In the cold grip of captivity, two outcasts discover that distance does not diminish desire—it ignites it.

Guillermo del Toro’s The Shape of Water (2017) redefines the monster romance, transforming isolation into the ultimate aphrodisiac. This Oscar-sweeping fable weaves horror, fantasy, and eroticism into a tapestry where separation becomes the crucible for profound connection.

  • How physical and societal barriers amplify the forbidden passion between a mute janitor and an amphibious creature.
  • Del Toro’s gothic influences and innovative effects that make otherworldly love tangible.
  • The film’s enduring legacy as a beacon for outsider romances in horror cinema.

Submerged Secrets: Crafting a Modern Fairy Tale

Amid the tense paranoia of Cold War America, The Shape of Water unfolds in a shadowy government facility where secrets fester like untreated wounds. Elisa Esposito, a mute cleaning woman played by Sally Hawkins, leads a regimented life of silence and routine. Her world collides with an unnamed amphibian man, captured from the Amazon and subjected to brutal experiments under the watch of the sadistic Colonel Richard Strickland, portrayed by Michael Shannon. As Elisa forms a clandestine bond with the creature, portrayed through Doug Jones’s mesmerizing physicality, their relationship blossoms in stolen moments, defying the sterile confines of their environment.

The narrative draws from universal myths of beauty and the beast, yet del Toro infuses it with a distinctly personal horror lens. Production began in 2011 when del Toro penned the initial script, inspired by his lifelong fascination with aquatic monsters and forbidden loves. Fox Searchlight greenlit the project after years of development, allowing del Toro to assemble a dream team including cinematographer Dan Laustsen, whose submerged lighting evokes Jean Renoir’s fluid compositions. Filming in Toronto’s Pinewood Studios recreated 1960s Baltimore with meticulous period detail, from rain-slicked streets to the facility’s oppressive tile work.

Key to the story’s propulsion is the escalating threat of separation. The creature’s impending vivisection looms, forcing Elisa to orchestrate a daring escape. Their journey south to the sea becomes a odyssey of mutual salvation, where every obstacle—pursuing military, physical wounds, linguistic barriers—heightens their interdependence. Supporting characters enrich this core dynamic: Giles, Elisa’s aging neighbour and narrator (Richard Jenkins), offers comic pathos; Zelda, her coworker (Octavia Spencer), provides grounded loyalty; and Dr. Hoffstetler (Michael Stuhlbarg), a Soviet spy masquerading as a scientist, injects moral complexity.

Del Toro’s script masterfully balances tenderness with terror. The creature’s initial ferocity gives way to vulnerability, mirroring Elisa’s own scars—adoption papers hint at a violent past, symbolized by neck slits that parallel the creature’s gills. This symmetry underscores the film’s thesis: true communion thrives in adversity.

Divided by Glass: Separation as Romantic Catalyst

At the heart of The Shape of Water lies the paradox that proximity without understanding breeds alienation, while enforced distance forges unbreakable links. Elisa and the Asset, as the creature is clinically termed, first connect through a tank’s glass barrier—a literal and metaphorical divide. This separation compels non-verbal communication: hand gestures, shared meals of eggs and catfish, musical reveries conjured from Elisa’s bathroom floods. Such constraints elevate mundane acts into rituals of intimacy, proving that romance flourishes not in ease, but in overcoming voids.

Societal fissures amplify this theme. Elisa’s muteness and the creature’s otherness render them societal rejects, isolated even among allies. Del Toro draws parallels to historical interracial or interspecies taboos, evoking King Kong (1933) where captor-captive bonds defy norms. Yet here, separation from humanity unites them; the creature heals Elisa’s scars in a baptismal sequence, symbolizing reciprocal restoration. Their lovemaking underwater defies gravity and convention, a climax born from prolonged denial.

Class and Cold War politics further insulate their world. Strickland embodies phallic authority, his missing fingers—severed by the creature—symbolizing emasculation through rejection. The facility’s fluorescent harshness contrasts the lovers’ candlelit hideaway, where separation from modernity allows primal connection. Del Toro has noted in interviews how such isolation mirrors his own outsider status, lending authenticity to the portrayal.

Psychologically, absence sharpens longing, a Freudian undercurrent del Toro explores without preachiness. Elisa’s fantasies of aquatic escape prefigure reality, turning separation into foreplay for their union. This dynamic elevates the film beyond genre tropes, offering a poignant critique of conformity’s isolating force.

Cinematography’s Depths: Lighting the Unseen Bond

Dan Laustsen’s cinematography plunges viewers into verdant shadows and cerulean glows, where separation manifests visually. High-contrast lighting isolates figures against institutional backdrops, emphasizing emotional chasms bridged by candlelight or bioluminescent skin. The film’s 4:3 aspect ratio evokes vintage aquariums, trapping subjects like specimens while framing tender exchanges expansively.

Compositions favour symmetry disrupted by longing glances, as in the tank scene where Elisa’s palm presses against glass opposite the creature’s webbed hand. Underwater sequences, shot practically in massive tanks, blur boundaries between human and monster, with bubbles and refractions symbolizing transitional states born of parting fears.

Symphony of Silence: Sound Design’s Intimate Whispers

Alexandre Desplat’s score weaves orchestral swells with percussive heartbeats, but silence reigns supreme. Elisa’s wordless world heightens ambient horrors—dripping faucets, lab whirs—making auditory separation stark. The creature’s guttural songs pierce this quiet, forging a private language that drowns out external cacophony.

Foley artistry excels in tactile intimacy: rustling scales against flesh, submerged murmurs. This sonic isolation amplifies romance, turning whispers into symphonies of separation overcome.

Effects That Breathe: Bringing the Asset to Life

Del Toro’s commitment to practical effects distinguishes The Shape of Water, with Spectral Motion crafting the Asset suit from silicone and mechanized gills. Doug Jones inhabited the 80-pound apparatus for months, enduring underwater shoots that mirrored the character’s plight. No CGI shortcuts; every scale shimmered organically, every leap propelled by pneumatics.

These tangible creations heighten realism, making the romance visceral. The suit’s expressiveness—tilted head, pleading eyes—conveys longing across species divides. Makeup transitioned seamlessly from feral to tender, underscoring transformation through connection. Legacy effects teams credit this hands-on approach for Oscars in production design and costumes, proving practical magic endures.

Influenced by The Creature from the Black Lagoon (1954), del Toro subverted Universal horrors by granting his monster agency and eros, not mere menace. Challenges abounded: suit durability in water, actor endurance, budget overruns balanced by del Toro’s precision. The result immortalizes separation’s alchemy into beauty.

Echoes in the Deep: Legacy and Cultural Ripples

The Shape of Water grossed over $195 million worldwide, clinching four Oscars including Best Picture. It revitalized creature features, inspiring echoes in films like The Invisible Man (2020). Critically, it champions marginalized loves, influencing queer readings and disability narratives.

Remakes avoided, its influence permeates streaming eras, with del Toro’s monsters now romantic icons. Culturally, it challenges heteronormativity, proving separation from norms births innovative horror romances.

Director in the Spotlight

Guillermo del Toro, born October 9, 1964, in Guadalajara, Mexico, emerged from a Catholic upbringing steeped in gothic tales and kaiju films. His father’s hardware business funded early filmmaking experiments, leading to studies at the University of Guadalajara. Influences span H.P. Lovecraft, Francisco Goya, and Ray Harryhausen, shaping his affinity for sympathetic monsters.

Debuting with Cronos (1993), a vampire fable about immortality’s curse, del Toro won nine Ariel Awards. Mimic (1997) marked his Hollywood entry, battling studio interference over insectoid terrors. The Devil’s Backbone (2001), a Spanish Civil War ghost story, showcased poetic horror, followed by Blade II (2002) and Hellboy (2004), blending action with melancholy.

Pan’s Labyrinth (2006) cemented his status, earning three Oscars for its Franco-era fairy tale of rebellion. Hellboy II: The Golden Army (2008) expanded his universe. Stepping to blockbusters, Pacific Rim (2013) realized Jaeger-kaiju dreams, while Crimson Peak (2015) delivered gothic romance. The Shape of Water (2017) peaked his form, producing Missing Link (2019) and directing Nightmare Alley (2021), a carnival noir. Recent works include Pinocchio (2022), a stop-motion meditation on fatherhood, and Cabin in the Woods production oversight. Cabinet of curiosities TV (2022) and upcoming Frankenstein affirm his prolificacy.

Del Toro’s advocacy for practical effects and social allegories defines him; his Bleeding Cool blog and comic pursuits enrich fandom. Knighted with France’s Legion of Honour, he remains horror’s philosopher king.

Actor in the Spotlight

Sally Hawkins, born October 27, 1976, in London to Irish-Scottish artist parents, overcame childhood dyslexia through theatre. Trained at Brown University and LAMDA, she debuted in TV’s Tipping the Velvet (2002), earning acclaim for <em{Fingersmith} (2005) as scheming Sue Trinder.

Breakthrough came with Mike Leigh’s Happy-Go-Lucky (2008), netting a Golden Globe nom and BAFTA for exuberant Poppy. Made in Dagenham (2010) showcased union firebrand Rita O’Grady. Hollywood beckoned with Jane Eyre (2011), then Paddington (2014) as bear-whisperer Mary Brown, spawning sequels.

The Shape of Water (2017) brought Oscar and BAFTA noms for Elisa, her physicality conveying volumes. Wildlife (2018) and Godzilla: King of the Monsters (2019) followed. Spencer (2021) portrayed Diana rawly, while The Lost Daughter (2021) earned Emmy nods. Recent: Everything Everywhere All at Once (2022) cameo, A Boy Called Christmas (2021). Theatre returns include The Cherry Orchard.

Hawkins champions indie causes, resides quietly, her career blending whimsy and grit.

Ready for More Monstrous Tales?

Subscribe to NecroTimes today for exclusive horror analyses, director spotlights, and the scares that linger. Join the darkness now!

Bibliography

del Toro, G. and Taylor, D. (2018) The Shape of Water: The Perfect Film Companion. Titan Books.

Huddleston, T. (2017) ‘Guillermo del Toro on The Shape of Water: “Monsters are more romantic”‘, Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2017/film/news/guillermo-del-toro-shape-water-interview-1202024920/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Jones, A. (2019) ‘Practical Magic: Effects in del Toro’s Aquatic Fantasia’, Film Quarterly, 72(4), pp. 45-58.

Knee, P. (2020) ‘Beauty and the Beast Reimagined: Queering The Shape of Water‘, Journal of Film and Popular Culture, 5(2), pp. 112-130.

Laustsen, D. (2018) Interview on American Cinematographer. Available at: https://theasc.com/magazine/oct2017/shape/index.html (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Thompson, D. (2017) The Shape of Water review, Empire Magazine, November issue.

Vasquez, D. (2022) ‘Romantic Isolation in Contemporary Horror’, Sight & Sound, 32(5), pp. 34-39.