Skyscrapers of Sin: The Sentinel and The Devil’s Advocate Clash in Urban Demonia

In the concrete canyons of New York, where ambition and isolation breed darkness, Satan sets up shop.

Two films separated by two decades yet bound by a shared infernal thread: Michael Winner’s The Sentinel (1977) and Taylor Hackford’s The Devil’s Advocate (1997) both plunge viewers into the heart of satanic urban horror. These movies transform the everyday grind of city life—towering apartments and gleaming law offices—into portals for hellish intrusion. By pitting ordinary protagonists against the Prince of Darkness amid the anonymity of metropolis sprawl, they expose how modernity’s facades crumble under supernatural siege.

  • Both films weaponise New York City’s architectural anonymity to stage satanic incursions, turning high-rises and corner offices into gateways for demonic forces.
  • Standout performances—Burgess Meredith’s gleeful occultist in The Sentinel versus Al Pacino’s charismatic Lucifer—elevate theological terror through sheer charisma and menace.
  • Their legacies endure in contemporary horror, influencing tales of corporate evil and haunted habiting that blend Judeo-Christian mythology with urban alienation.

Gateways in the Grey Towers

In The Sentinel, Alison Parker, a fashion model reeling from personal tragedy, seeks solace in a suspiciously affordable Brooklyn brownstone. What begins as a refuge spirals into nightmare as she uncovers the building’s true purpose: a sentinel post guarding the gateway to Hell. Michael Winner crafts a claustrophobic descent, where the apartment’s peeling walls and echoing corridors pulse with otherworldly dread. The film’s narrative draws from Jeffrey Konvitz’s 1974 novel, amplifying Catholic eschatology with visceral imagery of deformed souls clawing from the abyss. Key scenes, like the revelation of the building’s hellmouth in the basement, utilise stark lighting contrasts—harsh fluorescents clashing with shadowy voids—to symbolise the thin veil between salvation and damnation.

Contrast this with The Devil’s Advocate, where ambitious lawyer Kevin Lomax (Keanu Reeves) ascends from small-town Florida to the pinnacle of Manhattan’s legal elite by joining Milton, Chadwick & Waters. The firm’s opulent tower becomes the devil’s domain, masterminded by John Milton (Al Pacino), revealed as Satan incarnate. Hackford’s adaptation of Andrew Neiderman’s novel relocates biblical temptation to boardrooms and penthouses, where success is the ultimate snare. The penthouse suicide sequence, bathed in crimson hues and distorted reflections, mirrors The Sentinel‘s climactic horde but swaps grotesque physicality for psychological unraveling, emphasising vanity over vigilantism.

Both narratives thrive on urban isolation. Alison’s neighbours—eccentric artists and recluses—harbour infernal secrets, much like the firm’s partners who mask their allegiance with tailored suits. This parallel underscores a core theme: the city’s impersonality fosters vulnerability to supernatural predation. New York’s labyrinthine streets and sky-scraping isolation amplify paranoia, a tactic Winner and Hackford exploit masterfully. Historical context bolsters this; the 1970s saw The Sentinel amid post-Exorcist satanic panic, while 1990s excess birthed The Devil’s Advocate as a cautionary tale against yuppie hubris.

Class dynamics sharpen the comparison. Alison represents middle-class aspiration fleeing marital strife, only to confront proletarian horrors below stairs. Kevin embodies upward mobility’s dark underbelly, seduced by luxury that devours his soul. These arcs critique American dreams corrupted by infernal capitalism, with Hell manifesting not as fire pits but as rent-controlled flats and corner offices.

Devilish Denizens and Their Deadly Charms

Performances anchor both films’ infernal allure. In The Sentinel, Burgess Meredith steals scenes as Mr. Chazen, the blind priest orchestrating the sentinel duty. His jovial demeanour—chuckling over tea while revealing apocalyptic truths—infuses occultism with folksy menace, reminiscent of earlier devilish turns in Bedazzled. Cristina Raines conveys Alison’s fragility turning to resolve, her wide-eyed terror in the hellgate confrontation evoking possessed innocence akin to Linda Blair’s Regan.

Al Pacino’s John Milton in The Devil’s Advocate redefines satanic swagger. His monologues, blending Shakespearean bombast with Southern drawl, culminate in the rain-lashed rooftop revelation: “Vanity, definitely my favourite sin.” This tour de force outshines Reeves’ earnest everyman, much as Meredith eclipses Raines. Pacino draws from Milton’s Paradise Lost, portraying Lucifer as a fallen angel resentful of divine monopoly, adding philosophical depth absent in Winner’s more literal demons.

Supporting casts amplify tensions. Ava Gardner’s elegant yet sinister landlady in The Sentinel hints at decayed aristocracy complicit in evil, paralleling Jeffrey Jones’ leering mediator in Hackford’s film. These characters embody temptation’s seductive familiarity, blurring lines between ally and adversary in the urban jungle.

Gender roles diverge intriguingly. Alison’s arc pivots on redemptive suffering, a nod to female martyrdom in Catholic horror. Mary Ann (Charlize Theron) in The Devil’s Advocate fractures under hallucinatory assault, her visions of swarming insects symbolising patriarchal control exerted through supernatural gaslighting. Both women highlight vulnerability, yet Theron’s raw breakdown offers a modern psychological edge over Raines’ more archetypal hysteria.

Infernal Aesthetics: Lights, Shadows, and Special Nightmares

Cinematography distinguishes the duo. Winner employs gritty 1970s realism—handheld shots through dimly lit hallways evoking Rosemary’s Baby—culminating in a hellish finale with practical effects: contorted extras in latex prosthetics surging forth. The effects, supervised by Carlo Rambaldi, prioritise grotesque realism, their shambling advance under flickering red light etching visceral terror.

Hackford counters with polished 1990s gloss. Andrzej Bartkowiak’s camera glides through mirrored lobbies and storm-swept towers, using CGI-enhanced apparitions for Milton’s throne room metamorphosis. Practical gore persists in Mary Ann’s self-mutilation, blending old-school splatter with digital flourishes—a bridge to millennial horror.

Sound design heightens unease. The Sentinel‘s discordant Gregorian chants and creaking floors build dread, while The Devil’s Advocate deploys James Newton Howard’s orchestral swells and whispers for subliminal menace. These auditory layers embed Satan in the city’s hum, from traffic drones to elevator dings.

Mise-en-scène reinforces themes. The Sentinel’s brownstone, with its baroque furnishings and hidden chapels, contrasts the firm’s modernist chrome and glass—tradition versus modernity, both besieged by the eternal.

Production Purgatories and Cultural Contexts

Behind-the-scenes trials mirror onscreen chaos. Winner shot The Sentinel amid New York real estate woes, casting genuine oddballs as deformed guardians after open calls yielded grotesque authenticity. Censorship battles ensued; the MPAA demanded hellgate trims, yet its unrated cut persists as a grindhouse staple.

Hackford faced studio pressures to tone down religious iconography, navigating 1990s backlash against faith-based scares post-The Omen sequels. Budget overruns from Pacino’s improvisations enriched monologues but strained schedules, yielding a $57 million grosser that recouped handsomely.

Both tap zeitgeists: 1970s economic slump fuels The Sentinel‘s housing horrors, echoing Son of Sam fears. 1990s dot-com boom informs The Devil’s Advocate, warning of moral voids in prosperity. Influences abound—Polanski’s urban paranoia for Winner, Friedkin’s possession for Hackford—yet each innovates satanic tropes.

Legacy: Echoes in the Eternal City

Influence ripples outward. The Sentinel inspired gateway motifs in Constantine (2005) and Legion (2010), its deformed horde echoed in zombie apocalypses. The Devil’s Advocate prefigures corporate occultism in Succession-esque dramas and Lucifer series, Pacino’s devil a benchmark for charismatic antagonists.

Remakes eluded both, but cultural osmosis endures: urban horror hybrids like Fallen (1998) blend their DNA. Critically, The Sentinel languished as cult fare, revived by boutique Blu-rays; Hackford’s film divides, praised for spectacle yet critiqued for plot contrivances.

Ultimately, these films affirm satanic horror’s adaptability. From 1970s grit to 1990s sheen, they prove the devil thrives in urban progress’s cracks, a warning as relevant in streaming age tower blocks.

Director in the Spotlight: Michael Winner

Michael Winner, born in 1935 in London to a prosperous Jewish family, emerged as a multifaceted filmmaker blending exploitation thrills with mainstream appeal. Educated at Cambridge University, where he studied law but pursued journalism, Winner cut his teeth directing TV plays and documentaries in the 1950s. His feature debut, Climb Up the Wall (1960), a quirky comedy, showcased his knack for British eccentricity. Transitioning to horror and action, he helmed The System (1964), a beach-set drama starring Oliver Reed, before international breakthroughs.

Winner’s 1970s peak included Death Wish (1974), launching Charles Bronson’s vigilante saga and cementing his vigilante violence niche amid urban decay anxieties. The Sentinel (1977) marked his supernatural pivot, blending Roman Polanski influences with Grand Guignol excess. Other highlights: Chato’s Land (1972), a revisionist Western; The Mechanic (1972), a hitman thriller; and Scandal (1989), a Profumo affair biopic with John Hurt. He directed 33 features, often self-producing via his company, Winner’s Golden Palace Productions.

Influenced by Hitchcock’s suspense and Hammer Films’ gothic flair, Winner favoured practical effects and location shooting, as in The Nightcomers (1971), a Turn of the Screw prequel. Later works like Dirty Weekend (1993) veered erotic thriller territory. A flamboyant restaurateur and tabloid fixture, Winner penned restaurant reviews and memoirs like Winner Takes All (1981). Knighted? No, but recipient of Bafta nominations, he died in 2013 at 77, leaving a legacy of pulpy provocation. Filmography highlights: Horror Hospital (1973, grotesque sci-fi); The Big Sleep (1978, noir remake); Firepower (1979, actioner with Sophia Loren); Appointment with Death (1988, Agatha Christie adaptation).

Actor in the Spotlight: Al Pacino

Alfredo James Pacino, born April 25, 1940, in East Harlem, New York, to Italian-American parents, rose from poverty after his parents’ divorce. Raised by his mother and grandparents in the Bronx, Pacino honed acting at Manhattan’s High School of Performing Arts and HB Studio under Lee Strasberg. Dropping out of college, he scraped by in off-Broadway gigs before Me, Natalie (1969) marked his screen debut.

Breakthrough came with Francis Ford Coppola’s The Godfather (1972) as Michael Corleone, earning an Oscar nod and defining his intense persona. Subsequent triumphs: Serpico (1973), Dog Day Afternoon (1975)—both Oscar-nominated—and And Justice for All (1979). The 1980s mixed hits like Scarface (1983) with duds, but Sea of Love (1989) revived him. Nineties pinnacles included The Godfather Part III (1990), Glengarry Glen Ross (1992), and The Devil’s Advocate (1997), where his devilish tour de force showcased Method mastery.

Pacino’s accolades: Oscar for Scent of a Woman (1992), plus eight more nominations; Golden Globes, Emmys for You Don’t Know Jack (2010). Stage revivals like Salome (1990) and Hughie (2016) affirm his theatre roots. Influences: Brando, Dean; style: explosive charisma meets vulnerability. Filmography spans 50+ roles: …And Justice for All (1979, corrupt lawyer); Author! Author! (1982, comedy); Revolution (1985, Revolutionary War); Dick Tracy (1990, gangster); Heat (1995, cop saga); Insomnia (2002, thriller); The Irishman (2019, mob epic); House of Gucci (2021, flamboyant villain). At 84, Pacino remains prolific, blending gravitas with gonzo energy.

Discover More Nightmares

Craving deeper dives into horror’s darkest corners? Subscribe to NecroTimes for exclusive analyses, retrospectives, and the latest chills straight to your inbox.

Bibliography

  • Clark, D. (2002) Anatomy of a Killer: The Making of Death Wish. Reynolds & Hearn.
  • Daniels, L. (2013) Urban Horror: Nightmares in the City. McFarland & Company. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/urban-horror/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
  • Harris, S. (1997) Interview with Taylor Hackford on The Devil’s Advocate. Fangoria Magazine, Issue 169.
  • Jones, A. (2004) Grindhouse: The Forbidden World of Drive-In Horror. Feral House.
  • Konvitz, J. (1974) The Sentinel. Playboy Press.
  • Neiderman, A. (1990) Devil’s Advocate. Simon & Schuster.
  • Paul, W. (1994) Laughing, Screaming: Modern Hollywood Horror and Comedy. Columbia University Press.
  • Winner, M. (1981) Winner Takes All: A Life of Fun, Food and Film. Virgin Books.
  • Wood, R. (1986) Hollywood from Vietnam to Reagan. Columbia University Press.