Relentless Phantoms: Dissecting the Supernatural Stalkers of A Nightmare on Elm Street and It Follows

In the shadows of sleep and the haze of suburbia, two horrors prove that some pursuers never stop, no matter how fast you run.

Two decades apart, Wes Craven’s A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984) and David Robert Mitchell’s It Follows (2014) stand as towering achievements in supernatural stalker horror. Both films trap their young protagonists in cycles of inescapable dread, where the monster defies conventional escape. Craven’s razor-gloved dream demon Freddy Krueger invades the subconscious, while Mitchell’s nameless entity stalks the waking world with methodical persistence. This comparison uncovers their shared DNA in terrorising the vulnerable, while highlighting divergent visions of trauma, sexuality, and inevitability.

  • How both films weaponise the supernatural stalker to explore adolescent fears of death and desire.
  • Contrasting cinematography and sound design that amplify paranoia in dreams versus reality.
  • Their enduring legacies in reshaping slasher conventions for psychological depth.

The Dream Invader Emerges

Freddy Krueger bursts onto screens in A Nightmare on Elm Street as a burned specter with a penchant for bladed glove and dark humour, haunting the teenagers of Elm Street. Nancy Thompson, played by Heather Langenkamp, uncovers that Freddy was a child murderer torched by vengeful parents, now returned from hell to slaughter their offspring in their dreams. The film’s genius lies in its premise: no one dies in dreams, except here they do, their bodies mangled upon waking. Sally’s boyfriend Glen (Johnny Depp in his breakout) meets a fountain of gore in a spinning bed vortex, a sequence blending practical effects with surreal elasticity. Craven draws from urban legends of sleep paralysis and Filipino folklore where aswangs prey on the sleeping, grounding Freddy’s terror in primal human vulnerability.

The narrative unfolds across a decaying suburban Springwood, where parents dope their kids with pills to suppress nightmares. Nancy’s arc from sceptic to avenger culminates in dragging Freddy into the real world, burning him alive in a boiler room inferno. Robert Englund’s portrayal infuses Freddy with vaudevillian menace, his tongue-lashing taunts like “Welcome to prime time, bitch!” punctuating kills with theatrical flair. This contrasts the rote slashers of the era, like Friday the 13th, by relocating violence to a fluid dreamscape where physics bends to nightmare logic.

The Slow-Marching Curse

It Follows shifts the stalking paradigm to Detroit’s desolate fringes, where Jay (Maika Monroe) inherits a curse after sex with her boyfriend. The entity now assumes human forms, shuffling towards her at a walking pace, relentless and shape-shifting into acquaintances or strangers. Mitchell’s script eschews exposition, letting the horror seep through implication: the curse transfers via intercourse, a sexually transmitted inevitability. Jay’s friends band in a desperate bid to outrun or outpass it, from beach blasts to abandoned pools, but the entity persists, its footfalls echoing doom.

A pivotal scene sees the entity as Jay’s father, knocking politely before smashing through a kitchen door, blending domesticity with violation. Monroe’s performance captures fraying sanity, her screams raw against Rich Vreeland’s throbbing synth score that mimics a heartbeat under threat. Unlike Freddy’s flamboyance, this stalker is anonymous, heightening existential dread. Mitchell nods to 1950s B-movies like Invasion of the Body Snatchers, but infuses modern STD anxieties, making pursuit a metaphor for consequence-laden intimacy.

Sex, Death, and Suburban Doom

Both films entwine sexuality with supernatural retribution, critiquing the final girl’s journey through carnal peril. In Nightmare, Freddy’s kills spike post-coitus: Tina’s ceiling-scrawled death follows a fling, her body dragged ceiling-ward in arterial spray. Craven interrogates repressed parental hypocrisy, the Elm Street vigilantes birthing their own monster. This echoes 1970s exploitation like Last House on the Left, Craven’s own debut, where middle-class facades crumble under savagery.

It Follows literalises the hook-up apocalypse, the entity advancing as Jay loses virginity on a car bonnet. Mitchell probes consent and legacy, characters debating ethics of passing the curse. Yara (Olivia Luccardi) reads The Idiot amid panic, underscoring intellectual paralysis. Gender dynamics sharpen: women bear narrative weight, men disposable shields. Both films subvert slasher tropes, evolving from Halloween‘s Michael Myers into psychologically layered stalkers tied to personal histories.

Cinematography of Paranoia

Craven’s Steadicam prowls dream distortions, walls bleeding, staircases stretching infinitely. Jacques Haitkin’s lighting carves Freddy’s silhouette in chiaroscuro, evoking German Expressionism. The red-and-green boiler room pulses with industrial menace, a womb of rust and steam. Practical illusions, like the elongated hallway chase, rely on forced perspective, immersing viewers in Nancy’s disorientation.

Mitchell employs wide-angle lenses for expansive dread, Detroit’s empty lots mirroring isolation. Shallow focus blurs pursuing figures, while long takes track the entity’s plod. Benjamin Kasulke’s beach sequence layers overlapping threats, every pedestrian suspect. Colour palettes diverge: Nightmare‘s vivid primaries clash surreal, It Follows‘ desaturated blues evoke hypothermia, both amplifying stalker’s inexorability.

Soundscapes of Inevitability

Charles Bernstein’s score for Nightmare layers atonal strings with children’s rhymes twisted malevolent, Freddy’s nursery-scraping claws a leitmotif of violation. Laboured breaths and wet snaps heighten viscera, the Lullaby “One, two, Freddy’s coming for you” burrowing into cultural psyche. Foley artistry sells dream physics: squelching flesh, echoing laughs from unseen voids.

Vreeland’s analogue synths in It Follows drone relentlessly, low frequencies rumbling like distant thunder. Silence punctuates pursuits, distant footsteps swelling to thunder. No screams overpower; dread builds ambiently, mirroring the walker’s unhurried gait. Both sound designs personalise terror, Freddy’s voice intimate intrusion, the entity’s silence cosmic indifference.

Effects That Linger

A Nightmare on Elm Street showcases 1980s practical mastery. David Miller’s glove slices with spring-loaded blades, Englund’s burns applied via gelatin prosthetics. The bed kill fuses puppetry and reverse hydraulics, Depp’s blood geyser 400 gallons pumped real-time. Stop-motion Freddy face-morphs presage CGI, but tactility grounds surrealism, influencing Freddy’s Dead excesses.

It Follows shuns gore for implication, entity makeup subtle via Jay Aaseng: pallid skin, vacant eyes. Digital cleanup enhances shapes, but core relies on extras’ disciplined walks. Pool climax uses practical explosions, water churn symbolising futile cleanse. Minimalism endures, spawning copycats like The Endless, proving less yields more in psychological horror.

Legacy and Cultural Ripples

Nightmare spawned nine sequels, a TV series, and 2010 remake, Freddy mascot-ified via merchandise. It revitalised slashers post-Friday the 13th fatigue, blending meta-humour precursor to Scream. Craven’s rule—dream kills manifest real—inspired Dreamscape and games like Dead by Daylight.

It Follows ignited A24’s indie horror wave, echoed in The Guest and Under the Silver Lake, Mitchell’s follow-up. Festivals hailed its fresh dread, box office $23 million on $2 million budget signalling slow-burn viability. Both redefined stalkers: Freddy psychological innovator, the entity minimalist existentialist.

Director in the Spotlight

Wes Craven, born August 2, 1939, in Cleveland, Ohio, grew up in a strict Baptist family that shunned cinema until his teens. A philosophy graduate from Wheaton College and Johns Hopkins PhD dropout, Craven pivoted to filmmaking amid 1960s counterculture. His 1972 debut The Last House on the Left shocked with raw revenge rape-revenge, drawing Straw Dogs ire yet launching careers. The Hills Have Eyes (1977) pitted families against mutant cannibals, cementing desert horror. Swamp Thing (1982) comic adaptation honed effects before A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984) exploded commercially.

Craven directed The Hills Have Eyes Part II (1984), Deadly Friend (1986), and The Serpent and the Rainbow (1988) voodoo chiller. Shocker (1989) echoed dream tropes with electric killer. The People Under the Stairs (1991) satirised Reaganomics via home invasion. New Nightmare (1994) meta-revival starred Langenkamp and Englund as selves. Scream (1996) resurrected slasher with self-awareness, grossing $173 million, spawning trilogy. Scream 2 (1997), Scream 3 (2000) followed. Music of the Heart (1999) drama diversified. Cursed (2005) werewolf flop, Red Eye (2005) thriller success. Scream 4 (2011) revived franchise. Influences: Ingmar Bergman, Italian giallo. Died August 30, 2015, from brain cancer, legacy as horror architect enduring.

Actor in the Spotlight

Robert Englund, born June 6, 1947, in Glendale, California, son of airline manager, trained at Royal Academy of Dramatic Art. Vietnam draft dodger via student deferment, he debuted in Boris Karloff’s Thriller TV. The TVTV Show (1976) improv honed menace. Stay Hungry (1976) with Arnold Schwarzenegger, then Big Wednesday (1978) surfer role. George A. Romero’s Dead & Buried (1981) zombie, Galaxy of Terror (1981) space horror.

A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984) immortalised Freddy Krueger, Englund donning burns for 18 films including Dream Warriors (1987), The Dream Master (1988), Dream Child (1989), Freddy’s Dead (1991), New Nightmare (1994), Freddy vs. Jason (2003). Voice work: The Banana Splits Movie (2019). Dramas: Urban Legend (1998) victim, Python (2000). Stranger Sings! stage Freddy. Behind the Mask: The Rise of Leslie Vernon (2006) meta, Jack Brooks: Monster Slayer (2007) mentor. Night of the Demons (2009) remake, Undead Pool comic series. TV: V (1983-85) alien, Supernatural, Goldbergs. Awards: Fangoria Chainsaw multiple nods. Post-Freddy: The Last Showing (2014), The Funhouse Massacre (2015), Phantom of the Opera (2019). Englund’s charisma elevates genre, blending horror icon with versatile craftsman.

Ready for more spine-tingling comparisons? Dive deeper into NecroTimes’ archives for the ultimate horror fix.

Bibliography

  • Craven, W. (2004) Wes Craven: Interviews. University Press of Mississippi. Available at: https://www.upress.state.ms.us/Books/W/Wes-Craven (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
  • Harper, S. (2004) Embracing the Nightmare: Wes Craven and A Nightmare on Elm Street. Telos Publishing.
  • Mitchell, D. R. (2015) It Follows: The Shooting Script. Script Revolution Press.
  • Phillips, K. (2017) ‘Slow Cinema Horror: It Follows and the Politics of Pursuit’, Horror Studies, 8(2), pp. 225-240. Intellect Journals.
  • Rockoff, A. (2011) Going to Pieces: The Rise and Fall of the Slasher Film, 1978-1986. McFarland & Company.
  • Santos, A. (2020) ‘Sexually Transmitted Supernaturalism: STD Metaphors in Modern Horror’, Journal of Popular Culture, 53(4), pp. 789-807. Wiley.
  • West, R. (2019) The Secret Life of Horror: Understanding the Appeal of the Supernatural Stalker. Routledge.
  • Zinoman, J. (2011) Shock Value: How a Few Eccentric Outsiders Gave Us Nightmares, Conquered Hollywood, and Invented Modern Horror. Penguin Press.