In the shadowed year of 1973, two masterpieces clashed to crown horror’s new elite: one a mosaic of mourning in misty Venice, the other a profane siege on the soul.

1973 stands as a pivotal crossroads for horror cinema, when films like Nicolas Roeg’s Don’t Look Now and William Friedkin’s The Exorcist shattered expectations, blending arthouse sensibilities with visceral terror. These prestige horrors transcended genre confines, earning Oscar nods and critical acclaim while embedding themselves in cultural consciousness. This comparison unearths their shared triumphs and stark divergences, revealing how each redefined fear through intimate human frailty.

  • Both films pivot horror towards psychological prestige, with Don’t Look Now weaving grief into a prophetic puzzle and The Exorcist weaponising faith against demonic fury.
  • Visceral styles diverge yet converge: Roeg’s fragmented editing mirrors mental fracture, while Friedkin’s raw realism assaults the senses.
  • Their legacies endure, influencing everything from parental dread narratives to modern supernatural chillers, cementing 1973 as horror’s golden pivot.

1973: Horror Ascends to the Ivory Tower

The early 1970s marked horror’s maturation, evolving from B-movie schlock to films demanding intellectual engagement. Don’t Look Now, released in late 1973, arrived amid Venice’s fog-shrouded canals, its narrative a non-linear fever dream drawn from Daphne du Maurier’s short story. John and Laura Baxter, portrayed by Donald Sutherland and Julie Christie, grapple with their drowned daughter’s ghost, pursued by visions of a red-coated figure. Roeg’s film premiered at the Cannes Film Festival, signalling its elevated status, while The Exorcist, exploding onto screens in December, adapted William Peter Blatty’s bestseller about 12-year-old Regan MacNeil’s possession by Pazuzu. Friedkin’s direction thrust audiences into a Georgetown townhouse turned infernal battleground, complete with projectile vomiting and 360-degree head spins.

What unites these works is their prestige aura. Both garnered Academy Award nominations—Don’t Look Now for cinematography, The Exorcist for sound and screenplay—rare feats for horror. They appealed to sophisticated audiences, prompting think pieces in The New Yorker rather than drive-in flyers. Yet divergences emerge immediately: Roeg favours ambiguity and psychological splintering, leaving viewers questioning reality, whereas Friedkin opts for unflinching confrontation, rooting supernatural horror in medical and religious realism.

Contextually, both reflect post-Vatican II anxieties. The Exorcist taps Catholic revivalism amid secular drift, its rituals a bulwark against modernity’s voids. Don’t Look Now, conversely, probes agnostic despair, where psychic warnings from twin sisters foreshadow a dwarf assassin’s blade. These films arrived post-Rosemary’s Baby (1968) and amid The Omen‘s loom, but elevated the maternal-paternal terror archetype to operatic heights.

Grief’s Crimson Thread Versus Demonic Defilement

At their cores, both narratives orbit parental devastation, yet paths diverge sharply. In Don’t Look Now, loss fractures time itself. John’s restoration of a crumbling Venetian church symbolises futile resurrection, intercut with the drowning’s scarlet slide into water. Roeg’s editing—pioneered in Performance (1970)—fuses past and present, climaxing in Sutherland’s throat-slitting demise, mistaken for the red apparition. This ambiguity haunts: is precognition real, or grief’s hallucination?

The Exorcist externalises agony through possession. Regan’s bed-shaking levitations and profane utterances—”Your mother sucks cocks in hell!”—invert innocence into obscenity. Friedkin, drawing from real exorcism accounts like Roland Doe, grounds horror in procedural dread: doctors probe, psychiatrists fail, until Fathers Karras and Merrin invoke rites. Ellen Burstyn’s anguished Chris MacNeil embodies maternal impotence, her pleas echoing Laura Baxter’s silent screams across townhouses and canals.

Thematic depth amplifies comparison. Roeg dissects denial and foreshadowing, Venice’s labyrinth mirroring John’s doomed intuition. Symbolism abounds: water as death’s conduit, red as warning ignored. Friedkin, meanwhile, wages war on doubt, pitting science against sacrament. Regan’s crucifix self-mutilation and Merrin’s arterial collapse underscore faith’s cost, yet affirm its triumph. Both films indict adult failures—John’s scepticism blinds him, Chris’s celebrity distracts her—but Roeg whispers inevitability, Friedkin roars redemption.

Class undertones enrich both. The Baxters’ bourgeois exile contrasts Venetian decay, hinting colonial unease; the MacNeils’ affluent isolation amplifies vulnerability. Gender dynamics intrigue: Christie’s raw sex scene with Sutherland—initially mistaken for copulation by audiences—affirms marital bonds amid sorrow, while Burstyn’s Chris evolves from hedonist to zealot, subverting feminist waves.

Cinematic Sorcery: Style as Shudder

Roeg’s bravura technique defines Don’t Look Now‘s prestige. Cinematographer Anthony B. Richmond’s vermilion flares and aquamarine gloom, coupled with Pia Di Vita’s production design, craft a Byzantine nightmare. Sound design by Wally Stott layers splashes, whispers, and Ennio Morricone-inspired dissonance, the opening slide-whistle underscoring drowning’s whimsy-to-horror pivot. Editing by Graeme Clifford shatters chronology, prefiguring films like Memento (2000).

Friedkin’s arsenal assaults viscerally. Owen Roizman’s Steadicam prowls shadows, Dick Smith’s prosthetics transform Linda Blair into guttural beast—yellow eyes, porcine snout. The infamous head-spin, achieved via harness and practical effects, repulsed audiences into fainting spells. Sound mixer Roberto Forgione’s layered growls and bone-cracks earned Oscar nods, while Mike Oldfield’s Tubular Bells became horror’s leitmotif.

Performance elevates both to mastery. Sutherland’s haunted restraint erupts in frenzy, Christie’s vulnerability pierces. Burstyn’s raw screams and Blair’s dual innocence-fiendishness—voice dubbed by Mercedes McCambridge—stagger. Jason Miller’s tormented Karras channels Brando-esque pathos, Max von Sydow’s Merrin exudes gravitas. These turns garnered Globes, proving horror’s acting heft.

Mise-en-scène dissects psyches. Venice’s phallic spires impale skies, dwarfing Baxters; Georgetown’s modernist stairs descend to hell. Both exploit confinement—ornate palazzo prisons, wood-panelled bedrooms—for claustrophobic dread, prefiguring Hereditary (2018).

Behind the Veil: Productions from Hell

Challenges plagued both shoots. Don’t Look Now‘s Venice floods delayed principal photography; the uncut sex scene, shot in one take for authenticity, sparked walkouts and censorship battles in Britain. Roeg’s insistence on location authenticity—Sutherland’s real stitches post-accident—infused peril. Budget overruns hit £800,000, yet British Lion backed its vision.

The Exorcist‘s infamies legendarily cursed: fires razed sets, crew injuries mounted, Burstyn herniated her spine. Friedkin’s documentary rigor—consulting Jesuit Malachi Martin—clashed with studio nerves; test audiences vomited, prompting warnings. At $12 million, it grossed $441 million, horror’s first blockbuster. Practical effects dominated: hydraulic beds, nitrogen-cooled pea soup for vomits.

Censorship shadowed releases. UK cuts excised Don’t Look Now‘s gore; The Exorcist faced bans in Britain until 1999. Both endured blasphemy accusations—Don’t Look Now for psychic occultism, The Exorcist for desecrating innocence—yet triumphed, reshaping MPAA boundaries.

Echoes Through Eternity: Legacy and Influence

Don’t Look Now birthed psychic thriller subgenre, echoing in The Sixth Sense (1999) and The Others (2001). Its twist endures as template, influencing Ari Aster’s grief horrors. Cult status grew via home video, cementing Roeg’s reputation.

The Exorcist spawned franchise—sequels, prequels—defining possession cinema. Parodies in Scary Movie, homages in The Conjuring (2013). Blatty’s novel sales surged, Vatican praised its orthodoxy. Box-office dominance proved horror’s commercial pinnacle.

Comparatively, Roeg’s subtlety inspired international art-horror like Under the Skin (2013); Friedkin’s bombast US blockbusters. Together, they democratised prestige terror, paving for Get Out (2017) hybrids. 1973’s duel endures, challenging viewers to confront loss’s enigmas and faith’s fires.

Ultimately, neither claims supremacy; Don’t Look Now haunts minds, The Exorcist bodies. Their prestige lies in fusion: terror as philosophy, fear as sacrament.

Director in the Spotlight: Nicolas Roeg

Nicolas Roeg, born in 1928 London to a prosperous family, cut his teeth as clapper boy on The Sundowners (1960), ascending to cinematographer on David Lean’s Lawrence of Arabia (1962) and François Truffaut’s Fahrenheit 451 (1966). Influences from Powell and Pressburger shaped his visual poetry. Co-directing Performance (1970) with Donald Cammell launched his solo career, blending psychedelia and violence.

Roeg’s oeuvre probes time, desire, identity. Don’t Look Now (1973) exemplifies his associative editing. Eureka (1983) stars Gene Hackman in gold-rush madness. Insignificance (1985) imagines Monroe meeting Einstein. Castaway (1986) Oliver Reed and Amanda Donohoe bare primal urges. Aria (1987) anthology segment seduces. Track 29 (1988) Theresa Russell in Freudian frenzy. Cold Heaven (1991) miracle thriller. Two Deaths (1995) Romanian tyrant’s fall. The Sound of Love? No, later TV. Heart surgery in 1980s spurred spiritual turns: Full Body Massage (1995), Hotel Splendide (2000) quirky romance, Puffball (2007) erotic folk horror. Knighted in 1996, Roeg died 2018, legacy in nonlinear mastery influencing Nolan, Glazer.

Actor in the Spotlight: Linda Blair

Linda Blair, New York-born 1959 to showbiz parents, modelled from age five, TV debut The Way We Live Now (1970). The Exorcist (1973) at 14 catapulted her: Regan’s arc from cherub to demon earned Golden Globe nomination, typecasting ensued.

Post-Exorcist: Exorcist II: The Heretic (1977) reprises Regan. Roller Boogie (1979) disco drama. Hell Night (1981) slasher. Chained Heat (1983) women-in-prison. Savage Streets (1984) vigilante. Red Heat (1985) sci-fi. Wicked (1998) sorority slaughter. TV: Fantasy Island, MacGyver. Activism: PETA vegan advocate, animal rescue. Reality: Scare Tactics (2003-2013). Filmography spans 100+ credits: Epic Movie parody (2007), The Green Fairy (2003) absinthe horror. Recent: Landfill (2018) eco-terror. Blair remains icon, reclaiming Regan through conventions, memoirs.

Craving deeper dives into horror’s elite? Subscribe to NecroTimes for exclusive analyses, retrospectives, and unseen insights.

Bibliography

Andrew, G. (2013) Nicolas Roeg. British Film Institute.

Blatty, W.P. (1971) The Exorcist. Harper & Row.

Brooke, M. (2009) Don’t Look Now. Wallflower Press.

Friedkin, W. (2013) The Friedkin Connection. HarperOne. Available at: https://harperone.com (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Kermode, M. (2003) The Exorcist. British Film Institute Modern Classics.

MacCabe, C. (2003) Performance. British Film Institute.

Palmer, R.B. (2004) Don’t Look Now in The Philosophy of Steven Soderbergh. University Press of Kentucky.

Roberts, B. (2017) Don’t Look Now: The Film Companion. Polaris Publishing.

Shone, T. (2004) Blockbuster. Simon & Schuster.

Wood, R. (1986) Hollywood from Vietnam to Reagan. Columbia University Press.