873, at age 40. Her legacy: a cautionary tale immortalized in the folk rhyme “Mary Ann Cotton, she’s dead and she’s rotten.”
2. Belle Gunness: The Norwegian Black Widow of Indiana
Belle Gunness, a Norwegian immigrant active from 1884 to 1908 in the U.S., may have killed up to 40 people, mostly suitors responding to her lonely hearts ads. Posing as a wealthy widow seeking companionship, she lured men to her La Porte, Indiana farm, murdered them for their savings and insurance, and disposed of bodies in hog pens or under the farm.
Background and Deceptive Lure
Arriving in America in 1881, Gunness married twice, with both husbands dying suspiciously—John Gunness in a “accidental” axe fall. She insured everything insurable, from the farm to her children. Ads promised love and fortune, but victims arrived with cash, never to leave.
Crimes and Victims
Andrew Helgelein arrived in 1907 with $3,000; his brother Asle investigated after no word. Bodies unearthed included suitors like Ole Stavig and Peter Lindberg, plus her own children. Dental records and watch fobs identified remains. Her motive: pure greed, amassing thousands.
Investigation, Disappearance, and Legacy
A 1908 farmhouse fire revealed headless female remains, presumed Gunness, but handwriting experts later doubted it—she likely faked her death. No trial, but her crimes exposed immigrant vulnerabilities. Victims’ families sought justice in vain, their losses a grim footnote in American crime history.
3. Nannie Doss: The Giggling Granny
Nannie Doss, known as the “Giggling Granny,” confessed to killing 11 people between 1920 and 1954, including four husbands, a mother-in-law, and her own children and grandchildren. All for insurance money and to escape unhappy marriages, she poisoned with rat poison-laced prunes or coffee.
Life of Dissatisfaction
Born in 1905 in Alabama, Doss endured an abusive childhood and sought romance via magazines. Marriages to Charley Bragg, Frank Harrelson, and others ended in death after policies were cashed. She laughed during questioning, earning her moniker.
Victims and Pattern
Samuel Doss died in 1954 after a Halloween candy treat; autopsy found arsenic. Prior victims like Arlie Lanning (1945) followed suit. Grandchildren were killed to claim benefits. Her calm demeanor delayed suspicion.
Trial and Imprisonment
Confession led to a life sentence in 1955; she died in prison in 1965 at 59. Victims’ relatives grieved quietly, their trust exploited for modest payouts—around $500 per policy.
4. Lyda Southard: The Arsenic Angel of the West
Lyda Southard, active 1918-1920 in Idaho, killed four husbands, a brother-in-law, and her daughter with arsenic for insurance. Dubbed the “Lady Bluebeard,” she targeted isolated men, burning bodies to destroy evidence.
Early Deceptions
Born 1892 in Idaho, married at 17 to Robert Dooley, whom she poisoned in 1918. Remarried quickly as “Anna Eliza,” continuing the cycle with Paul Southard and others.
Crimes Exposed
By 1920, five suspicious deaths prompted investigation. Exhumations confirmed arsenic. Daughter Lorraine died similarly.
Conviction
Convicted of Dooley’s murder in 1921, sentenced to life but paroled in 1941 after 18 years. Died 1958. Victims’ families highlighted insurance fraud’s deadly cost.
5. Judy Buenoano: The Black Widow of Florida
Judy Buenoano killed three men—fiancé, son, husband—1971-1983 for $107,000 in insurance. Methods: arsenic, dynamite, drowning.
Calculated Schemes
Born 1943, married James Buenoano, who “drowned” 1971. Son Michael disabled via arsenic, then drowned 1980. Bobby Joe Morris poisoned 1978.
Detection and Justice
1983 arson attempt on lover failed; traces linked her. Convicted 1984, executed 1998—Florida’s first woman in 150 years. Victims remembered for her betrayal.
6. Dorothea Puente: The Boarding House Butcher
Dorothea Puente ran a Sacramento boarding house 1980s, killing nine elderly tenants for their Social Security checks, totaling thousands monthly.
Facade of Care
Born 1929, convicted thief turned caregiver. Tenants vanished; she forged signatures, spent checks on luxuries.
Gruesome Discovery
1988 missing reports led to yard digs: seven bodies with traces of drugs. Convicted 1993 of three murders, life sentence. Died 2011. Victims’ dignity stolen twice.
Conclusion
These six women—Cotton, Gunness, Doss, Southard, Buenoano, and Puente—embody greed’s lethal extreme, claiming dozens of lives for financial windfalls. Their stories, from arsenic eras to modern frauds, expose vulnerabilities in trust and systems. While justice prevailed in most cases, the enduring pain for victims’ families underscores prevention’s urgency: vigilance against patterns of “accidental” deaths tied to money. True crime reminds us: the deadliest motives often hide in plain sight.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289