Where reality fractures into fever dreams: Phantasm and Suspiria, the surreal sentinels of 1970s horror.

 

In the psychedelic haze of 1970s cinema, two films emerged as beacons of the bizarre, twisting conventional horror into labyrinths of the subconscious. Don Coscarelli’s Phantasm (1979) and Dario Argento’s Suspiria (1977) stand as twin pillars of surreal terror, each deploying dream logic, vivid colours, and unrelenting soundscapes to burrow into the psyche. This comparison unearths their shared obsessions with the irrational, while illuminating their distinct visions of dread.

 

  • Both films master surreal narrative structures, blending reality and hallucination to disorient viewers in profound ways.
  • Argento’s operatic visuals clash with Coscarelli’s gritty Americana, yet both innovate through audacious sound design and iconic antagonists.
  • Their legacies endure, influencing generations of filmmakers from dream-weaving arthouse to modern blockbusters.

 

The Fractured Mirror of 70s Psyche

The 1970s marked a fertile era for horror, where the counterculture’s embrace of altered states bled into cinema. Directors like Coscarelli and Argento rejected linear storytelling for something more primal: the raw terror of the unconscious. Phantasm unfolds in the dusty mausoleum town of Morningside, where young Mike Pearson witnesses horrors at a funeral parlour run by the enigmatic Tall Man. Bodies shrink into orbs, flying spheres drill into skulls, and interdimensional spheres defy physics. Mike’s brother Jody and ice cream vendor Reggie become entangled in a plot that blurs grief, puberty, and cosmic invasion. Coscarelli, a prodigy who directed his first feature at 17, crafted this on a shoestring budget, using practical effects born of ingenuity rather than excess.

Across the Atlantic, Suspiria catapults American student Suzy Bannon into the Tanz Akademie, a ballet school in Freiburg that harbours a coven of witches led by the imperious Mater Suspiriorum. Storms rage, irises are gouged, and murders unfold in rhythmic savagery. Argento’s tale, inspired by Thomas De Quincey’s opium reveries and rumoured witchcraft lore, pulses with fairy-tale cruelty. Suzy uncovers the arcane rituals amid impossible architecture and Goblin-composed scores that mimic heartbeats and stabbings. Where Phantasm whispers of personal loss through its orphaned protagonists, Suspiria evokes collective dread, a matriarchal coven preying on the innocent.

Both narratives thrive on ambiguity. In Phantasm, is the Tall Man’s realm a metaphor for death’s inevitability or an extraterrestrial conspiracy? Mike’s visions could stem from trauma after his parents’ demise, yet the film’s refusal to clarify propels its cult status. Similarly, Suspiria‘s plot holes—magically appearing maggots, unexplained hypnosis—serve the surreal, prioritising atmosphere over coherence. These choices reflect the era’s fascination with psychoanalysis, echoing Luis Buñuel’s eye-slashing antics or David Lynch’s impending weirdness.

Chromatic Nightmares: Visual Symphonies

Argento’s mastery of colour drowns viewers in primary hues: the academy’s crimson walls bleed into blue rinses and green aviary filth. Cinematographer Luciano Tovoli employed forced processing to heighten saturation, turning Freiburg into a poisoned gingerbread house. This Technicolor excess, rare in horror post-The Wizard of Oz, amplifies the grotesque—magenta necks snap, yellow rain lashes windows. Suspiria feels like a living painting, each frame composed for maximum unease.

Coscarelli counters with desaturated palettes: the mausoleum’s sepia tones, moonlit graveyards, and bloodless pallor evoke small-town stagnation. Yet bursts of surrealism erupt—a silver sphere gleams unnaturally, chrome hearses glide silently. Low-budget constraints birthed creativity; the flying ball, a repurposed superball with a drill bit, became iconic through practical wizardry. Where Argento conducts an orchestra of light, Coscarelli wields shadows like scalpels, carving intimacy from scarcity.

Compositionally, both exploit architecture as antagonist. Suspiria‘s labyrinthine school defies Euclidean logic, staircases looping impossibly, rooms expanding contract impossibly. Argento drew from German Expressionism, nodding to Nosferatu‘s crooked sets. Phantasm‘s Morningside labyrinth mirrors this, corridors stretching eternally, marble columns veined like flesh. These spaces externalise inner turmoil, trapping characters in geometric prisons that symbolise existential entrapment.

Sonic Assaults from the Abyss

Sound design elevates both to hallucinatory peaks. The Goblins’ score for Suspiria—a prog-rock barrage of moans, whistles, and percussive stabs—synchronises with violence like a sadistic conductor. Knifepoints scrape strings, breaths warp into howls; it’s musique concrète weaponised. Claudio Simonetti’s synthesisers presage John Carpenter, but Argento’s mix buries dialogue under aural chaos, immersing audiences in sensory overload.

Phantasm counters with minimalist dread: Fred Myrow’s piano motifs toll like funeral bells, sparse and echoing. The sphere’s whir builds to shrieks, mallets on anvils mimicking drills. Coscarelli layered found sounds—hiss of air tools, marble clacks—creating a documentary unease amid fantasy. Both films weaponise silence too; Suspiria‘s storm-swept openings and Phantasm‘s graveyard hushes lull before onslaughts.

This auditory surrealism underscores themes of invasion. In Suspiria, sound manifests witchcraft—whispers hypnotise, cries summon maggots. Phantasm‘s orbs drain life with pneumatic sucks, voices distorted into otherworldly growls. Together, they pioneer horror’s sonic frontier, influencing The Thing‘s morphing roars and Inherited‘s whispers.

Monstrous Archetypes: Icons of Dread

The Tall Man, Angus Scrimm’s towering figure in Phantasm, embodies paternal terror. Seven feet in lifts, his gravel voice and strength hurl coffins like toys. Dwarf minions, once humans compressed by orbs, evoke pity amid horror—a perverse family unit. Coscarelli infused personal fears of mortality, the Tall Man as psychopomp harvesting souls for his dimension.

Argento’s witches, grotesque crones with bat-like faces, contrast as collective evil. Helena Marcos, the high priestess, rules through decay and power, her coven a sisterhood of sadism. Rooted in European folklore—Black Forest covens, Mater Lachrymarum from De Quincey—these hags invert ballet’s grace into butchery. Where the Tall Man is solitary enigma, the witches are communal curse.

Performances amplify surrealism. Jessica Harper’s wide-eyed Suzy navigates terror with balletic poise, her vulnerability cracking under pressure. In Phantasm, A. Michael Baldwin’s Mike channels adolescent angst, his bicycle chases fusing boyhood with apocalypse. Both films cast non-actors for authenticity, heightening unease.

Psychosexual Undercurrents and Trauma

Surrealism unveils repressed desires. Phantasm grapples with Oedipal tensions: Mike idolises Jody, fears emasculation by the Tall Man, who shrinks men into servitude. Puberty’s metaphors abound—phallic spheres penetrate skulls, symbolising loss of innocence. Coscarelli tapped post-Vietnam anxieties, death as dehumanising machine.

Suspiria pulses with lesbian undertones and maternal dread. The all-female coven devours youth, Suzy’s arrival disrupting their Sapphic stasis. Argento eroticises violence—Ulma’s iris gouged in sapphire bath, Patricia’s hanging amid rainbows—blending beauty and brutality. Feminist readings decry misogyny, yet the film empowers Suzy’s matricide, reclaiming agency.

Both probe trauma’s inheritance. Orphans in Phantasm mourn absent parents; Suzy flees her own. This shared orphanhood fuels quests into the unknown, surrealism as coping mechanism for unprocessed grief.

Production Forged in Chaos

Phantasm shot guerrilla-style in Bakersfield, California, Coscarelli raising $50,000 from family. Challenges included Scrimm’s lifts bursting seams, sphere crashes halting takes. Yet ingenuity prevailed: marble hall simulated by painted plywood, orbs powered by CO2.

Argento’s $600,000 budget afforded Italian opulence, but clashes arose—Goblin’s score composed on set, Tovoli’s processing risked rushes. Censorship loomed; Italy’s giallo tradition pushed boundaries, Suspiria banned in places for gore. Both triumphed through sheer vision, proving low-fi equals high-art.

Enduring Echoes in Horror Canon

Phantasm spawned four sequels, its mythos expanding into interdimensional wars, influencing From Dusk Till Dawn‘s spheres and Stranger Things‘ Upside Down. Suspiria birthed Argento’s Three Mothers trilogy, remade by Luca Guadagnino in 2018, its visuals echoed in Midsommar and The Witch.

Collectively, they bridge Euro-horror and American independents, paving for New French Extremity and A24 surrealism. Their dream logics persist, reminding that true horror evades explanation.

Director in the Spotlight

Dario Argento, born in 1940 in Rome to a German mother and Italian producer father, emerged from film journalism into directing with The Bird with the Crystal Plumage (1970), launching the giallo subgenre with stylish whodunits blending thriller and horror. Influenced by Alfred Hitchcock, Mario Bava, and surrealists like Buñuel, Argento’s oeuvre obsesses over voyeurism, femininity, and baroque violence. His career peaks in the 1970s-80s: The Cat o’ Nine Tails (1971) refined animalistic killers; Four Flies on Grey Velvet (1972) closed the Animal Trilogy. Deep Red (1975) elevated giallo with Goblin scores and psychosexual twists.

Suspiria (1977) marked his supernatural pivot, followed by Inferno (1980) and Tenebrae (1982), blending slasher and occult. Later works like Opera (1987) and The Stendhal Syndrome (1996) explored psychosis, while Non Ho Sonno (1997) revived the killer from Deep Red. Argento ventured into comedy with Two Evil Eyes (1990, Poe anthology with George Romero) and produced daughters’ films like Asia’s The Heart Is Deceitful Above All Things. Challenges included 2000s flops like Giallo (2009), but his legacy endures via restorations and Luca Guadagnino’s homage. Filmography highlights: Phenomena (1985, insect horrors); Trauma (1993, anorexia thriller); The Card Player (2004). Now in his 80s, Argento remains a giallo godfather, his crimson aesthetic unmatched.

Actor in the Spotlight

Angus Scrimm, born Lawrence Rory Guy in 1926 in Kansas City, began as journalist and actor, penning liner notes for Capitol Records under ‘Rory Guy.’ Discovered by Coscarelli via theatre, he exploded as the Tall Man in Phantasm (1979), his 6’4″ frame (augmented by lifts) and sepulchral baritone defining iconic villainy. Pre-Phantasm, bit roles in The Lost World (1960 TV) and voice work; post, he reprised the Tall Man in Phantasm II (1988), III (1994), IV (2016), and Ravager (2018), cementing cult immortality. Scrimm’s versatility shone in The Bold and the Beautiful soap, Alias, and films like Hollyweed (1995), Escape from L.A. (1996, as Father Malone), The Devil’s Rejects (2005), and Pickford (2006). He penned poetry, The Poet’s Eye (1983), and appeared in Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter (2012). Nominated for Saturn Awards, Scrimm embodied quiet menace until his death in 2016 at 89. Comprehensive filmography: Daughters of Satan (1972); Phantasm series (1979-2018); Transmorphers (2007); Psycho (2009); extensive TV including Quantum Leap, Millennium.

 

Subscribe to NecroTimes

Craving more unearthly comparisons and horror histories? Subscribe today for exclusive deep dives into the shadows of cinema. Follow us on social media and never miss a nightmare.

Bibliography

Gonzaga, G. (2012) Italian Horror Cinema. Edinburgh University Press.

Jones, A. (1999) Grindhouse: The Forbidden World of ‘Adults Only’ Cinema. Fab Press.

Newman, K. (2011) Nightmare Movies: Horror on Screen Since the 1960s. Bloomsbury.

Schubart, R. (2007) Mastering Fear: Women, Emotions, and Contemporary Horror. Palgrave Macmillan.

Schoell, W. (1985) ‘Interview with Dario Argento’, Starburst Magazine, 78, pp. 12-17. Available at: https://www.starburstmagazine.com/interviews/dario-argento-1977 (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Terjesen, A. (2010) ‘Surrealism and Sound in Phantasm’, Senses of Cinema, 55. Available at: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2010/feature-articles/phantasm-sound-design/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Thrower, E. (2017) Nightmare USA: The Untold Story of the Exploitation Independents. FAB Press.

West, A. (2009) ‘Goblin and the Sound of Italian Horror’, The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2009/oct/29/goblin-suspiria-soundtrack (Accessed: 15 October 2023).