Three films, one unrelenting terror: curses that pass from victim to victim, promising doom unless the chain breaks. But can it ever truly end?

In the shadowed corridors of modern horror, few subgenres grip audiences with the icy finality of curse cinema. Films like Smile (2022), It Follows (2014), and The Ring (2002) masterfully exploit our primal fear of the inevitable, crafting narratives where malevolent forces latch on and refuse to let go. This comparative analysis peels back the layers of these masterpieces, examining their shared DNA while celebrating their unique horrors.

  • How each film’s curse mechanics innovate on the ancient folklore of inescapable doom, from videotapes to grins and spectral stalkers.
  • The psychological toll on protagonists, blending trauma, sexuality, and technology into visceral dread.
  • Their lasting influence on horror, redefining slow-burn tension and visual terror for a new generation.

Eternal Hauntings: Unpacking Curse Cinema in Smile, It Follows, and The Ring

The Curse Awakens: Origins and Transmission

The curse in The Ring, directed by Gore Verbinski, ignites with a simple act of voyeurism: watching a cursed videotape that promises death in seven days unless the viewer copies and shares it. Rooted in Japanese folklore via Hideo Nakata’s 1998 Ringu, Gore Verbinski’s American adaptation transforms Sadako’s vengeful spirit into Samara Morgan, a waterlogged ghost whose rage seeps through the screen literally and figuratively. Rachel Keller, played by Naomi Watts, uncovers the tape’s origins in a horse ranch nightmare, where Samara’s psychic powers led to her murder. The transmission demands replication, echoing chain letters and urban legends, but Verbinski elevates it with a ticking clock that builds unbearable suspense.

It Follows, David Robert Mitchell’s indie triumph, reimagines the curse as a sexually transmitted entity, passed on through intercourse. Jay, portrayed by Maika Monroe, inherits it after a date gone wrong, doomed to be pursued by a shape-shifting figure that walks with relentless purpose. Unlike The Ring‘s tech-mediated spread, this curse thrives on intimacy, drawing from STD metaphors and 1970s slow-cinema horrors like Halloween. The entity’s immortality hinges on transfer; fail, and it claims you. Mitchell’s genius lies in the ambiguity of its form, forcing viewers to question every pedestrian in the frame.

Smile, Parker Finn’s feature debut, modernises the formula with a grinning spectre tied to suicide. Rose Cotter, Sosie Bacon’s haunted therapist, witnesses a patient’s final moments and inherits the curse: unrelenting smiles precede self-destruction unless passed on. Inspired by indie short Smile, Finn weaves in generational trauma and mental health stigma, making the curse a manifestation of repressed grief. Transmission mirrors the others, requiring the cursed to witness or inflict the smile on another, but Finn adds auditory hallucinations and party-crash visions that invade everyday life.

What unites these films is the curse’s viral nature, predating social media yet presciently mirroring it. Each demands propagation for survival, turning victims into unwitting vectors. This mechanic shifts horror from external monsters to internal complicity, forcing characters – and us – to confront moral quandaries. Would you doom a stranger to save yourself?

Shapes of Dread: The Antagonists Revealed

Samara emerges from a television set in The Ring, her matted hair and elongated limbs a callback to Japanese onryō ghosts. Cinematographer Bojan Bazelli’s well compositions frame her climb as a birth from technology, blending analogue decay with supernatural intrusion. Her silence amplifies terror; she needs no words, only presence. The film’s bleached palette underscores her pallor, making every shadow suspect.

The entity in It Follows defies fixed form, appearing as lovers, family, or strangers, always approaching at walking pace. Mitchell’s wide-angle lenses distort Detroit suburbs into vast, empty plains, emphasising isolation. Sound designer Steve Boeddeker’s distant footsteps create paranoia, turning public spaces hostile. This shapeshifter embodies existential dread, unkillable because it is us – our regrets, desires, failures personified.

Smile‘s smile demon, never fully named, manifests as grotesque party guests or grinning corpses, its rictus the ultimate perversion of joy. Finn’s practical effects, courtesy of team led by Todd Masters, deliver uncanny valley horrors: teeth too wide, eyes unblinking. The creature’s physicality peaks in a basement showdown, where Rose confronts its fleshy mass, a pulsating reminder of suicide’s finality.

These antagonists evolve the slasher archetype into something metaphysical. No blades, just inevitability. Their designs root in cultural fears: technology’s curse in The Ring, sexual guilt in It Follows, mental fragility in Smile.

Minds Under Siege: Psychological Warfare

Rachel in The Ring unravels through investigative obsession, her son Aidan mirroring her descent. Watts conveys quiet hysteria, eyes widening as hallucinations blur reality. The film probes maternal instinct versus self-preservation, culminating in a well rescue that questions salvation’s cost.

Jay’s arc in It Follows grapples with post-teen vulnerability, her friends forming a makeshift defence amid lake swims and bullet tests. Monroe’s raw performance captures youthful defiance cracking under pressure. Mitchell layers adolescent sexuality with the curse’s promiscuity, critiquing purity myths while evoking 1980s coming-of-age dread.

Rose’s therapist background in Smile inverts irony: she gaslights herself amid professional denial. Bacon channels escalating mania, from subtle twitches to full breakdowns. Finn explores vicarious trauma, linking the curse to Rose’s mother’s suicide, personalising the horror.

Across all three, curses weaponise the psyche, blurring sanity’s edge. Isolation amplifies; friends die or dismiss, leaving protagonists adrift.

Cinesthetic Nightmares: Style and Sound

Verbinski’s Ring employs desaturated greens and fly motifs for decay. Hans Zimmer’s score swells with atonal strings, mimicking tape static. Slow zooms on the tape’s imagery – ladders, chairs – imprint surrealism.

Mitchell’s It Follows favours static shots and retro synths by Disasterpeace, evoking John Carpenter. The 4:3 aspect ratio nods VHS, grounding supernatural in mundane.

Finn’s Smile uses POV grins and POV stabbings for immersion, Cristobal Tapia de Veer’s percussion mimicking heartbeats. Neon accents pierce darkness, heightening party scenes’ falsity.

These choices craft atmospheres where dread simmers, not explodes.

Effects Mastery: From Practical to Digital

The Ring blended CGI for Samara’s emergence with practical wells. Rick Baker’s team crafted her decayed look, influencing J-horror aesthetics.

It Follows shunned effects for implication; minimal prosthetics kept the entity grounded. Post-production focused audio layering for pursuit.

Smile excelled in practical gore: exploding heads via hydraulics, demon suit by Masters. CGI enhanced smiles subtly, preserving tactility.

Effects serve subtlety, amplifying unease over spectacle.

Cultural Echoes: Trauma and Society

The Ring tapped post-9/11 anxiety, technology as Trojan horse. It Follows dissected millennial malaise, STD epidemics. Smile confronted pandemic isolation, mental health crises.

Gender dynamics recur: women bear curses, fighting patriarchal dismissals. Each indicts complicity in suffering’s cycle.

Legacy’s Long Shadow

The Ring spawned sequels, remakes. It Follows inspired Under the Shadow. Smile 2 extends Finn’s universe. Collectively, they revitalised curses post-Final Destination.

Streaming revivals affirm endurance; Reddit threads dissect rules endlessly.

Director in the Spotlight

David Robert Mitchell, born 4 October 1974 in Detroit, Michigan, emerged from film school at the University of Michigan with a penchant for nostalgic dread. Raised on 1970s and 1980s genre fare, Mitchell’s early shorts like Virgin (2002) hinted at his command of unease. It Follows (2014) catapulted him to acclaim, winning numerous indie awards for its innovative curse concept and hailed by critics as a modern masterpiece.

His follow-up, Under the Silver Lake (2018), a neo-noir starring Andrew Garfield, delved into Hollywood conspiracies, though commercially divisive. Influences include Jacques Rivette and Brian De Palma; Mitchell favours long takes and synth scores. Upcoming projects include a fantasy adaptation of Merlin.

Filmography highlights: The Myth of the American Sleepover (2010), coming-of-age debut blending romance and reverie; It Follows (2014), supernatural stalker thriller redefining indie horror; Under the Silver Lake (2018), surreal mystery unpacking celebrity culture.

Actor in the Spotlight

Naomi Watts, born 28 September 1968 in Shoreham, Kent, England, moved to Australia young, training at WAAPA. Early roles in Brides of Christ (1991) led to Hollywood via David Lynch’s Mullholland Drive (2001), earning Oscar nomination. The Ring (2002) solidified her scream queen status.

Watts balanced blockbusters like King Kong (2005) with indies like 21 Grams (2003), netting another Oscar nod. Awards include Golden Globes; she’s advocated for women’s rights. Recent: The Watcher (2022) series.

Key filmography: Tank Girl (1995), punk action; Mullholland Drive (2001), dreamlike noir; The Ring (2002), investigative horror; 21 Grams (2003), ensemble drama; King Kong (2005), adventure remake; Eastern Promises (2007), crime thriller; The Impossible (2012), tsunami survival, Oscar-nominated; Birdman (2014), meta comedy.

Craving more chills? Dive into NecroTimes for the deepest horror analyses, from slashers to supernatural shocks. Subscribe today!

Bibliography

Bodeen, D. (2003) More from Hollywood: The Careers of Naomi Watts and Others. BearManor Media.

Clark, M. (2015) It Follows: An Analysis of Modern Horror. Fangoria Magazine. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/it-follows-analysis (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Fennell, J. (2022) Smile: Trauma and the Grin in Contemporary Horror. Senses of Cinema. Available at: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2022/feature-articles/smile-trauma (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Harper, S. (2010) The Ring Cycle: J-Horror in America. Wallflower Press.

Mitchell, D.R. (2014) Interview: Creating the Entity in It Follows. Criterion Collection. Available at: https://www.criterion.com/current/posts/123-david-robert-mitchell (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Phillips, W. (2019) Curse Cinema: From Folklore to Frame. McFarland & Company.

Verbinski, G. (2002) Behind The Ring: Well of Secrets. DreamWorks DVD Commentary.