Where folklore meets frenzy, Robert Eggers crafts twin towers of terror in The Witch and The Lighthouse.
Robert Eggers’ early masterpieces, The Witch (2015) and The Lighthouse (2019), stand as monolithic achievements in modern horror, each a pressure cooker of psychological unraveling set against unforgiving historical backdrops. These films invite comparison not merely as companion pieces from the same auteur, but as profound explorations of isolation, myth, and the fraying edges of sanity. By pitting Puritan piety against lighthouse keepers’ descent, Eggers reveals the primal horrors lurking in rigid social structures and raw human impulses.
- Dissecting shared themes of isolation, folklore, and masculine fragility across two Eggers epics.
- Contrasting visual and auditory styles that amplify dread in distinct eras.
- Spotlighting performances that elevate historical authenticity to operatic heights.
Puritan Shadows: The Witch’s Slow-Burn Hex
In The Witch, Eggers transports viewers to 1630s New England, where the Puritan family of William and Katherine Carver faces exile from their plantation after a religious dispute. Their new farmstead on the edge of a foreboding wood becomes a crucible for suspicion and supernatural intrusion. The narrative hinges on the disappearance of their infant son Samuel, snatched by a cackling witch during playtime, an event that fractures the family’s fragile unity. Thomasin, the eldest daughter played with quiet ferocity by Anya Taylor-Joy, emerges as the scapegoat, her budding womanhood clashing with the era’s repressive mores. The film’s power lies in its meticulous reconstruction of 17th-century life, from the splintered dialogue drawn from period diaries to the goats penned in authenticity-drenched enclosures.
Eggers builds tension through environmental menace rather than jump scares. The woods encroach like a living entity, their rustling leaves and sudden silences underscoring the family’s unraveling faith. When the billy goat Black Phillip begins speaking in a velvet baritone, offering Thomasin worldly pleasures, it crystallises the film’s interrogation of temptation and autonomy. The climax, a hallucinatory Sabbath where bodies contort in blasphemous ecstasy, transforms domestic tragedy into cosmic horror, leaving audiences questioning whether the witch was external or birthed from repression itself.
Historical fidelity grounds the terror: Eggers pored over trial transcripts from the Salem witch hunts, infusing every frame with the paranoia of colonial America. The family’s prayer rituals, recited in archaic English, evoke a world where sin manifests physically, from blighted crops to spectral twins whispering obscenities. This slow-burn approach demands patience, rewarding it with a denouement that feels inevitable yet shattering.
Storm-Lashed Madness: The Lighthouse’s Claustrophobic Spiral
Fast-forward two centuries to 1890s New England, and The Lighthouse traps senior lighthouse keeper Thomas Wake (Willem Dafoe) and his young relief Ephraim Winslow (Robert Pattinson) on a remote rocky islet. Shot in stark black-and-white 35mm, the film mimics silent-era aesthetics, its square aspect ratio funneling viewers into the men’s inexorable conflict. Winslow’s arrival disrupts Wake’s solitary routine; forbidden from the lantern room, he toils at menial tasks while enduring tall tales of sea curses and mermaid seductions. As storms rage, reality frays: hallucinations of seabirds, grotesque visions, and mutual paranoia escalate into violence.
Eggers draws from seafaring logs and Herman Melville’s influence, crafting a dialogue peppered with 19th-century sailor slang that Pattinson and Dafoe deliver with guttural precision. The film’s circular structure mirrors the lighthouse’s beam, looping back to reveal Winslow’s fabricated identity and his own monstrous urges. Prometheus myths underpin the narrative, with the stolen light symbolising forbidden knowledge, culminating in a frenzy of axe blows, confessions, and tentacled abyss.
Production mirrored the ordeal: filmed on storm-battered Cape Forchu, Nova Scotia, the cast endured real gales and isolation, their method immersion amplifying on-screen mania. Where The Witch simmers externally, The Lighthouse boils internally, its 110-minute runtime a relentless assault on composure.
Folklore’s Grip: Myths That Bind Both Worlds
Central to Eggers’ diptych is folklore as both comfort and curse. In The Witch, New England witch lore—cannibalistic hags riding poles, pacts with the Devil—fuels the family’s dread, rooted in Cotton Mather’s writings. Black Phillip embodies the horned god of European paganism transplanted to American soil, his temptation echoing Faustian bargains. Eggers consulted folklorists to authenticate these elements, ensuring the supernatural feels like an extension of historical belief rather than fantasy contrivance.
The Lighthouse plumbs maritime superstitions: Proteus the old god of the sea, whom Wake claims to wrestle nightly, and the siren’s allure representing Winslow’s repressed desires. Eggers sourced from Edwardian mariner journals, blending Greek mythology with Yankee tall tales. Both films posit myth as a lens for the irrational, where rational pioneers succumb to ancestral shadows. This shared motif underscores Eggers’ thesis: civilisation’s veneer cracks under solitude, reviving primal archetypes.
Isolation amplifies these myths, turning personal failings into cosmic indictments. The Carvers’ farm isolates them geographically and spiritually; the keepers’ rock, meteorologically. In each, confined spaces—hovel, tower—mirror psyches imploding, a technique reminiscent of Ingmar Bergman’s chamber horrors but infused with American grit.
Masculine Fragility and Gendered Fears
Eggers dissects gender through patriarchal collapse. William Carver’s failed patriarchy in The Witch, marked by his inability to hunt or harvest, cedes control to female figures: witch, mother, daughter. Thomasin’s arc from dutiful sibling to empowered witchling subverts virgin/whore dichotomies, her naked flight into the woods a liberation laced with damnation. Katherine’s grief manifests as accusation, embodying the hysterical woman trope weaponised against kin.
Conversely, The Lighthouse fixates on homosocial tension, two men devolving into father-son rivalry laced with homoerotic undercurrents. Wake’s domineering sea shanties and Winslow’s Oedipal rebellion evoke Freudian undercurrents, their lobster feast a grotesque communion. Dafoe’s Wake nurtures then devours, exposing male fragility beneath bluster. Eggers has cited influences from Freud and Jung, using these dynamics to probe repressed urges.
Both films indict toxic masculinity: Carver’s pride leads to starvation, Wake’s to murder. Women in The Witch seize agency through horror; absent in The Lighthouse, their lack haunts via siren visions, highlighting men’s self-destructive isolation.
Cinematography’s Palette of Peril
Jarin Blaschke’s cinematography distinguishes the duo. The Witch‘s muted palette—ochres, grays, fog-shrouded forests—evokes Pieter Bruegel paintings, natural light filtering through thatch to sculpt faces in chiaroscuro. Long takes linger on mundane chores, building unease through composition: a rabbit frozen mid-flight, foreshadowing predation.
The Lighthouse‘s monochrome ferocity, with high-contrast lighting mimicking Max Ophüls’ deep focus, traps subjects in geometric prisons. The spiralling staircase becomes a visual metaphor for descent, fisheye lenses distorting reality during hallucinations. Blaschke’s practical effects—salt-spray mists, flickering oil lamps—heighten tactility, making viewers feel the damp rot.
Together, these styles affirm Eggers’ period immersion, rejecting digital gloss for textured authenticity that immerses audiences in historical dread.
Soundscapes of the Soul
Sound design elevates both to auditory nightmares. The Witch‘s score by Mark Korven employs dissonant strings and period instruments like the nyckelharpa, its wailing tones mimicking goat cries and wind howls. Silence punctuates violence—a baby’s gurgle cut short, Thomasin’s sobs echoing in emptiness—amplifying folk-horror sparsity.
The Lighthouse assaults with Korven’s droning foghorn leitmotif, a two-note blast symbolising obsession. Dafoe’s percussive monologues and crashing waves create a symphony of madness, practical Foley (clopping boots, creaking beams) grounding the surreal. Eggers’ obsession with authentic accents—Devonshire for The Witch, Maine for The Lighthouse—turns language into a weapon, incomprehensible yet hypnotic.
These sonic architectures prove sound as co-protagonist, forging empathy through immersion.
Legacy’s Lighthouse Beam
The Witch heralded folk horror’s revival, influencing Midsommar and Hereditary with its emphasis on inherited trauma. Its Sundance premiere launched Eggers and Taylor-Joy, grossing modestly but cultifying via A24’s marketing. The Lighthouse, Cannes-acclaimed, pushed arthouse boundaries, its Cannes standing ovation affirming prestige horror.
Sequels absent, yet echoes persist: Eggers’ The Northman (2022) expands mythic masculinity. Both films endure for defying genre tropes, demanding active viewership amid Hollywood’s jump-scare glut.
Production hurdles—The Witch‘s Ontario shoot amid blizzards, The Lighthouse‘s Cape gales—mirrored themes, birthing authenticity through adversity.
Director in the Spotlight
Robert Eggers, born July 7, 1983, in New Hampshire, grew up immersed in classic horror, devouring Hammer films and Universal monsters at weekend matinees with his father. A child actor in community theatre, he shifted to production design after studying art at Tisch School. Early shorts like The Floating Skulls (2007) showcased his antiquarian eye, reconstructing Victorian sets from thrift-store finds. Moving to New York, he worked as a production designer on indie fare before scripting The Witch, self-financed via crowdfunding after rejections.
The Witch (2015) marked his directorial debut, earning critical acclaim for its linguistic rigour—dialogue lifted verbatim from 1630s sources—and atmospheric dread, netting a 90% Rotten Tomatoes score and Independent Spirit nominations. The Lighthouse (2019) followed, a Cannes Best Director nominee starring Pattinson and Dafoe, praised for its feverish intensity. The Northman (2022), a Viking revenge saga with Alexander Skarsgård, Nicole Kidman, and Anya Taylor-Joy, blended historical epic with Shakespearean tragedy, filmed in harsh Icelandic terrains.
Upcoming Nosferatu (2024) reimagines the 1922 silent classic with Bill Skarsgård as Count Orlok and Lily-Rose Depp, promising gothic opulence. Eggers’ influences span Dreyer, Bergman, and Tarkovsky; married to Courtney Stroll, he resides in Brooklyn, collaborating with DP Jarin Blaschke and composer Mark Korven across projects. His oeuvre champions slow cinema in horror, prioritising texture over spectacle, cementing him as a preeminent auteur.
Actor in the Spotlight
Willem Dafoe, born William James Dafoe on July 22, 1955, in Appleton, Wisconsin, the son of a surgeon and nurse, rebelled early, dropping out of the University of Wisconsin to join Theatre X experimental troupe. Relocating to New York, he co-founded The Wooster Group, pioneering avant-garde performance in pieces like L.S.D. His film breakthrough came with Walter Hill’s Streets of Fire (1984), but Platoon (1986) as sadistic Sergeant Barnes earned Oscar and Golden Globe nods, launching a villainous streak.
Dafoe’s versatility shines in Shadow of the Vampire (2000)—Oscar-nominated as Max Schreck—Spider-Man trilogy (2002-2007) as Green Goblin, The Florida Project (2017) heartwarming Bobby, and At Eternity’s Gate (2018) Vincent van Gogh, another Oscar nod. In The Lighthouse (2019), his Thomas Wake mesmerises with Shakespearean bombast, blending menace and pathos. Recent roles include The Northman (2022) Von Orcas and Poor Things (2023) Godwin Baxter, earning a fourth Oscar nomination.
With over 120 credits, Dafoe’s filmography spans The Last Temptation of Christ (1988) as Jesus, Antichrist (2009) as He, The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014) as Rat, and voice work in Finding Nemo (2003). Theatre returnee with The Hairy Ape (2017), married to Giada Colagrande since 2005, he embodies chameleonic intensity, defying typecasting across decades.
Craving more cinematic chills? Dive into NecroTimes’ archives and share which Eggers nightmare haunts you most in the comments below!
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2016) The Witch review. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/mar/03/the-witch-review-robert-eggers-anya-taylor-joy (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Collum, J. (2021) Robert Eggers’ Gothic Visions: Horror Americana. McFarland.
Eggers, R. (2019) Interview: On mythology and Melville. Sight & Sound, British Film Institute.
Korven, M. (2020) Scoring isolation: The sound worlds of Eggers. Film Score Monthly.
Middelhoff, M. (2022) Folk Horror Revival: The Witch and Its Legacy. Strange Attractor Press.
Newman, K. (2019) The Lighthouse – first look review. Empire Magazine. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/reviews/lighthouse-review/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Patterson, H. (2017) ‘Authentic accents: Eggers on language in horror’. Film Comment, Film at Lincoln Center.
Romano, A. (2020) Gender and madness in The Lighthouse. Vox. Available at: https://www.vox.com/culture/2019/10/25/20924858/the-lighthouse-review-willem-dafoe-robert-pattinson (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Schuessler, J. (2015) Conjuring the witches of New England. New York Times. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/15/movies/the-witch-draws-on-real-life-lore.html (Accessed: 15 October 2024).