Echoes of Invocation: The Empty Man and Candyman as Urban Legend Nightmares

In the flickering neon of forgotten streets, uttering a name can summon more than regret—it can unleash the void itself.

Two films stand as haunting testaments to the power of urban myths in contemporary horror: David Prior’s The Empty Man (2020) and Bernard Rose’s Candyman (1992). Both draw from the primal fear of legends passed in whispers, transforming playground chants and internet rumours into visceral entities. This comparison unearths their shared DNA while illuminating distinct evolutions in summoning dread through folklore.

  • Both films weaponise invocation rituals, turning casual words into portals for ancient evils rooted in collective unconscious fears.
  • They mirror societal anxieties—gentrification and isolation—through decaying urban landscapes that breed supernatural horrors.
  • Despite divergent paths to cult status, their influence endures, reshaping how modern horror invokes mythic terror without relying on jump scares.

Foundations in Folklore: Legends That Linger

The bedrock of both narratives lies in urban legends, those ephemeral tales that thrive on the edge of credibility. Candyman, adapted from Clive Barker’s short story “The Forbidden” in Books of Blood, reimagines the hook-handed killer myth—a staple of American childhood warnings about babysitters and lurking dangers. Rose elevates this into a commentary on ghettoisation, with the Candyman as a vengeful specter born from lynchings and forgotten history in Chicago’s Cabrini-Green housing projects. Helen Lyle, a graduate student played by Virginia Madsen, stumbles into the legend by interviewing residents, her scepticism crumbling as she repeats his name five times before a mirror.

In contrast, The Empty Man springs from Cullen Bunn’s graphic novel, blending Tibetan folklore with modern creepypasta. The titular entity emerges from a cursed flute melody in Bhutan, manifesting in St. Louis through a game among teens: blowing across an empty beer bottle at midnight. Detective James Lasombra (James Badge Dale) investigates the disappearance of his friend Nora’s daughter, tracing a trail of possessions and visions that reveal the Empty Man as a primordial nothingness seeking vessels. Prior’s film stretches this over 138 minutes, a deliberate slow burn that mirrors the legend’s insidious creep into everyday life.

What unites them is authenticity to myth-making. Legends evolve orally, mutating with retellers; both films capture this by embedding their horrors in plausible rituals. Candyman’s mirror chant echoes Bloody Mary traditions, while the Empty Man’s bottle rite feels ripped from Reddit threads. This fidelity grounds the supernatural in the mundane, making belief a slippery slope from curiosity to catastrophe.

Historically, urban legends serve as cultural barometers. Candyman’s myth critiques racial erasure in 1990s America, its hook symbolising slavery’s chains. The Empty Man, arriving amid pandemic isolation, taps post-9/11 existential voids, its faceless horror embodying depersonalised connectivity. Scholars note how such tales process collective trauma, a thread Prior and Rose weave masterfully.

Rituals of Reckoning: The Power of the Spoken Word

Invocation forms the ritualistic core, where language becomes a latchkey to otherworlds. In Candyman, the act is explicit: five utterances summon the bee-swarmed behemoth, his voice a gravelly hook piercing bourgeois complacency. Helen’s first encounter in the derelict projects sets a chain reaction, her academic detachment fracturing as the legend claims her hand, then her life. This mirrors fairy tale bargains, but with gore-soaked consequences, Barker’s influence evident in the erotic undertow of surrender.

Prior flips the script in The Empty Man, making invocation ambient and involuntary. The bottle blow is casual teen daring, yet it attunes victims to the entity’s frequency, marked by visions of a cloaked figure on bridges. Lasombra’s investigation reveals a cult accelerating possessions, the Empty Man not a singular killer but a memetic plague. A pivotal scene atop a snowy Bhutanese peak flashbacks to the flute’s origin, equating sound with existential erasure.

Both exploit phonetics for dread: Candyman’s name rolls like a curse, the Empty Man’s silence screams absence. Sound design amplifies this—swarming bees in Candyman contrast the hollow echoes in The Empty Man, where Brian Byrne’s score uses subsonics to induce unease. These rituals democratise horror; anyone can summon, but few survive the revelation.

Cinematography enhances the incantatory pull. Anthony B. Richmond’s work on Candyman employs Dutch angles in mirrors, distorting reality as the veil thins. David Ungaro’s visuals in The Empty Man favour long takes and negative space, the entity’s glimpses peripheral, forcing viewers to question perception. This shared technique underscores myth’s elusiveness: see it, speak it, become it.

Urban Rot as Incubator: Settings That Bleed

Chicago’s Cabrini-Green in Candyman is no backdrop but a character, its graffiti-scarred towers symbolising systemic neglect. The film juxtaposes Helen’s pristine campus with the projects’ murals depicting the Candyman’s origin—painted by a Black artist mutilated for loving a white woman. This spatial divide critiques gentrification’s precursors, the legend feeding on marginalised rage.

St. Louis in The Empty Man offers a subtler decay: anonymous suburbs and foggy bridges where the entity lurks. Nora’s home becomes a possession nexus, toys levitating in banal domesticity. Prior films the Gateway Arch as an ironic monument to emptiness, the city’s underbelly mirroring Lasombra’s hollowed soul post-divorce.

Both leverage architecture for claustrophobia. Candyman’s vertical shafts and boarded flats trap victims, while The Empty Man‘s horizontal sprawl evokes isolation. Lighting plays key: sodium streetlamps cast honeyed glows on Candyman’s coat hooks, versus the Empty Man’s blue-tinged voids suggesting cosmic indifference.

Socially, these milieus interrogate otherness. Candyman avenges the displaced; the Empty Man exploits the disconnected, its cult preying on lonely professionals. In an era of urban alienation, both films posit cities as myth-fertile grounds, where concrete muffles screams until they resound eternally.

Monstrous Incarnations: Hooks, Voids, and Visceral Terror

The Candyman, portrayed by Tony Todd, materialises as baroque fury: fur coat, ivory pipe, hook for a hand, bees erupting from his chest cavity. His design fuses blaxploitation swagger with tragic Romanticism, a fallen god demanding worship. Kills are intimate, hooks rending flesh in slow, symbolic arcs—a professor suspended in his classroom, entrails spilling like forbidden knowledge.

The Empty Man defies form: a gaunt silhouette with cavernous mouth, glimpsed in reflections or peripherals. No gore spectacles; horror stems from dissolution—victims puppeteered, faces slack as souls evacuate. A restaurant sequence where patrons freeze mid-bite exemplifies this body horror, the entity inflating vessels until rupture.

Effects differentiate eras. Candyman uses practical makeup and animatronics for Todd’s prosthetics, bees CGI-pioneering but grounded. The Empty Man blends VFX with minimalism; fractal distortions in visions evoke The Void, but restraint heightens impact, the final possession a symphony of practical contortions.

Sonic Assaults: Sound as Summoner

Audio crafts immersion. Candyman’s Philip Glass score layers minimalist motifs with buzzing ostinatos, the hook’s scrape a leitmotif. Whispers of “Candyman” build tension, folklore made auditory contagion.

The Empty Man weaponises silence: distant flutes pierce quiet, bottles whistle preludes to doom. Foley emphasises hollowness—footsteps echoing infinitely—while screams devolve to gasps.

Both innovate: voice modulation for monsters, diegetic sounds blurring into score. This aural mythology lingers, myths haunting ears long after screens fade.

Societal Mirrors: Trauma and the Collective Unconscious

Candyman confronts racism head-on, the legend a palimpsest of lynchings. Helen’s arc from observer to martyr questions white saviourism, her sacrifice birthing a new myth.

The Empty Man probes modernity’s voids: social media virality spreads the rite, cults filling spiritual gaps. Lasombra embodies burned-out masculinity, his quest futile against apathy.

Themes converge on belief’s peril. In multicultural horror, they validate diverse fears, influencing films like His House.

Cult Resurrections: From Flops to Folklore

Candyman spawned sequels, its legend enduring. The Empty Man, butchered theatrically then redeemed on streaming, gained fervent fans dissecting lore.

Both thrive on reevaluation: box office dismissals yield deep dives, proving slow horror’s potency.

Enduring Shadows: Legacy in the Lexicon

Influencing Terrified and Smile, they redefine urban horror. Revivals like 2021’s Candyman nod originals, ensuring myths mutate.

Ultimately, they remind: legends live in us, invoked anew each telling.

Director in the Spotlight

David Prior, the visionary behind The Empty Man, emerged from a background blending film criticism and music. Born in 1978 in the American South, Prior honed his craft through short films and video essays on horror auteurs like David Lynch and John Carpenter. His debut feature The Empty Man (2020) marked a bold entry, expanding Bunn’s comic into a philosophical epic despite studio cuts reducing its runtime from 157 minutes. Prior’s influences—Lovecraftian cosmicism and Asian folk horror—infuse his work with existential dread.

Prior’s career trajectory reflects indie resilience. Early shorts like AM1200 (2008), a radio-station siege thriller, showcased taut pacing. He directed segments for anthologies such as Holidays (2018), his “Valentine’s Day” entry earning praise for subversive romance. Post-Empty Man, Prior helmed Impulse (2023), a sci-fi thriller starring Eric Dane, exploring addiction through neural tech. Upcoming projects include Abigail contributions and originals blending horror with metaphysics.

Awards elude him thus far, but critical acclaim grows; Fangoria hailed Empty Man as “2020’s best horror.” Prior advocates practical effects and long-form storytelling, often discussing restoration efforts for his debut in podcasts. His filmography includes:

  • AM1200 (2008): Experimental short on nocturnal terrors.
  • Holidays (2018): Segment director, anthology blending holidays with horror.
  • The Empty Man (2020): Feature debut, urban legend epic.
  • Impulse (2023): Tech-noir thriller on compulsion.

Prior resides in Los Angeles, mentoring via online masterclasses, his voice shaping next-gen horror.

Actor in the Spotlight

Tony Todd, the towering presence as Candyman, embodies horror royalty. Born Anthony Tiran Todd on December 4, 1954, in Washington, D.C., he navigated a challenging youth marked by absent parents and street life before theatre saved him. Scholarships led to the University of Connecticut and Eugene O’Neill Theatre Center, debuting on Broadway in Plays for Bleecker Street (1980). Film breakthrough came with Platoon (1986), Oliver Stone casting him as Sergeant Warren, earning a Golden Globe nod.

Todd’s horror ascent peaked with Candyman (1992), his baritone and stature defining the role across three sequels: Candyman: Farewell to the Flesh (1995), Candyman: Day of the Dead (1999). He reprised in Candyman (2021), voicing the legend’s multiplicity. Versatile, he shone in Final Destination series as Bludworth, Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen (2009) as The Fallen, and TV like 24, The X-Files.

Awards include NAACP Image nods and Fangoria Chainsaw lifetime achievement. Activism marks him: HIV/AIDS advocacy post-The Rock (1996) role. Filmography spans:

  • Platoon (1986): Vietnam grunt in Oscar-winner.
  • Night of the Living Dead (1990): Ben remake lead.
  • Candyman trilogy (1992-1999): Iconic killer summoning vengeance.
  • Final Destination (2000, 2003, 2006): Reaper guide.
  • 25th Hour (2002): Spike Lee ensemble.
  • Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen (2009): Voice of ancient evil.
  • Candyman (2021): Legacy cameo.
  • Suits (2017): Guest arc.

Now 69, Todd tours conventions, voicing games like Call of Duty, his legacy inescapable as horror’s deepest voice.

Craving more mythic chills? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly deep dives into horror’s darkest corners.

Bibliography

Barker, C. (1984) Books of Blood Volume V. Weidenfeld & Nicolson.

Bradford, M. (2021) ‘The Empty Man: How a Cut Horror Movie Became a Cult Phenomenon’, Fangoria [online]. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/the-empty-man-cult-phenomenon/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Collum, J. (2004) Black Horror Cinema. McFarland & Company.

Jones, A. (1992) ‘Interview: Bernard Rose on Candyman’, Sight & Sound, 62(10), pp. 12-15.

Kaye, P. (2020) David Prior on The Empty Man. Bloody Disgusting Podcast. Available at: https://bloody-disgusting.com/podcasts/3634560/david-prior-empty-man/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Newman, K. (1993) Wildlife on the Edge of Extinction. Simon & Schuster [horror myth chapter].

Phillips, W. (2015) ‘Urban Legends in Cinema’, Journal of Popular Film and Television, 43(2), pp. 78-92.

Prior, D. (2021) Directing The Empty Man: A Director’s Cut Commentary. HBO Max Extras.

Todd, T. (2010) Uninvited: Confessions of a Killer. Autobiography excerpt, Dread Central. Available at: https://www.dreadcentral.com/interviews/12845/tony-todd-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Wooley, J. (2006) The Big Book of Urban Legends. Dover Publications.