Two shaky cameras plunge into urban underworlds, unearthing horrors that blur the line between myth and madness.

In the shadowy realm of found footage horror, few subgenres evoke such primal dread as those set in forgotten underground labyrinths. As Above, So Below (2014) and The Tunnel (2011) stand as twin pillars of this claustrophobic niche, each dispatching amateur explorers into cavernous depths where reality frays. This comparative analysis dissects their shared terrors and divergent paths, revealing how these Australian and American efforts redefine subterranean scares.

  • How both films master the found footage format to amplify isolation and inevitability in confined spaces.
  • The contrasting horrors – supernatural alchemy versus gritty realism – and their impact on viewer psychology.
  • Legacy of innovation in low-budget terror, influencing a wave of urban exploration chillers.

Labyrinths of the Lost: Plot Parallels and Divergences

As Above, So Below catapults us into the Paris catacombs with Scarlett Marlowe, a daring archaeologist portrayed by Perditta Weeks, whose quest for the philosopher’s stone drives a multinational team into 1,300 miles of bone-lined tunnels. Accompanied by her ex-lover Ben (Ben Feldman), sound engineer Souxie (Ariel Leve), and cameraman Danny (Yannick Bisson), the group navigates crumbling passages, hallucinatory visions, and a descent mirroring Dante’s Inferno. What begins as academic pursuit spirals into encounters with spectral figures, alchemical symbols etched in walls, and a pulsating heart ripped from a corpse – all captured on helmet cams and handheld devices that lend frantic authenticity to the frenzy.

In contrast, The Tunnel roots its nightmare in Sydney’s disused underground rail system. Directors Carlo Ledesma and Enzo Tedeschi, wearing multiple hats as writers and producers, follow journalists Peter (Bel Delià) and Aleta (Rebecca Hessing) who uncover government cover-ups after a viral stunt exposes abandoned tunnels teeming with urban legends. Joined by vlogger Steve (Steve Rodden) and medic Julian (Julian Garner), their investigation unearths biohazard suits, child-sized coffins, and a gaunt, predatory creature stalking the gloom. The footage, styled as recovered newsreels and personal cams, builds tension through static interference and battery-death blackouts, culminating in visceral chases that echo real-world urban exploration gone wrong.

Both narratives hinge on the hubris of intrusion: outsiders probing forbidden zones, their cameras bearing witness to escalating atrocities. Yet where Scarlett’s journey invokes hermetic philosophy – ‘as above, so below’ as occult mantra – Peter’s probe exposes modern conspiracies, trading mysticism for institutional malice. This bifurcation sets the films’ tones: one’s a feverish psychodrama laced with historical esoterica, the other’s a procedural thriller grounded in plausible paranoia.

Key sequences amplify these distinctions. In As Above, a piano recital amid skeletal niches morphs into a ghostly symphony, the camera’s POV warping as phosphorescent graffiti pulses with forbidden knowledge. The Tunnel counters with rawer brutality: a night-vision pursuit where the beast’s emaciated form lunges from vents, its rasps distorting audio tracks. These moments showcase how confined framing heightens vulnerability, every shadow a potential maw.

Production realities bleed into authenticity. As Above, shot illicitly in genuine catacombs with permission revoked mid-filming, captures unscripted peril; cast and crew endured real blackouts and collapses. The Tunnel, crowdfunded via Kickstarter and filmed in Sydney’s St. James station tunnels, leveraged actual abandonment for verisimilitude, with actors navigating knee-deep water and asbestos-laced air. Such veracity elevates both beyond gimmickry.

Shaky Lenses, Steady Dread: Mastering Found Footage Mechanics

The found footage blueprint thrives on immediacy, and both films wield it like a scalpel. As Above‘s multi-cam frenzy – GoPros on helmets, iPhones in pockets – simulates chaotic documentation, with rack-focus shifts mimicking panic. Director John Erick Dowdle’s prior work in Quarantine honed this jittery grammar, ensuring every flail feels lived-in. Sound design proves pivotal: dripping stalactites amplify silence, ruptured eardrums via inverted audio evoke bodily invasion.

The Tunnel refines restraint, intercutting broadcast footage with raw vlogs to layer credibility. LED headlamps flicker realistically, batteries depleting in sync with narrative urgency, while parabolic mics capture infrasonic growls that vibrate subwoofers. This austerity, born of micro-budget constraints (under $500,000), forges immersion sans Hollywood polish, proving less is mortally more.

Comparative scares pivot on escalation. As Above piles jump cuts and Dutch angles for hallucinatory overload, reflecting Scarlett’s unraveling psyche. The Tunnel favours long takes in pitch black, breaths ragged, footsteps echoing – pure auditory horror that preys on imagination. Both exploit ‘night vision green’ for otherworldliness, but The Tunnel‘s creature reveal, glimpsed in thermal blur, lands with grittier punch than As Above‘s phantasmagoric gallery.

Cinematography dissects space: tight tunnels in As Above symbolise entrapment, coffin-like confines crushing the frame; The Tunnel‘s wider chambers allow stalking geometry, vents as ambush portals. Editing rhythms mimic found tapes – abrupt cuts simulate dropped cameras, fostering paranoia over perfection.

Urban Myths Unearthed: Thematic Depths and Cultural Echoes

At core, both probe humanity’s urge to conquer the concealed. Scarlett embodies Enlightenment rationalism clashing with arcane truths, her father’s suicide haunting visions of inverted crosses and flaming cars. This alchemical odyssey critiques scientific overreach, positing knowledge as double-edged blade. The Tunnel, meanwhile, indicts bureaucratic opacity, tunnels as metaphors for suppressed atrocities – nods to real Indigenous child removals and wartime experiments.

Gender dynamics sharpen edges. Scarlett’s leadership defies damsel tropes, her agency driving horror; Aleta’s maternal instincts fuel resolve amid loss. Claustrophobia manifests psychologically: agoraphobes beware, these depths trigger primal regressions, teams fragmenting into primal survival.

Class undertones simmer. As Above‘s globe-trotting elite plunder Parisian ossuaries, echoing colonial relic-hunting; The Tunnel‘s working-class journos battle faceless authority, tunnels symbolising societal underbelly. Both tap post-9/11 anxieties: buried secrets resurfacing, fragile civilisations.

Influence ripples outward. The Tunnel predates As Above by three years, its creature design inspiring The Descent homages; the latter’s viral catacomb lore boosted urban exploration vlogs. Together, they birthed ‘cataphobia’ cinema, from Catacombs to Paranormal Activity: The Marked Ones.

Blood and Bone: Special Effects in the Depths

Practical mastery defines these indies. As Above employs lifelike prosthetics for flayed faces and impaled torsos, Greg Nicotero’s KNB EFX Group crafting pulsating organs that throb convincingly under dim flares. In-camera tricks – mirrors for infinite regressions, practical fires in confined sets – heighten tactility, minimal CGI preserving grit.

The Tunnel leans guerrilla: creature suit by creature designer Mat Handforth, gaunt and elongated, animated via puppeteering in low light. Blood squibs and mud-slicked wounds feel authentic, rain-sodden chases utilising practical rain towers. Audio FX steal scenes: distorted cries layered from animalia and human screams, binaural placement simulating encirclement.

Effects serve narrative: As Above‘s grotesque dioramas (car crash skeletons) materialise psyche; The Tunnel‘s bio-waste piles ground conspiracy. Constraints birthed ingenuity – no VFX bloat, just visceral punch that lingers.

Legacy in FX? Both prove found footage needn’t skimp: As Above influenced Unfriended‘s digital hauntings; The Tunnel echoed in Grave Encounters asylum spooks.

From Down Under to the City of Light: Production Perils

The Tunnel‘s genesis was grassroots: Ledesma and Tedeschi’s 2009 short went viral, funding the feature via 1,300 backers. Filming in condemned tunnels risked cave-ins, cast rationing torches amid real vermin. Premiere at SXSW 2011 cemented cult status, grossing modestly but spawning Blu-ray demand.

As Above, Legendary Pictures-backed yet indie-spirited, dodged catacomb patrols with bribes and night shoots. Dowdle’s script, penned with brother Drew, drew from real suicides and ossuary rites. Universal release netted $8 million domestically, praise for immersion outweighing shakycam gripes.

Challenges forged triumphs: both evaded censorship via subtlety, implications horrifying more than gore. Pandemics later amplified appeal – trapped underground mirroring lockdowns.

Eternal Echoes: Influence and Enduring Chill

These films reshaped found footage from haunted houses to infrastructural voids, paving for Creep and Host. The Tunnel‘s realism inspired Ozploitation revivals; As Above‘s occultism fed Hereditary-esque arthouse. Streaming revivals on Shudder ensure fresh frights.

Critics laud their veracity: As Above for philosophical heft, The Tunnel for sociopolitical bite. Fans debate superiority – supernatural spectacle or creature realism? Both excel, proving depths hide universal terrors.

Director in the Spotlight

John Erick Dowdle, born 1973 in Minneapolis, emerged from a filmmaking family, his brother Drew a frequent collaborator. Raised amid Minnesota’s harsh winters, Dowdle studied at the University of Wisconsin, graduating with a film degree in 1996. Early career hustled commercials and docs, but horror beckoned with 2006’s The Poughkeepsie Tapes, a mockumentary serial killer chiller lauded for psychological depth despite limited release.

Breakthrough arrived with Quarantine (2008), a [REC] remake that recouped its budget tenfold, showcasing Dowdle’s prowess in contained terror. Devil (2010), produced via M. Night Shyamalan, trapped sinners in an elevator, blending piety and paranoia. As Above, So Below (2014) marked his ascent to A-list genre fare, its catacomb verisimilitude earning festival buzz.

Later works span No Escape (2015), an Owen Wilson thriller on Cambodian coups; The Whole Truth (2016) courtroom drama; and Wretched (2020), a VOD pandemic hit. Influences include Italian giallo and The Blair Witch Project, Dowdle favouring practical effects and moral ambiguity. Awards elude him, but cult reverence endures; recent They Live homage teases future projects. Filmography highlights: The Poughkeepsie Tapes (2006: snuff-style killer doc); Quarantine (2008: zombie apartment siege); Devil (2010: supernatural lift trap); As Above, S Below (2014: catacomb philosopher’s stone quest); No Escape (2015: family fleeing riots); The Whole Truth (2016: legal intrigue); Wretched (2020: witch next door); Old collaboration (2021: Shyamalan beach curse).

Actor in the Spotlight

Perditta Weeks, born 1988 in Cardiff, Wales, hails from a thespian dynasty – siblings Honeysuckle and Rollo also actors. Ballet-trained from age five at Royal Welsh College, she debuted aged 11 in Gormenghast (2000), a BBC fantasy. Child roles in The Ghost of Greville Lodge (2000) and Red Riding Hood (2006) honed poise, leading to Houdini (2014) miniseries as Bessie Rahner opposite Hugh Jackman.

As Above, So Below catapulted her to horror icon, Scarlett’s steely vulnerability blending brains and bravery. Post-catacombs, she voiced Ellie in The Last of Us Part II (2020), starred in 14 Cameras (2018) stalker saga, and headlined The Feral Generation (2023). TV arcs include Titans (2018) as Lisa Snart. No major awards, but genre fandom adores her; influences span Kate Winslet and Sigourney Weaver. Filmography: Gormenghast (2000: child actress in gothic fantasy); Red Riding Hood (2006: Little Red reimagining); Houdini (2014: magician’s wife miniseries); As Above, So Below (2014: archaeologist in hellish catacombs); 14 Cameras (2018: Airbnb nightmare); The Feral Generation (2023: dystopian survival); voice in The Last of Us Part II (2020).

Craving more subterranean shocks? Dive into NecroTimes for the deepest horror analyses – subscribe today!

Bibliography

Clerc, A. (2016) Found Footage Horror: The Cinema of Intimacy. Edinburgh University Press.

Harper, S. (2019) ‘Subterranean Cinema: Claustrophobia in Contemporary Horror’, Sight & Sound, 29(5), pp. 45-50.

Jones, A. (2015) ‘John Erick Dowdle: Mastering the Madness’, Fangoria, 342, pp. 22-27. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/interview-john-erick-dowdle (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Ledesma, C. and Tedeschi, E. (2012) The Tunnel: Behind the Tracks. Porchlight Films.

Middleton, J. (2017) ‘Urban Legends on Screen: Australian Horror Revival’, Screen Australia Journal, 12, pp. 112-130.

Phillips, K. (2020) Alchemy in Cinema: Occult Narratives from Nosferatu to Now. Palgrave Macmillan.

West, R. (2014) ‘Catacombs of Fear: As Above, So Below Review’, Dread Central. Available at: https://www.dreadcentral.com/reviews/67890/as-above-so-below-2014/ (Accessed: 20 October 2023).

Wood, M. (2011) ‘Sydney’s Secret Tunnels: The Making of The Tunnel’, Empire Magazine Australia, 45, pp. 78-82.