What Lurks in Laughter: The Vampire Humour Showdown Between The Lost Boys and What We Do in the Shadows

In the shadowed annals of vampire mythology, where fangs meet farce, two films stake their claim as comedy cornerstones, transforming eternal predators into punchline prey.

Vampire lore has long danced on the knife-edge between terror and temptation, but few tales flip the script quite like these two cult favourites. One rides the waves of 1980s excess with a rock ‘n’ roll bite, the other shambles through modern flatshare absurdities with a handheld camera’s unflinching gaze. Together, they chart the beast’s comedic evolution from headbanging horror to sitcom slaughter.

  • The Lost Boys harnesses neon-drenched adolescence and hair metal swagger to mock vampire clichés amid a carnival of carnage.
  • What We Do in the Shadows elevates the mundane to monstrous hilarity, dissecting undead domesticity through mockumentary precision.
  • Juxtaposed, they reveal humour’s transformative power, evolving the mythic bloodsucker from gothic menace to relatable rogue.

Neon Fangs on the Boardwalk

The Lost Boys bursts onto screens in 1987, directed by Joel Schumacher, capturing the Santa Carla boardwalk’s pulsating underbelly where summer nights pulse with saxophone wails and leather-clad allure. Newcomer Michael (Jason Patric) and his younger brother Sam (Corey Haim) tumble into a vortex of vampire allure after Michael falls for the enigmatic Star (Jami Gertz), ensnared by the charismatic David (Kiefer Sutherland) and his gang of eternal teenagers. What unfolds is a symphony of blood-soaked bravado, as comic book-obsessed Sam rallies the Frog brothers—video store sentinels armed with stakes and sarcasm—to combat the nest. The narrative revels in sensory overload: fireworks exploding like arterial sprays, sax solos underscoring seductive flights, and head vampires perched on cavernous thrones fashioned from antlers and taxidermy. Schumacher layers in 1980s iconography—the mullets, the MTV sheen, the fear of latchkey adolescence—turning vampirism into a metaphor for rebellious rites of passage gone fatally awry.

Humour erupts from the collision of juvenile bravado and supernatural stakes. The Frog brothers’ earnest monster-hunting zeal, complete with garlic grenades and holy water squirt guns, parodies every B-movie trope while nodding to the Hammer horrors of yore. David’s crew, with their perpetual youth frozen in punk-rock posturing, lampoons the immortal curse as eternal embarrassment—imagine Dracula trading capes for aviators. A pivotal scene sees Michael half-turning, battling vampire urges at a dinner table, mistaking a TV vampire hunter commercial for reality; the farce peaks when he crunches on maggot-riddled rice, spitting it out in revulsion. This domestic horror-comedy blend elevates the film beyond schlock, rooting laughs in the awkward limbo between boyhood and bloodlust.

Visually, the film’s special effects marry practical gore with MTV aesthetics. Greg Cannom’s makeup transforms Sutherland into a feral cherub, porcelain skin cracking to reveal fangs amid smeared lipstick. Bat transformations utilise animatronics and wires, soaring over comic con crowds in a blur of practical magic that predates CGI excess. The boardwalk finale, a bonfire inferno devouring the vampire nest, symbolises suburban America’s purge of its wild children, yet the humour lingers in survivors’ deadpan quips amid the ashes.

Undead Flatmates and Found Footage Folly

Fast-forward to 2014, and What We Do in the Shadows arrives from New Zealand, helmed by Taika Waititi and Jemaine Clement, who also star as Viago and Vladislav. This mockumentary tracks four vampires—centuries-old Petyr, dandyish Viago, flamboyant Vladislav, and newbie Nick—navigating Wellington’s modern mundanities. Crewed by mortal familiar Jackie, the film captures their nocturnal squabbles: laundry disputes over bloodied sheets, rivalries with local werewolves, and failed hunts at house parties where victims prove disappointingly uncooperative. The plot thickens with Nick’s transformation sparking werewolf turf wars and a police raid gone gruesomely awry, all framed as a fly-on-the-wall farce.

Humour thrives in the minutiae of immortality’s drudgery. Viago’s aristocratic pretensions clash hilariously with flatmate chores—he hypnotises a victim only to fuss over spilled blood on the carpet. Vladislav’s impotence curse, rendering his powers comically feeble (a levitation spell yields mere inches off the floor), skewers the macho vampire archetype. Iconic set-pieces abound: a werewolf transformation scored to dance beats, vampires arguing club entry fees, and Petyr’s Nosferatu-like lair evoking silent-era grotesques. The film masterfully pastiches reality TV tropes, from confessional interviews to slow-motion brawls, making eternal life feel like an endless episode of flatshare hell.

Creature design shines through subtle artistry. Weta Workshop alumni craft fangs and pallor with prosthetic finesse, while Nick’s post-turn awkwardness—learning to fly by crashing into walls—mirrors human adolescence. A standout sequence pits vampires against werewolves in a full-moon truce meeting, devolving into petty jabs about fashion and hygiene, transforming mythic enmity into playground rivalry. This grounded absurdity reimagines folklore’s beasts as bickering bureaucrats, their immortality a punchline rather than a power fantasy.

Humour’s Bloody Lineage

Both films draw from vampire mythology’s comedic undercurrents, traceable to folklore where bloodsuckers often met absurd ends—garlic farts in Eastern European tales, or sunlight immolations mid-seduction. The Lost Boys echoes the 1920s Nosferatu’s rat-like menace but injects California cool, evolving Bram Stoker’s seductive count into a gang leader aping Lost Boys’ real-world surf punks. Shadows, meanwhile, nods to F.W. Murnau’s shadows while aping The Office’s cringe comedy, flattening the gothic hierarchy into egalitarian dysfunction.

Contrasts sharpen their styles: Schumacher’s film pulses with high-octane montage, humour born from visceral excess—vampires exploding in fireworks, heads saxophone-spiked. Waititi and Clement favour deadpan dryness, laughs accruing from understatement, like Nick’s casual reveal of fangs to oblivious friends. The Lost Boys’ humour skewers teen angst, vampirism as metaphor for peer pressure’s bite; Shadows mocks domestic ennui, eternity as eternal roommate roulette. Yet both humanise the monster: David’s gang craves family amid immortality’s isolation, while Viago’s coven clings to ritual amid modernity’s erosion.

Production tales underscore their spirits. Schumacher battled studio meddling, insisting on R-rating grit amid PG pushes, birthing a cult hit grossing modestly but enduring via VHS. Shadows emerged from Flight of the Conchords’ improv roots, shot guerilla-style on New Zealand streets, its $1.6 million budget yielding $26 million worldwide, spawning a TV series. Censorship dodged both—Lost Boys’ gore trimmed lightly, Shadows’ restraint amplifying laughs.

Influence ripples outward. The Lost Boys birthed 1990s vampire romps like Buffy, blending horror with heart; Shadows revitalised mockumentaries post-This Is Spinal Tap, paving for Get Out’s satirical scares. Together, they democratise the vampire myth, from aristocratic predator to everyman’s eternal embarrassment, proving laughter the sharpest stake.

Mise-en-Scène of Mockery

Stylistically, lighting carves their comedic cores. Schumacher bathes Santa Carla in Day-Glo neons and fog-shrouded caves, composition framing vampires against comic book posters—symbolic nods to pulp origins. Shadows employs harsh fluorescents in cramped flats, handheld shakes mimicking reality TV, underscoring the chasm between mythic grandeur and grotty reality. Sound design amplifies: Echo & the Bunnymen’s brooding tracks propel Lost Boys’ flights, while Flight of the Conchords’ deadpan voiceovers narrate Shadows’ banal horrors.

The monstrous feminine diverges too. Star’s ambiguous allegiance adds tragicomic tension, her torn loyalty fuelling farce; Shadows sidelines romance for platonic prickliness, Nandor’s ex-girlfriend a punchline victim. Both critique masculinity: alpha posturing crumbles—David’s throne toppled, Vladislav’s spells fizzling—revealing vulnerability beneath bravado.

Legacy’s Lasting Bite

Decades on, these films anchor vampire comedy’s canon. Remakes flopped—Lost Boys direct-to-video duds, Shadows’ American series thriving on original spirit. Culturally, they echo in Twilight parodies and What We Do spin-offs, affirming humour’s role in myth evolution: from fear’s thrall to farce’s friend.

Director in the Spotlight

Taika Waititi, born Taika David Cohen in 1975 in Te Whanganui-a-Tara (Wellington), New Zealand, to a Māori mother of Ngāti Porou and Te Whānau-ā-Apanui descent and a Jewish father, grew up immersed in storytelling traditions blending indigenous oral histories with Hollywood imports. A former art school dropout and stand-up comedian, Waititi co-founded the theatre troupe Humourbeast before pivoting to short films. His breakthrough came with the Oscar-nominated Two Cars, One Night (2003), a poignant vignette of sibling mischief. Teaming with Jemaine Clement on What We Do in the Shadows (2014) catapulted him globally, its mockumentary mastery earning cult adoration.

Waititi’s career skyrocketed with Hunt for the Wilderpeople (2016), a heartfelt road comedy grossing millions on a shoestring, followed by Thor: Ragnarok (2017), where his script infused Marvel’s Norse god with punk irreverence, earning a billion-dollar haul. Jojo Rabbit (2019), his Oscar-winning satire on Nazi delusion with a imaginary Hitler sidekick, showcased his penchant for wartime whimsy. Directing Thor: Love and Thunder (2022) blended mythic bombast with personal loss, while Next Goal Wins (2023) chronicled American Samoa’s soccer redemption. Influences span Wes Anderson’s quirk and Spike Lee’s bite, evident in his visual poetry and cultural specificity. Filmography highlights: Eagle vs Shark (2007, awkward romance debut), Boy (2010, Māori childhood memoir), Free Fire (2016, gangster siege comedy), and TV’s Our Flag Means Death (2022-, pirate queerness romp). Waititi’s oeuvre evolves folklore into farce, cementing his as cinema’s merry myth-maker.

Actor in the Spotlight

Kiefer Sutherland, born in 1966 in London to actors Donald Sutherland and Shirley Douglas, spent childhood shuttling Canadian sets, imbibing craft early. Debuting at 13 in Max Dugan Returns (1983), he rocketed via The Lost Boys (1987) as David, his brooding charisma defining vampire cool. Stand by Me (1986) showcased teen menace, while Young Guns (1988) launched a Western phase with Young Guns II (1990).

The 1990s brought Flatliners (1990, metaphysical thriller), A Few Good Men (1992, courtroom drama), and The Vanishing (1993 remake). Pivoting to TV, 24 (2001-2010, 2014) as counter-terrorist Jack Bauer earned seven Emmys and a Golden Globe, its real-time pulse revolutionary. Films continued: Phone Booth (2002), Behind Enemy Lines (2001), Designated Survivor (2016-2019, presidential intrigue). Recent: The Caine Mutiny Court-Martial (2023), voice in Monsters University (2013). Awards include MTV Movie Awards for Lost Boys, Satellite for 24. Filmography spans Crazy Moon (1987), Bright Lights, Big City (1988), Renegades (1989), Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me (1992), The Nutcracker Prince (1990 voice), Article 99 (1992), The Three Musketeers (1993), Eye for an Eye (1996), Beat (2000), Desert Saints (2001), Dead Heat (2002), L.A. Confidential (TV 2013 pilot), Forsaken (2015), Flatliners (2017 remake). Sutherland embodies rugged intensity, from feral fangs to ticking-clock heroism.

Craving more mythic mirth? Dive deeper into HORRITCA’s vampire vault and subscribe for eternal updates.

Bibliography

Abbott, S. (2007) Celluloid Vampires: Life After Sunset in the Modern World. University of Texas Press.

Carroll, N. (1990) The Philosophy of Horror: Or, Paradoxes of the Heart. Routledge.

Dika, V. (1990) Games of Terror: Halloween, Friday the 13th, and the Films of the Stalker Cycle. Fairleigh Dickinson University Press.

Glover, D. (1996) Vampires, Mummies, and Liberals: Bram Stoker and the Politics of Popular Fiction. Duke University Press.

Hearne, L. (2014) ‘Interview: Taika Waititi and Jemaine Clement on What We Do in the Shadows’, IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/features/general/what-we-do-in-the-shadows-taika-waititi-jemaine-clement-interview-89185/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Schumacher, J. (1987) Production notes for The Lost Boys, Warner Bros. Archives.

Skal, D.N. (1993) The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror. W.W. Norton & Company.

Waller, G.A. (1986) The American Horror Film. University of Illinois Press.

Wood, R. (1986) Hollywood from Vietnam to Reagan. Columbia University Press.