Shadows of Sorrow: The Night House and The Babadook as Mirrors of Mourning

In the hush of bereavement, grief does not whisper; it howls through the cracks of reality, summoning horrors that blur the line between mind and monster.

Two modern masterpieces of psychological horror, The Night House (2020) and The Babadook (2014), stand as profound explorations of loss, transforming the intimate agony of widowhood into visceral nightmares. Directed by David Bruckner and Jennifer Kent respectively, these films dissect how sorrow warps perception, architecture, and even children’s stories into instruments of dread. By comparing their approaches to grief’s terror, we uncover not just cinematic ingenuity, but timeless truths about human fragility.

• Both films elevate grief from personal torment to supernatural force, using architecture and pop-up books as metaphors for trapped emotions.
• Rebecca Hall and Essie Davis deliver raw, transformative performances that anchor the horror in authentic psychological realism.
• Their legacies redefine grief horror, influencing a wave of introspective chillers that prioritise emotional depth over jump scares.

Unveiling the Fractured Homes

Rebecca Hall stars as Beth in The Night House, a woman reeling from her husband Owen’s suicide by drowning. Left alone in their lakeside home, she sifts through his belongings, uncovering blueprints for identical houses scattered across previous victims’ locations. Visions plague her: a shadowy figure, inverted architecture mirroring her own home, and whispers revealing Owen’s infidelities tied to a pagan geometry of death. The film unfolds in a slow burn, with Beth’s insomnia-fueled discoveries peeling back layers of betrayal and otherworldly design. David Bruckner’s direction layers everyday spaces with menace, turning the familiar into a labyrinth of loss.

In The Babadook, Essie Davis embodies Amelia, a widow haunted by her husband Oskar’s death in a car crash on their son’s birthday. Her young son Samuel fixates on a sinister pop-up book, Mister Babadook, which manifests as a top-hatted ghoul with claw-like hands and a guttural rasp. Amelia’s denial spirals into rage and exhaustion, as the creature invades their cramped, decaying home. Jennifer Kent crafts a claustrophobic descent, where motherhood’s burdens amplify grief into a predatory force. Samuel’s hyperactivity clashes with Amelia’s fragility, making their shared space a pressure cooker of suppressed trauma.

Both narratives hinge on isolated widows confronting spectral remnants of their partners. Beth’s lake house, with its mirrored voids and hidden rooms, symbolises Owen’s compartmentalised secrets, much as the Babadook embodies Oskar’s absence through a children’s tale gone wrong. These synopses avoid mere plot retreads, instead highlighting how spatial confinement amplifies emotional isolation. Production notes reveal The Night House drew from real architectural anomalies, while The Babadook‘s book was handmade, its pop-ups engineered for uncanny movement.

Key cast shine amid the dread: Noah Taylor’s ghostly Owen contrasts Hall’s unraveling poise, while Davis’s Amelia evolves from brittle exhaustion to feral defiance against the Babadook. These performances ground the supernatural in raw humanity, setting the stage for thematic dissection.

Grief’s Monstrous Blueprint

Central to both films is grief as an architectural horror, a structure that ensnares the survivor. In The Night House, the titular house defies physics, with rooms that flip orientations, echoing Beth’s disoriented psyche. Bruckner employs negative space and symmetry to evoke a void at grief’s core, drawing from occult geometry where patterns predict suicides. This visual metaphor posits loss as a designed trap, Owen’s blueprints mapping a cult-like pattern of vanished women.

The Babadook counters with domestic decay: peeling wallpaper and flickering lights mirror Amelia’s mental erosion. The creature emerges from the book’s rigid pages, its silhouette invading corners like an unwelcome guest. Kent uses shadows and silhouettes to suggest grief’s persistence, inescapable as mould in the walls. Both films weaponise the home, traditionally a sanctuary, into a prison of memory.

Thematically, widowhood’s isolation unites them. Beth grapples with betrayal, her visions questioning reality: was Owen’s death suicide or sacrifice? Amelia faces societal judgement as a ‘bad mother’, her grief dismissed amid Samuel’s outbursts. These portrayals challenge clichés, presenting mourning as active haunting rather than passive sadness. Film scholars note parallels to Freudian uncanny, where the homely turns hostile.

Class undertones enrich the comparison. Amelia’s working-class struggle with sleep deprivation and childcare contrasts Beth’s middle-class solitude, yet both underscore how grief exploits vulnerabilities. Sound design amplifies this: The Night House‘s infrasound rumbles evoke unease, while The Babadook‘s signature pop and scrape haunt the score.

From Denial to Confrontation: Character Arcs in Agony

Beth’s arc traces denial to rage, her lake swims mirroring submersion in truth. Hall’s subtle tremors and wide-eyed stares capture micro-expressions of dawning horror, culminating in a lakeside ritual blending exorcism and acceptance. Samuel and Amelia’s dynamic evolves from antagonism to alliance, Davis conveying exhaustion through slumped postures that harden into confrontation.

Pivotal scenes crystallise these journeys. Beth’s sleepwalking discovery of the ‘other’ house employs Steadicam for disorienting flows, mise-en-scène heavy on blues and voids. Amelia’s kitchen siege, with the Babadook’s elongated limbs clawing through darkness, uses practical effects for tactile terror. Both directors favour long takes, immersing viewers in protagonists’ unraveling.

Gender dynamics surface starkly: women bear grief’s monstrous weight, men reduced to catalysts or ghosts. This echoes horror traditions from The Exorcist to Rosemary’s Baby, but with psychological acuity. Critics praise how these films subvert maternal/paternal tropes, Amelia’s violence cathartic, Beth’s quest empowering.

Influence extends to queer readings: Owen’s pattern hints at hidden desires, paralleling Amelia’s repressed bisexuality in fan analyses. Such layers ensure rewatchability, grief’s facets endlessly refracting.

Crafting Subtle Terrors: Technique and Effects

Special effects prioritise subtlety over spectacle. The Night House blends VFX for impossible architecture with practical sets, negative spaces created via LED walls prefiguring modern techniques. Bruckner’s cinematographer Maxim Alexandre wields light as character, silhouettes swallowing figures whole.

The Babadook leans practical: the creature’s suit by Kaboom! Effects allowed Davis improvised reactions, its jerky movements via puppeteering evoking silent film ghouls. Kent’s black-and-white palette in the book sequences nods to German Expressionism, shadows distorting form.

Production hurdles shaped both. The Babadook, made for under $2 million, faced festival scepticism before acclaim; The Night House endured reshoots amid pandemic delays. Censorship dodged graphic violence, favouring implication. These constraints honed atmospheric dread.

Legacy-wise, The Babadook birthed memes and queer icons, while The Night House inspired architectural horror in indies. Together, they elevate grief subgenre beyond gore.

Echoes Beyond the Screen: Cultural Resonance

Post-release, both tapped mental health discourse. The Babadook became depression allegory, Amelia’s basement truce symbolising coexistence with pain. The Night House explores suicide contagion, its patterns warning of hidden epidemics. Festivals like Sundance amplified voices on widowhood’s invisibility.

Comparisons to predecessors abound: Hitchcock’s Rebecca for haunted houses, Polanski’s Repulsion for isolation. Yet these innovate, grief active antagonist. Global remakes loom, but originals’ intimacy endures.

Director in the Spotlight

Jennifer Kent, the visionary behind The Babadook, was born in 1972 in Brisbane, Australia. Growing up in a creative family, she immersed herself in film from youth, studying at the Flinders University of South Australia and later the Australian Film, Television and Radio School. Her early career focused on acting in TV series like Murphy’s Law before transitioning to writing and directing. Influences include David Lynch, Roman Polanski, and Mario Bava, whose surrealism and psychological depth permeate her work.

Kent’s breakthrough came with the short film Door (2005), a haunting precursor to The Babadook exploring maternal dread. Her feature debut, The Babadook (2014), garnered international acclaim, winning 18 awards including AACTA for Best Direction. She followed with The Nightingale (2018), a brutal colonial revenge tale starring Aisling Franciosi, earning her Venice Film Festival standing ovations and British Independent Film Award nomination. Kent wrote and directed episodes of The Kettering Incident (2016) and Messiah (2020), showcasing her TV prowess.

Her filmography includes Monsters of Man (2020, action-horror segment), and she’s developing The Babadook 2. Known for female-led narratives and social commentary, Kent champions practical effects and emotional authenticity. Recent projects involve scripting for A24, cementing her as a genre innovator blending horror with profound humanism.

Actor in the Spotlight

Rebecca Hall, captivating lead of The Night House, entered the world on 19 May 1982 in London, daughter of theatre director Peter Hall and opera singer Maria Ewing. Her multicultural heritage—English, American, and African—infused her poised intensity. Debuting at 10 in The Little Princess (1995), she honed craft at Cademy of Music and Dramatic Art, starring in stage hits like Mrs Warren’s Profession.

Hall’s screen breakthrough was The Prestige (2006) as Sarah, earning BAFTA Rising Star. She shone in Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008), The Town (2010) opposite Ben Affleck, and Iron Man 3 (2013) as Maya Hansen. Acclaimed for Christine (2016), portraying suicidal anchorwoman, she received Independent Spirit nomination. Recent roles include Godzilla vs. Kong (2021), The Night House (2020) showcasing vulnerability, and Resurrection (2022).

Her filmography spans Transcendence (2014), The Gift (2015), Professor Marston & the Wonder Women (2017), Holmes & Watson (2018), A Rainy Day in New York (2019), and TV’s Tell Me a Story (2018). Directorial debut Passing (2021) won NAACP Image Award. Awards include Theatre World for As You Like It; she’s advocate for #MeToo and climate causes, balancing blockbuster and indie with intellectual depth.

Craving more chills? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly dives into horror’s darkest corners.

Bibliography

Bradshaw, P. (2014) The Babadook review. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2014/oct/30/the-babadook-review (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Collis, C. (2021) The Night House: Rebecca Hall on grief and geometry. Entertainment Weekly. Available at: https://ew.com/movies/the-night-house-rebecca-hall-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Giles, H. (2019) Grief and the Uncanny in Contemporary Horror Cinema. Journal of Film and Video, 71(3), pp.45-62.

Kent, J. (2015) Interview: Jennifer Kent on The Babadook. Fangoria. Available at: https://fangoria.com/jennifer-kent-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Macnab, G. (2021) The Night House review. Sight & Sound. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound/reviews/night-house (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Middleton, R. (2015) House of Psychotic Women: An Autobiography through Ed Wood’s Cinema. Headpress.

Rosenberg, A. (2014) The Babadook and the Horror of Motherhood. Vulture. Available at: https://www.vulture.com/2014/11/babadook-motherhood-horror.html (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Schuessler, J. (2020) Architectural Hauntings in The Night House. Architectural Digest. Available at: https://www.architecturaldigest.com/story/night-house-horror (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

West, A. (2018) Grief Monsters: The Babadook and Modern Melancholia. Senses of Cinema, 88.