In 1981, two films clawed their way from the shadows of Hollywood, pitting savage lycanthropy against mordant wit. Which werewolf epic still sends chills down the spine?

1981 stands as a landmark year for werewolf cinema, when Joe Dante’s The Howling and John Landis’s An American Werewolf in London burst onto screens, blending horror with humour in unprecedented ways. Both films revitalised a sagging subgenre, drawing on folklore while embracing practical effects and social satire. This comparison dissects their narratives, techniques, and legacies, revealing why they remain cornerstones of shape-shifting terror.

  • Contrasting tones: The Howling‘s campy cult frenzy versus An American Werewolf in London‘s poignant black comedy.
  • Effects revolutions: Groundbreaking transformations that set new standards for body horror.
  • Enduring influence: How these films reshaped werewolf lore and inspired generations of filmmakers.

Moonlit Origins: The Pack Forms

The genesis of The Howling traces back to a turbulent Hollywood landscape in the late 1970s. Producer Michael Finlerberg acquired rights to Gary Brandner’s novel after its modest success, envisioning a tale of hidden werewolves infiltrating society. Joe Dante, fresh from cult hits like Piranha, was tapped to direct, infusing the project with his signature irreverence. Scriptwriter John Sayles layered in references to real-life cults and psychotherapy fads, turning the story into a multifaceted allegory. Filming unfolded in California, with key interiors shot on practical sets mimicking a secluded coastal retreat called "The Colony." Budget constraints spurred ingenuity, particularly in effects overseen by Rob Bottin, whose designs would eclipse contemporaries.

Meanwhile, An American Werewolf in London emerged from John Landis’s personal obsessions. Inspired by a backpacking trip across the Yorkshire moors, Landis penned the script in 1969, shelving it until Universal greenlit it over a decade later. He aimed to merge American innocence with British folklore, drawing from Dracula and Hammer Horror traditions. Production spanned London and the Pennines, capturing authentic fog-shrouded landscapes. Landis’s insistence on practical effects led to Rick Baker’s involvement, forging a partnership that birthed cinema’s most iconic werewolf metamorphosis. Both films arrived amid a post-Exorcist boom in creature features, yet they subverted expectations by wedding gore to guffaws.

These origins highlight divergent paths: Dante’s film as a product of New World Pictures’ low-budget ambition, Landis’s as a Universal-backed passion project. Yet shared timing—premiering mere months apart—sparked a friendly rivalry, with each acknowledging the other’s innovations. Dante later quipped that Landis’s film "stole our thunder," though both capitalised on pent-up demand for lupine lore.

Feral Narratives: Chasing the Beast Within

The Howling opens with television reporter Karen White venturing into a sleazy porn booth to confront serial killer Eddie Quist, only to trigger a traumatic blackout. Escaping narrowly, she retreats to the Colony, a commune led by Dr. George Waggner, where residents harbour a shocking secret: they are werewolves suppressing their urges through therapy. As full moons rise, Karen uncovers the pack’s plan to unleash lycanthropy on humanity, culminating in a fiery showdown blending slapstick with savagery. Performances shine, particularly Dee Wallace as the fraying Karen, whose arc from victim to vengeful warrior mirrors feminist awakenings.

In contrast, An American Werewolf in London follows backpackers David Kessler and Jack Goodman, attacked by a moorland beast. Jack perishes gruesomely, haunting David as a decaying spectre in dreams and waking life. Confined to a London hospital, David grapples with lycanthropy, his transformation exploding in a flat under Rick Baker’s mastery. Nurse Alex Price offers solace amid blackout rampages, but David’s inevitable change forces a Piccadilly Circus bloodbath before marksmen end his torment. Griffin Dunne’s posthumous comic turn as Jack steals scenes, underscoring themes of mortality and mateship.

Narratively, The Howling sprawls into ensemble horror, populating The Colony with eccentric werewolves like the diminutive Marcia or the hulking T.C. This communal focus evokes Invasion of the Body Snatchers, positing lycanthropy as viral conformity. Werewolf, however, tightens on David’s solitary descent, evoking Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde in its psychological intimacy. Both dissect transformation as sexual metaphor—Karen’s ordeal laced with orgasmic undertones, David’s with frustrated virility—yet Dante leans conspiratorial, Landis existential.

Key scenes amplify distinctions. The Howling’s booth encounter pulses with voyeuristic dread, Quist’s wolfish leer shattering Karen’s psyche. Werewolf’s moors attack deploys fog and silence masterfully, the beast’s silhouette a primal silhouette against stars. Transformations serve as climaxes: Bottin’s in The Howling favour elastic, cartoonish elongation, while Baker’s in Werewolf prioritises visceral realism, Naughton’s screams grounding the agony.

Effects Under the Full Moon: A Practical Revolution

Special effects anchor both films’ immortality, with The Howling showcasing Rob Bottin’s prodigious talent. At 21, Bottin crafted animatronics like the wolf-mannequin hybrid in the finale, blending latex appliances with pneumatic mechanisms for fluid shifts. Karen’s climactic change employs reverse footage and prosthetics, her jaw unhinging in a cascade of saliva and fangs. Dante’s meta touches—werewolves watching The Wolf Man—nod to history while parodying it. These effects, though ambitious, occasionally veer whimsical, aligning with the film’s tongue-in-cheek vibe.

Rick Baker’s work in An American Werewolf in London redefined the benchmark. David’s bathroom metamorphosis unfolds in real time: Naughton moulded into position nightly, Baker layering foam appliances cured with heat for muscle-ripping realism. The sequence, shot in one take, captures dermal tears and limb extensions with unprecedented fidelity, earning Baker his first Oscar. Subsequent wolf form, a towering furred abomination, rampages via stop-motion and puppetry, marrying horror to pathos.

Comparing techniques reveals paradigms. Bottin’s designs emphasise multiplicity—a werewolf orgy, TV newscasts of changes—pushing quantity. Baker’s singular focus achieves qualitative depth, influencing The Thing and beyond. Both shunned early CGI precursors, committing to practicals that aged gracefully, unlike digital wolves in later fare.

Production anecdotes underscore dedication. Bottin suffered health issues from marathon sessions, while Baker endured Naughton’s discomfort, forging bonds amid gore. These efforts not only terrified audiences but elevated effects artistry, proving lycanthropy ripe for innovation.

Tones in the Night: Laughs Amid the Lupine

Tone delineates the duo starkly. The Howling revels in camp, from Dick Miller’s gun-shop rants to werewolf erotica nods. Dante peppers sight gags—a transforming newscaster birthing pups on air—balancing scares with satire on media sensationalism and self-help cults. This playfulness anticipates Gremlins, positioning horror as farce.

Werewolf tempers humour with melancholy. Jack’s nude hospital visits and porno-dream sequences elicit grins, yet David’s isolation pervades. Landis draws from Ealing comedies and Hammer pathos, crafting a requiem for lost youth. The blend peaks in David’s flat plea: "I will not endanger anyone," undercut by inevitable doom.

Such contrasts reflect directors’ sensibilities: Dante’s pop-culture collage versus Landis’s narrative restraint. Both innovate by humanising monsters, yet Howling‘s pack dynamics foster communal mirth, Werewolf‘s solitude breeds tragic laughs.

Thematic Bites: Society’s Hidden Fangs

Beyond scares, both probe repression. The Howling skewers 1980s California wellness culture, Waggner’s therapy masking primal urges. Lycanthropy symbolises unleashed id, commenting on sexual liberation amid AIDS fears. Karen’s empowerment arc critiques victimhood tropes.

Werewolf explores American abroad naivety, David’s curse a Vietnam-era loss-of-innocence parable. Jack’s gallows wit confronts mortality, while moors folklore nods to rural-urban divides. Gender roles surface too: Alex’s agency contrasts passive damsels.

Influence permeates. Howling spawned seven sequels, its Colony motif echoing in The Faculty. Werewolf birthed Landis’s monster trilogy, impacting Twilight and Underworld. Together, they supplanted Universal’s stoic wolves with multifaceted beasts.

Legacy endures in festivals and restorations. Both enjoy cult status, their effects tributes in museums. They proved werewolves viable post-Jaws, blending genres fruitfully.

Censorship battles honed edges: Howling trimmed guts for UK release, Werewolf its wolfman close-ups. These skirmishes amplified notoriety, cementing midnight screening staples.

Director in the Spotlight

Joe Dante, born November 28, 1946, in Morristown, New Jersey, emerged from a film-obsessed youth, devouring monster magazines and B-movies. Graduating from the University of Southern California film school, he honed skills editing trailers for Roger Corman before co-directing Hollywood Boulevard (1976), a meta-exploitation lark. Piranha (1978) showcased his satirical bite, skewering Jaws with genetically altered fish.

The Howling (1981) propelled him mainstream, blending horror homage with social jabs. Dante followed with Gremlins (1984), a blockbuster yuletide terror spawning merchandised mayhem. Innerspace (1987) ventured sci-fi comedy, starring Dennis Quaid miniaturised inside Martin Short. The Gremlins sequel Gremlins 2: The New Batch (1990) amplified chaos in a Trump Tower parody.

Further highlights include The ‘Burbs (1989), a suburban paranoia romp with Tom Hanks probing neighbours; Matinee (1993), a nostalgic Corman tribute set during the Cuban Missile Crisis; and Small Soldiers (1998), toy warfare critiquing militarism. Dante directed episodes of Eerie, Indiana (1991-1992), The Phantom (1996 serial), and Looney Tunes: Back in Action (2003), reviving cartoons with live-action flair.

Later works encompass Explorers (1985, troubled sci-fi kids adventure), Innerspace producer credits, and The Hole (2009), a dimensional dread chamber. Influenced by Looney Tunes and Ray Harryhausen, Dante champions practical effects and political allegory. Awards include Saturn nods; he remains active in documentaries like The Moviemakers (2000s series) and restorations, a genre custodian.

Comprehensive filmography: Hollywood Boulevard (1976, co-dir.); Piranha (1978); The Howling (1981); Gremlins (1984); Innerspace (1987); The ‘Burbs (1989); Gremlins 2 (1990); Matinee (1993); Small Soldiers (1998); Looney Tunes: Back in Action (2003); The Hole (2009); plus TV like Amazing Stories ("The Family Dog," 1987).

Actor in the Spotlight

David Naughton, born February 13, 1951, in Hartford, Connecticut, cut his teeth in musical theatre, starring in Broadway’s Hair and London’s Oh! Calcutta! before TV’s Makin’ It (1979), a disco sitcom. An American Werewolf in London (1981) catapulted him, his agonised transformation etching body horror annals.

Post-werewolf, Naughton navigated genre: Hot Dog… The Movie (1984) ski slasher; Separate Vacations (1986) rom-com; Overnight (1986) comedy. TV credits abound: Growing Pains, MacGyver, Melrose Place. Horror resurged with Shark Attack (1999), Wild Horses (2008), and voicework in Demonic Toys (2010).

Notable roles include Into the Fire (1988), a Gulf War drama; The Sleeping Car (1990) ghost train; Body Bags (1993) anthology cadaver. Theatre persisted, with regional Grease and Chicago. No major awards, yet cult acclaim endures; he emcees horror cons.

Filmography highlights: Midnight Madness (1980); An American Werewolf in London (1981); Hot Dog… The Movie (1984); Not for Publication (1984); Separate Vacations (1986); Overnight (1986); Body Bags (1993); Urban Legend (1998); Shark Attack (1999); Wild Horses (2008); plus myriad TV guest spots across Seinfeld, 3rd Rock from the Sun.

Recent ventures include Clown Town (2016) and podcasts, his boy-next-door charm undimmed.

Craving more monstrous matchups? Dive into NecroTimes’ archive of horror showdowns and subscribe for the latest chills!

Bibliography

Brown, D. (2005) Werewolf Cinema: A Companion Guide. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/werewolf-cinema/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Harper, J. (2004) Legacy of Blood: A Comprehensive Guide to Slasher Movies. Manchester University Press.

Landis, J. (1981) ‘An American Werewolf in London: Director’s Commentary’. Universal Pictures DVD Edition.

Meehan, P. (1998) Sauchorrorific!: A Century of Sexy, Scary, and Campy Slasher Cinema. Midnight Marquee Press.

Nutman, P. (1989) ‘Rob Bottin: Master of the Macabre’. Fangoria, 82, pp. 20-25.

Phillips, J. (2012) ‘Shape-Shifters: The Evolution of Werewolf Effects’. Sight & Sound, 22(5), pp. 34-38. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-sound (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Savini, T. (2006) Grande Illusions II: Effects and Makeup Masterclass. Imagine Books.

Warren, J. (1983) Keep Watching the Skies! American Science Fiction Movies of 1958. McFarland. [Adapted for 1980s context].

Woods, P. (2007) ‘Joe Dante: King of the Bs’. Empire, 214, pp. 112-115. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com (Accessed: 15 October 2023).