In the suffocating grip of unseen threats, two 2016 masterpieces prove that the scariest prisons are those built by the human mind.
John Goodman’s unhinged Howard in 10 Cloverfield Lane and James McAvoy’s fractured Kevin in Split embody the terror of confinement not just physically, but psychologically, turning basements and zoos into labyrinths of doubt and delusion. These films, both released in 2016, masterfully blend suspense with mental unraveling, forcing viewers to question reality alongside their protagonists.
- Mary Elizabeth Winstead and Anya Taylor-Joy’s resourceful survivors navigate gaslighting and isolation, highlighting gendered resilience in horror.
- Directorial visions from Dan Trachtenberg and M. Night Shyamalan elevate confined spaces into metaphors for fractured psyches and societal fears.
- Through sound design, performances, and twists, both movies redefine psychological horror, influencing a wave of bunker thrillers.
Basements of the Soul: Setting the Stage for Dread
The genius of 10 Cloverfield Lane lies in its immediate plunge into uncertainty. After a car accident, Michelle (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) awakens chained in a bunker owned by Howard (John Goodman), who insists a chemical attack has poisoned the outside world. This setup, penned by Josh Campbell, Matthew Stuecken, and Damien Chazelle, transforms a single location into a pressure cooker of paranoia. Every creak of the bunker door, every flickering fluorescent light, amplifies the sense of entrapment. Dan Trachtenberg’s direction, honed from music videos and commercials, uses tight framing to mirror Michelle’s growing claustrophobia, making the audience feel the walls closing in.
In contrast, Split scatters its confinement across an underground labyrinth beneath a Philadelphia zoo, where Kevin (James McAvoy) imprisons three teenage girls. M. Night Shyamalan crafts this space as an extension of Kevin’s dissociative identity disorder, with each personality altering the environment’s perceived safety. The zoo’s abandoned maintenance tunnels become a warren of shifting threats, where Claire (Haley Lu Richardson), Marcia (Jessica Sula), and especially Casey (Anya Taylor-Joy) must exploit psychological fractures for survival. Shyamalan’s return to form after a string of disappointments taps into his signature blend of the mundane and the monstrous.
Both films weaponize architecture against their characters. Howard’s bunker, stocked with survivalist paraphernalia, reflects Cold War-era fears updated for post-9/11 anxieties about bioterrorism. Kevin’s lair, conversely, evokes urban decay and hidden societal underbellies, drawing from real cases of multiple personality disorders sensationalized in media. These spaces are not mere backdrops; they symbolize the protagonists’ internal battles, where escape hinges on piercing layers of deception.
Production notes reveal how location choices amplified tension. For 10 Cloverfield Lane, a real Louisiana bunker set allowed practical effects, immersing actors in genuine discomfort. Split utilized Philadelphia’s abandoned facilities, enhancing authenticity. Critics like those in Sight & Sound praised this verisimilitude, noting how it grounds supernatural elements in visceral reality.
Monsters Within: Performances That Shatter Sanity
John Goodman’s portrayal of Howard stands as a tour de force of ambiguity. Is he a protector or predator? Goodman’s history in Coen Brothers films like Barton Fink informs his ability to oscillate between folksy charm and explosive rage, particularly in a scene where he recounts a fabricated daughter’s death, his eyes betraying buried grief. This duality keeps viewers off-balance, much like Michelle’s own doubts.
James McAvoy eclipses even this with his portrayal of 23 personalities in Split, shifting from the childlike Hedwig to the sophisticated Patricia, and culminating in the superhuman Beast. McAvoy’s physical transformations—slouched postures, altered accents, even changes in eye color via subtle makeup—demand Oscar-level commitment. A pivotal therapy session with Dr. Karen Fletcher (Betty Buckley) exposes the trauma fueling these alters, adding pathos to the horror.
Winstead and Taylor-Joy anchor these performances as the rational cores. Winstead’s Michelle evolves from victim to strategist, crafting a Molotov cocktail in a desperate bid for freedom. Taylor-Joy, fresh from The Witch, brings haunted depth to Casey, whose own abuse history mirrors Kevin’s, culminating in a revelation that reframes her captivity. These women subvert final girl tropes, relying on intellect over brute force.
Film scholars have dissected these dynamics. In Horror Film Histories, authors argue such performances revive the unreliable narrator tradition from Psycho, but with contemporary twists on mental health stigma. Goodman and McAvoy’s work earned critical acclaim, with McAvoy netting a slew of nominations despite controversy over the film’s portrayal of DID.
Soundscapes of Suspicion: Auditory Assaults
Sound design in both films elevates psychological torment. 10 Cloverfield Lane‘s score by Bear McCreary layers dissonant strings with radio static, mimicking Howard’s conspiracy-laden broadcasts. A hammering sequence on the bunker door builds unbearable tension through escalating percussion, symbolizing encroaching madness.
Split employs whispers and echoes in the tunnels, with West Dylan Thomsen’s score fracturing into motifs for each personality. The Beast’s emergence accompanies guttural growls, blurring human and animal. Shyamalan’s use of diegetic sounds—like dripping water or distant zoo roars—heightens isolation.
These choices draw from Hitchcockian suspense, where sound fills visual voids. Production audio logs highlight improvisational elements, such as Goodman’s ad-libbed folksy tales, which unnerve through domestic normalcy.
Cinematography’s Crushing Embrace
Trachtenberg’s camera prowls the bunker’s confines with Dutch angles and extreme close-ups, distorting reality much like Michelle’s perceptions. Charlotte Bruus Christensen’s cinematography plays with shadows, hinting at unseen horrors without revealing them prematurely.
Shyamalan and Mike Gioulakis in Split favor long takes through corridors, creating disorienting movement that mirrors personality shifts. Harsh fluorescents and dim corners evoke a fractured mind, with Casey’s POV shots immersing viewers in her terror.
Both cinematographers, influenced by Repulsion‘s apartment horrors, use mise-en-scène—cluttered shelves in the bunker, graffiti-scarred walls in the zoo—to convey psychological decay.
Twists That Trap: Narrative Sleights of Hand
10 Cloverfield Lane‘s climax shatters expectations, linking to the Cloverfield universe while affirming Howard’s partial truths. This hybrid reveal balances plausibility with spectacle, critiquing blind faith in authority.
Split‘s post-credits ties to Unbreakable, validating the Beast’s powers and igniting franchise fever. Shyamalan’s twist interrogates nature vs. nurture, though ethicists debate its implications for mental illness representation.
These pivots, rooted in 1970s paranoia films like The Parallax View, force reevaluation, cementing both as modern classics.
Effects in Extremis: Practical Magic Over CGI
Special effects prioritize practicality. 10 Cloverfield Lane uses miniatures for external destruction and prosthetic burns for visceral impact. Legacy Effects crafted alien tendrils with silicone, blending seamlessly in low light.
Split‘s Beast transformation relied on McAvoy’s contortions and subtle prosthetics—elongated limbs via sleeves—avoiding overreliance on digital. Howard Berger’s team drew from The Thing, emphasizing body horror.
This restraint heightens credibility, as noted in Cinefex, influencing successors like His House.
Legacy Locked In: Cultural Ripples
Both films spawned imitators: The Platform echoes vertical confinement, while Old extends Shyamalan’s style. They tapped 2010s anxieties—pandemics foreshadowed COVID lockdowns, mental health amid rising diagnoses.
Critics hail their influence on “elevated horror,” per A24’s ethos, though Split faced backlash from DID advocates, sparking dialogues on representation.
Their endurance proves confinement’s timeless appeal, where minds prove the ultimate battleground.
Director in the Spotlight
M. Night Shyamalan, born Manoj Nelliyattu Shyamalan on August 6, 1970, in Mahé, India, moved to Philadelphia as an infant, where his family resides today. Developing a passion for filmmaking early, he shot his first film at age eight using his father’s Super 8 camera. Shyamalan attended New York University’s Tisch School of the Arts, graduating in 1992. His breakthrough came with The Sixth Sense (1999), a ghost story that grossed over $670 million worldwide and earned six Oscar nominations, catapulting him to fame with its iconic twist.
Shyamalan’s career trajectory includes highs and lows. Unbreakable (2000) explored superhero origins with Bruce Willis, followed by Signs (2002), an alien invasion tale blending faith and family. The 2000s saw The Village (2004), criticized for its twist but praised for visuals; Lady in the Water (2006), a self-indulgent fairy tale; The Happening (2008), an eco-horror flop; and The Last Airbender (2010), a notorious adaptation disaster. Personal struggles with expectations fueled a comeback via The Visit (2015), a found-footage success.
Influenced by Steven Spielberg and Alfred Hitchcock, Shyamalan’s style features moral fables, rural Americana, and revelatory twists. Split (2016) marked his resurgence, leading to the Unbreakable trilogy closer Glass (2019). Recent works include Old (2021), a beach-time horror; Knock at the Cabin (2023), an apocalyptic thriller; and series like Servant (2019-2023) for Apple TV+. He founded Blinding Edge Pictures in 2006, maintaining creative control. Awards include an Oscar nomination for The Sixth Sense, Emmys for Tales from the Crypt episodes, and a 2023 Gotham Award. Shyamalan remains a polarizing auteur, revered for innovation amid criticism.
Comprehensive filmography highlights: Praying with Anger (1992, debut drama on cultural identity); Wide Awake (1998, family comedy); The Sixth Sense (1999, psychological supernatural); Unbreakable (2000, superhero mystery); Signs (2002, alien invasion); The Village (2004, period horror); Lady in the Water (2006, fantasy); The Happening (2008, eco-thriller); The Last Airbender (2010, fantasy epic); After Earth (2013, sci-fi); The Visit (2015, found-footage horror); Split (2016, psychological thriller); Glass (2019, superhero culmination); Old (2021, body horror); Knock at the Cabin (2023, end-times suspense).
Actor in the Spotlight
James McAvoy, born on April 21, 1979, in Glasgow, Scotland, grew up in a working-class family, attending St Thomas Aquinas Secondary School. Discovered at 16 by a producer visiting his school, he deferred university for acting, training at the Royal Scottish Academy of Music and Drama. McAvoy debuted in Ratcatcher (1999), but stardom arrived with The Last King of Scotland (2006) as Forest Whitaker’s aide, earning British Independent Film Award acclaim.
His career exploded with the X-Men franchise as young Charles Xavier starting in X-Men: First Class (2011), showcasing dramatic range amid blockbusters. Breakthrough roles included Atonement (2007), netting Oscar and BAFTA nods for his tragic soldier; The Wanted (2014), a revenge thriller; and Victor Frankenstein (2015). McAvoy excels in psychological depths, from Filth (2013) as a corrupt cop to Split (2016), where his 23-personality tour de force won MTV and Saturn Awards.
Influenced by Scottish theatre and actors like Daniel Day-Lewis, McAvoy champions neurodiversity post-Split, collaborating with charities. Recent highlights: It Chapter Two (2019), The Couper Gang miniseries (2022), and stage work like Cyrano de Bergerac (2019). Nominated for two BAFTAs, two Saturns, and more, he boasts versatility across genres.
Comprehensive filmography: Ratcatcher (1999, drama); Shooting Stars (2002, miniseries); State of Play (2003, thriller); Inside I’m Dancing (2004, comedy-drama); The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005, fantasy); Starter for 10 (2006, comedy); The Last King of Scotland (2006, political thriller); Atonement (2007, romance drama); Wanted (2008, action); X-Men: First Class (2011, superhero); Prometheus (2012, sci-fi); Trance (2013, heist thriller); X-Men: Days of Future Past (2014, superhero); X-Men: Apocalypse (2016, superhero); Split (2016, horror); Glass (2019, thriller); Dark Phoenix (2019, superhero).
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2016) 10 Cloverfield Lane review – a pitch-black triumph. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/mar/11/10-cloverfield-lane-review (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Clark, J. (2017) Sound Design in Contemporary Horror Cinema. Edinburgh University Press.
Hutchinson, T. (2016) Split review – James McAvoy’s monstrous multiple personalities. The Telegraph. Available at: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/films/0/split-review-james-mcavoy-monstrous-multiple-personalities/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Kerekes, D. (2020) Creepy Crawly Cinema: Psychological Thrillers of the 2010s. Headpress.
McCreary, B. (2016) Scoring 10 Cloverfield Lane: Bunker Tension. Bear McCreary Blog. Available at: https://bearmccreary.com/blog/10-cloverfield-lane/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Middleton, R. (2018) ‘Confinement and the Female Gaze in Post-Millennial Horror’, Journal of Horror Studies, 4(2), pp. 145-162.
Shyamalan, M. N. (2017) Interview: The Making of Split. Empire Magazine, March issue.
Trachtenberg, D. (2016) Directing in Close Quarters. Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2016/film/news/dan-trachtenberg-10-cloverfield-lane-1201723456/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
West, A. (2019) Special Effects: From Practical to Digital in Indie Horror. Focal Press.