In the flickering glow of a cursed camcorder, an urban legend claws its way from folklore into raw, unrelenting reality.
Butterfly Kisses (2018) stands as a haunting testament to the found footage subgenre’s enduring power, transforming a local Pennsylvania myth into a visceral nightmare that blurs the line between tall tale and tangible terror. Directed by Erik Kristopher Myers, this micro-budget gem captures the primal fear of the unknown lurking in abandoned woods, where every rustle and shadow hides a deeper malice.
- Unravelling the insidious urban legend of the Butterfly Kisses Killer and its roots in real-world folklore.
- Dissecting the masterful deployment of found footage aesthetics to amplify authenticity and dread.
- Tracing the film’s psychological ripples through horror cinema and its subtle critique of voyeurism in the digital age.
The Mythology of Midnight Kisses
At the heart of Butterfly Kisses pulses an urban legend whispered among the backwoods communities of Clarion County, Pennsylvania: the Butterfly Kisses Killer. This spectral figure, a gaunt woman glimpsed only in fleeting night visions, allegedly murders her victims by smothering them with peculiar bruises beneath their eyes, mimicking the delicate imprint of butterfly wings. The film opens with this lore, presented through a mosaic of amateur footage compiled posthumously, as if pieced together by a doomed archivist desperate to expose the truth. Investigators, led by a ragtag crew of urban explorers and paranormal enthusiasts, venture into the dense forests near Cook Forest State Park, armed with handheld cameras and a reckless curiosity.
The narrative unfolds in layers, mimicking the fragmented nature of viral internet scares. Early sequences introduce the team stumbling upon eerie relics: discarded VHS tapes etched with cryptic markings, abandoned trailers riddled with occult symbols, and Polaroids depicting wide-eyed figures frozen in agony. As they delve deeper, the legend manifests through Ah-na, a feral young woman embodying the killer’s essence. Her presence shifts from apparition to antagonist, her pale face smeared with dirt and malice, whispering incantations that summon gusts of unnatural wind. Myers constructs the plot with meticulous restraint, allowing the myth to metastasise organically from hearsay to horror.
Key to the synopsis is the film’s temporal dislocation. Footage spans decades, intercutting 1990s camcorder clips with modern smartphone recordings, suggesting a curse perpetuated across generations. The crew uncovers evidence of prior expeditions—rival filmmakers vanished years earlier, their screams echoing from rusted hard drives. This recursive structure evokes real found footage precedents, where discovery begets doom. Production notes reveal Myers drew from Pennsylvania’s rich tapestry of ghost stories, including the Mothman-like sightings and Native American lore of forest spirits, grounding the supernatural in regional authenticity.
The climax erupts in a frenzy of handheld chaos, as Ah-na’s ritualistic pursuits corner the protagonists amid thorny underbrush. Victims succumb not to gore but to suffocating visions, their final frames capturing butterfly imprints blooming like bruises. Myers avoids cheap jump scares, favouring atmospheric escalation: distant howls morph into human cries, fireflies swarm in unnatural patterns, and the camera’s battery drains at pivotal moments, symbolising encroaching oblivion.
Found Footage’s Fractured Lens
Butterfly Kisses exemplifies found footage’s evolution beyond Blair Witch Project (1999) gimmickry, wielding the format as a scalpel for psychological incision. The film’s verisimilitude stems from its adherence to amateur production values: shaky pans, battery-death blackouts, and audio dropouts that mimic genuine peril. Myers, a veteran of the subgenre through acting roles in V/H/S segments, calibrates every frame to feel illicitly obtained, as if viewers trespass on private damnation.
Cinematography, courtesy of a collaborative effort among cast and crew doubling as operators, employs natural lighting—moonlight filtering through canopy, flashlight beams carving grotesque silhouettes. This low-fi approach heightens immersion; audiences strain alongside characters to discern shapes in the gloom. Influences from Cannibal Holocaust (1980) abound, yet Myers infuses modern irony: smartphones capture clearer horrors, only to glitch under spectral interference, critiquing our addiction to documentation amid chaos.
Sound design emerges as the true virtuoso, with layers of foley—twigs snapping like bones, wind mimicking laboured breaths—building unbearable tension. Diegetic audio dominates, unpolished and intimate, punctuated by Ah-na’s guttural chants derived from Pennsylvania Dutch hex signs. Critics praise this auditory realism for evoking ASMR turned malevolent, where whispers burrow into the subconscious long after viewing.
The format’s meta-commentary shines in sequences where characters review their own footage, spotting anomalies invisible in real-time. This self-referential loop questions reality’s fabric, positing the camera as both saviour and curse-bearer. In an era of TikTok hauntings, Butterfly Kisses anticipates how legends proliferate online, their authenticity eroded yet potency amplified.
Ah-na: Embodiment of Primal Fury
IF Whitney Lewis delivers a tour de force as Ah-na, transforming a mythic archetype into a multifaceted terror. Emerging from the treeline like a wraith, her portrayal fuses feral instinct with poignant vulnerability—eyes hollowed by isolation, movements a blend of animal grace and ritual rigidity. Lewis, drawing from method immersion in local woods, imbues Ah-na with authenticity born of physical endurance: hours smeared in mud, enduring Pennsylvania’s biting cold to capture unscripted ferocity.
Character analysis reveals Ah-na as more than monster; she symbolises repressed communal guilt. Legends portray her as a scorned outcast, perhaps a victim of 1980s satanic panic hysteria, her “kisses” a vengeful perversion of maternal affection. Scenes of her stalking prey dissect voyeurism’s ethics: the crew’s lenses objectify her, mirroring audience complicity. Lewis’s physicality—contorted dances under starlight—evokes possession films like The Exorcist (1973), yet rooted in folk horror traditions.
Motivational arcs pivot on revelation footage: Ah-na’s origin as a lost child, corrupted by woodland entities. This humanises without softening, culminating in a confrontation where empathy fractures under survival imperative. Performances around her, including Myers as the obsessive filmmaker, amplify dynamics; their descent parallels Ah-na’s ascent, blurring hunter and hunted.
Shadows and Symbols: Visual Alchemy
Mise-en-scène in Butterfly Kisses weaponises the ordinary into omen. Decaying cabins festooned with moth-eaten quilts, rusted swing sets creaking in void, and fire pits ringed by concentric stones form a sigil of entrapment. Lighting schemes—harsh LED flares against perpetual twilight—cast elongated shadows that presage Ah-na’s form, employing negative space for dread.
Symbolism abounds: butterflies, absent yet omnipresent in nomenclature, represent fleeting innocence crushed by nature’s cruelty. Bruise motifs recur, from victims’ faces to mottled leaves, tying personal horror to ecological decay. Comparisons to Midsommar (2019) illuminate shared pagan undercurrents, though Butterfly Kisses remains earthbound, scorning daylight rituals for nocturnal hauntings.
Editing mimics archival frenzy: nonlinear inserts disrupt chronology, fostering paranoia. Jump cuts within long takes simulate tape degradation, eroding temporal trust. This technique, honed in post-production marathons, elevates the film beyond peers, earning festival nods for technical innovation.
Echoes Through the Canopy: Sound and Fury
Audio craftsmanship distinguishes Butterfly Kisses, where silence screams loudest. Ambient forest nocturnes—owls hooting in dissonant harmony, leaves hissing like serpents—establish baseline unease. Ah-na’s vocalisations, layered with subharmonics, induce physiological responses, akin to infrasound experiments in horror soundscapes.
Foley artistry replicates intimacy: footsteps squelching in loam, breaths ragged with exertion. Music sparsity yields to percussion—heartbeats thundering via contact mics—mirroring Blair Witch’s restraint. Post-production enhanced these with field recordings from Clarion woods, authenticating the sonic terror.
The film’s climax unleashes cacophony: overlapping screams, camera impacts, and ethereal wails converge, overwhelming senses. This auditory overload critiques media saturation, where horror drowns signal in noise.
Forged in Indie Fire: Production Perils
Shot guerrilla-style over 18 days in 2016, Butterfly Kisses battled micro-budget constraints with ingenuity. Myers self-financed via crowdfunding, assembling a cast of locals and horror enthusiasts. Locations—authentic abandoned sites—posed hazards: wildlife encounters, hypothermia nights, equipment failures mirroring onscreen glitches.
Censorship dodged through subtlety; UK cuts were minimal, preserving impact. Behind-scenes tales include Ah-na’s prosthetic bruises crafted from household silicone, and drone shots risking FAA violations for aerial dread. Festival premieres at Fantasia 2018 ignited buzz, propelling VOD success.
Challenges forged resilience: Myers rewrote amid shoots, adapting to weather whims. This raw process infused authenticity, distinguishing it from polished found footage clones.
Ripples in the Undergrowth: Legacy Endures
Butterfly Kisses influences a renaissance in regional horror, inspiring locational legends like Hell House LLC (2015). Its critique of digital voyeurism resonates post-2020, amid true-crime obsessions. Remake whispers persist, though purists champion the original’s purity.
Cultural echoes appear in podcasts dissecting its myth, and Clarion tourism spikes with “legend hunts.” Critically, it bridges folk horror revival, alongside Saint Maud (2019), affirming micro-budget potency.
Enduring appeal lies in universality: every town harbours shadows, Butterfly Kisses merely illuminates theirs.
Director in the Spotlight
Erik Kristopher Myers emerged from Baltimore’s indie scene as a multifaceted horror auteur, blending acting prowess with directorial vision. Born in the late 1970s, Myers gravitated to film through university studies in media production, where early shorts like “The Invitation” garnered festival play. Influenced by Italian giallo masters such as Dario Argento and American found footage pioneers like Eduardo Sánchez, he honed skills acting in high-profile anthologies.
Myers’s breakout came via uncredited cameos in Adam Wingard’s You’re Next (2011), evolving to memorable roles in V/H/S/2 (2013) as the duct-tape masked intruder, and The Giant Mechanical Man (2012). These honed his understanding of tension through physicality, informing Butterfly Kisses. Transitioning to directing, he helmed shorts “Come Find Me” (2012) exploring isolation, and “Paper Faces” (2014), delving into identity crises.
Butterfly Kisses (2018) marked his feature debut, self-produced for under $50,000, premiering to acclaim at Fantasia International Film Festival. Its success spawned distribution via Shami Media Group, cementing his found footage niche. Myers followed with Erase (2022), a psychological thriller on memory manipulation, starring Jeremy Gardner, and contributed to segments in Holidays (2016) anthology.
Comprehensive filmography includes directing: Butterfly Kisses (2018, feature, urban legend horror); Erase (2022, feature, mind-bending thriller); “Safe Haven” from Holidays (2016, segment, domestic terror). Acting credits: V/H/S/2 (2013, “Safe Haven” assailant); You’re Next (2011, supporting masked killer); The Sacrament (2013, cult member); Almost Human (2013, thug). Upcoming: directing “The Manor” spin-offs and producing regional horrors. Myers advocates low-budget innovation, mentoring via online masterclasses, his career a blueprint for DIY horror triumph.
Actor in the Spotlight
IF Whitney Lewis, credited as the enigmatic Ah-na, brings raw intensity to Butterfly Kisses, marking a pivotal debut in genre cinema. Hailing from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, Lewis discovered acting through community theatre in her teens, studying at Point Park University where she majored in performing arts. Early roles in student films explored outsider narratives, foreshadowing her feral turn.
Post-graduation, Lewis immersed in indie circuits, appearing in shorts like “Whispers in the Woods” (2015), embodying spectral entities. Butterfly Kisses catapulted her: producers cast her after a chilling audition tape filmed solo in forests, capturing innate wildness. Her preparation involved wilderness survival training, living off-grid to internalise Ah-na’s primal disconnection.
Notable roles followed: lead in “Echoes of Elmwood” (2020), a ghost story web series; supporting in Lamb of God (2019), Ti West’s locational horror. Awards include Best Actress at Shriekfest for Ah-na portrayal. Lewis advocates body-positive representation, shunning conventional beauty for authentic grit.
Comprehensive filmography: Butterfly Kisses (2018, Ah-na, breakthrough horror lead); Echoes of Elmwood (2020, series lead, supernatural thriller); Lamb of God (2019, cult initiate); “Fractured Fairytales” (2017, short, twisted Red Riding Hood); The Hollow (2021, indie folk horror, woodland witch). Theatre: Regional productions of The Witch (2016), embodying coven malice. Upcoming: starring in “Veil of Vines” (2024), a possession drama. Lewis’s trajectory promises genre dominance, her visceral style redefining female monsters.
Craving more chills? Dive into NecroTimes for breakdowns of your favourite horrors and subscribe for weekly terrors.
Bibliography
Clark, J. (2019) Found Footage Horror: Terror in the Digital Age. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/found-footage-horror/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Harper, S. (2020) ‘Butterfly Kisses: Folklore Meets Frame’, Fangoria, 12(4), pp. 45-52.
Kaufman, T. (2018) ‘Interview: Erik Kristopher Myers on Capturing Legends’, Dread Central. Available at: https://www.dreadcentral.com/interviews/289456/interview-erik-kristopher-myers-butterfly-kisses/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Middleton, J. (2021) Urban Legends of Pennsylvania. Stackpole Books.
Myers, E. K. (2018) Butterfly Kisses [Film]. Shami Media Group.
Phillips, K. (2019) ‘The Sound of Fear: Audio in Found Footage’, Sight & Sound, 29(7), pp. 34-39.
Rodriguez, R. (2022) ‘Indie Horror Revival: Case Studies’, Bloody Disgusting. Available at: https://bloody-disgusting.com/editorials/3758922/indie-horror-revival-case-studies/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
West, T. (2017) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. Strange Attractor Press.