When the devil invades the home, no family escapes unscathed: two masterpieces redefine possession through intimate terror.

In the pantheon of horror cinema, few subgenres grip the soul like possession films, where the battle for a human body becomes a proxy war for cosmic forces. William Friedkin’s The Exorcist (1973) set the gold standard, shattering box office records and cultural taboos with its visceral depiction of a girl’s demonic takeover. Nearly half a century later, Ari Aster’s Hereditary (2018) arrived as a spiritual successor, trading Catholic rites for hereditary curses and amplifying the familial devastation. This comparison unearths their shared DNA in family horror while spotlighting divergences in tone, technique, and terror.

  • Both films centre possession within the nuclear family, transforming domestic spaces into infernal battlegrounds and exposing parental impotence against the supernatural.
  • The Exorcist leans on religious ritual and practical effects for its shocks, while Hereditary embraces psychological fragmentation and subtle dread for a slower burn.
  • Their legacies endure, influencing generations of filmmakers by blending grief, faith, and the uncanny to probe humanity’s fragility.

Unveiling the Demonic Archetype

Possession narratives trace back to ancient folklore, from the Bacchic frenzies of Greek myth to medieval accounts of witches and incubi, but cinema elevated them to visceral art. The Exorcist drew from William Peter Blatty’s 1971 novel, inspired by the 1949 exorcism of Ronald Edmonds in St Louis, where a boy exhibited levitation, guttural voices, and stigmata-like marks. Friedkin amplified these into a screenplay that prioritised authenticity, consulting Jesuit priests and filming in Iraq’s Nineveh ruins for the opening sequence. The result was a film that premiered amid controversy, with audiences fainting in theatres and critics decrying its blasphemy, yet it grossed over $440 million worldwide on a $12 million budget.

Contrast this with Hereditary, where Ari Aster roots possession in matrilineal occultism rather than opportunistic evil. The Graham family’s torment stems from the late Ellen Leigh’s cultish legacy, invoking Paimon, a king of Hell from the Lesser Key of Solomon. Aster’s script eschews historical precedents for invented mythology, building unease through inherited miniatures and cryptic heirlooms. Released to A24’s arthouse buzz, it earned $82 million against a $10 million budget, praised for its emotional rawness amid slow-building horror. Both films weaponise the familiar—bedrooms, dining tables—into loci of dread, proving the home inviolable only in illusion.

The MacNeil Descent: The Exorcist‘s Sacred Defilement

Chris MacNeil (Ellen Burstyn), a celebrated actress filming in Georgetown, notices her daughter Regan (Linda Blair) suffering seizures and personality shifts. Doctors diagnose hyperactivity, but as Regan’s bed shakes violently, profane Aramaic spews from her mouth, and her head spins 360 degrees in one of cinema’s most infamous scenes. Father Damien Karras (Jason Miller), a doubting priest haunted by his mother’s death, joins Father Lankester Merrin (Max von Sydow) for the rite, culminating in Merrin’s death and Karras’s self-sacrifice by leaping from a window, only to be revived sans demon.

Friedkin’s direction masterfully blends documentary realism with supernatural eruptions. The crucifix scene, where Regan masturbates with a metallic statuette, shocked 1970s audiences, leading to bans in parts of the UK. Practical effects by Rob Bottin and Dick Smith—prosthetics for facial distortions, pneumatic rigs for levitation—ground the horror in tangible grotesquery. Burstyn’s raw screams, captured in unfiltered takes that injured her back, infuse maternal desperation with unbearable authenticity.

Graham’s Inheritance: Hereditary‘s Generational Doom

Annie Graham (Toni Collette), a miniaturist grieving her secretive mother, faces escalating tragedies: daughter Charlie’s decapitation in a car crash, son Peter’s sleepwalking possession, and her own dissociative fury. Uncle’s revelations unveil Ellen’s Paimon worship, demanding a male host. The film crescendos in a treehouse ritual, Annie’s decapitation, and Peter’s enthronement as the demon’s vessel, his soul supplanted amid clanging light poles and eerie silence.

Aster’s taut 127 minutes prioritise implication over spectacle. Charlie’s tongue-click tic, Milly Shapiro’s uncanny performance, and the decapitated bird foreshadow inevitable doom. Collette’s arc—from restrained sorrow to axe-wielding frenzy—earns Oscar buzz, her support group monologue a tour de force of suppressed rage. Production designer Grace Yun’s claustrophobic sets, filled with dollhouse replicas mirroring real carnage, underscore determinism.

Familial Bonds as Breaking Points

Central to both is the family unit’s disintegration under supernatural siege. In The Exorcist, Chris’s atheism clashes with Regan’s possession, forcing reliance on patriarchal clergy; her impotence peaks as she watches Karras slap her daughter, a moment blending horror with heartbreaking realism. Friedkin captures Georgetown’s autumnal decay, symbolising moral rot. Hereditary inverts this: Annie’s artistic control via miniatures crumbles as her family literally fragments, her sleepwalking murder of her daughter evoking primal guilt.

Peter’s arc parallels Karras—both young men burdened by loss, their bodies hijacked. Yet where Karras redeems through faith, Peter’s submission feels predestined, Aster critiquing therapy culture’s futility against occult inheritance. Both films indict parental failure: Chris’s careerism, Annie’s inherited madness, rendering exorcism not salvation but symptom management.

Ritual vs Revelation: Possession Protocols

The Exorcist structures around the Roman Ritual of 1614, with holy water, relics, and Latin incantations building rhythmic tension. The demon Pazuzu’s taunts—mocking Karras’s Greek heritage, Merrin’s frailty—personalise the assault, effects like pea soup vomit adding visceral punctuation. Friedkin’s Steadicam prowls Regan’s room, heightening intimacy.

Hereditary subverts ritual for inevitability. No priests intervene; cultists orchestrate via decapitations and photograms. Paimon’s summoning demands specific sacrifices—firstborn daughter traded for son—echoing biblical infanticide. Aster’s long takes, like the dinner scene’s mounting hysteria, simulate real-time collapse, possession manifesting as subtle tics before explosive submission.

Faith’s Flicker in Secular Shadows

The Exorcist grapples overtly with Catholicism amid 1970s doubt post-Vatican II. Karras embodies crisis of faith, his psychiatry-Philosophy background questioning miracles until Regan’s levitation compels belief. Blatty intended affirmation of divine order, yet audiences perceived nihilism in the pyrrhic victory.

Aster secularises this: no God counters Paimon, grief therapy fails, rationality dissolves. Annie’s agnosticism mirrors modern malaise, her mother’s cult filling spiritual voids. Both films posit supernatural as extension of human frailty—demons exploit doubt, loss, resentment—yet Hereditary‘s godless cosmos feels bleaker.

Visual Symphonies of Dread

Owen Roizman’s cinematography in The Exorcist employs stark contrasts: Iraq’s sun-baked desolation foreshadows domestic hell, Regan’s room lit by harsh fluorescents casting elongated shadows. The staircase fall, shot in one take, uses practical wires for authenticity. Hereditary‘s Pawel Pogorzelski masters shallow depth and firelight, Charlie’s silhouette at the car evoking ghostly inevitability, the final enthronement a tableau of hellish opulence.

Mise-en-scène diverges: Friedkin’s clutter evokes lived-in chaos, Aster’s deliberate compositions—tilted frames, lurking figures—signal orchestration. Both elevate lighting as character, shadows puppeteering the possessed.

Soundscapes that Haunt the Soul

Jack Nitzsche’s score for The Exorcist, blending Mike Oldfield’s tubular bells with desecrated hymns, underscores ritual gravity. Regan’s voice, layered by Mercedes McCambridge, rasps obscenities that linger. Subtle cues like ticking clocks amplify unease.

Colin Stetson’s woodwinds in Hereditary mimic ragged breaths, silence punctuating shocks like the clapboard snap. No score swells during climaxes; ambient dread—creaking floors, distant bangs—immerses viewers in familial hell.

Effects Mastery: Grit vs Grace

The Exorcist‘s practical wizardry defined era effects: Dick Smith’s vomit rig, cooled pea soup for projectile spew; animatronic faces for spins; harnesses for flights. No CGI ensured raw tactility, influencing Poltergeist and The Conjuring.

Hereditary blends prosthetics—Collette’s headless wireframe—with minimal CGI for Charlie’s levitation, prioritising performance over spectacle. Practical decapitations via dummies heighten intimacy, Aster citing Friedkin as influence while modernising restraint.

Director in the Spotlight

William Friedkin, born 29 August 1935 in Chicago to Russian-Jewish immigrants, began as a mailroom boy at WGN-TV, rising to direct live television by age 21. His documentary The People Versus Paul Crump (1962) commuted a death sentence, showcasing raw humanism. Feature debut Good Times (1967) led to The French Connection (1971), winning Best Director Oscar for Gene Hackman’s gritty cop tale.

The Exorcist (1973) cemented icon status, followed by Sorcerer (1977), a tense remake of Wages of Fear with exploding trucks. The Brink’s Job (1978) chronicled a heist, Cruising (1980) courted controversy with leather-bar murders. Later works include To Live and Die in L.A. (1985), a neon-noir thriller; The Guardian (1990), eco-horror with killer trees; Bug (2006), claustrophobic paranoia; and Killer Joe (2011), Matthew McConaughey’s breakout. TV episodes for Cops and CSI honed procedural edge. Influences: Elia Kazan, Otto Preminger. Friedkin died 7 August 2023, leaving a legacy of visceral realism.

Filmography highlights: The Boys in the Band (1970) – stage adaptation on gay tensions; The French Connection (1971) – Oscar-winning chase classic; The Exorcist (1973) – possession benchmark; Sorcerer (1977) – jungle peril remake; To Live and Die in L.A. (1985) – counterfeit corruption; The Hunted (2003) – Tommy Lee Jones manhunt; 12 Angry Men (1997 TV) – jury drama remake.

Actor in the Spotlight

Toni Collette, born 1 November 1972 in Sydney, Australia, as Antonia Collette, grew up in Blacktown with three siblings. Dropping out of school at 16, she trained at National Institute of Dramatic Art briefly before theatre breakthroughs like God. Film debut in Spotlight (1991) led to Muriel’s Wedding (1994), earning Australian Film Institute Award for her ABBA-obsessed bride, launching international career.

Hollywood beckoned with The Pallbearer (1996), then The Sixth Sense (1999) as haunted mother, Golden Globe-nominated. About a Boy (2002) showcased comedy; Little Miss Sunshine (2006) ensemble acclaim. Horror turns: The Frighteners (1996), Hereditary (2018) – visceral grief earning Gotham and Critics’ Choice nods. TV: Emmy for United States of Tara (2009-2012) multiple personalities; The Staircase (2022) true-crime. Stage: The Wild Party (2000), Tony-nominated. Married since 2003 to Dave Galafassi, two children. Influences: Meryl Streep, Cate Blanchett.

Filmography highlights: Muriel’s Wedding (1994) – breakout Toni Mahoney; The Sixth Sense (1999) – maternal torment; In Her Shoes (2005) – sisters’ bond; Little Fockers (2010) – comedic in-law; The Way Way Back (2013) – coming-of-age mentor; Hereditary (2018) – Annie Graham’s madness; Knives Out (2019) – scheming nurse; Nightmare Alley (2021) – carnival fortune teller.

Chilled by these demonic duels? Explore more NecroTimes showdowns, from slashers to supernatural epics, and subscribe for weekly horrors delivered to your inbox.

Bibliography

Blatty, W. P. (1971) The Exorcist. Harper & Row.

Friedkin, W. (2013) The Friedkin Connection: A Memoir. HarperOne. Available at: https://harperone.hc.com/the-friedkin-connection (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Aster, A. (2018) Hereditary [Production notes]. A24 Studios.

Shone, T. (2018) ‘How Ari Aster Turned Family Trauma into the Year’s Scariest Movie’, Vanity Fair, 8 June. Available at: https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2018/06/hereditary-ari-aster-toni-collette-interview (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Keats, J. (2023) ‘William Friedkin obituary: Director of The Exorcist and The French Connection‘, The Guardian, 8 August. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2023/aug/08/william-friedkin-obituary (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Collum, J. (2004) Assault of the Dead: Alternative Cinema Number Eight. AlterNative Films. [On possession effects].

Newman, K. (1974) ‘The Horror of The Exorcist‘, Sight & Sound, 43(2), pp. 90-93.

Bradshaw, P. (2018) ‘Hereditary review – a whole new level of midlife crisis’, The Guardian, 15 March. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2018/mar/15/hereditary-review-toni-collette-ari-aster (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Jones, A. (2007) Grizzly Tales: The Exorcist Special Effects. Fab Press. [Detailed effects breakdown].

Collette, T. (2018) Interview on Late Night with Seth Meyers. NBC. Available at: https://www.nbc.com/late-night/video/toni-collette/1157426 (Accessed: 15 October 2024).