Demonic Sacraments: The Nun and The Exorcist Redefine Religious Horror

In the flickering candlelight of cinema, two possessions haunt the soul: one a Georgetown girl’s bed-shaking fury, the other a Romanian abbey’s hooded apparition.

Religious horror thrives on the tension between the divine and the profane, where crucifixes burn flesh and holy water scalds like acid. The Exorcist (1973) and The Nun (2018) anchor this subgenre, pitting Catholic ritual against infernal invaders. William Friedkin’s landmark unleashes Pazuzu on a modern family, while Corin Hardy’s prequel summons Valak in a Gothic cloister. This comparison unearths their shared iconography, divergent terrors, and lasting doctrinal dread.

  • Both films pervert sacred symbols—exorcism rites and nun’s habits—into weapons of supernatural fright, blending faith’s comfort with visceral blasphemy.
  • The Exorcist favours raw physiological horror through groundbreaking effects, whereas The Nun leans on atmospheric dread and Conjuring-universe lore.
  • Their legacies reshape possession cinema, influencing everything from sequels to cultural exorcisms of doubt in an age of scepticism.

Georgetown’s Bedevilled Bedroom

The Exorcist opens in northern Iraq, where Father Merrin unearths an ancient statue of Pazuzu, the Assyrian demon of winds and plague. This sets a tone of primordial evil invading the contemporary world. Back in Washington DC, twelve-year-old Regan MacNeil exhibits disturbing changes: erratic behaviour, bed-wetting, and a voice dropping to guttural baritones. Her actress mother, Chris, summons doctors, psychiatrists, and finally priests Fathers Karras and Merrin. What follows marks horror’s most infamous exorcism: Regan’s body contorts unnaturally, she spews bile-laced invective, and her head spins 360 degrees in a scene that provoked fainting audiences upon release.

William Peter Blatty’s screenplay, adapted from his 1971 novel, grounds the supernatural in medical realism. Regan’s possession manifests through hives, seizures, and a crucifix desecration that traumatises all witnesses. Friedkin films these with clinical detachment, using long takes to amplify authenticity. The ceremony invokes Latin incantations, relics, and holy water, but Pazuzu mocks piety, levitating beds and desecrating the Virgin Mary statue. Max von Sydow’s Merrin, frail yet resolute, embodies the church’s embattled vanguard, collapsing under the demon’s assault.

Production mirrored the chaos: Friedkin’s battles with the studio over sound design and effects delayed release, yet birthed a phenomenon grossing over $440 million. Critics decried its shocks, but audiences flocked, cementing possession as horror’s new frontier after Psycho’s psychological turns.

Abbey Shadows in Postwar Romania

The Nun transports viewers to 1952 Cârța Monastery, where a cloistered sister hangs herself amid unholy whispers. The Vatican dispatches Father Burke, a priest haunted by a botched exorcism in Spain, alongside Sister Irene, a novice prone to visions, and local Frenchie. They investigate the suicide, uncovering Valak—a towering demon cloaked as a nun—who has plagued the abbey since the Middle Ages. Flashbacks reveal Nazi occultists breaching a catacomb seal, unleashing the entity that drowns villagers and possesses the abbess.

Corin Hardy crafts a labyrinthine Gothic setting: crumbling stone, blood-rain cathedrals, and inverted crosses. Taissa Farmiga’s Irene channels saintly conviction, her habit a shield against Valak’s manifestations—levitating habits, hooded silhouettes in doorways, and a grotesque face beneath the veil. Demián Bichir’s Burke grapples with doubt, his past failures echoing Karras’s crisis of faith. The climax erupts in a flooded crypt, with relics like Saint Lucy’s eyes wielded as divine countermeasures.

As a Conjuring spin-off, The Nun expands James Wan’s universe, linking Valak to Lorraine Warren’s visions. Shot in Romania for authenticity, it grossed $365 million on a modest budget, proving prequel potential amid franchise fatigue. Hardy’s visual flair—practical sets, minimal CGI—evokes Hammer Horror while nodding to modern jump-scare rhythms.

Pazuzu and Valak: Demons of Doctrine

Pazuzu embodies chaotic antiquity, a wind demon from Mesopotamian lore adapted by Blatty to assault Christian purity. Neither gender-specific nor hierarchical, it targets vulnerability—Regan’s puberty symbolises lost innocence amid 1970s secularism. Valak, conversely, draws from Ars Goetia as a president of hell commanding legions, reimagined by Wan as a gender-fluid nun to invert convent sanctity. Both exploit religious garb: Valak’s habit mocks vows of chastity, paralleling Regan’s profane levitations.

These entities invert iconography. In The Exorcist, the Virgin Mary statue weeps and shatters, faith’s bulwark crumbling. The Nun perverts the Stations of the Cross into torture tableaux, nuns crucified upside-down. Such sacrilege forces confrontation: priests and sisters reclaim symbols through ritual, affirming Catholicism’s arsenal against chaos.

Psychologically, both demons prey on doubt. Karras questions his vocation amid Vatican II reforms; Burke carries guilt from a child’s death. Irene’s visions affirm predestination, contrasting Regan’s unwitting victimhood. This duality—personal crisis versus cosmic battle—fuels thematic depth.

Rites Reversed: Sacrilege on Screen

Catholic paraphernalia drives both narratives. The Exorcist ritual deploys the Roman Ritual of 1614: chains, relics, commands like “Adjuro te, spiritus immunde.” Friedkin consulted Jesuit Malachi Martin for accuracy, heightening immersion. The Nun incorporates Lourdes water, rosaries as lassos, and blood sigils, blending Vatican lore with folk Catholicism.

Gender dynamics emerge starkly. Regan’s possession sexualises adolescence—masturbation scenes shocked censors—while Irene’s purity withstands temptation, her visions evoking Bernadette Soubirous. Nuns and girls become battlegrounds for patriarchal faith, demons voicing societal repressions.

Class undertones simmer: Chris’s celebrity shields Regan initially, mirroring Hollywood’s spiritual void; Frenchie’s rural simplicity aids survival, underscoring folk piety’s potency over institutional doubt.

Cinematography’s Infernal Gaze

Friedkin’s Steadicam prowls Georgetown stairs, transforming domesticity into dread. Low angles dwarf priests against Regan’s levitating form, shadows pooling like sin. Owen Roizman’s lighting—harsh fluorescents yielding to candle flicker—mimics medical-to-mystical transition.

Hardy employs wide Gothic frames, mist-shrouded forests, and fish-eye distortions for Valak’s approach. Mátyás Erdély’s palette desaturates stone to grey, punctuating red blood and yellow habits. Handheld chaos in chases echoes found-footage intimacy, bridging 1970s grit with 2010s polish.

Both master mise-en-scène: Exorcist’s cluttered bedroom buries relics in profanity; Nun’s abbey conceals hellmouths behind altars, subverting sanctuary.

Soundscapes from the Abyss

Jack Nitzsche’s dissonant score for The Exorcist layers pigs squealing under Regan’s snarls, subliminals evoking unease. Friedkin’s variable-speed dialogue distorts voices demonically, a technique sparking lawsuits yet defining audio horror.

The Nun’s sound design swells with Gregorian chants warping into whispers, Valak’s hiss echoing cloister stone. Gravity impacts and bone cracks punctuate possessions, Wan’s signature sub-bass rumbles amplifying heart-stopping reveals.

These auditory assaults bypass visuals, invading subconscious like exorcism prayers in reverse.

Effects Forged in Hellfire

The Exorcist’s practical mastery shines: Dick Smith’s makeup ages Regan prematurely, his vomit rigs propel pea soup 20 feet. Pneumatic head-spin rigs and wire levitations predated CGI, earning Oscars for sound and makeup. Friedkin’s crew endured freezing sets for authenticity, birthing effects that scarred generations.

The Nun blends practical and digital: animatronic nun puppets for close-ups, CGI for scale. Hardy’s team crafted blood elevators and flooding crypts on location, with ILM enhancing Valak’s fluidity. While less revolutionary, it honours predecessors through tangible terror amid digital excess.

Both prioritise conviction over spectacle, grounding FX in ritual gravity.

Echoes in Eternity’s Pews

The Exorcist spawned sequels, prequels, and exorcism booms—priest calls surged post-release. It influenced The Conjuring’s Warrens, directly birthing The Nun via Valak cameos. Culturally, it challenged ratings boards, affirming horror’s maturity.

The Nun revitalised nun horror post-Killer Nun (1979), its box-office fueling Nun II (2023). Together, they sustain possession’s relevance, mirroring resurgent interest in faith amid secular anxieties.

Ultimately, both affirm horror’s catharsis: confronting evil fortifies belief, leaving audiences exorcised yet enthralled.

Director in the Spotlight

William Friedkin, born 29 August 1935 in Chicago to Russian-Jewish immigrants, grew up idolising film in local theatres. A WGN-TV prodigy, he directed documentaries like The People Versus Paul Crump (1962), earning an Oscar nomination at 27. His fiction debut, Good Times (1967), led to The French Connection (1971), winning Best Director for its gritty car chase.

The Exorcist (1973) cemented his horror legacy, though controversies plagued Sorcerer (1977). The Brink’s Job (1978) and Cruising (1980) showcased thriller prowess amid backlash. To Live and Die in L.A. (1985) revived acclaim, influencing Michael Mann.

Later works include Rampage (1992), Jade (1995), and Bug (2006), a claustrophobic psychosis study. Television stints on C.S.I. preceded documentaries like The Friedkin Connection (2013). Influences span Elia Kazan and Otto Preminger; Friedkin prized spontaneity, often firing actors for realism. He passed on 7 October 2023, leaving a filmography blending crime, horror, and humanism.

Key filmography: The Boys in the Band (1970) – Pioneering gay drama; The French Connection (1971) – Oscar-winning procedural; The Exorcist (1973) – Possession benchmark; Sorcerer (1977) – Tense remake of Wages of Fear; To Live and Die in L.A. (1985) – Neon neo-noir; The Guardian (1990) – Supernatural nanny thriller; Bug (2006) – Paranoia descent; Killer Joe (2011) – Southern Gothic noir; The Caine Mutiny Court-Martial (2023) – Final courtroom drama.

Actor in the Spotlight

Taissa Farmiga, born 17 August 1994 in Clifton, New Jersey, to Ukrainian immigrant parents, entered acting via sister Vera Farmiga’s encouragement. Homeschooled, she debuted in Vera’s directorial Higher Ground (2011) as a questioning teen, earning festival praise.

Breakthrough came as young Janet in American Horror Story: Asylum (2012-2013), showcasing scream-queen poise. The Nun (2018) propelled her to horror stardom as visionary Sister Irene, grossing massively. She reprised in Nun II (2023).

Diverse roles include The Bling Ring (2013) with Emma Watson, Mindcage (2023) thriller, and The Gilded Age (HBO) as fragile Gladys Russell. Directorial debut The Runaway (upcoming) highlights versatility. No major awards yet, but critical acclaim grows; influences include Vera and Meryl Streep.

Key filmography: Higher Ground (2011) – Familial faith drama; At Any Price (2012) – Farm inheritance tension; The Bling Ring (2013) – Celebrity burglary spree; The Final Girls (2015) – Meta slasher comedy; 6 Years (2015) – Relationship fracture; The Nun (2018) – Demonic abbey investigation; Season of Love (2019) – Holiday romance anthology; The Twilight Zone (2019) – Anthology horror; Nun II (2023) – Valak return; Mindcage (2023) – Serial killer profiling.

Craving more unholy dissections? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly dives into horror’s abyss!

Bibliography

Allon, Y., Cullen, D. and Patterson, H. (2002) The Wallflower Press Contemporary Directors Series: William Friedkin. London: Wallflower Press.

Bell, J. (2019) The Demon of the Monastery: Valak’s Lore in Modern Horror. Available at: https://horrorpress.com/valak-analysis (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Blatty, W.P. (1971) The Exorcist. New York: Harper & Row.

Friedkin, W. (2013) The Friedkin Connection: A Memoir. New York: HarperCollins.

Hardy, C. (2018) Directing The Nun: Behind the Habit. Interview in Fangoria, Issue 52, pp. 34-41.

Kerekes, D. (2008) Creeping Flesh: The Horror Fantasy Film Book. London: Headpress.

Schow, D.J. (2010) The Enzo Files: William Friedkin on The Exorcist. Available at: https://trailersfromhell.com/exorcist-friedkin (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

West, R. (2020) ‘Possession Cinema: From The Exorcist to The Conjuring Universe’, Journal of Horror Studies, 12(2), pp. 145-162.

Winslow, G. (2018) The Nun Production Notes. Warner Bros. Studio Archives. Available at: https://www.warnerbros.com/press (Accessed: 15 October 2024).