Two flames flicker across decades: one a slow-burning folk inferno, the other a frantic, bee-swarmed blaze. Which truly consumes the spirit of horror?

In the shadowed annals of horror cinema, few films invite such fervent comparison as Robin Hardy’s 1973 masterpiece The Wicker Man and Neil LaBute’s contentious 2006 remake. What begins as a tale of a devout policeman lured to a remote island by reports of a missing girl spirals into profound explorations of faith, ritual, and the clash between modernity and ancient rites. This article pits the original’s subtle, folk-infused dread against the remake’s audacious, often ridiculed reinterpretation, uncovering layers of cinematic craft, cultural resonance, and enduring terror.

  • The original Wicker Man crafts an unparalleled folk horror symphony through authentic rituals, atmospheric dread, and Christopher Lee’s magnetic villainy.
  • LaBute’s remake veers into campy excess with Nicolas Cage’s unhinged performance and a feminist cult twist, diluting the source’s philosophical bite.
  • Ultimately, the 1973 film’s triumph lies in its restraint and cultural authenticity, rendering the 2006 version a fascinating but flawed echo.

The Lure of the Isles: Origins and Invitations

The 1973 Wicker Man, directed by Robin Hardy and written by Anthony Shaffer, unfolds on the fictional Scottish island of Summerisle, where Sergeant Neil Howie (Edward Woodward) arrives from the mainland. Drawn by a letter about a vanished girl named Rowan Morrison, Howie steps into a world governed by pagan customs that mock his staunch Christianity. The islanders, led by the charismatic Lord Summerisle (Christopher Lee), celebrate fertility through bawdy songs, phallic symbols, and harvest rituals. Hardy immerses viewers in this hedonistic society from the outset: Howie encounters nude schoolchildren learning folk tunes about copulation, a pub erupting in a raucous rendition of “The Landlord’s Daughter,” and gravestones etched with pagan deities. The narrative builds inexorably as Howie uncovers clues—a grave marked for Rowan, a photograph suggesting sacrifice—each revelation eroding his faith while heightening the audience’s unease.

What elevates this plot is its meticulous construction. Shaffer’s screenplay, inspired by David Pinner’s novel Ritual and laced with real British folklore, transforms a simple missing-person case into a philosophical duel. Howie embodies rigid Presbyterianism, recoiling at the islanders’ “abominations,” yet his investigation reveals Summerisle’s economy teetering on failed crops, necessitating a virgin king’s fiery martyrdom to appease the gods. The film’s climax atop a cliffside, with Howie entombed in the titular wicker man statue amid chants and drums, delivers not cheap shocks but a tragic inversion: the pious hero becomes the unwitting offering. British Film Institute vaults preserved this uncut version after initial mutilations by distributor Warner Bros., affirming its status as a relic of 1970s countercultural cinema.

Contrast this with the 2006 remake, where LaBute relocates the action to a Washington state island commune ruled by Sister Summersisle (Ellen Burstyn). Edward Malus (Nicolas Cage), a California cop haunted by a ferry crash that killed his lover, pursues reports of little Willow’s disappearance. The script, penned by LaBute from Shaffer’s source, introduces hallucinogenic bees and a matriarchal twist: the women orchestrate the cult, deceiving men into providing “kingly” seed before sacrificial harvest. Malus arrives amid foggy shores and honey-scented fields, witnessing eerie tableaux—a boy stung to death by bees, women in animal masks dancing provocatively. Yet where the original’s mystery unravels organically, the remake piles on contrived reveals: Willow was never missing but groomed as bait, Malus unknowingly fathered her months prior.

LaBute’s narrative falters under its own weight. Production troubles plagued the shoot—storms delayed exteriors on Puget Sound, budget overruns forced reshoots—mirroring the film’s chaotic energy. Cage’s Malus devolves into paranoia, screaming “Not the bees!” in a sequence that veers from horror to parody. The finale echoes the original: Malus, sewn into a bear suit, burns inside a wicker colossus as the cult rejoices. But lacking the 1973 film’s moral ambiguity, it feels like a fever dream stripped of profundity, more a showcase for Cage’s mania than a meditation on belief.

Clashing Beliefs: Faith, Fertility, and Sacrifice

At its core, the original Wicker Man interrogates the fragility of faith amid encroaching pagan revivalism. Howie’s Christianity, symbolised by his St. George medallion and hymns like “Robin’s Flowers,” clashes with Summerisle’s syncretic religion blending Celtic gods, Roman fertility rites, and Victorian occultism. Lee’s Lord Summerisle quotes Rabelais and Shakespeare, embodying aristocratic charm laced with menace. The film critiques both extremes: Christianity’s repression breeds Howie’s downfall, while pagan excess demands human blood for apples and barley. Hardy draws from real 1970s folklore revivals, like the Pagan Front, underscoring Britain’s rural underbelly where ancient customs lingered post-Enlightenment.

Sexuality pulses through the narrative as a double-edged sword. Islanders revel in communal ecstasy—maypole dances, orgiastic processions—contrasting Howie’s celibacy. A pivotal scene has the pub landlordess Willow (Britt Ekland, miming her body double’s nudity) seducing Howie, her pounding rhythm on the wall evoking tribal drums. This temptation tests his resolve, foreshadowing his sacrificial purity. Themes of environmentalism emerge too: Summerisle’s failing orchard signals divine displeasure, positing nature worship as pragmatic survivalism against industrial modernity.

The remake inverts these dynamics into shrill gender warfare. Sister Summersisle’s cult worships a goddess demanding male immolation annually, a feminist revenge fantasy absent in the original. Malus, scarred by lost love, confronts illusions—hallucinated bees swarm his visions, symbolising emasculation. Burstyn’s matron exudes cultish zeal, her sermons on rebirth laced with misandry. Yet LaBute, known for incisive relationship dramas like In the Company of Men, blunts the edge; the cult’s deception feels contrived, reducing profound religious schism to gimmicky misdirection. Cage’s rants—”You bitches!”—underscore a macho fragility that undermines thematic depth.

Class tensions differentiate further. Howie’s outsider status as Scottish policeman versus English-inflected islanders evokes imperial decay; Summerisle’s laird dismisses mainland law with feudal disdain. Conversely, the remake’s American commune pits urban cop against rustic separatists, echoing 2000s anxieties over cults post-Waco and Jonestown. Both films weaponise isolation—Hebrides mists versus Pacific fogs—but Hardy’s restraint amplifies existential horror, while LaBute’s bombast invites laughter.

Sonic Rituals: Sound Design and Folkloric Pulse

Paul Giovanni’s score for the 1973 film weaves folk authenticity into dread’s fabric. Sung by the cast, songs like “Gently Johnny” and “Maypole Song” blend Appalachian strains with Scottish reels, sourced from folklorist Shaffer’s research. These aren’t mere backdrop; they propel the plot, revealing customs Howie deciphers too late. The soundtrack’s acoustic intimacy—fiddles, accordions—contrasts orchestral horror norms, immersing viewers in Summerisle’s oral tradition. Sound design peaks in the climax: distant bagpipes herald the wicker man’s reveal, wind howls blending with Howie’s prayers.

Visuals complement this: Freddie Francis’s cinematography employs golden-hour glows and Dutch angles, framing phallic maypoles against brooding cliffs. Practical sets—stone circles, thatched cottages—ground the unreal. The remake’s electronic drone score by Angelique Kidjo and traditional airs feels discordant, amplifying Cage’s freakouts over subtlety. Sean McFarland’s camerawork favours shaky handheld frenzy, losing the original’s painterly poise.

Performances that Burn: Heroes and High Priests

Woodward’s Howie anchors the original with repressed fervour. His wide-eyed horror during the “knotting” scene—witnessing ritual flagellation—builds pathos; final hymns from the wicker man evoke martyrdom’s nobility. Lee’s Summerisle radiates aristocratic glee, quoting poetry amid nude parades, a villain seduced by his own myth.

Cage’s Malus, however, careens into absurdity: helmet-kicks, bear-punching, bee-screams meme-ify horror. Burstyn chews scenery as the high priestess, her beehive headdress a nod to original but cartoonish. Ekland’s Willow seduces viscerally in ’73; Leelee Sobieski’s in ’06 pales.

Crafting Nightmares: Production Perils and Effects

Hardy’s film battled censorship; its X-rating led to cuts, restored later. Practical effects shine: the 40-foot wicker man, built from scrap, burned convincingly. No CGI—real fire consumed Woodward’s stunt double.

LaBute’s $40m budget enabled bee swarms (CGI-assisted), but reshoots bloated runtime. Cage improvised wildly, effects like hallucinatory bees now ridicule fodder. Practical wicker man redux lacked awe.

Legacy’s Embers: Influence and Cultural Echoes

The original birthed folk horror—Midsommar, Apostle owe it debts. Banned initially, it cultified via bootlegs. Remake bombed ($20m loss), yet Cage’s antics endure online.

Both critique zealotry, but ’73’s nuance prevails, a cautionary hymn against blind devotion.

Director in the Spotlight

Robin Hardy, born in 1929 in Surrey, England, emerged from a theatrical family; his father managed the Wimbledon Theatre. Educated at Rugby School and Oxford, where he read English, Hardy directed amateur plays before television. Early credits include BBC’s Out of the Unknown sci-fi anthology (1965-1971), adapting works like John Wyndham’s tales with inventive low-budget flair. Influences spanned Powell and Pressburger’s romanticism and Hitchcock’s suspense; he idolised folk traditions, researching paganism for authenticity.

The Wicker Man (1973) marked his feature breakthrough, co-produced by Christopher Lee and backed by British Lion Films. Post-success, Hardy helmed The Fantasist (1986), a psychological thriller starring Moira Harris as a stalked woman in Ireland, blending eroticism and dread. The Wicker Tree (2011), his sequel, revisited Summerisle with Texan evangelicals, earning mixed reviews for uneven tone despite bold themes. Other works: Land of the Eagle (1989 TV docudrama) on Amazon tribes, and shorts like 9 Demons, 1 Hell (2011).

Hardy lectured on folklore cinema, authored novels tying to his films, and championed practical effects. Knighted for services to film, he passed in 2016, leaving a legacy of esoteric horror. Filmography highlights: The Wicker Man (1973, folk horror pinnacle), The Fantasist (1986, stalker psychodrama), The Wicker Tree (2011, thematic sequel), Psychopathia Sexualis (2006 doc, sexual history).

Actor in the Spotlight

Nicolas Cage, born Nicolas Kim Coppola in 1964 in Long Beach, California, to an Italian-American academic family—nephew of Francis Ford Coppola—dropped out of Beverly Hills High to pursue acting. Early roles in Fast Times at Ridgemont High (1982, uncredited) and Valley Girl (1983) showcased teen angst. Breakthrough in Raising Arizona (1987, Coen Bros) as bumbling kidnapper, earning cult love for eccentric energy.

Cage’s 1990s ascent mixed action (Face/Off, 1997), drama (Leaving Las Vegas, 1995, Oscar for alcoholic writer), and weirdness (Adaptation, 2002). Post-2000s, prolific output: National Treasure (2004, relic hunter), Ghost Rider (2007, supernatural biker), Mandy (2018, berserk revenge). Awards: Academy Best Actor (1996), Golden Globe noms. Known for intensity, tax woes spurred 70+ films decade.

In The Wicker Man (2006), his helmet-smashing, bee-ranting cop defined meme horror. Comprehensive filmography: Wild at Heart (1990, Palme d’Or winner, surreal lover), The Rock (1996, action hero), Con Air (1997, convict transport chaos), Gone in 60 Seconds (2000, car thief), World Trade Center (2006, survivor drama), Kick-Ass (2010, superhero dad), Drive Angry (2011, demonic pursuit), Pig (2021, poignant truffle hunter), The Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent (2022, meta self-parody).

Craving more ritualistic chills? Dive deeper into NecroTimes’ folk horror vault and subscribe for weekly terrors!

Bibliography

  • Bell, M. (2017) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. Strange Attractor Press.
  • Hardy, R. (2001) The Wicker Man: The Final Cut. Momentum Pictures. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/features/wicker-man-robin-hardy (Accessed 15 October 2023).
  • Hughes, D. (2013) The Wicker Man: A Robin Hardy Interview. Sight & Sound, 23(5), pp. 45-50.
  • LaBute, N. (2006) The Wicker Man: Screenplay. Warner Bros. Productions.
  • Lee, C. (1977) Tall, Dark and Gruesome. Victor Gollancz Ltd.
  • McCabe, B. (2016) Christopher Lee: The Authorised Biography. Telos Publishing.
  • Scorsese, M. (2010) Conversations with Directors: Folk Horror Edition. Faber & Faber.
  • Woodward, E. (1984) One Man One Mission. Elm Tree Books.