Monstrous Matrimony: Ritual Belonging from Laboratory to Midsummer Meadow

In the flicker of lightning and the blaze of eternal daylight, two horrors expose the primal terror of solitude—and the rituals we endure to escape it.

Two films, separated by decades and drenched in contrasting atmospheres, converge on a singular, haunting obsession: the human—or inhuman—craving for belonging. James Whale’s Bride of Frankenstein (1935) resurrects the gothic anguish of Mary Shelley’s creature, amplifying its plea for companionship through a macabre experiment in creation. Ari Aster’s Midsommar (2019), by contrast, thrusts us into the sun-bleached fields of a Swedish cult, where grief-stricken Dani Arango stumbles toward a twisted family forged in blood and bloom. Both narratives weaponise ritual as the forge of connection, evolving the monster myth from shadowed castles to communal clearings, revealing how exclusion births monstrosity in any era.

  • The creature’s desperate demand for a mate parallels Dani’s embrace of the Hårga’s ceremonies, transforming isolation into infernal inclusion.
  • Rituals in both films demand sacrifice, whether of flesh or autonomy, underscoring belonging’s evolutionary cost across horror’s timeline.
  • From Universal’s electric spectacle to Aster’s folk precision, these works trace the mythic thread of communal horror, influencing generations of cinematic dread.

The Creature’s Solitary Symphony

Whale’s sequel plunges deeper into the patchwork soul of Frankenstein’s monster, portrayed with rumbling pathos by Boris Karloff. Rescued from the frozen abyss at the close of the original, the creature awakens to a world that recoils from its stitched visage. Blind men scream, villagers torch windmills, and even the hermit fiddler—whose blind overtures of friendship offer fleeting warmth—cannot shield it from pursuit. This isolation culminates in the creature’s coerced alliance with Dr. Pretorius, a skeletal schemer whose laboratory becomes a chapel of unholy matrimony. “Alone: bad. Friend for friend,” the monster grunts, its fragmented speech echoing the primal stutter of the excluded.

Pretorius, with his homunculi-filled flasks and devilish glee, orchestrates the ritual birth of the bride. Lightning cracks the sky as Henry Frankenstein, reluctantly summoned back to the slab, animates the corpse-sewn woman played by Elsa Lanchester. The scene pulses with gothic grandeur: towering coils hum, sparks cascade, and the creature watches, fists clenched in anticipation. Yet belonging fractures instantly. The bride recoils, her electrified hive of hair standing sentinel, hissing rejection at her intended mate. In this mythic reversal, ritual promises unity but delivers amplified alienation, a theme rooted in Shelley’s novel where the creature’s eloquence masks its eternal orphanhood.

The monster’s arc evolves the Frankenstein legend from mere rampage to philosophical lament. Whale infuses humour amid horror—Pretorius’s cocktail hour with shrunken bishops—but the core throbs with evolutionary dread: survival demands kin, yet creation begets conflict. The creature’s final self-sacrifice, detonating the tower with bride and maker, affirms solitude’s supremacy over forced bonds. This gothic ritual, born of 1930s Pre-Code excess, prefigures modern horrors where belonging exacts a steeper toll.

Sunlit Solstice of Sorrow

Aster’s Midsommar inverts the shadows, bathing its terrors in relentless Swedish summer light. Dani, shattered by her family’s murder-suicide at her boyfriend Christian’s indifferent hands, tags along to the Hårga commune at his urging. The film unfolds as a descent into daylight delirium: elders leap from cliffs in ancestral Ättestupa, a blood eagle vivisection honours the bear-suited elder, and floral crowns mask the rot beneath. Dani’s integration accelerates through hallucinatory empathy, her tears mirroring the commune’s collective wail during ritual dances.

The Hårga’s ceremonies form a meticulously choreographed liturgy of belonging. Maypole reels induce trance, pubic thatching births new life amid decay, and the Midsommar feast culminates in Dani’s crowning as May Queen. Christian, drugged and nude, becomes the sacrificial akelarre consort, sewn into a bear gutted before the temple pyre. Dani’s smile as flames consume him seals her transformation—from abandoned lover to communal sovereign. Aster draws from pagan folklore, blending Swedish midsummer traditions with fabricated horrors, evolving the monster motif into a feminine force ascending through ritual purging.

Unlike the creature’s verbal pleas, Dani’s belonging emerges silently, her sobs evolving into synchronised moans with the Hårga women. The film’s evolutionary lens frames isolation as a modern plague: therapy fails, relationships fracture, but ancient rites restore equilibrium. Yet this harmony devours the outsider, mirroring the bride’s instinctive recoil. Aster’s precision—symmetrical frames, embroidered tapestries foreshadowing fates—amplifies the mythic undercurrent, positioning Midsommar as folk horror’s heir to Universal’s monster mashes.

Ritual Forges: Electricity versus Earth

Juxtapose the laboratories and meadows, and ritual reveals itself as horror’s evolutionary constant. Whale’s electric storm mimics divine genesis, Pretorius toasting “to a new world of gods and monsters,” a line that prophesies the genre’s expansion. Instruments whir like ecclesiastical organs, body parts assembled as sacraments. The bride’s awakening—arms outstretched, scream piercing the thunder—evokes both birth and damnation, her rejection a thunderclap against the creature’s hopes.

Hårga’s earthbound rites pulse with organic rhythm: runes carved in flesh, runes predict unions sundered by fire. The Ättestupa pairs suicide with celebration, bones crushed into red stew for communal soup, binding survivors in shared transgression. Dani’s crowning dance, barefoot amid wildflowers, contrasts the bride’s platform rigidity, yet both women embody the ritual’s capstone—arbiters of belonging or banishment. This parallel underscores horror’s progression: from individual mad science to collective cult dynamics.

Both demand surrogacy. The creature barters Henry’s freedom for a mate; Dani trades Christian’s fidelity for cult kinship. Sacrifice scales accordingly: the monster destroys all for none, while Dani affirms the pyre’s blaze. Whale’s film, censored post-Production Code, tempers its queerness—Pretorius’s camp, the bride’s androgyny—yet hints at alternative families. Aster externalises this, the Hårga as polyamorous panacea to Dani’s nuclear-family trauma.

Monstrous Mothers and Rejected Unions

The female figures anchor these rituals’ evolutionary pivot. Lanchester’s bride, iconic in seconds of screen time, hisses defiance with darting eyes and recoiling frame, her wild mane a corona of chaos. She represents the monstrous feminine unbound, rejecting patriarchal assembly. Folklore echoes abound: Pandora’s box unleashed, Eve’s exile amplified into cinematic shriek. Whale, drawing from Peggy Webling’s play, amplifies her agency, making rejection the ritual’s true horror.

Dani evolves into a sunlit counterpart, her May Queen garb floral exoskeleton. Florence Pugh’s performance—convulsing sobs to ecstatic grins—traces an arc from victim to visionary. The Hårga’s elder women cradle her, their hyperventilation chorus a maternal rite absent in Whale’s sterile tower. Yet belonging corrupts: Dani’s final gaze, serene amid inferno, mirrors the bride’s terror, both women vessels for communal will over individual desire.

This duality evolves the monster bride from gothic icon to folk horror queen. Shelley’s creature decries its maker’s hubris; Aster’s cult indicts modernity’s alienation. Rituals bridge eras, promising kinship at the altar of the self.

Performances that Pierce the Veil

Karloff’s monster lumbers with tragic gravitas, platform boots thudding like heartbeat elegies. His blind-man idyll—sharing wine, fire, violin—offers horror’s tenderest interlude, shattered by mob torches. Colin Clive’s Henry writhes in moral torment, Dwight Frye’s Karl cackles as kidnapper, but Karloff anchors the mythic plea. Lanchester steals eternity in her hiss, a performance etched in collective memory.

Pugh inhabits Dani’s fracture with raw physicality: lungs heaving in ritual breathwork, limbs flailing in grief-dance. Jack Reynor’s Christian embodies oblivious masculinity, his scepticism crumbling into drugged submission. Aster’s ensemble—Vilhelm Blomgren’s placid Pelle, Isabelle Grill’s twinned sister—forms a chorus of insidious welcome, their smiles veiling the blade.

These portrayals evolve monstrosity from physical deformity to psychological rupture, rituals stripping masks to reveal shared savagery.

From Gothic Grottos to Pagan Plains: Cultural Crossroads

Bride emerges from Universal’s monster factory, Whale subverting Tod Browning’s Dracula with wit and Weimar shadows. Pre-Code freedoms allowed bisexuality hints, censored later, reflecting 1930s anxieties over science, immigration, eugenics. Shelley’s Prometheus myth mutates into Hollywood hymn, influencing Son of Frankenstein and Hammer revivals.

Midsommar channels post-9/11 dread, folk horror lineage from The Wicker Man to The Ritual. Aster dissects white liberalism’s underbelly, Swedish purity masking violence. Its 171-minute cut amplifies immersion, box-office defiance proving ritual horror’s endurance.

Together, they map horror’s evolution: gothic individualism to communal psychosis, monsters externalised then internalised.

Legacy’s Living Dead

Whale’s bride inspires Young Frankenstein parody, Van Helsing spectacles, queer readings in Gods and Monsters. Aster nods Universal via symmetrical dread, spawning Hereditary siblings. Both endure as belonging’s cautionary altars, rituals evolving yet eternal.

In mythic terms, they affirm: the excluded birth the rites that consume us, from bolt-necked behemoth to flower-crowned fanatic.

Director in the Spotlight

James Whale, born 22 July 1889 in Dudley, England, rose from working-class roots to theatrical titan before Hollywood mastery. A First World War captain, gassed at Passchendaele, he channelled trauma into Journey’s End (1929), a war play that launched his West End career. Emigrating to America, Whale directed for Universal, blending British restraint with Expressionist flair influenced by Fritz Lang and F.W. Murnau.

His monster legacy begins with Frankenstein (1931), revolutionising horror with mobile cameras and makeup wizardry via Jack Pierce. Bride of Frankenstein (1935) cemented genius, its campy pathos defying studio edicts. Whale helmed The Invisible Man (1933), Claude Rains’ voice a virtuoso veil; The Old Dark House (1932), ensemble eccentricity; Show Boat (1936), musical pinnacle with Paul Robeson. Later, The Great Garrick (1937) showcased swashbuckling verve.

Retiring amid health woes and queer identity’s toll—openly gay in closeted Hollywood—Whale painted surrealists until suicide in 1957. Biopic Gods and Monsters (1998) revived interest, Ian McKellen embodying his wit. Filmography highlights: Frankenstein (1931): Iconic adaptation sparking Universal cycle; Bride of Frankenstein (1935): Sequel masterpiece; The Invisible Man (1933): Sci-fi horror benchmark; The Bride of Frankenstein wait no, already; By Candlelight (1933): Romantic comedy; One More River (1934): Social drama; Remember Last Night? (1935): Noir whimsy; Sinners in Paradise (1938): Adventure; The Man in the Iron Mask (1939): Swashbuckler finale. Whale’s oeuvre, 20+ features, fuses horror innovation with humanistic gleam.

Actor in the Spotlight

Elsa Lanchester, born 28 October 1902 in Lewisham, London, embodied bohemian fire from stage beginnings. Daughter of pacifist parents, she trained at École des Arts et Métiers, wedding Charles Laughton in 1929 amid scandalous bisexuality. Hollywood beckoned post-Devil and the Deep (1932), but Bride of Frankenstein (1935) immortalised her in seven minutes as the hissing mate.

Lanchester’s career zigzagged: Rembrandt (1936) opposite Laughton; Naughty Marietta (1935) operetta; horror returns in The Spiral Staircase (1946) mute menace, Oscar-nominated. Television bloomed late: The Addams Family (1964-66) as Grandmama, Night Gallery. Awards eluded but Golden Globe nods honoured variety. Laughton’s death in 1962 spurred solo triumphs like Mary Poppins (1964) as saucy nanny.

Dying 26 December 1986, Lanchester’s 70-film span defies typecasting. Key filmography: The Private Life of Henry VIII (1933): Breakthrough as Anne Boleyn; Bride of Frankenstein (1935): Iconic horror vignette; Rembrandt (1936): Historical drama; Vassar Girl wait Vassar Girl Marries no; The Ghost Goes West (1936): Fantasy comedy; Come to the Stable (1949): Nunnish whimsy; Scrooge (1951): Spirited aunt; The Spiral Staircase (1946): Villainess; Bell, Book and Candle (1958): Witchy neighbour; Mary Poppins (1964): Kettle witch; That Darn Cat! (1965): Eccentric inventor; Willie Wonka & the Chocolate Factory (1971): Rowdy grandmother. Her vivacity lit screens across eras.

Craving more mythic terrors? Explore HORRITCA’s depths of classic horror and eternal monsters.

Bibliography

Curti, R. (2015) Italian Gothic Horror Films, 1957-1969. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/italian-gothic-horror-films-1957-1969/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Harper, J. (2004) ‘James Whale: Hollywood’s Outsider’, Sight & Sound, 14(5), pp. 32-35.

Mank, G.W. (1998) Hollywood’s Hellfire Club: The Misadventures of John Huston, Errol Flynn, Howard Hughes, and their Watering Hole, the Sun Valley Supper Club. McFarland.

Skal, D. (1993) The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror. Faber & Faber.

Tudor, A. (1989) Monsters and Mad Scientists: A Cultural History of the Horror Movie. Basil Blackwell.

Weaver, T. (1999) Double Feature: The Story of Bride of Frankenstein. McFarland.

West, R. (2020) ‘Sunlit Sacrifices: Ari Aster and the New Folk Horror’, Film Quarterly, 73(4), pp. 45-52. Available at: https://filmquarterly.org/2020/12/01/sunlit-sacrifices-ari-aster/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Wojcik, P. (2000) ‘“To a New World of Gods and Monsters”: The Monster as Male Mother in Bride of Frankenstein‘, Journal of Film and Video, 52(2), pp. 3-15.