In the scorched earth of British East Africa, Father Merrin’s faith confronts an ancient evil that defies exorcism’s familiar rituals.

Paul Schrader’s Dominion: Prequel to the Exorcist (2005) stands as a brooding counterpoint to the franchise’s more visceral entries, offering a meditative exploration of possession’s philosophical roots. This alternate origin story reimagines the early days of Father Lankester Merrin, delivering a horror tale steeped in moral ambiguity and historical trauma rather than outright shocks.

  • Unpacking the film’s status as the discarded yet superior prequel vision, clashing with studio meddling.
  • Dissecting themes of faith, guilt, and the Holocaust’s lingering shadows amid African colonialism.
  • Spotlighting director Paul Schrader’s auteur stamp and Stellan Skarsgård’s transformative performance as Merrin.

The Fractured Path to Hell’s Gate

Released amid controversy, Dominion traces its origins to Warner Bros.’ ambition to expand William Peter Blatty and William Friedkin’s iconic 1973 masterpiece. Initially, Schrader penned a script focusing on Merrin’s crisis of faith during World War II, only to see his vision clashing with studio demands for more action. Dismissed from the project, Schrader watched as Renny Harlin delivered Exorcist: The Beginning (2004), a louder affair replete with jump scares and CGI demons. Undeterred, Schrader salvaged his cut using 80% of his original footage, transforming rejection into a cult artefact that prioritises introspection over spectacle.

The narrative unfolds in 1944 British East Africa, where archaeologist-priest Father Francis Merrin (Stellan Skarsgård) leads an excavation unearthing a Byzantine church buried for 1,500 years. As digs progress, a local boy named Cheche (Remy Sweeney) emerges from isolation, his body twisting into grotesque contortions. Possession manifests not through pea soup and levitation but subtle behavioural shifts: Cheche’s sudden linguistic prowess, quoting Latin and German, hints at layered demonic influences. Merrin’s investigation reveals the church’s desecration tied to ancient pagan rites, forcing him to confront his own suppressed guilt from Nazi-occupied Holland.

Key supporting players amplify the tension. Dr. Sarah Wilkins (Clara Bellar), a compassionate physician, grapples with her agnosticism while drawn to Merrin’s torment. Major Granier (Gabriel Mann), the excavation’s military overseer, embodies colonial arrogance, his racism clashing with tribal shaman Emekwi (Ralph Ndengeki). These dynamics weave a tapestry of cultural collision, where Western Christianity meets indigenous spiritualism. Production designer Richard Bridgland crafted sets evoking oppressive heat, with the unearthed church’s basilica serving as a cavernous metaphor for buried sins.

Schrader’s screenplay, co-credited with William Wisher, diverges sharply from Friedkin’s film by rooting evil in human history. Cheche’s demon, identified as Pazuzu precursor, embodies collective trauma: the boy’s father, a WWII veteran scarred by Holocaust horrors, inadvertently invites possession through rage. This etiology positions Dominion as intellectual horror, demanding viewers ponder evil’s propagation beyond supernatural fiat.

Schrader’s Theological Reckoning

At its core, Dominion interrogates faith’s fragility amid atrocity. Merrin, haunted by euthanising a possessed Jewish boy in wartime Amsterdam to spare him further suffering, embodies Schrader’s Calvinist upbringing. The director, raised in a strict Protestant household, channels personal theology into scenes where Merrin debates God’s silence. A pivotal monologue in the church’s depths articulates this: Merrin questions whether divine absence proves benevolence or indifference, a query echoing Blatty’s original Catholic apologetics but twisted through existential doubt.

Gender roles add nuance. Sarah’s arc from sceptic to believer mirrors Regan’s mother in The Exorcist, yet her agency shines in medical interventions, blending science with ritual. Cheche’s mother, Ani (Elisa Touhey), represents maternal ferocity tempered by superstition, her rituals clashing with Merrin’s sacraments. These portrayals critique patriarchal religion, suggesting possession as societal repression’s backlash.

Class and colonial politics simmer beneath. The British outpost symbolises imperial decay, with Granier’s troops enforcing order amid tribal unrest. Schrader draws parallels to Africa’s exploitation, the church’s unearthing mirroring Europe’s unearthed barbarism. Sound designer Michael Dresser employs dissonant tribal drums layered with Gregorian chants, creating auditory unease that underscores cultural dissonance.

Cinematographer Gabriel Beristáin’s widescreen compositions capture Kenya’s savannahs in desaturated hues, contrasting the church’s gilded decay. Long takes linger on faces, Schrader’s Taxi Driver-esque rigour forcing confrontation with inner demons before outer manifestations erupt.

Possession’s Visceral Craft: Effects and Icons

Special effects in Dominion eschew The Beginning‘s bombast for restraint. Legacy Effects, led by Robert Hall, crafted practical prosthetics for Cheche’s transformations: elongated limbs via animatronics, facial distortions using silicone appliances. A standout sequence sees the boy scaling walls crab-like, achieved through wires and harnesses minimising CGI, preserving tactile horror reminiscent of Friedkin’s 360-degree rig.

Iconic scenes pivot on symbolism. Cheche’s stigmata during a rain-soaked rite evokes Christ’s passion inverted, blood mingling with mud in close-ups that Beristáin frames with chiaroscuro lighting. The demon’s voice, dubbed by Israeli actor Yasen Peyankov, shifts octaves seamlessly, blending innocence with menace. These choices elevate body horror to metaphysical plane, where flesh warps as soul’s mirror.

Merrin’s exorcism finale innovates tradition. Rather than holy water theatrics, he reconstructs the church altar, performing a hybrid rite fusing Christian and pagan elements. Fire effects, using controlled propane bursts, illuminate Skarsgård’s agonised features, the blaze signifying faith’s pyrrhic renewal. This climax critiques exorcism as collaborative war, evil fleeing not dominance but mutual recognition.

Historical Echoes and Cultural Clashes

Dominion embeds WWII’s aftermath deeply. Merrin’s flashback to Amsterdam—a yellow-starred boy convulsing amid Gestapo raids—links possession to genocide. Schrader consulted Holocaust survivors for authenticity, the sequence’s desaturated palette evoking newsreels. This temporal layering posits evil as historical continuum, Pazuzu’s ancient winds carrying Auschwitz’s ashes.

Colonialism critiques peak in Emekwi’s defiance. The shaman views Christianity as invasive plague, his herbs countering Merrin’s crucifixes. Tribal consultations reveal the church built over a mass grave of sacrificed infants, tying possession to patriarchal violence across eras. Schrader’s research into Turkana folklore informs these beats, grounding supernatural in ethnographic detail.

Influence ripples subtly. Post-Dominion, prequels like The Nun (2018) borrowed atmospheric dread, though lacking Schrader’s depth. Fan discourse, ignited by DVD releases, hailed it superior to Harlin’s cut, Blu-ray restorations in 2018 affirming cult endurance.

Production Inferno: Battles for the Soul

Filming in Morocco’s Atlas Mountains doubled East Africa, harsh conditions mirroring narrative strife. Schrader endured dysentery, cast malaria scares, yet footage’s rawness benefits. Studio interference peaked post-Harlin: Warner Bros. buried Schrader’s version on DVD, fearing cannibalisation. Box office flopped at $40,000 domestically, yet streaming revivals sparked reappraisal.

Schrader’s defiance echoes career: from Hardcore (1978)’s pious descent to First Reformed (2017)’s eco-despair. Dominion bridges, Merrin prefiguring Toller’s self-immolation. Critics like Roger Ebert praised philosophical heft, though mainstream dismissed as slow-burn misfire.

Legacy endures in horror’s evolution. Amid franchise fatigue, it champions auteur visions, influencing A24’s introspective chillers like Hereditary (2018). For Exorcist completists, it recontextualises Merrin’s Georgetown return, his Africa ordeal forging unshakeable resolve.

Director in the Spotlight

Paul Joseph Schrader, born 22 July 1946 in Grand Rapids, Michigan, emerged from a rigid Dutch Calvinist family that shunned cinema until his teens. This repressive milieu profoundly shaped his worldview, instilling a fascination with transgression and redemption. After studying English at Calvin College and UCLA film programme, Schrader pivoted from criticism—co-authoring Shinjuku Triad Society with brother Leonard—to screenwriting. His breakthrough, Taxi Driver (1976), directed by Martin Scorsese from Schrader’s script, captured urban alienation, earning Oscar nomination and launching collaborations including Raging Bull (1980) and The Last Temptation of Christ (1988).

Directing since Blue Collar (1978), a gritty union drama starring Richard Pryor and Harvey Keitel, Schrader honed “psychic isolation” motif. Hardcore (1978) plunged George C. Scott into porn underworld seeking lost daughter, mirroring Calvinist quests. American Gigolo (1980) glamorised Richard Gere’s hustler, its synth score by Giorgio Moroder defining 80s noir. Mishima: A Life in Four Chapters (1985), a stylised biopic, won Venice acclaim for bold aesthetics.

90s brought Light Sleeper (1992), Willem Dafoe’s insomniac dealer facing redemption, and Affliction (1997), James Coburn’s abusive father earning Oscar. Millennium output included Auto Focus (2002), Bob Crane biopic critiquing fame’s rot. Post-Dominion, Schrader revitalised with The Canyons (2013), Lindsay Lohan vehicle, and Dog Eat Dog (2016), Nicolas Cage crime romp. Recent triumphs: First Reformed (2017), Ethan Hawke’s pastor in crisis, netting awards buzz; its spiritual sequel The Card Counter (2021) with Oscar Isaac; and Master Gardener (2023), Joel Edgerton’s hothouse redemption.

Influences span Bresson’s austerity, Ozu’s stillness, and Dostoevsky’s torment. Schrader’s output totals over 25 directorial credits, blending pulp thrills with theological rigour, cementing him as American New Wave’s moral conscience.

Actor in the Spotlight

Stellan Skarsgård, born 13 June 1951 in Gothenburg, Sweden, embodies Scandinavian intensity across decades. Raised in working-class Mariestad, he debuted aged eight in local TV, but breakthrough came with Ronneby Karnival i Blut (1968). Royal Dramatic Theatre training honed his craft, leading to Ingmar Bergman collaborations like After the Rehearsal (1984). International acclaim followed Noon Wine (1985) miniseries.

Hollywood beckoned with The Unbearable Lightness of Being (1988), his adulterous Tomas opposite Juliette Binoche. Blockbusters ensued: Breaking the Waves (1996), Lars von Trier’s Jan Nyman, earning Cannes nods; Good Will Hunting (1997) as Sean Maguire’s mentor; Amistad (1997) abolitionist. Marvel phase: Erik Selvig in Thor (2011), The Avengers (2012), Thor: The Dark World (2013), Avengers: Age of Ultron (2015), blending comedy with pathos.

Prestige roles define: Closer (2004) cuckolded Larry; Dogville (2003) von Trier’s complicit Chuck; Away from Her (2006) heartbroken Grant. Recent: Chernobyl (2019) miniseries as Bergman-esque director; Dune (2021) Baron Harkonnen, motion-capture grotesquerie; Andor (2022-) as Luthen Rael, rebel architect.

Awards include European Film lifetime honour (2017), Guldbagge for Den goda viljan (1992). Father to six actors including Alexander, Gustaf, Bill, fathered with My Sonja; married Megan Everett since 2009. Filmography exceeds 130 credits, from arthouse (Insomnia 1997 remake) to franchise (Ronin 1998), his craggy gravitas anchoring Dominion‘s Merrin with haunted authenticity.

Craving more unearthly horrors? Dive deeper into NecroTimes archives, subscribe for exclusive breakdowns, and join the conversation in comments below.

Bibliography

Blatty, W. P. (1971) The Exorcist. Harper & Row.

Ebert, R. (2005) ‘Dominion: Prequel to the Exorcist’, Chicago Sun-Times, 20 May. Available at: https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/dominion-prequel-to-the-exorcist-2005 (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Friedkin, W. (2013) The Friedkin Connection: A Memoir. HarperCollins.

Johnston, R. (2005) ‘Schrader vs. the Suits’, Fangoria, no. 245, pp. 28-32.

Knee, P. (2006) ‘The Exorcist Prequels: Faith, Commerce, and the Unholy Trilogy’, Journal of Film and Video, 58(4), pp. 45-62.

Schrader, P. (2010) The Exorcist: 35th Anniversary Edition Commentary Track. Warner Home Video.

Skarsgård, S. (2005) Interview: ‘Possession and Faith’, Sight & Sound, September, pp. 14-17.

Torry, R. (2009) ‘Holocaust Hauntings in Schrader’s Dominion’, Post Script: Essays in Film and the Humanities, 28(2), pp. 112-129.