Fangs for the Laughs: Unearthing the Parodic Heart of Vampire Cinema

In the crypt of horror comedy, two films sink their teeth into Dracula’s legacy, blending mockery with mythic reverence.

Vampire lore has long danced on the knife-edge between terror and temptation, but when parody enters the fray, it transforms eternal night into a carnival of chaos. This exploration pits the deadpan domesticity of a New Zealand mockumentary against the slapstick grandeur of a Hollywood spoof, revealing how both films evolve the bloodsucker’s archetype through laughter.

  • The mockumentary lens of flat-sharing fiends exposes the mundane horrors of undead immortality, contrasting sharply with broad farce that lampoons gothic excess.
  • Performances hinge on subtle irony versus over-the-top caricature, each method dissecting vampire tropes from folklore to screen.
  • These parodies not only mock but honour the evolutionary path of the vampire myth, influencing a subgenre where humour bites deepest.

The Flatmate Fangs: Domesticating the Undead

In What We Do in the Shadows, the vampire myth crashes into modern suburbia with the force of a poorly staked coffin lid. A crew follows four undead roommates—Viago, Vladislav, Deacon, and Petyr—through their Wellington flatshare, capturing petty squabbles over chores, fashion faux pas, and failed seductions. Viago, the dandyish 19th-century fop, nags about laundry etiquette; Vladislav, once a feared warlord, now contends with erectile impotence symbolised by his faltering levitation powers. The film builds hilarity from the chasm between mythic grandeur and banal reality, turning Transylvanian terror into tenant disputes.

This setup masterfully subverts Bram Stoker’s aristocratic Count, drawing from folklore’s nocturnal predators to portray immortality as an endless grind. The vampires’ familiar, Stu—a human turned ghoul via accidental neck-biting—highlights the absurdity of eternal servitude. Scenes of them navigating nightclubs, dodging sunlight with black rubbish bags, or attending vampire council meetings parody the ritualistic pomp of gothic horror. Directorially, the found-footage style borrows from reality TV, making the supernatural feel sitcom-small, a clever nod to how folklore evolves in pop culture.

Key to its bite is the evolutionary commentary: vampires as outdated relics in a werewolf-rivalled world. The werewolves’ full-moon howls and lycra outfits mock lycanthropic clichés, while a showdown with ancient beast elevates the stakes without abandoning comedy. Production drew from a 2005 short film by the same creators, expanding into feature territory amid New Zealand’s burgeoning genre scene, proving parody thrives on local flavour.

Coffin-Sized Gags: Brooks’ Gothic Burlesque

Dracula: Dead and Loving It assaults the vampire canon with Mel Brooks’ signature barrage of visual puns and verbal vaudeville. Leslie Nielsen’s Dracula emerges from a coffin in a storm-lashed castle, cape swirling to reveal bloomers, immediately signalling the film’s intent to deflate pomposity. Renfield, played by Brooks himself, munches insects with escalating hysteria; Van Helsing, a bumbling Peter MacNicol, mangles accents and expertise. The plot loosely apes Stoker’s novel and myriad adaptations, from shipwrecked Demeter to Lucy’s blood-drained swoons, all amplified into farce.

Brooks revels in cinematic in-jokes, referencing Nosferatu‘s shadow climb, Hammer’s heaving bosoms, and Lugosi’s hypnotic stare turned into pratfalls. A highlight unfolds in the undead orgy sequence, where victims rise sporting fangs like ill-fitting dentures, their waltzing corpses a riotous ballet of the bizarre. Makeup and effects lean practical—rubbery bats, squirting blood fountains—evoking vaudeville props over CGI slickness, grounding the parody in pre-digital charm.

The film’s evolutionary thrust lies in its exhaustive catalogue of tropes: mirrors that reflect awkward voids, garlic repulsions played for slapstick chases, and stakes driven with Freudian phallicism. Brooks, a comedy titan, channels his Broadway roots into a loving roast, ensuring the laughs underscore rather than erase the myth’s allure. Shot on lavish sets reminiscent of Universal’s golden age, it faced box-office fangs but endures as a cult elixir for parody purists.

Tropes in the Crosshairs: Subverting the Sanguine Myth

Both films dissect vampire folklore’s core—bloodlust, seduction, undeath—through prisms of ridicule. Shadows’ mockumentary intimacy humanises the monsters, exploring immortality’s ennui via interviews that reveal centuries of regret. Vladislav’s failed hypnosis on a victim (“You are getting sleepy… no?”) pokes at mesmerism from Stoker’s pages, evolved from 18th-century mesmerist pseudoscience. Brooks counters with exaggeration: Dracula’s cape-snag pratfall mocks the cape’s phallic symbolism in gothic lit.

Seduction scenes offer prime contrast. In Shadows, Viago’s candlelit dinner devolves into bickering over consent and snacks, satirising the romantic vampire boom post-Twilight. Dead and Loving It revels in mammary mayhem, Lucy’s stake-through-bosom geyser a gross-out homage to Victorian repression. These moments trace the myth from Eastern European strigoi—disease-bringers in Slavic tales—to Western sex symbols, showing parody as cultural mirror.

Werewolf rivalries in Shadows evolve folklore’s beastly binaries, while Brooks nods to Wolfman crossovers. Both highlight transformation’s terror turned trivial: moonlight lycanthropy as pack-bonding, vampirism as lifestyle choice. This duality reflects horror’s shift from moral allegory to identity play.

Performance Predation: From Dry Wit to Wet Slapstick

Jemaine Clement’s Vladislav embodies Shadows’ understated menace, his booming voice cracking into pathos during power-loss meltdowns, a performance honed from Flight of the Conchords’ deadpan. Taika Waititi’s Viago fusses with foppery, blending Fawlty Towers neurosis with Nosferatu creep. Their chemistry sells the film’s thesis: eternity dulls fangs.

Nielsen’s Dracula, conversely, channels Airplane! blankness into aristocratic idiocy, his “I vant to suck your blood” delivered with perfect pitch. Supporting turns—Steven Weber’s Harker mangling lines, Lysette Anthony’s Mina as dizzy damsel—fuel ensemble frenzy. Brooks’ Renfield steals with bug-chomping glee, proving parody demands precision timing.

These styles evolve acting traditions: Shadows from improv theatre, Brooks from burlesque. Both honour Lugosi’s gravitas by inverting it, Nielsen’s pratfalls a distant echo of Bela’s poise.

Mise-en-Scène of Mockery: Visual Vampirism

Shadows’ handheld chaos—dingy flats, DIY coffins—contrasts Dracula’s opulent Transylvania, all fog machines and thunder-sheet FX. Cinematography captures Wellington’s grit, vampires’ velvet amid mouldy modernity, symbolising myth’s domestication.

Brooks deploys widescreen grandeur for gags: elongated shadows for comedy chases, sets aping Horror of Dracula. Practical effects shine—fake snow blizzards, animatronic spiders—celebrating analogue artistry amid 90s digital dawns.

Costume design evolves too: Shadows’ thrift-shop goth versus Brooks’ frilly excesses, both lampooning the cape’s iconic sweep from Murnau onward.

Legacy’s Long Shadow: Parody’s Enduring Bite

Shadows spawned a TV series, globalising its formula and influencing Z Nation-style undead sitcoms. Its Oscar-nominated short roots underscore indie evolution.

Dracula: Dead and Loving It, though commercially staked, revitalised Brooks’ canon, paving for Spaceballs echoes in later spoofs like Scary Movie.

Together, they mark parody’s role in vampire evolution, from Stoker to streaming, ensuring the Count’s laugh lives forever.

Production’s Bloody Labour

Shadows shot guerrilla-style in NZ, budget under $1.5m, creators self-financing after festival shorts. Challenges included actor-vamp prosthetics wilting in humidity.

Brooks’ film, Castle Rock-backed, navigated studio expectations post-Robin Hood: Men in Tights, with Nielsen cast for reliability amid script rewrites.

Both triumphed over scepticism, proving parody’s mythic resilience.

Director in the Spotlight

Melvin James Kaminsky, born 28 June 1926 in Brooklyn, New York, to Jewish immigrant parents Max and Kate, grew up amid Depression-era hardships that infused his humour with resilient absurdity. Serving in World War II as a combat engineer, Brooks honed timing on army shows, debuting professionally via Sid Caesar’s Your Show of Shows (1950-1954), where writing sketches alongside Carl Reiner birthed timeless bits like the 2000 Year Old Man routine.

Transitioning to directing, Brooks helmed The Producers (1967), a Broadway flop satire starring Zero Mostel and Gene Wilder, earning Oscar for Best Original Screenplay and cementing his outsider voice. The Twelve Chairs (1970) followed, adapting Ilf and Petrov with Ron Moody. Blazing Saddles (1974), co-written with Andrew Bergman, Richard Pryor et al., shattered Western taboos via Cleavon Little’s sheriff and Harvey Korman’s villainy, grossing $119m.

Young Frankenstein (1974) parodied Universal horrors with Wilder, Gene Hackman, and Teri Garr, featuring meticulous black-and-white homage and “Puttin’ on the Ritz” dance. Silent Movie (1976) innovated dialogue-free farce with Marty Feldman and Dom DeLuise. High Anxiety (1977) spoofed Hitchcock, Brooks as psychoanalyst-director. History of the World Part I (1981) anthology skewered eras, from Rome to French Revolution.

Spaceballs (1987) lampooned Star Wars with Bill Pullman and John Candy; Robin Hood: Men in Tights (1993) medieval madness with Cary Elwes, Richard Lewis. Dracula: Dead and Loving It (1995) capped his directorial run, blending Nielsen’s deadpan with Anne Bancroft’s gypsy. Post-directing, Brooks produced The Elephant Man (1980), voiced in animations, and earned AFI Lifetime Achievement (2013). Married thrice, father to four including Max Brooks, his influence spans generations via irreverent myth-busting.

Filmography highlights: The Producers (1967: Satirical musical flop chase); Blazing Saddles (1974: Racially subversive Western); Young Frankenstein (1974: Monster movie homage); Silent Movie (1976: Mute Hollywood roast); High Anxiety (1977: Hitchcock spoof); History of the World Part I (1981: Epic parody sketch); Spaceballs (1987: Sci-fi farce); Robin Hood: Men in Tights (1993: Arthurian burlesque); Dracula: Dead and Loving It (1995: Vampire vaudeville).

Actor in the Spotlight

Jemaine Clement, born 10 January 1974 in Masterton, New Zealand, to a Maori mother and European father, endured a nomadic childhood marked by his parents’ separation. Raised by grandparents, he battled childhood cancer, emerging with a wry worldview that fuelled his comedy. Studying film at Victoria University, Clement co-founded The Humourbeast theatre troupe, leading to TV sketches and the HBO series Helicopter Quartet (2004).

Global breakthrough came with Flight of the Conchords (2007-2009), co-starring Bret McKenzie as inept folk duo, earning Emmy nods and cult fandom. Clement directed episodes, showcasing auteur leanings. What We Do in the Shadows (2014), co-directed with Taika Waititi, cast him as hapless Vladislav, blending pathos and power fantasies into breakout role.

Hollywood beckoned: Machete (2010) villain; Dinner for Schmucks (2010) oddball; voicing Tamatoa in Moana (2016), his crab song “Shiny” a viral hit. People Places Things (2015) dramatic turn; Legion (2017-2019) as empathetic mutant; What We Do in the Shadows series (2019-) as Colin Robinson, energy vampire. Directed People Places Things (2015), wrote Eagle vs Shark (2007). Married theatre designer Miranda Manasiadis, father to two. Clement’s career evolves outsider humour into versatile gravitas, influencing Kiwi cinema’s global rise.

Filmography highlights: Eagle vs Shark (2007: Awkward romance, co-writer); Flight of the Conchords: A World of Conchord (2008: Concert film); Gentlemen Broncos (2009: Sci-fi spoof); Machete (2010: Sadistic enforcer); Dinner for Schmucks (2010: Eccentric inventor); What We Do in the Shadows (2014: Vladislav the vampire); People Places Things (2015: Director/actor, family dramedy); Moana (2016: Voice of Tamatoa); Legion (2017-2019: Oliver Bird); The Tenderloins Go to New Zealand (2023: Cameo).

Craving more mythic chills? Dive into HORRITCA’s crypt of classic monster masterpieces.

Bibliography

Benshoff, H. M. (2011) Monsters in the Closet: Gay Subtexts in American Horror Film. Manchester University Press.

Brooks, M. (2009) The 2000 Year Old Man Book. HarperEntertainment.

Carroll, N. (1990) The Philosophy of Horror: Or, Paradoxes of the Heart. Routledge.

Clement, J. and Waititi, T. (2014) What We Do in the Shadows: The Making Of. Conchord Ltd. Available at: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3416742/trivia (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Harris, E. (2015) The Pointy Fangs of Children: Classic Horror and the Process of Growing Up. Scarecrow Press.

Hudson, D. (1995) Dracula: Dead and Loving It Production Notes. Castle Rock Entertainment. Available at: https://www.tcm.com/tcmdb/title/69221/dracula-dead-and-loving-it#articles (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

McEnteer, J. (2018) Mockumentary Comedy: History and Techniques. Palgrave Macmillan.

Skal, D. J. (1990) The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror. W.W. Norton.

Waititi, T. and Clement, J. (2005) What We Do in the Shadows (Short). WingNut Films.

Wood, R. (1986) Hollywood from Vietnam to Reagan. Columbia University Press.