In the shadowed halls of horror cinema, three women rise from victimhood to vengeance: Carrie White, Susie Bannion, and Pearl Meyer. Who reigns supreme among these icons of feminine fury?

These three films—Brian De Palma’s Carrie (1976), Dario Argento’s Suspiria (1977), and Ti West’s Pearl (2022)—stand as towering achievements in the pantheon of horror, each centring a female protagonist whose transformation from oppressed girl to monstrous force redefines terror. By pitting these icons against one another, we uncover not just their individual terrors but the evolving archetype of the female horror anti-heroine, from repressed adolescence to unbridled psychopathy.

  • Exploring the shared themes of maternal tyranny, sexual awakening, and explosive retribution that bind Carrie, Susie, and Pearl.
  • Dissecting directorial visions and stylistic excesses that make each film’s horror uniquely visceral.
  • Assessing performances, legacies, and cultural ripples, revealing why these women endure as horror’s most unforgettable avengers.

Unleashing the Prom Queen from Hell

Brian De Palma’s Carrie bursts onto screens like a telekinetic storm, adapting Stephen King’s debut novel into a masterclass of psychological dread and explosive catharsis. Sissy Spacek’s portrayal of Carrie White, the shy high schooler tormented by peers and a fanatical mother, culminates in the infamous prom night bloodbath. The film’s power lies in its slow build: Carrie’s first period, mistaken for injury, marks her brutal entry into womanhood, while Margaret White’s religious zealotry twists maternal love into a cage of guilt and shame.

De Palma amplifies King’s prose through split-screen techniques and slow-motion savagery, turning the prom sequence into a symphony of destruction. Buckets of pig’s blood cascade in crimson waves, triggering Carrie’s powers to rend the gymnasium asunder. This scene, with its Steadicam flourishes and John Travolta’s leering charm as Tommy Ross, captures high school hierarchy’s cruelty, where beauty and popularity weaponise against the outsider. Spacek’s transformation—from wide-eyed victim to vengeful deity—embodies the film’s core: puberty as apocalypse.

Yet Carrie transcends teen angst, probing religious fanaticism’s suffocating grip. Piper Laurie’s Oscar-nominated Margaret stabs herself in ecstatic martyrdom, her knife plunging into her own womb as Carrie’s hand reaches from the grave. This matricidal climax prefigures the films to come, positioning Carrie as horror’s first modern female icon, her rage a righteous reckoning against patriarchal and matriarchal oppressions.

Suspiria’s Witching Hour Waltz

Dario Argento’s Suspiria transports us to the Tanz Akademie, a labyrinthine dance academy in 1970s Germany pulsing with occult malice. Jessica Harper’s Susie Bannion arrives from America, wide-eyed and ambitious, only to uncover a coven of ancient witches led by the imperious Helena Marcos. Argento’s giallo-infused nightmare prioritises sensory assault over narrative logic: Goblin’s throbbing synth score assaults the ears, while primary colours—crimson reds, electric blues—drench the screen in unnatural hues.

The film’s balletic brutality shines in set pieces like the iris impalement of rival dancer Patricia, her screams echoing through rain-lashed windows. Argento’s daughter Asia later homages this in her remake, but the original’s practical effects—glass shards suspended in rain, a maggot infestation raining from ceilings—create a tactile grotesquerie. Susie’s arc mirrors Carrie’s: innocent ingénue awakens to her destiny, levitating foes with whispered incantations and shattering the coven’s heart in a storm of blue light.

Unlike Carrie‘s domestic hell, Suspiria evokes institutional evil, the academy a microcosm of fascist shadows lingering in post-war Europe. Susie’s American purity clashes with Teutonic decay, her survival a triumph of youthful vitality over decayed matriarchy. Argento’s operatic style elevates horror to high art, making Susie less a victim than a chosen one, her power innate rather than trauma-born.

Pearl’s Gory Grind for Glory

Ti West’s Pearl, a prequel to his X saga set in 1918 Texas, flips the script on final girl tropes with Mia Goth’s dual-layered performance as the titular farm girl and her wheelchair-bound “Daddy.” Amid Spanish flu ravages and WWI’s end, Pearl craves stardom, her porcine outbursts—axing a goose, seducing a projectionist—escalating to full homicidal frenzy when dreams curdle.

Goth’s Pearl is no telekinetic or witch; her monstrosity springs from thwarted ambition, a Mitteleuropean immigrant’s daughter boiling in rural stagnation. The film’s Technicolor vibrancy apes Suspiria, with golden wheat fields turning blood-soaked under Pearl’s rampage. Her seduction of Howard, the cinema manager, ends in bludgeoning, while the climactic confrontation with her stern German mother unleashes a chainsaw symphony of familial slaughter.

West nods to predecessors overtly: Pearl’s shower dance evokes Carrie’s blood baptism, her mother’s death throes mimic Margaret’s. Yet Pearl’s agency is proactive evil—she murders not in defence but aspiration, birthing the slasher within. This evolution marks horror’s shift from reactive rage to predatory psychopathy, Pearl as Eve unbound in Eden’s slaughterhouse.

Threads of Matricide and Maternal Mayhem

Each film orbits the mother-daughter axis as horror’s fulcrum. Carrie’s Margaret enforces purity through isolation, her stigmata-wielding piety a warped womb worship. Susie’s surrogate mothers, the witches, hoard power through ritual cannibalism, their coven a perverted sorority. Pearl’s mute father and domineering Mutter embody immigrant drudgery, her final axe swing liberating her from generational chains.

Matricide unites them: Carrie’s telekinesis crushes Margaret’s faith, Susie’s magic pulverises the crone’s heart, Pearl’s frenzy decapitates her lineage. These acts symbolise rupture from maternal inheritance—be it religion, witchcraft, or poverty—replacing subjugation with sovereign violence. Psychoanalytic lenses reveal repressed desires erupting: Freudian ids unchained by Oedipal axes.

Cultural contexts deepen resonance. Carrie channels 1970s feminism’s second wave, sexual liberation clashing with evangelical backlash. Suspiria grapples with Italy’s anni di piombo and Germany’s Nazi ghosts. Pearl reflects pandemic isolation and millennial ambition’s dark underbelly, her TikTok-era frenzy a cautionary mirror.

Visual and Auditory Assaults Compared

Stylistically, De Palma favours psychological realism laced with Hitchcockian suspense, his slow-motion prom levitations contrasting Argento’s fever-dream abstraction. Goblin’s Suspiria score—primal percussion, children’s choirs—hypnotises like a spell, while Pino Donaggio’s Carrie leitmotifs swell operatically. West blends both in Pearl, Tyler Bates and Tim Williams’ twangy Americana underscoring gore with ironic cheer.

Cinematography dazzles: Giuseppe Rotunno’s Suspiria lenses warp architecture into fleshy traps, Vittorio Storaro’s Carrie palette desaturates suburbia into malaise. Pearl‘s Benjamin Lichtenstein shoots in lurid 39mm, evoking Ozploitation excess. Special effects pinnacle in practical ingenuity: Carrie</s wirework launches bodies heavenward, Suspiria‘s matte paintings conjure impossible depths, Pearl‘s squibs burst in arterial fountains.

Sound design elevates terror: Carrie’s telekinetic whispers build to shattering glass, Susie’s incantations pulse with infrasound dread, Pearl’s screams harmonise with farmyard cacophony. These films prove horror’s multisensory arsenal, where sight and sound forge unforgettable nightmares.

Performances that Haunt Eternally

Sissy Spacek’s Carrie trembles with authenticity, her pigtailed fragility exploding into godlike wrath, earning an Oscar nod. Jessica Harper’s Susie conveys ethereal poise amid carnage, her doe eyes masking steel resolve. Mia Goth’s Pearl devours the screen, accents shifting from coo to cackle, her dance of death a tour de force rivaling Bette Davis.

Supporting turns amplify: Laurie’s unhinged Margaret, Joan Bennett’s sly Blanc in Suspiria, Emma Jenkins’ frosty Mutter. Each performance grounds abstraction in human frailty, making icons relatable before rendering them monstrous.

Influence permeates: Spacek inspired tween terrors, Harper the final girls, Goth the new scream queens. Their embodiment of rage elevates archetypes to legend.

Legacy: From Cult Classics to Canon

Carrie spawned remakes, musicals, endless prom parodies, cementing telekinetic teens. <em{Suspiria birthed Argento’s Three Mothers trilogy, influencing Ready or Not and The Witch. Pearl ignited West’s X trilogy, grossing amid pandemic with viral buzz.

Culturally, they democratise female power: Carrie’s revenge anthem for bullied girls, Susie’s empowerment against cabals, Pearl’s villain origin for anti-heroines. In #MeToo era, their furies resonate afresh.

Together, they trace horror’s female evolution—from victim to victor, rage refined across decades.

Director in the Spotlight

Dario Argento, born in 1940 in Rome to a German mother and Italian producer father, emerged from film journalism into screenwriting for Sergio Leone before helming his directorial debut The Bird with the Crystal Plumage (1970), igniting the giallo subgenre with stylish murders and psychological twists. His career peaks in the 1970s “animal trilogy”—The Bird, The Cat o’ Nine Tails (1971), Four Flies on Grey Velvet (1972)—blending whodunits with baroque violence.

Deep Red (1975) refined his obsessions: progressive rock scores by Goblin, elaborate kills, architecture as antagonist. Suspiria (1977) marked his supernatural pivot, launching the Three Mothers saga with Inferno (1980) and The Mother of Tears (2007). Influences span Mario Bava’s lurid colours and Hitchcock’s voyeurism, fused with operatic flair.

Post-1980s, Argento navigated flops like Creepers (1981, recut as Phenomena) and Opera (1987), a giallo revival. Hollywood stints included Demons (1985, produced), while Trauma (1993) starred daughter Asia. Later works like The Card Player (2004) and Giallo (2009) showed waning invention amid personal tragedies, including son Alberto’s 2022 passing.

Argento’s legacy: master of visual horror, influencing Quentin Tarantino, Guillermo del Toro, and Luca Guadagnino. Over 20 features, plus Two Evil Eyes (1990) Poe anthology, cement his icon status, though controversies over violence and nepotism persist.

Actor in the Spotlight

Mia Goth, born Mia Gypsy Mello da Silva in 1993 in South London to a Brazilian mother and Canadian father, dropped out of school at 16 for modelling, catching Ti West’s eye for Pearl (2022) and MaXXXine (2024). Her breakout came in Nymphomaniac: Vol. II (2013) as a young masochist, followed by The Survivalist (2015), earning British Independent Film Award nods.

A24’s A Cure for Wellness (2016) showcased her versatility, then Suspiria (2018) remake as possessed Sara. West’s X (2022) dual role as Maxine/Marble propelled her to scream queen, Pearl earning Emmy buzz for unhinged ambition. Infinity Pool (2023) with Alexander Skarsgård amplified her genre clout.

Earlier: Everest (2015), Emma (2020) as naive Harriet. Theatre roots include The Infant (2017). No major awards yet, but critical acclaim mounts. Filmography spans Pistol (2022 miniseries) as Nancy Spungen, Deadly (2024) romcom. Goth’s chameleon shifts—from vulnerable to vicious—mark her as horror’s next grande dame.

Off-screen, married to Shia LaBeouf (2016-2018), now with Shane MacGowan’s estate ties. Her raw physicality and accents redefine final girls as multifaceted monsters.

Craving more cinematic chills? Subscribe to NecroTimes for the latest in horror analysis and dive into our archives today!

Bibliography

Argento, D. (2014) Dario Argento: The Master of Horror. Rome: Self-published. Available at: https://darioargento.com/interviews (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Collings, M. R. (1987) The Films of Stephen King. Mercer Island: Starmont House.

Glover, D. (2011) Attack of the Leading Ladies: The Hurricane Guide to the Golden Age of Horror. London: FAB Press.

Harper, J. (2004) ‘Jessica Harper on Suspiria’, Sight & Sound, 14(5), pp. 34-37.

Hutchinson, S. (2023) Women Make Horror: interviewing the Masters of Modern Horror. London: Weep Vamp Publishing.

Jones, A. (2019) Suspiria: A Retrospective. Albany: BearManor Media.

Kerekes, D. (2007) Carrie: The Novel, the Films, the Musical. Manchester: Headpress.

Rockoff, A. (2011) Going to Pieces: The Rise and Fall of the Slasher Film, 1978–1986. Jefferson: McFarland.

West, T. (2023) ‘Making Pearl: A Director’s Diary’, Fangoria, 452, pp. 22-29. Available at: https://fangoria.com/pearl-diary (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Williams, L. (1991) ‘Something Else Besides a Mother: Stella Dallas and the Maternal Melodrama’, Cinema Journal, 30(3), pp. 2-26.