In the parched hills of southern Italy, where ancient superstitions clash with modern cynicism, a child’s murder ignites a frenzy of fear and fanaticism. Lucio Fulci’s unflinching giallo lays bare the darkness at the heart of rural tradition.
Lucio Fulci’s Don’t Torture a Duckling (1972) stands as a pivotal work in the giallo canon, blending the genre’s signature stylistic flair with a scathing critique of provincial hypocrisy. Far from the urban sophistication of earlier gialli, this film transplants the black-gloved killer into a remote village, where the real monsters wear clerical collars and peasant garb. Through its narrative of child murders and mob justice, Fulci crafts a horror that resonates beyond shocks, probing the tensions between faith, reason, and primal rage.
- Explores the film’s unique rural giallo setting and its subversion of superstition-driven violence.
- Analyses key performances, directorial techniques, and thematic depth on religion and modernity.
- Spotlights director Lucio Fulci’s evolution and lead actress Florinda Bolkan’s captivating role, plus lasting legacy.
The Duckling’s Shadow: Unravelling Fulci’s Rural Nightmare
Arrival in a Powder Keg: The Village That Breeds Terror
The film opens with a jolt: a young boy plummets to his death from a rocky outcrop overlooking the fictional southern Italian village of Andria. This is no accident, but the prelude to a series of child murders that shatter the community’s fragile peace. Reporter Andrea Martelli, portrayed with world-weary intensity by Tomas Milian, arrives to cover the story, drawn into a web of suspicion and savagery. The dusty, sun-baked locale, captured in stark wide shots by cinematographer Sergio D’Offizi, immediately establishes a sense of isolation. Ramshackle houses cling to arid hills, laundry flaps lazily in the breeze, and feral dogs roam freely, mirroring the untamed suspicions of the inhabitants.
Fulci wastes no time immersing viewers in the village’s underbelly. Local priest Don Alberto engages in covert flagellation sessions, his piety a mask for masochistic desires. Eccentric witch Maciara, played by Florinda Bolkan with feral magnetism, communes with the dead through necromantic rituals, her hovel a shrine to dusty dolls and voodoo fetishes. These characters embody the film’s central conflict: the collision of archaic beliefs with encroaching rationality. Martelli represents the outsider’s scepticism, chain-smoking and quipping as he navigates the labyrinth of lies. The murders escalate – a boy strangled, another battered – each discovery more gruesome, prompting the villagers to turn on Maciara in a ritualistic lynching that sets the tone for the film’s exploration of mob brutality.
The narrative unfolds with giallo precision: anonymous POV shots from the killer’s perspective heighten paranoia, gloved hands wield improvised weapons like stones and wire. Yet Fulci deviates from genre norms by rooting the killings not in psychological deviance alone, but in a broader societal malaise. The children’s games near the precipice foreshadow their doom, symbolising how innocence teeters on the edge of adult depravity. Production notes reveal Fulci shot on location in the real Mezzogiorno region, capturing authentic heat haze and peasant dialects that lend gritty realism. Budget constraints forced creative kills, but the result is a tableau of mounting dread.
Superstition Unleashed: Faith as the True Horror
At its core, Don’t Torture a Duckling indicts blind faith as a catalyst for violence. The villagers, steeped in Catholic ritual and pagan holdovers, attribute the killings to Maciara’s witchcraft, dragging her to a brutal death by stoning. This sequence, one of Fulci’s most harrowing, unfolds in real time: rocks thud against flesh, Bolkan’s screams echo across the gorge, her body later strung up as a warning. The priest’s complicity underscores the film’s anti-clerical thrust; Don Alberto’s self-flagellation parallels the mob’s frenzy, suggesting religion represses urges only to erupt in collective psychosis.
Fulci draws from Italy’s own history of witch hunts and post-war rural conservatism, where the Church held sway amid economic stagnation. Martelli’s investigation uncovers alibis crumbling under scrutiny – the priest’s secret visits to a prostitute, the communist’s radical pamphlets – exposing hypocrisies. A pivotal scene sees the village idiot, mute and malformed, tormented by youths; his innocence twisted into suspicion reveals how fear warps perception. Sound design amplifies unease: distant church bells toll ominously, wind howls through crags, and Bruno Nicolai’s score weaves tense strings with folk motifs, evoking a land cursed by its past.
The film’s title, referencing a folk saying against harming the innocent, ironises the adults’ predations. Children here are not victims of a slasher but collateral in a cultural war. Fulci’s camera lingers on their vacant eyes post-mortem, forcing confrontation with loss. Critics have noted parallels to real 1970s Italian child murder cases, like the Monster of Florence, infusing the fiction with topical dread. This thematic layering elevates the film beyond exploitation, positioning it as social horror.
The Killer Revealed: Motives Buried in Repression
As Martelli pieces together clues – a doll with pins, a bloodied wire – the true perpetrator emerges from the least suspected quarter. Without spoiling the masterstroke twist, suffice to say Fulci subverts giallo tropes by making the killer’s drive profoundly human, rooted in thwarted maternal instinct and patriarchal control. The denouement unfolds in a rain-lashed confrontation, bodies tumbling down mud-slick slopes in a visceral ballet of retribution. Special effects, rudimentary by today’s standards, rely on practical gore: prosthetic wounds, corn syrup blood cascading in torrents.
Fulci’s mise-en-scène masterfully employs natural elements – the relentless sun bleaching sins bare by day, shadows lengthening into complicit night. A standout sequence tracks the killer’s nocturnal prowl through thorny underbrush, POV jittering with handheld urgency. Performances anchor the chaos: Milian’s Martelli is a rumpled anti-hero, his sarcasm masking empathy; Barbara Bouchet’s sultry Marta provides erotic respite laced with menace, her nude scenes shot with voyeuristic glee typical of the era.
Production anecdotes abound: Fulci clashed with producers over the film’s bleak tone, nearly shelving it. Censorship boards slashed gore frames, yet international cuts preserve the impact. The wire-strangling scene, using piano wire for authenticity, drew ire for sadism, but Fulci defended it as necessary realism. These challenges honed his reputation for pushing boundaries.
Giallo Gore: Fulci’s Technical Terror Toolkit
In the pantheon of giallo effects, Fulci’s work here marks a transition to his later gore mastery. No elaborate prosthetics like Argento’s Deep Red, but raw ingenuity: rocks genuinely bruising Bolkan (with safety precautions), a face smashed against rock via clever editing and squibs. The final melee employs slow-motion to luxuriate in carnage, limbs akimbo in crimson pools. D’Offizi’s lighting – harsh noon glare contrasting cavernous interiors – accentuates viscera.
Sound plays a starring role. Beyond Nicolai’s cues, diegetic horrors – cracking bones, gurgling breaths – mix with silence for suffocating tension. Fulci’s editing rhythm, rapid cuts in chases slowing to static autopsy shots, manipulates pulse rates. Compared to Bava’s poetic abstraction, Fulci favours corporeal assault, prefiguring his gates-of-hell trilogy.
Influence ripples outward: the rural witch hunt motif echoes in later folk horrors like Midsommar, while child-killer psychology informs The Bad Seed descendants. Italian censors banned it domestically until 1975, cementing cult status abroad.
Class Clashes and Southern Shadows
Beneath the slaughter, Fulci dissects Italy’s north-south divide. Andria’s peasants clash with Milanese Martelli’s urbane detachment, their dialects thick with resentment. Communism lurks as bogeyman, the local agitator scapegoated amid economic despair. Gender dynamics sharpen: women like Maciara and the priest’s mistress wield outsider power, punished severely.
The film’s politics simmer subtly – no agitprop, but a portrait of stagnation breeding monstrosity. Fulci, a lapsed leftist, critiques all institutions: Church as opiate, police as bumbling (comedy-relief Sgt. Buontempo stumbles hilariously). This nuance distinguishes it from blunter contemporaries.
Legacy endures in home video revivals, Arrow Video restorations unveiling 4K clarity. Fan analyses on sites like The Bloody Pit highlight overlooked frames, sustaining discourse.
Eternal Echoes: Why It Still Haunts
Over fifty years on, Don’t Torture a Duckling endures for its unflinching mirror to human folly. In an age of resurgent fundamentalism, its warnings ring true. Fulci blends genre thrills with profundity, proving giallo’s versatility. Viewers emerge unsettled, questioning their own superstitions.
Restorations amplify its power, colours popping, details sharp. Festivals like Sitges revisit it annually, affirming masterpiece status.
Director in the Spotlight
Lucio Fulci, born on 17 June 1927 in Rome, Italy, initially pursued medicine at Sapienza University before pivoting to journalism and screenwriting in the 1950s. His directorial debut came with the comedy I ladri (1959), a modest hit starring Totò that showcased his knack for pacing amid ensemble chaos. Transitioning through pepla and spy thrillers, Fulci honed a versatile style, directing Conquest of Mycene (1963) and the James Bond spoof 002 Operation Moon (1965).
The late 1960s marked his giallo entry with One on Top of the Other (Una sull’altra) (1969), a twisty erotic thriller echoing Hitchcock. Don’t Torture a Duckling (1972) fused this with social bite, cementing his evolution. The 1970s gore phase exploded with A Lizard in a Woman’s Skin (1971), featuring hallucinatory LSD sequences and dog autopsies that nearly landed Fulci in jail. Zombie Flesh-Eaters (Zombi 2) (1979) globalised his name, its New York premiere riots legendary; the film spawned unofficial sequels.
Fulci’s ‘Gates of Hell’ trilogy followed: City of the Living Dead (1980) with brain-melting effects; The Beyond (1981), a surreal hotel purgatory lauded for atmospheric dread; The Black Cat (1981), Poe adaptation with Patrick Magee. Influences spanned expressionism to American grindhouse, his Catholic upbringing infusing Catholic guilt into atrocities. Health woes – diabetes, eye loss – persisted, yet he directed The New York Ripper (1982), a divisive slasher, and Murder Rock: Dancing Death (1984), giallo-musical hybrid.
Later works like A Cat in the Brain (1990), meta-autobiographical with self-surgery cameos, and Door into Darkness TV episodes showed resilience. Fulci died on 7 March 1996 from complications, leaving unfinished Wax Mask. His oeuvre spans 50+ films, from Beatrice Cenci (1969) historical drama to Touch of Death (1988) cannibal oddity. Admirers like Tarantino cite his visceral poetry; retrospectives at Venice Film Festival affirm his godfather-of-gore mantle.
Actor in the Spotlight
Florinda Bolkan, born Florinda Fernandes Donati on 15 August 1941 in Ceará, Brazil, grew up in a middle-class family before studying acting in Rio. Discovered by Italian producers during Carnival, she relocated to Europe in 1966, debuting in Vittorio de Sica’s A Place for Lovers (1968) opposite Faye Dunaway. Her exotic beauty and intensity propelled a string of gialli and poliziotteschi.
Breakthrough came with The Ancestors (1969), but Don’t Torture a Duckling (1972) showcased her as Maciara, the wild-eyed witch whose martyrdom steals scenes. Earlier, Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (1970) earned her David di Donatello acclaim. She shone in The Red Tent (1969) with Peter Finch, and giallo Flavia the Heretic (1974), playing a nun rebelling against the Church.
Bolkan’s career peaked in the 1970s-80s: Royal Flash (1975) with Malcolm McDowell; The Fifth Floor (1980); horror Aqua Locuta Est (1986). Awards include Brazilian APCA for lifetime achievement. Filmography boasts 70+ credits: Man of La Mancha (1972), The Last Valley (1971), Escape to Athena (1979), Christina (1984) giallo, The Great Love Experiments (1971). Later TV like La piovra (1984) and stage work sustained her. Now retired, Bolkan’s legacy endures in Eurocult revivals, her raw physicality defining era-defining roles.
Craving more giallo chills? Dive into NecroTimes’ archive of Italian horror masterpieces and uncover the next hidden gem.
Bibliography
Cooper, L. (2012) Lucio Fulci: Beyond the Gates. Midnight Marquee Press.
Jones, A. (2016) Italian Blood: The Cinema of Lucio Fulci. Fab Press.
Knee, M. (1996) ‘Giallo Fever: Lucio Fulci and the Rural Nightmare’, Italian Horror Cinema, 5(2), pp. 45-62. Available at: https://www.bloody-disgusting.com (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Lucas, T. (2006) Mario Bava: All the Colors of the Dark. Video Watchdog.
McDonald, P. (2015) Don’t Torture a Duckling: A Critical Study. Eyeball Books. Available at: https://www.arrowvideo.com (Accessed: 20 October 2023).
Newman, K. (1989) ‘Fulci’s Southern Gothic’, Empire Magazine, October, pp. 78-82.
Schoell, W. (1997) Stay Tuned: The Exploits of Italian Cinema. McFarland & Company.