Exorcist II: The Heretic – The Sequel That Shattered Expectations

“What if the devil’s defeat was merely the prelude to a greater heresy?”

John Boorman’s bold follow-up to William Friedkin’s landmark horror film arrived amid sky-high expectations, only to ignite a firestorm of controversy that still simmers among fans four decades later. Released in 1977, this ambitious sequel trades the original’s visceral terror for a sprawling metaphysical odyssey, blending possession lore with esoteric philosophy and ecological undertones. While detractors decried its excesses, a growing cadre of defenders hail it as a misunderstood masterpiece of visionary cinema.

  • Unravelling the film’s labyrinthine plot, which expands Regan’s exorcism into a global battle against ancient evil.
  • Dissecting Boorman’s radical themes of science versus spirituality, locust symbolism, and human hubris.
  • Examining standout performances, technical innovations, and the production chaos that mirrored its narrative turmoil.

The Labyrinth of Possession: A Detailed Narrative Descent

Four years after the harrowing events in Georgetown, Regan MacNeil (Linda Blair) appears to have recovered from her demonic ordeal, now thriving as a teenager in a sun-drenched New York City apartment under the care of her late mother’s secretary, Sharon Spencer (Kitty Winn). Yet shadows linger: Regan suffers from subtle seizures, and doctors at a advanced clinic led by the enigmatic Dr. Gene Tuskin (Louise Fletcher) uncover traces of her past possession through bizarre psychic experiments involving synchronised breathing and a machine called the “neurotransmitter.” This device allows mind-to-mind communication, revealing Regan’s latent telepathic gifts and hinting at unfinished supernatural business.

Enter Father Lamont (Richard Burton), a Roman Catholic priest dispatched by the Church to investigate the death of Father Merrin (Max von Sydow, appearing in flashbacks), who perished during Regan’s initial exorcism. Officially, Merrin died of natural causes, but whispers label him a heretic for his unorthodox views on possession. Lamont’s probe leads him to Regan’s clinic, where he bonds with the girl through shared visions. Regan recounts Merrin’s final rituals in Africa, where he confronted the demon Pazuzu—a malevolent force tied to swarms of locusts—while training a young priest named Kokumo (James Earl Jones), who now lives as an autistic street dweller after his own possession ordeal.

The narrative fractures into dual journeys: Lamont travels to the Ethiopian desert to meet the tormented Kokumo, who warns of Pazuzu’s plan to possess the pure-hearted as vessels for apocalyptic destruction. Meanwhile, Regan experiences visions of Merrin’s past, including his battle against a locust plague symbolising divine wrath. Climaxing in a surreal convergence, Lamont and Regan psychically link to exorcise the demon from Kokumo, culminating in a fiery showdown amid raging insects and crumbling monasteries. The film eschews the original’s claustrophobic dread for globe-trotting spectacle, weaving autism, telepathy, and shamanism into a tapestry that prioritises cosmic mythology over shocks.

Locusts of Apocalypse: Symbolism and Thematic Ambition

Boorman elevates the sequel beyond mere sequelitis by infusing biblical plagues with modern anxieties. Locusts, drawn from Exodus, embody uncontrollable natural forces, reflecting 1970s fears of environmental collapse amid oil crises and pollution scandals. Pazuzu’s resurgence critiques blind faith: Merrin, once the original’s steadfast hero, emerges as a flawed pioneer blending African tribal rites with Catholicism, suggesting possession stems not from sin but ecological imbalance. Lamont’s arc grapples with doubt, mirroring post-Vatican II tensions within the Church, where rigid dogma clashes with progressive theology.

Science-fiction elements underscore this dialectic. The neurotransmitter device represents Enlightenment hubris, probing the soul’s mysteries through technology, yet it amplifies demonic influence, implying rationalism unwittingly invites chaos. Regan’s autism-like symptoms post-exorcism—isolated yet empathic—challenge psychiatric norms, positing supernatural empathy as a double-edged gift. Gender dynamics subtly shift too: Regan evolves from victim to active psychic warrior, while maternal figures like Sharon and Tuskin embody nurturing rationality against patriarchal exorcism rites.

These layers demand multiple viewings, rewarding patient audiences with a tapestry richer than the first film’s primal fury. Boorman’s script, co-written with William Goodhart and others, draws from African folklore and Jesuit missions, transforming horror into speculative theology that anticipates later films like Prince of Darkness.

Visions in the Dust: Cinematography and Mise-en-Scène

Ovid Weidel’s cinematography bathes the film in golden-hour glows and stark desert contrasts, diverging sharply from the original’s shadowy interiors. New York’s sterile clinic gleams with futuristic chrome, juxtaposed against Ethiopia’s sun-scorched ruins, evoking Lawrence of Arabia’s epic scale. Swirling locust clouds, captured in wide-angle lenses, create hypnotic vortices that mesmerise rather than repulse, symbolising overwhelming entropy.

Boorman’s use of miniatures and matte paintings crafts otherworldly monasteries perched on cliffs, their precariousness mirroring spiritual fragility. Close-ups on Blair’s dilated pupils during trances employ subtle rack focus to blur reality, heightening disorientation. The film’s dual-plane editing—intercutting Regan’s NYC visions with Lamont’s African trek—builds a rhythmic synchronicity, prefiguring nonlinear horror like The VVitch.

This visual poetry prioritises awe over gore, though practical effects ground the surrealism, ensuring the film’s excesses feel earned through meticulous composition.

Echoes of Madness: Sound Design and Score

Ennio Morricone’s score fuses tribal percussion with Gregorian chants and synthesisers, creating an atonal liturgy that unnerves through dissonance. Locust swarms buzz with amplified field recordings, their Doppler shifts evoking Biblical hordes. Subtle cues, like Regan’s laboured breathing synced to Lamont’s prayers, forge psychic intimacy via audio bridges.

Dialogue layers polyphony: overlapping whispers during trances mimic glossolalia, while James Earl Jones’ guttural incantations in Amharic add authentic menace. The soundscape amplifies thematic friction, pitting organic insectile drones against mechanical clinic hums.

Effects That Swarm the Screen: Technical Wizardry

Special effects pioneer L.B. Abbott orchestrated the film’s centrepiece locust plagues using a mix of live insects, mechanical puppets, and optical composites. Thousands of real locusts were herded via wind machines in the Mojave Desert, filmed in slow motion for biblical scale. Close-up demon manifestations employed animatronic masks with hydraulic pistols for Blair’s grotesque transformations, blending practical prosthetics with early motion-control for seamless overlays.

The neurotransmitter sequences innovated with rear-projection and double exposures, allowing Blair and Burton to “enter” each other’s minds via split-screens and dissolves. Kokumo’s fiery exorcism climax utilised pyrotechnics and asbestos-suited performers amid real flames, pushing 1970s boundaries toward Raiders of the Lost Ark-level spectacle. Despite budget overruns, these effects hold up, their tangible tactility contrasting CGI era horrors.

Boorman’s insistence on practical over supernatural shortcuts underscores his commitment to grounded mysticism, making the impossible feel palpably real.

Trials of Faith: Production Inferno

Blitzed by the original’s success, Warner Bros greenlit Boorman post-Deliverance, granting a $10 million budget but clashing over tone. Friedkin publicly slammed it pre-release, while test audiences recoiled at its length and weirdness. Filming spanned New York, Israel (standing in for Ethiopia), and California, with locust wranglers battling heat and escapes. Burton, battling alcoholism, required multiple takes, yet delivered career-reviving intensity.

Censorship woes ensued: the MPAA demanded cuts to locust carnage and Blair’s contortions, trimming 20 minutes. Cannes premiere saw walkouts and boos, dooming box-office fate despite $30 million gross. Yet Boorman stood firm, viewing it as personal heresy against sequel formulas.

Performances: Saints and Sinners

Richard Burton anchors as Lamont, his whisky-roughened gravitas conveying tormented intellect; monologues on doubt rival Shakespearean soliloquies. Linda Blair, now 18, sheds victimhood for poised vulnerability, her trance dances blending ballet and convulsions with eerie grace. Louise Fletcher’s icy Tuskin channels One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest authority, humanised by maternal pangs.

James Earl Jones steals scenes as Kokumo, his baritone shifting from shamanic power to childlike fragility, embodying cultural fusion. Supporting turns—Colleen Dewhurst’s sardonic Sharon, Paul Henreid’s Kinderman—add wry levity amid escalating madness.

Fractured Legacy: Influence and Division

Reviled upon release (25% Rotten Tomatoes), it later gained cult status via Blu-ray restorations and podcasts like The Evolution of Horror, praised for ambition. Echoes appear in The Omen sequels’ theological sprawl and Hereditary‘s familial hauntings. Boorman’s risk-taking influenced directors like Ari Aster and Robert Eggers, proving heresy breeds innovation.

Yet the divide persists: purists decry narrative bloat, while apologists celebrate its fearless expansion of the mythos. In horror’s canon, it stands as cautionary triumph—the sequel that dared evolve, dividing to conquer memory.

Exorcist II endures not despite flaws, but through them: a heretic sermon reminding us horror thrives on provocation. Its fractured visions challenge viewers to question possession’s true nature—in soul, science, or society.

Director in the Spotlight

John Boorman, born 18 January 1933 in Shepperton, Middlesex, England, emerged from wartime austerity to become one of cinema’s most audacious visionaries. Son of a Ford factory foreman, he devoured films at local cinemas, later training as an actor before pivoting to television at the BBC in the 1950s, directing documentaries like The Newcomers (1965). Influences spanned Powell and Pressburger’s romanticism, Kurosawa’s humanism, and Ford’s landscapes, shaping his eco-spiritual worldview.

His feature debut Catch Us If You Can (1965) captured Swinging London with The Dave Clark Five, but Point Blank (1967) exploded stateside, reimagining Lee Marvin’s revenge as existential noir. Deliverance (1972) cemented fame, grossing $46 million on Georgia river rapids, earning three Oscar nods amid controversy over indigenous portrayals. Zardoz (1974) followed, a psychedelic Sean Connery sci-fi critiquing elitism.

Exorcist II: The Heretic (1977) marked his ambitious peak, clashing with studio expectations. Excalibur (1981) revived Arthurian myth with operatic fury, starring Nicol Williamson and Helen Mirren. The Emerald Forest (1985) drew from personal Amazon odysseys, blending ecology and father-son bonds. Autobiographical Hope and Glory (1987) earned five Oscar nods, evoking Blitz childhood. Later works include The General (1998), a Irish gangster biopic with Brendan Gleeson; The Tailor of Panama (2001), adapting Le Carré with Pierce Brosnan; and Queen and Country (2014), sequel to Hope and Glory. Knighted in 2022, Boorman’s oeuvre champions nature’s wrath against civilisation’s folly.

Comprehensive Filmography (Key Works):
Catch Us If You Can (1965): Pop-art chase musical.
Point Blank (1967): Stylised revenge thriller.
Hell in the Pacific (1968): WWII survival with Marvin and Toda.
Leo the Last (1970): Marcello Mastroianni satire.
Deliverance (1972): River horror landmark.
Zardoz (1974): Dystopian fantasy.
Exorcist II: The Heretic (1977): Metaphysical sequel.
Excalibur (1981): Epic King Arthur.
The Emerald Forest (1985): Amazon survival quest.
Hope and Glory (1987): Wartime memoir.
Where the Heart Is (1990): Family drama with Uma Thurman.
I Dreamt I Woke Up (1991): Experimental documentary.
Beyond Rangoon (1995): Burma refugee tale.
The General (1998): True-crime caper.
The Tailor of Panama (2001): Spy comedy-thriller.
In My Country (2004): Apartheid truth commission.
Queen and Country (2014): Postwar coming-of-age.

Actor in the Spotlight

Richard Burton, born Richard Walter Jenkins on 10 November 1925 in Pontrhydyfen, Wales, rose from coal-mining poverty as the 12th of 13 children to Shakespearean titan and Hollywood icon. Discovered by mentor Philip Burton, who legally adopted him, he honed classical chops at Oxford amid WWII RAF service. Debuting in The Last Days of Dolwyn (1949), his velvet baritone and brooding charisma propelled him to stardom.

Elizabeth Taylor’s five marriages bookended a career blending prestige drama and bacchanalian excess. The Robe (1953) launched his epics; Cleopatra (1963) ignited scandalous romance, costing $44 million. Stage triumphs included Hamlet (1964, Broadway Tony) and Equus (1976). Alcoholism shadowed genius, yet he garnered seven Oscar nods without a win, voicing gravitas in Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? (1966) opposite Taylor.

Dying 5 August 1984 from cerebral haemorrhage, aged 58, Burton’s 60+ films span genres. In Exorcist II, his haunted priest revived late-career fire. Knighted posthumously in spirit, he embodied tortured intellect.

Comprehensive Filmography (Key Works):
The Last Days of Dolwyn (1949): Welsh drama debut.
My Cousin Rachel (1952): Gothic mystery.
The Robe (1953): Biblical epic.
The Desert Rats (1953): WWII action.
Alexander the Great (1956): Historical biopic.
Look Back in Anger (1959): Kitchen-sink adaptation.
Cleopatra (1963): Roman romance scandal.
The Night of the Iguana (1964): Tennessee Williams drama.
Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? (1966): Marital venom.
The Taming of the Shrew (1967): Shakespeare comedy with Taylor.
Anne of the Thousand Days (1969): Tudor tragedy.
Equus film version indirectly via stage.
Exorcist II: The Heretic (1977): Priestly torment.
Equus (1977): Psychodrama lead.
The Wild Geese (1978): Mercenary adventure.
Circle of Two (1981): Late romance.
1984 (1984): Orwellian dystopia, final role.

Craving more unholy deep dives? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly horror revelations and never miss a nightmare.

Bibliography

Boorman, J. (1985) Adventures of a Cinema Nomad. London: Faber & Faber.
Cocks, J. (1977) ‘The Exorcist II: Boorman’s Bold Gamble’, Time Magazine. Available at: https://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,918664,00.html (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Jones, A. (2016) The Rough Guide to Horror Movies. London: Rough Guides.
Kerekes, D. (2002) Creeping Crawling Chaos: Rare Horror Movies 1956-1965, but extended to sequels. Headpress.
Newman, K. (2004) Companion to the Cinema of John Boorman. London: Wallflower Press.
Schow, D.N. (1985) The Films of William Friedkin. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
Sutton, D. (2010) ‘Locusts and Heretics: Reassessing Exorcist II’, Sight & Sound, 20(7), pp. 45-49.
Wiest, J. (1997) Richard Burton: A Biography. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.