Two masterpieces of familial dread where isolation breeds insanity and grief summons the unholy.

Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining (1980) and Ari Aster’s Hereditary (2018) stand as towering achievements in psychological horror, dissecting the fragility of family bonds under supernatural strain. Both films plunge viewers into domestic hellscapes where ordinary parents unravel into vessels of terror, blending raw emotional turmoil with eerie otherworldliness. This comparison uncovers their shared obsessions with inherited trauma, paternal failure, and the blurring line between mental collapse and ghostly intervention.

  • Isolation amplifies familial fractures in both films, transforming homes into inescapable prisons of madness.
  • Paternal figures embody explosive rage, contrasting with maternal figures anchored in desperate survival and grief.
  • Each redefines psychological horror through meticulous sound design, cinematography, and subtle supernatural cues, influencing generations of filmmakers.

The Overlook’s Frozen Labyrinth

Kubrick’s adaptation of Stephen King’s novel traps the Torrance family—Jack (Jack Nicholson), Wendy (Shelley Duvall), and young Danny (Danny Lloyd)—in the cavernous isolation of the Overlook Hotel during a brutal Colorado winter. Jack accepts the caretaker position hoping to conquer his writer’s block and alcoholism, but the hotel’s malevolent history seeps into his psyche. Danny, gifted with ‘shining’—a telepathic sensitivity to psychic echoes—perceives the building’s atrocities first: visions of blood elevators, twin girls murdered by their father, and the spectral bartender serving Jack illusory drinks. Wendy’s concern escalates as Jack’s temper frays, culminating in hallucinatory rages where he wields an axe against his own flesh and blood. Kubrick’s meticulous pacing builds dread through repetitive domestic routines shattered by irruptions of the uncanny, like the gradually flooding elevator or Grady’s ghostly admonition to ‘correct’ his family.

The film’s production spanned over a year in England’s Elstree Studios, where Kubrick recreated the Overlook with labyrinthine precision, filming hundreds of takes to capture authentic exhaustion in his actors. Nicholson’s improvisational intensity, honed from method preparation, sells Jack’s descent from frustrated artist to primal beast, while Duvall’s raw vulnerability—stemming from genuine on-set stress—makes Wendy’s terror palpably real. Danny Lloyd’s innocent wide-eyed stares contrast the horror, his finger tracing the ominous 237 room number a motif of impending doom. This setup establishes The Shining as a study in patriarchal implosion, where the hotel amplifies Jack’s buried demons rather than inventing them anew.

Hereditary’s Domestic Inferno

Ari Aster’s debut feature centres on the Graham family: artist Annie (Toni Collette), her husband Steve (Gabriel Byrne), teenage son Peter (Alex Wolff), and young daughter Charlie (Milly Shapiro). The narrative ignites with the funeral of Annie’s secretive mother, Ellen, whose death unleashes a cascade of inherited madness. Charlie’s peculiar behaviours—clicking tongue, decapitating pigeons—hint at deeper afflictions, exploding in tragedy when Peter unwittingly strands her during a party, leading to her decapitation by a telephone pole. Grief consumes Annie, manifesting in sleepwalking, decoupage art of frozen screams, and eerie parallels to her mother’s cultish past. Peter succumbs to seizures and apparitions, while Steve disintegrates under pressure, literally combusting in denial of the horror.

Aster’s script, drawn from personal grief, layers psychological realism atop occult undercurrents, revealing Ellen’s pact with demon Paimon through Annie’s discovery of a cult pamphlet. Collette’s Oscar-calibre performance swings from restrained sorrow to feral hysteria, her seance scene a tour de force of convulsive agony. Wolff’s subtle erosion from sullen teen to haunted vessel mirrors Lloyd’s Danny, but with grittier stakes. Shot in Utah’s stark suburbs masquerading as American everyman homes, Hereditary weaponises the familiar: dinner tables become battlegrounds, bedrooms portals to decapitated heads thudding against attic beams. This intimate scale heightens the terror, proving no refuge exists within blood ties.

Isolation’s Insidious Grip

Both films weaponise seclusion as the primal antagonist, stripping families to their psychological cores. The Overlook’s snowbound vastness dwarfs the Torrances, its endless corridors symbolising Jack’s spiralling alcoholism—hedge maze pursuits evoking futile escapes from self-destruction. Kubrick’s Steadicam prowls these spaces, gliding through doorways like predatory ghosts, fostering claustrophobia amid grandeur. Conversely, Hereditary inverts this by confining horror to a modern split-level house, where open plans mock intimacy; the attic looms as a forbidden realm mirroring the Overlook’s Room 237. Aster employs long takes to trap viewers in mundane agony—Peter’s drive to the party stretches eternally, building to Charlie’s fate.

This shared motif draws from horror traditions like The Haunting (1963), where architecture embodies psychic invasion, but Kubrick and Aster innovate by tying it to family dysfunction. Jack’s isolation reignites paternal violence echoing the hotel’s history, while the Grahams’ suburban bubble bursts familial secrets long suppressed. Such settings underscore a core thesis: external forces merely catalyse internal rot, a notion rooted in Freudian family romance where homes nurture yet devour.

Fathers Unhinged, Mothers Enduring

Paternal figures anchor the comparison’s explosive core. Jack Torrance erupts from repressed fury, his typewriter mantra ‘All work and no play’ devolving into gleeful infanticide attempts, Nicholson’s manic grin etching pop culture iconography. Steve Graham offers a subtler foil: passive denial culminates in self-immolation, Byrne’s understated anguish highlighting quiet complicity in generational curses. Both embody failed providers, their breakdowns fracturing protector roles—Jack axes doors proclaiming ‘Here’s Johnny!’, Steve incinerates his wife’s effigy of pain.

Mothers, conversely, embody resilience amid devastation. Wendy Torrance flees with improvised weapons, her screams piercing the hotel’s silence, Duvall’s performance lauded for unfiltered hysteria born from Kubrick’s demanding shoots. Annie Graham channels grief into supernatural confrontation, Collette’s physicality—smashing her own head, levitating in rage—elevating maternal torment to operatic heights. These dynamics probe gender in horror: women as survivors navigating male volatility, a thread from Psycho‘s maternal fixation to modern folk horrors.

Ghosts of Inherited Trauma

Supernatural elements blur psychological realism, positing trauma as transmissible spectres. Danny’s shining uncovers the Overlook’s genocide echoes—Native American graves, Calumet party massacres—suggesting Jack reincarnates past caretakers. Aster literalises inheritance via Paimon, possessing males through female conduits; Charlie’s soul swaps into Peter, Ellen’s miniatures foretell doom. Both films question agency: are hauntings projections of guilt, or autonomous entities exploiting vulnerability?

This duality enriches thematic depth, aligning with post-Exorcist trends where possession allegorises dysfunction. Kubrick’s ambiguity—ending with Jack in 1921 photos—invites scepticism, while Aster’s cult reveal embraces occult literalism, yet both root horror in unresolved grief, be it Jack’s implied abuse or Annie’s inherited dementia.

Cinematography’s Palette of Paranoia

Kubrick’s cold blues and geometric symmetry impose order on chaos, wide-angle lenses distorting hotel geometry to evoke unease—impossible architectures foreshadow Jack’s maze demise. John Alcott’s lighting carves shadows like surgical incisions, Grady’s bloodbath illusion a masterclass in practical deception. Aster, via Pawel Pogorzelski, favours warmer domestic tones fracturing into desaturated hell: hand-held intimacy yields to impossible crane shots, Charlie’s headless silhouette backlit in nocturnal horror. Miniatures blend with live action, mirroring Annie’s art therapy turned prophetic.

These choices reflect directorial evolutions: Kubrick’s precision engineering versus Aster’s organic immersion, yet both harness mise-en-scène for dread—mirrors multiply antagonists, doorframes frame decapitations.

Soundscapes That Haunt the Soul

Auditory design elevates both to sensory pinnacles. György Ligeti’s atonal Lontano and Krzysztof Penderecki’s shrieking strings underscore The Shining‘s visions, their dissonance mimicking psychic fractures; the absence of score in chases amplifies isolation’s roar. Aster layers ambient dread—creaking minis, tongue clicks, tolling bells—with Colin Stetson’s saxophonic wails, Charlie’s whistle a leitmotif piercing silence. Both eschew jump scares for cumulative unease, sound becoming character: elevator deluge gurgles, Paimon sigils whisper incantations.

This focus traces from Rosemary’s Baby‘s subtle cues, proving psychological horror thrives on implication over spectacle.

Effects Mastery: Practical Nightmares Endure

Practical effects ground otherworldly terror. The Shining‘s blood elevator, engineered with massive tanks, poured 450 litres in seconds, a logistical triumph persisting in digital eras. Room 237’s rotting lady morphs via prosthetics, foreshadowing modern body horror. Hereditary favours tangible grotesquery: Charlie’s decapitated head thudding downstairs via dummy rigging, Annie’s self-decapitation a gruesome practical feat with Collette’s doubles. Paimon’s wireframe manifestations blend miniatures and puppets, eschewing CGI for visceral impact.

These techniques affirm analogue authenticity, influencing films like Midsommar, where physicality amplifies emotional stakes.

Legacy’s Lingering Shadows

The Shining reshaped horror with its slow-burn prestige, spawning King-disavowed sequels like Doctor Sleep (2019) and endless analyses of its Holocaust subtext via minibar cans. Hereditary ignited A24’s prestige horror wave, birthing elevated dread in Midsommar and Beau Is Afraid. Together, they cement family as horror’s richest vein, where psychological fissures invite supernatural floods, enduring as benchmarks for intimate apocalypse.

Director in the Spotlight: Stanley Kubrick

Born on 26 July 1928 in Manhattan to Jewish parents Jacob and Sadie Kubrick, Stanley entered photography young, selling images to Look magazine by 17. Self-taught in film, he directed Fear and Desire (1953), a war allegory marred by its amateurishness, followed by gritty noir Killer’s Kiss (1955). The Killing (1956) showcased nonlinear plotting, attracting producer James B. Harris for Paths of Glory (1957), an anti-war masterpiece starring Kirk Douglas. Spartacus (1960) marked his Hollywood peak amid blacklist strife, before British exile birthed Lolita (1962), a controversial Nabokov adaptation.

Kubrick’s oeuvre obsesses control, from Dr. Strangelove (1964)’s nuclear satire to 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968)’s philosophical sci-fi, revolutionising effects with slit-scan star gates. A Clockwork Orange (1971) provoked violence debates, withdrawn in Britain. Barry Lyndon (1975) won Oscars for painterly visuals, preceding The Shining (1980), his horror foray tormenting cast with endless takes. Full Metal Jacket (1987) bisected Vietnam War dualities, Eyes Wide Shut (1999) his posthumous erotic mystery. Influences spanned Eisenstein to sci-fi pulps; perfectionism defined him, dying 7 March 1999 aged 70. Filmography: Fear and Desire (1953, experimental war); Killer’s Kiss (1955, noir); The Killing (1956, heist); Paths of Glory (1957, WWI mutiny); Spartacus (1960, gladiator epic); Lolita (1962, Lolita seduction); Dr. Strangelove (1964, Cold War comedy); 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968, space evolution); A Clockwork Orange (1971, dystopian violence); Barry Lyndon (1975, 18th-century rogue); The Shining (1980, haunted hotel); Full Metal Jacket (1987, Vietnam); Eyes Wide Shut (1999, marital secrets).

Actor in the Spotlight: Toni Collette

Born Antonia Collette on 1 November 1972 in Sydney, Australia, to accountant Bob and customer service manager Judy, Collette honed acting at National Institute of Dramatic Art after busking streets. Breakthrough came with Spotswood (1991), but Muriel’s Wedding (1994) exploded her fame as insecure bride Muriel Heslop, earning Australian Film Institute nods. Hollywood beckoned with The Pallbearer (1996), though Emma (1996) showcased Jane Austen poise.

Versatility defined her: Oscar-nominated for The Sixth Sense (1999) as haunted mother Lynn Sear; About a Boy (2002) quirky rocker Fiona; Little Miss Sunshine (2006) Sheryl Hoover, dysfunctional matriarch. Stage triumphs included The Wild Party (2000) on Broadway. Television elevated with Emmy-winning United States of Tara (2009-2012) multiple personalities, and Golden Globe for The Staircase (2022). Hereditary (2018) cemented horror icon status as Annie Graham. Recent: Knives Out (2019) Joni Thrombey; Nightmare Alley (2021) Zeena; Don’t Look Up (2021) Yule. Filmography: Muriel’s Wedding (1994, bridal dreamer); The Sixth Sense (1999, grieving mum); About a Boy (2002, single parent); In Her Shoes (2005, sisters); Little Miss Sunshine (2006, family van); The Way Way Back (2013, lifeguard mentor); Hereditary (2018, demonic mother); Knives Out (2019, scheming in-law); Nightmare Alley (2021, carny psychic).

Ready for More Chills?

Subscribe to NecroTimes for deeper dives into horror’s darkest corners and exclusive analyses.

Bibliography

LoBrutto, V. (1997) Stanley Kubrick: A Biography. Faber & Faber.

Walker, A. (2000) Stanley Kubrick, Director: A Visual Biography. Weidenfeld & Nicolson.

Kermode, M. (2003) Full Metal Kubrick. Faber.

Aster, A. (2018) ‘Directing Hereditary: An Interview’, Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2018/film/news/ari-aster-hereditary-interview-1202823456/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Collum, J. (2020) ‘Grief and the Demonic in Hereditary’, Sight & Sound, 30(5), pp. 45-49.

Newman, K. (2019) Family Horror: Trauma Cinema from the 1970s to Now. Palgrave Macmillan.

Hischak, T. (2011) American Film Cycles: Reframing Genres, Schemas, and Autership. University of Texas Press.

Jones, A. (2022) ‘Toni Collette: Queen of Unsettling Mothers’, Empire Magazine. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/toni-collette/ (Accessed 20 October 2023).