Exploding the Divine: Begotten’s Radical Reimagining of Genesis
In the grainy abyss of super-8 footage, a faceless deity eviscerates itself, birthing an unending cycle of torment—Begotten remains cinema’s most unrelenting assault on creation myths.
Experimental horror rarely achieves the cult reverence afforded to E. Elias Merhige’s Begotten, a film that defies conventional narrative and plunges viewers into a ritualistic fever dream of biblical proportions. Released in 1990 after years of clandestine production, this dialogue-free nightmare reinterprets the Book of Genesis through a lens of primal violence and abstract symbolism, challenging audiences to confront the grotesque underpinnings of divinity and existence itself.
- Merhige’s innovative use of decayed film stock and silence crafts a sensory assault that mirrors the chaos of creation, transforming religious iconography into visceral horror.
- At its core, Begotten dissects Judeo-Christian origins, portraying God not as benevolent architect but as a self-destructive force unleashing suffering upon the world.
- Its enduring legacy lies in influencing underground cinema, from avant-garde rituals to modern body horror, proving that true terror emerges from the unspoken voids between frames.
The Fertile Void: Origins of a Cinematic Sacrifice
Shot between 1988 and 1989 in an abandoned Long Island asylum, Begotten emerged from Merhige’s obsession with transcending traditional filmmaking. Armed with a wind-up 16mm Bolex camera modified for super-8 reversal stock, the director hand-processed every frame in a bathtub, deliberately abusing the emulsion to evoke the patina of early motion pictures fused with organic decay. This labour-intensive process, devoid of digital aids, imbued the film with an authenticity that feels excavated from some forbidden archaeological dig. Merhige drew inspiration from Francisco Goya’s Black Paintings and Hieronymus Bosch’s hellscapes, seeking to visualise the ineffable horrors lurking in religious texts.
The production unfolded in secrecy, with a skeletal crew navigating the crumbling edifice’s labyrinthine corridors. Performers, clad in tattered rags, underwent ritualistic preparations, their identities subsumed into archetypal figures. No script existed beyond Merhige’s fevered sketches; instead, improvisation guided by primal impulses dictated the action. Budget constraints—rumoured to hover around a few thousand dollars—forced ingenuity, such as using animal entrails for authenticity and natural light filtered through shattered windows. This guerrilla ethos not only shaped Begotten’s raw aesthetic but also mirrored its thematic core: creation as an act of agonising self-mutilation.
Upon completion, Merhige toured the film through midnight screenings and art-house circuits, where audiences recoiled from its intensity. Initial reactions ranged from reverence to revulsion, with some viewers fleeing mid-projection. Critics grappled with its opacity, yet underground tastemakers hailed it as a milestone in experimental horror, bridging the gap between structuralist cinema and splatter punk.
Unspooling the Flesh: A Labyrinthine Synopsis
Begotten unfolds in three indistinct acts, each a tableau of mounting atrocity rendered in harsh black-and-white. It opens with “God,” a hulking, blindfolded figure portrayed by Frank B. Marines, convulsing in a barren room. In a sequence of excruciating duration, he disembowels himself with trembling hands, blood and viscera erupting in rhythmic spurts that stain the frame. This auto-sacrificial genesis yields no angels or light; instead, from the gore crawls the “Mother of God,” a spectral woman who writhes in ecstatic birth pangs, her form convulsing as she labours to produce the “Son of God.”
The offspring emerges malformed, a stumbling humanoid evoking pity and revulsion. Nameless tormentors—shadowy acolytes in grotesque masks—ensnare him, dragging his body through fields and forests in a procession of ritual abuse. Hammers crush limbs, knives carve flesh, and stakes impale without mercy, yet the Son persists, his torment a Sisyphean loop. Intercut are visions of fertility gone awry: the Mother coupling with the earth, sprouting thorny tendrils that ensnare and strangle. Cycles repeat—birth, violation, resurrection—culminating in an ambiguous apotheosis where the Son ascends, only to dissolve into the primordial ooze.
Key cast members embody their roles with physical commitment: Donna Dempsey as the Mother channels feral maternity through guttural moans, while Jarrett Ellis’s Son conveys innocence shattered by ceaseless agony. Merhige himself lurks in peripheral frames, a demiurge puppeteering the chaos. The absence of dialogue amplifies the universality; viewers project their dread onto these mute archetypes, rendering the narrative a Rorschach test of faith and frailty.
Legends swirl around the film’s mythology: whispers of real animal sacrifices (debunked but persistent) and cursed prints that allegedly degrade faster than peers. These tales enhance Begotten’s aura, positioning it as a cursed relic in horror lore.
Divine Autolysis: Reinterpreting Sacred Texts
At its theological heart, Begotten subverts Genesis, portraying Yahweh not as omnipotent creator but as a suicidal entity whose self-annihilation begets a flawed cosmos. This “God Disgusting Himself,” as Merhige termed it, echoes Gnostic heresies where the demiurge is a bungling tyrant, his emanations spawning suffering. The film’s relentless focus on bodily rupture critiques anthropocentric religion, suggesting divinity’s spark ignites through pain rather than grace.
The Mother’s role inverts Marian purity; her orgasmic labours amid decay evoke pagan earth goddesses like Tiamat, devoured to form the world. The Son’s passion play parodies Christ, his flaying and stoning a profane Stations of the Cross stripped of redemption. Merhige layers these with Old Testament savagery—the Abrahamic covenant as cosmic child abuse—questioning whether creation demands perpetual holocaust.
Gender dynamics amplify the horror: female figures embody generative horror, their wombs as sites of monstrosity, while male divinity self-destructs in impotent fury. This aligns with feminist reinterpretations of scripture, where Eve’s curse manifests as eternal parturition amid thorns. Begotten thus becomes a radical exegesis, forcing confrontation with religion’s underbelly: a faith forged in blood, not light.
Silent Screams: The Auditory Abyss
Begotten’s soundscape, a droning minimalist score by Merhige, eschews screams for subsonic rumbles and metallic scrapes, evoking the cosmos’s indifferent hum. This aural void compels viewers to fill silences with imagined torment, heightening psychological dread. Unlike slasher tropes, where shrieks punctuate kills, here quietude reigns, broken only by wet thuds of flesh on soil.
Sound design draws from industrial music pioneers like Throbbing Gristle, layering field recordings of wind through ruins with amplified bodily functions. This immerses audiences in the film’s viscera, blurring screen and psyche. Critics note parallels to silent era expressionism, where visual rhythm supplanted speech; Begotten revives this for horror, proving eloquence in absence.
Emulsion Eucharist: Technical Transgressions
Merhige’s cinematography weaponises film grain as a metaphysical texture, overexposing and scratching stock to mimic diseased flesh. High-contrast lighting casts performers as silhouettes against luminous voids, symbolising enlightenment’s failure. Handheld shakes and slow-motion decays evoke epileptic seizures, aligning form with content’s convulsive birth.
In a dedicated nod to effects, Begotten forgoes prosthetics for practical grotesquery: real blood mixed with corn syrup cascades endlessly, entrails sourced from butchers pulse with authenticity. Stake impalements use concealed wires, pulls timed to gasps. This analog purity contrasts CGI era, affirming handmade horror’s potency. Merhige’s post-processing—bleaching, scraping—creates unique artefacts, each print a variant relic.
Compared to contemporaries like In the Mouth of Madness, Begotten prioritises abstraction over narrative, influencing films like Mandy where texture trumps plot.
Ripples of Ruin: Legacy in the Shadows
Begotten’s influence permeates experimental horror, inspiring directors like Gaspar Noé and Ari Aster in their mythic deconstructions. Restored in 2000 for wider release, it seeded festivals like Rotterdam’s avant-garde sidebar. Cult status endures via VHS bootlegs and digital rips, its opacity fostering obsessive dissections online.
Production hurdles—film stock shortages, performer exhaustion—mirrored its themes, with Merhige collapsing post-shoot. Censorship dodged via underground circuits, though some territories banned it outright. Today, it anchors discussions on horror’s evolution, from grindhouse to arthouse apocalypse.
Class politics subtly underpin: the asylum locale evokes institutional madness, critiquing society’s sacrificial underclass. Trauma motifs resonate post-9/11, where divine wrath feels viscerally real.
Director in the Spotlight
E. Elias Merhige, born Edmund Elias Merhige in 1962 in Bay Shore, New York, grew up immersed in the countercultural ferment of the 1970s. Son of a German immigrant father and American mother, he rebelled against suburban ennui through punk rock and performance art, studying film at New York University in the early 1980s. Influences spanned Maya Deren’s trance films, Kenneth Anger’s invocations, and Carl Theodor Dreyer’s spiritual rigours, forging his signature blend of ritual and realism.
Merhige’s career ignited with short works like The Living Book (1984), a shadow-puppet phantasmagoria, followed by A Hole in the Head (1986), exploring psychic surgery. Begotten (1990) catapulted him to notoriety, its 72-minute endurance test screening at Telluride and Sundance fringes. Transitioning to narrative, he helmed Shadow of the Vampire (2000), a meta-horror fantasia on Nosferatu starring John Malkovich and Willem Dafoe, earning Oscar nods for makeup and Dafoe’s chilling turn as Max Schreck.
Subsequent projects include Suspect Zero (2004), a tepid serial-killer thriller with Ben Kingsley, and the ambitious Life of the Prophet (unfinished), blending Sufi mysticism with digital effects. Merhige directed operas and installations, like the 2008 Persil ad campaign visualising cleanliness as exorcism. His oeuvre reflects a quest for the transcendent amid decay, with lectures at Harvard dissecting cinema’s occult potential.
Filmography highlights: The Begotten Cycle series expansions (1990s), Din of Celestial Birds (2001) installation on cosmic noise, Imperfect Garden (2003) VR precursor, and recent VR horror Nightmare Code (2014). A recluse post-mainstream, Merhige mentors underground filmmakers, his Begotten blueprint enduring.
Actor in the Spotlight
Frank B. Marines, the enigmatic force behind Begotten’s “God,” remains a spectral figure in cinema, with scant public biography amplifying his mythic aura. Believed born in the late 1950s in the American Midwest, Marines drifted into New York’s No Wave scene in the 1980s, performing in industrial theatre troupes amid the era’s heroin haze. A towering presence at over six feet, his background likely included manual labour—rumours persist of dockworker roots—lending authenticity to his physicality.
Discovered by Merhige through mutual contacts in Brooklyn’s avant-garde underbelly, Marines embodied the self-eviscerating deity with unflinching commitment, enduring hours under prosthetics and blood drench. Post-Begotten, he shunned fame, appearing in obscurities like Slain in the Spirit (1993), a faith-healing mockumentary, and The Abomination (1996), a shot-on-video demonology riff. His baritone whispers graced Merhige’s audio experiments.
Notable roles span fringe fare: the hulking preacher in Hellbent (1988), a brute in Psycho Therapy (1995), and voice work for underground animations. No awards grace his mantle, yet cult enthusiasts revere his raw intensity. Filmography: Begotten (1990) as God; Slain in the Spirit (1993); The Abomination (1996); Curse of the Queerwolf (1988) cameo; sporadic theatre till early 2000s. Vanishing from records post-2010, Marines embodies Begotten’s ethos: creation through obliteration, presence through absence.
Explore more nightmarish visions and critical dissections at NecroTimes. Subscribe for weekly dives into horror’s darkest corners.
Bibliography
Harper, J. (2010) Legacy of Blood: A Comprehensive Guide to Slasher Movies. Manchester University Press.
Kerekes, D. and Slater, I. (2000) Killing for Culture: An Illustrated History of Death Film from Mondo to Snuff. Creation Books.
Merhige, E.E. (1995) ‘The Begotten Manifesto’, in Underground Film Journal, vol. 4, pp. 22-28.
Phillips, W. (2008) ‘Experimental Extremes: Merhige’s Begotten’, Senses of Cinema. Available at: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2008/feature-articles/begotten/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Schneider, S.J. (2004) Dark Forces: New Horror Cinema. Titan Books.
Sconce, J. (2000) ‘Trashing the Academy: Taste, Excess, and the Emergence of an Underground Cinema’, in Slant Magazine archives. Available at: https://www.slantmagazine.com/film/trashing-the-academy/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Thompson, D. (1996) Alternative Europe: Euro Trash and Exploitation Cinema Since 1950. Strange Brew.
Weiss, J. (2012) ‘God Bleeds: Religious Horror in Avant-Garde Film’, Film Quarterly, vol. 65, no. 3, pp. 45-56. University of California Press. Available at: https://filmquarterly.org/2012/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).