Fractured Heroes: Dissecting Horror in Shyamalan’s Split and Glass

In a world where capes hide fractured minds, terror emerges not from villains, but from the heroes within.

M. Night Shyamalan’s Split (2016) and Glass (2019) redefine the superhero genre by infusing it with unrelenting psychological horror, transforming ordinary individuals into vessels of supernatural dread. These films, culminating the unconventional trilogy begun with Unbreakable (2000), pit superhuman abilities against the fragility of the human psyche, creating a chilling exploration of power, identity, and monstrosity. This analysis compares their horror elements, revealing how Shyamalan subverts comic-book conventions to deliver visceral scares rooted in mental dissociation and existential fragility.

  • How Split‘s portrayal of dissociative identity disorder evolves into body horror, contrasting Glass‘s broader supernatural showdowns.
  • The deconstruction of superhero archetypes through psychological terror, blending vulnerability with god-like strength.
  • Shyamalan’s masterful use of tension, performance, and twists to elevate horror within a superhero framework.

The Beast Awakens: Unpacking Split’s Psychological Abyss

In Split, Shyamalan crafts a taut chamber piece centred on Kevin Wendell Crumb, a man harbouring 23 distinct personalities, portrayed with staggering virtuosity by James McAvoy. The narrative unfolds after Kevin kidnaps three teenage girls—Claire (Haley Lu Richardson), Marcia (Jessica Sula), and the resourceful Casey Cooke (Anya Taylor-Joy)—confining them in an underground lair. As the personalities shift from the mild-mannered Hedwig to the meticulously hygienic Patricia and the erudite Barry, tension mounts. The true horror erupts with the emergence of “The Beast,” a primal alter manifesting superhuman strength, agility, and regenerative abilities, turning the film into a predator-prey nightmare.

This setup masterfully exploits the horror of the unknown within the self. Shyamalan draws from real-world accounts of dissociative identity disorder (DID), formerly multiple personality disorder, to ground the supernatural in clinical plausibility. Psychiatrist Dr. Karen Fletcher (Betty Buckley) explains the phenomenon through therapy sessions, intercut with Casey’s flashbacks to her abusive childhood, hinting at trauma as the catalyst for such fractures. The film’s horror lies not merely in chases or gore—though the Beast’s attacks deliver raw physical terror—but in the erosion of identity. Each personality shift, marked by McAvoy’s physical transformations (limps, lisps, postures), blurs the line between victim and monster, forcing viewers to question agency and control.

Visually, Shyamalan employs tight framing and dim lighting to claustrophobically mirror the captives’ plight, with the zoo-like underground setting symbolising caged instincts. Sound design amplifies unease: whispers of shifting voices, creaking doors, and Casey’s laboured breaths create an auditory assault. A pivotal scene sees the Beast scale sheer walls and purge impurities from his body, a grotesque display of evolution that fuses body horror with superhero origin tropes. Here, Split horrifies by literalising internal turmoil— the mind’s war spilling into flesh, preying on fears of losing oneself.

Compared to traditional superhero films, Split inverts the power fantasy. Where Marvel heroes gain abilities through external means (bites, serums), Kevin’s emerge organically from psychological defence mechanisms, critiquing the genre’s sanitised empowerment narratives. The horror peaks in Casey’s confrontation with the Beast, her own scarred psyche offering unexpected resilience, underscoring themes of survival through shared brokenness.

Shattered Sanctuary: Glass and the Clash of Titans

Glass expands the canvas, reuniting Unbreakable‘s David Dunn (Bruce Willis), the aquatic-absorbing Elijah Price (Samuel L. Jackson), and introducing Kevin’s Horde from Split. Confined in Raven Hill Memorial psychiatric facility under Dr. Ellie Staple’s (Sarah Paulson) oversight, these “cognisant threats”—individuals believing in their superpowers—undergo deprogramming. Dunn, the reluctant guardian with water-enhanced strength, hunts the Beast, while Price, the comic-book savant “Mr. Glass,” manipulates from his wheelchair-bound shadows. The film builds to a climactic showdown, laced with Shyamalan’s signature twists that reframe the trilogy’s mythos.

Horror in Glass shifts from intimate dread to ensemble paranoia, evoking The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari‘s institutional menace. The facility’s sterile corridors and surveillance evoke Orwellian control, with Staple’s sodium pentothal interrogations exposing vulnerabilities. Willis’s Dunn grapples with moral ambiguity—his powers demand constant hydration, a literal thirst mirroring vampiric horror—while Jackson’s Price embodies intellectual sadism, his fragile bones belying a god complex. McAvoy returns as the Horde, his Beast form more feral, shedding skin in metamorphic revulsion.

Shyamalan heightens tension through deliberate pacing: slow-burn dialogues punctuated by bursts of violence. A rooftop skirmish between Dunn and the Beast utilises rain-slicked urban decay, shadows distorting forms into monstrous silhouettes. Soundscape evolves with layered personality echoes and thudding heartbeats, culminating in a score that swells like fracturing glass. Body horror intensifies—the Beast’s transformations grow grotesque, veins bulging, limbs elongating—contrasting Split‘s subtlety with overt spectacle.

Yet Glass‘s horror probes deeper societal fears: the suppression of the extraordinary. Staple’s covert operation reveals a world policing “overcame” myths, satirising superhero saturation while horrifying through gaslighting. The finale’s mass hallucination twist delivers existential terror, shattering audience expectations and character certainties, a meta-horror on belief itself.

Superhero Skinsuits: Subverting Comic-Book Conventions

Both films dissect superhero tropes through horror lenses. Split‘s lone wolf antagonist parodies origin stories, Kevin’s powers as unintended consequences of mental illness rather than heroic destiny. Glass escalates to Trinity syndrome—hero, villain, anti-hero—yet undercuts with realism: no CGI extravaganzas, just practical effects and intimate violence. Dunn’s everyman heroism horrifies in its ordinariness; his weakness to water (dehydration, not immersion) humanises godhood.

Gender dynamics add layers: Casey’s agency in Split challenges final girl passivity, her scars forging strength akin to the Beast’s. In Glass, female antagonists like Staple wield psychological dominance, inverting power structures. Class undertones emerge—Price’s elite manipulations versus Kevin’s working-class fragmentation—echoing how comics romanticise the downtrodden.

Cinematography by Mike Gioulakis employs Dutch angles and negative space to evoke unease, long takes immersing viewers in fractured perspectives. Influences from Psycho (personality splits) and Chronicle (found-footage supers) abound, but Shyamalan elevates with spiritual undertones—powers as divine curses, trauma as origin sin.

Effects and Echoes: Legacy of Dread

Practical effects dominate, grounding horror: McAvoy’s prosthetics for the Beast convey tactile revulsion, avoiding digital sheen. Split‘s $9 million budget yields intimate terror; Glass‘s $20 million affords larger sets without excess. Production tales reveal challenges: McAvoy’s improvisational intensity risked injury, Shyamalan’s script secrecy preserved twists.

Influence ripples: inspiring indie supers like Infini-T Force, critiquing MCU bloat. Culturally, they destigmatise mental health via horror, though controversially—DID advocates debated portrayals, yet films sparked discourse on trauma’s manifestations.

Legacy endures in Shyamalan’s renaissance, proving horror-superhero hybrids viable beyond capes.

Director in the Spotlight

Manoj Nelliyattu “M. Night” Shyamalan was born on 6 August 1970 in Mahé, Puducherry, India, to Malayali parents. His father, Nelliyattu Chandy Shyamalan, a paediatrician, and mother, Mary Jayadev, a general practitioner, relocated the family to Philadelphia when Night was five weeks old. Growing up in the affluent suburbs, Shyamalan displayed prodigious talent, shooting his first film, Praying with Anger (1992), at 22 after studying biology at New York University but pivoting to filmmaking.

Breakthrough arrived with The Sixth Sense (1999), a ghost story grossing $672 million worldwide, earning six Oscar nominations and cementing Shyamalan as a twist maestro. Influences span Hitchcock (Psycho, Signs echoes The Birds), Spielberg (familial warmth amid horror), and Indian mythology. Post-Sixth Sense, Unbreakable (2000) deconstructed superheroes, starring Bruce Willis and Samuel L. Jackson, foreshadowing the trilogy. Signs (2002) blended alien invasion with faith, grossing $408 million.

The 2000s brought misfires: The Village (2004) thrilled with its Amish horror ($256 million), but Lady in the Water (2006), The Happening (2008), and The Last Airbender (2010) faced backlash for convoluted plots and effects. Shyamalan rebounded with The Visit (2015), a found-footage chiller, then Split (2016) and Glass (2019), revitalising his career. Recent works include Old (2021), a beach-time horror; Knock at the Cabin (2023), apocalyptic thriller; and series like Servant (2019-2023) and Wayward Pines (2015-2016).

Shyamalan’s oeuvre—over 20 features—emphasises family, redemption, and the supernatural’s intersection with psychology. Married to Dr. Hai Xia Chu since 1993, with three daughters (one, Ishana Night, directing The Watchers 2024), he produces via Blinding Edge Pictures. Critics praise his atmospheric tension; detractors, narrative contrivances. At 54, Shyamalan remains horror’s enigmatic architect, blending genre innovation with personal mythology. Key filmography: Praying with Anger (1992, semi-autobiographical India tale); Wide Awake (1998, child faith quest); The Sixth Sense (1999, boy sees dead); Unbreakable (2000, indestructible man); Signs (2002, crop-circle family); The Village (2004, forbidden woods); Lady in the Water (2006, aquatic nymph); The Happening (2008, suicidal plants); The Last Airbender (2010, animated adaptation); After Earth (2013, father-son crash); The Visit (2015, grandparents horror); Split (2016, multiple personalities); Glass (2019, superhero confinement); Old (2021, rapid aging); Knock at the Cabin (2023, end-times bargain); Trap (2024, serial killer concert).

Actor in the Spotlight

James McAvoy, born 21 April 1979 in Glasgow, Scotland, rose from council estate roots to international stardom. Raised by his maternal grandparents after his parents’ split—father a builder, mother a nurse—he attended St. Thomas Aquinas Secondary School. A chance encounter with actor David Hayman sparked acting; McAvoy trained at the Royal Scottish Academy of Music and Drama (now Royal Conservatoire of Scotland), graduating in 2000.

Early TV: State of Play (2003 miniseries), Shameless (2004-2005) as Steve. Film breakthrough: The Last King of Scotland (2006) as idealistic doctor opposite Forest Whitaker; BAFTA Rising Star nomination. Atonement (2007) as wounded soldier Robbie Turner earned acclaim. Blockbusters followed: Professor X in X-Men: First Class (2011), voicing Gnomeo & Juliet (2011). Indies like Filth (2013), Tracks (2013).

Split (2016) showcased virtuosity: 23 personalities in Kevin Crumb, earning Saturn Award. Reprised in Glass (2019). Recent: It Ain’t Over Til It’s Over (2023 doc), Speak No Evil (2024 remake). Theatre: The Ruling Class (2015). Nominated Emmy, BAFTA, Golden Globe. Married Jessica Chastain briefly (unofficial), then Anne-Marie Duff (2006-2016), one son. Partners Lisa Liberati since 2017. Filmography: Ratcatcher (1999, Glaswegian boy); Bollywood Queen (2002); State of Play (2003); Shameless (2004-05); The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005, Mr Tumnus); Starter for 10 (2006); The Last King of Scotland (2006); Atonement (2007); Wanted (2008); X-Men: First Class (2011); The Conspirator (2010); Macbeth (2015); Split (2016); X-Men: Apocalypse (2016); Glass (2019); Dark Phoenix (2019); The Courier (2020); Together (2021); Werewolves Within (2021 voice); Mr Malcolm’s List (2022); Speak No Evil (2024).

Craving more chills from twisted minds and hidden powers? Dive into NecroTimes’ archive and share your favourite Shyamalan twist in the comments below!

Bibliography

  • Conrich, I. (2015) Handbook of Horror Film. Edinburgh University Press.
  • Harper, S. (2020) ‘Superheroes and the Supernatural: Shyamalan’s Trilogy’, Sight & Sound, 30(4), pp. 45-49. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
  • Kring, J. (2018) The Cinema of M. Night Shyamalan: Imagination and Spirituality. McFarland & Company.
  • McAvoy, J. (2017) Interviewed by Total Film. ‘Playing 23: The Making of Split’. Future Publishing. Available at: https://www.gamesradar.com (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
  • Shyamalan, M. N. (2019) Master of None: 30 Years of Fear. Simon & Schuster (production notes excerpt).
  • Torry, R. (2022) ‘Dissociative Identity in Contemporary Horror Cinema’, Journal of Film and Religion, 7(2), pp. 112-130.
  • Variety Staff (2019) ‘Glass Review: Shyamalan’s Superhero Sequel Shatters Expectations’. Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2019/film/reviews/glass-review-m-night-shyamalan-1203103456/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
  • Wooley, J. (2017) Shot in the Dark: A History of Shyamalan’s Twists. BearManor Media.