Two cinematic nightmares from different eras that capture the raw terror of adolescence, where puberty meets the paranormal and revenge spells doom.

In the pantheon of teen horror, few films cast shadows as long or as dark as Brian De Palma’s Carrie (1976) and David Robert Mitchell’s It Follows (2014). Both masterpieces dissect the brutal crucible of high school life, transforming everyday humiliations into supernatural cataclysms. This comparison unearths their shared DNA while celebrating their unique terrors, revealing why they remain benchmarks for a subgenre obsessed with youthful vulnerability.

  • Carrie establishes the vengeful telekinetic teen archetype, blending Stephen King’s prose with operatic visuals to indict religious fanaticism and bullying.
  • It Follows reinvents inescapable dread through a sexually transmitted curse, swapping spectacle for slow-burn paranoia in a post-recession American suburbia.
  • Together, they illuminate teen horror’s evolution, from explosive catharsis to ambient anxiety, influencing generations of filmmakers and scarring audiences worldwide.

From Pig’s Blood to Poolside Stalkers: Architects of Adolescent Dread

Carrie (1976) erupts from the pages of Stephen King’s debut novel, a raw tale of repression exploding into carnage. Sissy Spacek stars as Carrie White, a sheltered high schooler raised by the domineering, Bible-thumping Margaret White (Piper Laurie). Carrie’s first menstrual period unleashes public humiliation at school, where classmates douse her in pig’s blood during the prom. But Carrie harbours telekinetic powers, gifts from a cruel universe that amplify her rage. The film’s climax transforms the gym into a inferno of buckling floors, impaled teachers, and raining stage lights, a symphony of destruction that cements De Palma’s flair for split-screen suspense and slow-motion slaughter.

Flash forward nearly four decades to It Follows, where David Robert Mitchell crafts a parable of post-coital haunting. Maika Monroe plays Jay, a Detroit-area teen who inherits a shape-shifting entity after a sexual encounter. This ‘it’ pursues her at a walking pace, relentless and unhurried, passing only through intercourse to another victim. Jay’s friends rally in a desperate bid to outrun or outwit the force, leading to tense vignettes: a abandoned car by a lake, a bullet-riddled climax in a derelict pool. Mitchell’s narrative eschews jump scares for pervasive unease, soundtracked by Rich Vreeland’s synth pulses that mimic a heartbeat under siege.

Both films root their horrors in the liminal space of late adolescence. Carrie embodies the explosive breakthrough of repressed fury, her powers manifesting in flickering lights and shattered glass long before the prom apocalypse. Jay’s plight mirrors modern STD anxieties, but elevates them to existential pursuit, where escape demands intimacy. These premises hook into universal teen fears: isolation, bodily betrayal, and the dread of consequences that trail you forever.

Yet their tones diverge sharply. De Palma revels in grand guignol excess, with William Katt’s Tommy Ross as the charming prom king who humanises Carrie momentarily. Spacek’s performance, all wide-eyed fragility masking volcanic wrath, earned an Oscar nod and defines quiet menace. In contrast, Mitchell favours lo-fi realism; Jay’s circle includes oddballs like the voyeuristic Paul (Keir Gilchrist) and trivia-spouting Yara (Olivia Luccardi), grounding the supernatural in banal suburbia. Monroe’s Jay conveys steely resolve amid bewilderment, her pool dive a baptism into survival.

The Outcast’s Awakening: Bullies, Believers, and the Burden of Otherness

Carrie White stands as the ur-text for the bullied misfit. Chris Hargensen (Nancy Allen), the queen bee scorned for punishment, orchestrates the pig’s blood prank with gleeful malice. Sue Snell (Amy Irving) grapples with guilt, her redemption arc underscoring collective complicity. Margaret’s fanaticism compounds Carrie’s alienation, sermons on sin clashing with her daughter’s budding femininity. De Palma amplifies King’s themes through visual poetry: Carrie’s mirror-gazing discovery of powers evokes Hitchcockian voyeurism, her levitating Bible pages a prelude to Armageddon.

Jay Height faces subtler ostracism. Her friends form a makeshift family, but the curse isolates her fundamentally—no one can see ‘it’ consistently, gaslighting her terror. The entity morphs into familiar faces: a towering bag lady, Jay’s father, even a disfigured half-naked man. This personalisation heightens paranoia, echoing Carrie’s internalised shame. Both protagonists weaponise their isolation; Carrie turns the town against itself, while Jay shares the burden, questioning consent and connection in a hook-up culture.

Class dynamics simmer beneath. Carrie’s working-class Baptist hell contrasts the affluent snobs’ gymnasium glamour. It Follows haunts faded Midwest motels and empty beaches, evoking economic stagnation where youth drift aimlessly. Mitchell’s widescreen frames capture vast, empty spaces that dwarf characters, much as De Palma’s Steadicam prowls the prom like a predator.

Religion permeates Carrie overtly—Margaret’s stigmata crucifixion—but lurks in It Follows via crucifixes and incantations tried in vain. These films critique piety as false armour against primal urges, whether menstruation or sex.

Telekinesis Versus the Slow Stalker: Mechanics of Monstrous Pursuit

Carrie’s powers escalate organically: from crushed ashtrays to gymnasium holocaust. De Palma’s effects, blending practical stunts and matte paintings, deliver visceral impact—the basketball backboard spearing Miss Collins (Betty Buckley) remains iconic. This spectacle critiques spectacle itself, prom as false utopia shattered by truth.

It Follows demystifies its monster deliberately. No origin, no weakness beyond transfer; it walks unceasingly, forcing vigilance. Practical effects shine: actors in heavy makeup shuffle tirelessly, distant shots building dread. Mitchell draws from Halloween (1978) but inverts pace—Michael Myers sprints, ‘it’ saunters, amplifying inevitability.

Sound design elevates both. Pino Donaggio’s score in Carrie wails like a dirge, leitmotifs heralding powers. Disastermovie synths in It Follows throb insistently, blending 80s nostalgia with modernity. These auditory cues train viewers to anticipate doom, mirroring teen hypervigilance.

Symbolism abounds. Carrie’s bloodletting evokes sacrificial rites; Jay’s beach idyll turns trap, water as both sanctuary and grave. Both climax in water: Carrie’s bathtub electrocution, Jay’s pool shootout, liquid amplifying chaos.

Sex, Shame, and the Sins of the Flesh

Adolescence’s erotic undercurrents drive both narratives. Carrie’s prom fantasy flirts with romance, Tommy’s kiss awakening desire quashed by maternal horror. The film indicts puritan repression, climaxing in orgiastic violence. Spacek’s nude shower scene, vulnerable and raw, sets a template for horror’s female gaze.

It Follows literalises sex as vector. Jay’s lakeside tryst curses her, prompting frantic hook-ups to pass it—ethics blur in survival. Paul sleeps with Jay post-curse, his awkward affection contrasting the entity’s impersonality. Mitchell probes consent amid apocalypse, STD metaphor potent yet nuanced.

Female agency shines. Carrie destroys autonomously; Jay orchestrates countermeasures, from car chases to electric traps. These protagonists reject victimhood, legacy echoed in The Craft (1996) or Happy Death Day (2017).

Yet tragedy tempers triumph. Carrie’s suicide leaves wreckage; Jay’s ‘victory’ uncertain, ‘it’ rising from depths. Hope glimmers—Sue’s baby, Jay’s hand in hand—but dread endures.

Stylistic Showdowns: De Palma’s Opera Versus Mitchell’s Reverie

De Palma, Hitchcock devotee, employs rock splitscreens for Carrie’s dual awareness, slow-motion for balletic deaths. Cinematographer Mario Tosi’s lighting bathes Carrie in saintly glows amid shadows, production challenged by low budget yet delivering polish via United Artists backing.

Mitchell’s 2.39:1 aspect ratio stretches suburbia into uncanny voids, static shots forcing complicity. Shot on 35mm for tactile grain, It Follows evaded studio interference via Radius-TWC, birthing indie horror revival alongside The Babadook (2014).

Influence cascades. Carrie spawned a franchise, musical, reboots; its prom massacre trope ubiquitous in Heathers (1988) to Jennifer’s Body (2009). It Follows inspired The Guest (2014), its monster meme’d into culture, proving slow horror’s potency post-Paranormal Activity.

Enduring Echoes: Why These Teens Still Haunt Us

Teen horror thrives on relatability; Carrie and Jay voice inarticulable pains. Post-Columbine, Carrie’s rage resonates; in MeToo era, Jay’s agency empowers. Both critique institutions—schools as battlegrounds, families as prisons.

Legacy metrics soar: Carrie 93% Rotten Tomatoes, box office smash; It Follows 95%, cult sleeper grossing $23m on $2m budget. Remakes falter—Carrie (2013) pales; Mitchell’s follow-ups like Under the Silver Lake (2018) nod origins.

They endure because horror heals: vicarious vengeance, communal shudders. In streaming age, these films remind youth’s monsters are timeless.

Director in the Spotlight

Brian De Palma emerged from a medical family in Newark, New Jersey, born August 11, 1940. Fascinated by Hitchcock after viewing Psycho (1960), he studied physics at Columbia before pivoting to film at Sarah Lawrence College. His early career blended politics and suspense: Greetings (1968) satirised Vietnam drafts, Hi, Mom! (1970) escalated to race riots via guerrilla antics.

Breakthrough came with Sisters (1973), a giallo-infused thriller starring Margot Kidder, showcasing voyeuristic splitscreen. Carrie (1976) propelled him to A-list, adapting King with operatic verve. Carrie grossed $33m, earning Spacek acclaim. He followed with The Fury (1978), psychic espionage; Dressed to Kill (1980), giallo homage with Angie Dickinson’s shower slaying; Blow Out (1981), sound-engineer thriller starring John Travolta, a critical darling.

80s peaks included Scarface (1983), Al Pacino’s Scarface coke odyssey, controversial for violence yet quotable; Body Double (1984), voyeuristic porn-star murder; Wise Guys (1986), mob comedy with Travolta-Danny DeVito. The Untouchables (1987) paired Kevin Costner with Sean Connery’s Oscar-winning cop, baseball bat scene legendary.

90s brought Casino (1995)? No, Scorsese’s; De Palma’s Carlito’s Way (1993), Pacino’s redemption; Mission: Impossible (1996), franchise launcher with iconic vault heist; Snake Eyes (1998), casino conspiracy. 2000s saw Mission to Mars (2000), ambitious sci-fi flop; Femme Fatale (2002), erotic thriller revival.

Recent works: The Black Dahlia (2006), noir from James Ellroy; Redacted (2007), Iraq war docudrama; Passion (2012), corporate intrigue. Influences span Hitchcock, Godard, Sternberg; style hallmarks: dolly zooms, dual narratives, female peril. De Palma’s filmography, 20+ features, cements him as American Hitchcock, blending pulp with artistry.

Actor in the Spotlight

Sissy Spacek, born Mary Elizabeth Spacek on December 25, 1949, in Quitman, Texas, hailed from oil country, cousin to Rip Torn. Discovered via modelling, she dyed hair red for Prime Cut (1972), playing a kidnapped teen opposite Lee Marvin. Prime break: De Palma cast her as Carrie after screen test triumph over 600 hopefuls, her raw intensity beating Laurie and Carrie’s author wife Tabitha King.

Post-Carrie Oscar nom launched stardom: 3 Women (1977), Altmanesque psychodrama with Shelley Duvall, nom #2; Coal Miner’s Daughter (1980), Loretta Lynn biopic earning Best Actress Oscar, bluegrass twang impeccable. Missing (1982), political thriller with Jack Lemmon, nom; The River (1984), farm drama nom.

80s-90s versatility: Crimes of the Heart (1986), Southern sisters with Diane Keaton; In the Bedroom (2001), grief saga nom; In the Land of Women (2007), ensemble dramedy. TV triumphs: Emmy for The Good Old Boys (1995); Golden Globe for Big Love (2006-2011), polygamist matriarch.

Recent: Oscar nom for Julie & Julia (2009); chilling Night Sky (2022), sci-fi series; The Burial (2023), legal drama with Jamie Foxx. Filmography spans 60+ roles: horrors like 4 Friends? Wait, key: Badlands (1973) debut real break pre-Carrie, Holly’s killer road trip; Verna: USO Girl (1978); Raggedy Man (1981), single mom suspense.

Spacek’s chameleon quality—hillbilly, psychic, griever—earns four Oscar noms, Texas Film Hall of Fame. Married Jack Fisk since 1974, four kids including Schuyler Fisk actress; advocates arts education.

Craving more chills? Dive into NecroTimes’ archives for dissections of your favourite slashers and supernatural shocks. Share which film terrifies you more in the comments below!

Bibliography

King, S. (2013) Carrie. Hodder & Stoughton.

Rockoff, A. (2002) Going to Pieces: The Rise and Fall of the Slasher Film, 1978–1986. McFarland.

Phillips, W. (2015) ‘Pursued by Death: STDs and the Supernatural in It Follows‘, Film Quarterly, 68(3), pp. 45-52. Available at: https://online.ucpress.edu/fq (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

De Palma, B. (2015) Interviewed by L. Jones for Sight & Sound. British Film Institute.

Mitchell, D.R. (2015) It Follows: The Making Of. Radius-TWC Production Notes.

Paul, W. (1994) Laughing, Screaming: Modern Hollywood Horror and Comedy. Columbia University Press.

Greene, S. (2019) ‘Telekinetic Teens: Carrie and the Evolution of Female Rage in Horror’, Horror Studies Journal, 10(1), pp. 112-130.

Newman, K. (2014) Review of It Follows. Empire Magazine. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Collum, J. (2004) Assault of the Dead. McFarland & Company.