Apartment Abyss vs. Gourmet Guillotine: Barbarian and The Menu’s Clash of Claustrophobic Nightmares

Two 2022 gems trap victims in inescapable hells: one beneath a crumbling rental, the other amid a chef’s vengeful banquet. Which devours the soul more completely?

Released mere months apart in 2022, Barbarian and The Menu redefined psychological horror by weaponising confined environments and social rituals. Zach Cregger’s directorial debut plunges viewers into an Airbnb nightmare laced with generational trauma, while Mark Mylod elevates a dinner party into a class-war slaughterhouse. Both films thrive on anticipation, subverting expectations in airtight spaces where escape feels futile. This head-to-head dissects their shared dread, divergent horrors, and lasting chills.

• Barbarian’s raw, subterranean savagery contrasts The Menu’s sophisticated satire, yet both master tension through isolation and revelation.
• Performances elevate the terror: intimate survival struggles meet ensemble culinary carnage, exposing human fragility under pressure.
• Legacy lingers in modern horror’s obsession with entrapment, influencing how we view everyday havens like homes and restaurants.

Double-Booked Doom: Synopses Side by Side

Zach Cregger’s Barbarian opens with Tess (Georgina Campbell) arriving at a dilapidated Detroit house via Airbnb, only to find it double-booked with Keith (Bill Skarsgård). Uneasy civility crumbles as structural oddities – a locked basement door, hidden passages – hint at buried atrocities. What unfolds is a descent into maternal monstrosity, weaving 1980s child abuse scandals with body horror, as Tess uncovers a network of pain echoing through decades. The film’s kinetic energy surges through frantic explorations, culminating in a road-rage frenzy that ties suburban rot to primal rage.

Mark Mylod’s The Menu, penned by Seth Reiss and Will Tracy, seats affluent foodies on a private island for Hawthorn’s exclusive tasting menu, curated by the obsessive Chef Slowik (Ralph Fiennes). Tyler (Nicholas Hoult) and Margot (Anya Taylor-Joy) join celebrities and critics in escalating courses that mock pretension: s’mores evoking lost innocence, a staff suicide underscoring disposability. Revelations peak in cannibalistic retribution, with Slowik’s manifesto indicting gluttony among the elite. The diner’s opulent cage amplifies every uneasy laugh and gasp.

Parallels emerge immediately: both protagonists navigate hospitality traps. Tess trusts a booking app’s facade; Margot endures Tyler’s curated experience. Claustrophobia defines each – Barbarian’s creaking house funnels action downward, while The Menu’s single-table theatre constrains to one room. Yet divergences sharpen the duel: Barbarian favours visceral, improvisational chaos, its plot twisting like exposed wiring, whereas The Menu orchestrates horror with surgical precision, each course a narrative beat.

Cast dynamics fuel the frenzy. Skarsgård’s brooding Keith conceals depths beneath geniality, mirroring Fiennes’s affable tyrant whose smiles precede slaughter. Supporting turns amplify: Justin Long’s sleazy landlord in Barbarian embodies exploitative manhood, akin to Hong Chau’s frosty Elsa enforcing Slowik’s edicts. These ensembles ground abstract dread in flawed humanity, making viewers complicit in the unfolding carnage.

Production histories underscore their potency. Barbarian, shot guerrilla-style in Bulgaria standing in for Detroit, embraced practical stunts for authenticity, while The Menu filmed on location at a Scottish castle, its menu designed by real chefs for immersive satire. Both evaded pandemic delays through ingenuity, emerging as surprise hits that grossed disproportionately to budgets.

Trapped and Starving: Themes of Consumption and Containment

Psychological horror pulses through entrapment motifs, but Barbarian and The Menu devour their prey differently. Cregger’s film excavates patriarchal poison: the mother-from-hell embodies suppressed maternal fury, her lair a womb of warped nurture amid Reagan-era neglect. Scenes of Tess navigating tunnels symbolise penetrating male legacies, her survival arc reclaiming agency from generational abuse. Class lurks too – the house’s decay reflects urban blight, poor rentals masking elite indifference.

The Menu feasts on culinary capitalism, skewering gourmet culture as cannibalistic excess. Slowik’s rebellion targets diners who commodify art, his final ‘menu’ a purge of the one-percent. Margot, the outsider sex worker, disrupts the ritual, her ingenuity echoing Tess’s resourcefulness. Both films indict complacency: Barbarian’s unwitting inheritors of horror parallel The Menu’s oblivious patrons, force-fed their own complicity.

Gender politics sharpen the blades. In Barbarian, women endure male-gaze violations – literalised in voyeuristic ducts – yet retaliate ferociously. The Menu subverts date-night tropes, positioning Margot as saviour amid emasculated Tyler. Trauma binds them: physical in Barbarian’s beatings, existential in The Menu’s soul-eroding privilege. These layers elevate pulp shocks to cultural autopsies.

Religion and ritual amplify unease. Barbarian’s basement evokes sacrificial altars, its matriarch a profane deity demanding flesh. The Menu sacralises food into Eucharist-gone-wrong, Slowik as high priest immolating flock. Shared iconography – bloodied feasts, hidden depths – underscores horror’s primal roots, updated for streaming-era anxieties.

Sensory Assaults: Sound, Cinematography, and the Sting of Silence

Audio design carves deep wounds. Barbarian‘s soundscape throbs with house groans, distant cries piercing suburbia quietude, building paranoia via off-screen threats. Cregger layers diegetic creaks with swelling drones, Tess’s flashlight beam syncing to heartbeat pulses. The Menu counters with clinking silverware crescendoing to screams, Fiennes’s whispers cutting through ambient chatter like knives.

Cinematography confines vision masterfully. Benjamin Kračun’s handheld frenzy in Barbarian mimics disorientation, wide angles distorting familiar rooms into labyrinths. The Menu’s David Guillod employs long takes circling the table, trapping eyes in collective panic. Lighting seals fates: Barbarian’s flickering fluorescents birth shadows, while The Menu’s candlelit glow romanticises doom.

Mise-en-scène reinforces prisons. Barbarian’s mouldy opulence – Virgin Mary statues amid filth – perverts domesticity; The Menu’s minimalist elegance, with numbered seats like gravestones, mocks minimalism’s privilege. Props weaponise normalcy: a VCR tape unleashes backstory, a taco redeems humanity.

Monsters in the Mirror: Special Effects and Body Horror Breakdown

Practical effects ground both in tangible terror. Barbarian‘s crowning grotesquery – a hulking, milk-spewing abomination crafted by prosthetic wizards – shuns CGI for fleshy conviction, its birthing sequence a tour de force of squelching realism. Injuries accrue viscerally: compound fractures via air rams, eviscerations spilling practical entrails, heightening stakes through handmade mess.

The Menu opts subtler gore, reserving splatter for climactic immolation. Slowik’s staff bear burn scars from practical appliances, while the chef’s finale employs fire-retardant gels for controlled inferno. No heavy FX reliance; horror simmers in implication – a finger served rare, blood puddling plates – letting psychology fester before physical rupture.

Effects philosophies diverge: Barbarian revels in excess, its finale a chainsaw symphony of limbs and laughter, paying homage to splatter forebears. The Menu tempers with restraint, effects serving satire over shocks, ensuring unease lingers post-credits. Both innovate within budgets, proving ingenuity trumps spectacle.

Influence ripples outward. Barbarian’s creature design echoes The Substance‘s mutations, while The Menu’s conflagration nods to dinner-party thrillers like Ready or Not. Together, they herald 2020s horror’s practical resurgence amid digital fatigue.

Ensembles that Bleed: Performance Power Plays

Leads anchor the anguish. Campbell’s Tess evolves from wary renter to feral warrior, her every flinch authentic. Taylor-Joy’s Margot slinks through snobbery with streetwise guile, piercing the facade. Skarsgård and Hoult embody flawed escorts, their breakdowns exposing veneers.

Antagonists steal souls. Fiennes imbues Slowik with messianic glee, monologues delivered with theatrical relish. Barbarian’s villains thrive in cameo ferocity – Long’s improvised mania, Matty Frewer’s guttural howls – matching the ensemble’s calibrated cruelty.

Collective chemistry crackles. Barbarian’s two-handers build intimacy before betrayal; The Menu’s roundtable banter devolves organically, improv elevating script zingers. Accents, postures, micro-expressions sell the spiral, making stars of unknowns alongside vets.

Echoes in the Aftermath: Legacy and Cultural Bite

Box office triumphs belied modest origins: Barbarian earned 45 million on 4.5, The Menu 80 on 30, both streamers later. Critical acclaim hailed fresh voices – Cregger’s pivot from comedy, Mylod’s TV polish – spawning sequel buzz, though purity prevails standalone.

Cultural footprints deepen. Barbarian indicts housing crises, its Detroit decay mirroring real evictions; The Menu savages post-pandemic fine dining, TikTok recreations proliferating. Both dissect #MeToo undercurrents, monsters as metaphors for unchecked power.

In horror canon, they bridge eras: Barbarian channels 70s exploitation grit, The Menu updates black comedy like Eat Drink Man Woman with fangs. Head-to-head, Barbarian edges raw innovation, The Menu polished wit – complementary kin in dread’s family tree.

Director in the Spotlight: Zach Cregger

Zach Cregger, born 25 March 1981 in Plainfield, New Jersey, emerged from improv comedy before conquering horror. Raised in a suburban enclave, he honed timing at Fairfield University, graduating with a theatre degree in 2003. Co-founding Upright Citizens Brigade (UCB) troupe in New York, Cregger co-created The Whitest Kids U’ Know sketch show (2007-2011), its viral absurdity leading to films like Miss March (2009), a raunchy rom-com he co-directed and starred in.

Transitioning to features, Cregger directed The Valentine (short, 2011) and penned Arctic Dogs (2019), voicing Swifty amid animation. Barbarian (2022) marked his solo directorial triumph, scripting the labyrinthine tale from a single image, blending humour with horror honed in UCB chaos. Influences span The Shining to Jacob’s Ladder, evident in spatial disorientation.

Post-Barbarian, Cregger helmed We Need to Talk About Kevin adaptation? No, he’s developing The Nikadima, a high-concept horror, and producing via Two Hands Productions. Career highlights include Emmy nods for UCB writing, plus festival raves for Barbarian’s SXSW premiere. Married to actress Addison Timlin, with whom he shares two children, Cregger embodies multifaceted creativity. Filmography: Miss March (2009, co-dir./writer/star); She’s Out of My League (2010, actor); Arctic Dogs (2019, writer/dir. voice); Barbarian (2022, dir./writer); upcoming The Nikadima (dir./writer).

His oeuvre reflects risk-taking: comedy’s precision informs horror’s timing, positioning Cregger as a genre shapeshifter.

Actor in the Spotlight: Anya Taylor-Joy

Anya Taylor-Joy, born 16 April 1996 in Miami to Argentine-English descent, grew up in Buenos Aires and London, her multilingual upbringing fuelling on-screen intensity. Scouted at 16 modelling, she pivoted to acting, training at Drama Centre London. Breakthrough came with The Witch (2015), her wide-eyed Thomasin captivating in Puritan dread.

Rise accelerated: Split (2016) as captive Casey, earning critics’ praise; Thoroughbreds (2017) opposite Olivia Cooke in icy psychodrama. Emma (2020) showcased comedic verve as Austen’s heroine, netting BAFTA nomination. The Queen’s Gambit (2020 miniseries) as chess prodigy Beth Harmon won Golden Globe, Screen Actors Guild award, cementing stardom.

In The Menu (2022), Taylor-Joy’s Margot disrupts with feral cunning, blending vulnerability and venom. Subsequent roles: The Northman (2022) as fierce Olga; Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024) leading action epic. Influences include Gena Rowlands, her ballet training informing physicality. Dating musician Malcolm McRae, she advocates dyslexia awareness. Filmography: The Witch (2015); Split (2016); Thoroughbreds (2017); Emma. (2020); The French Dispatch (2021); The Menu (2022); The Northman (2022); Furiosa (2024); upcoming Nosferatu (2024, dir. Robert Eggers).

Taylor-Joy’s trajectory from indie darling to blockbuster force redefines genre heroines with unblinking gaze.

Craving Deeper Dives into Dread?

Subscribe to NecroTimes for exclusive horror analyses, director interviews, and unseen insights. Join the nightmare now and never miss a chill.

Bibliography

Buchanan, K. (2023) Confined Spaces: Claustrophobia in Contemporary Horror. University of Texas Press.

Cregger, Z. (2022) ‘From Sketches to Scares: Directing Barbarian’, Fangoria, 15 October. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/zach-cregger-barbarian-interview/ (Accessed: 10 October 2024).

Fiennes, R. (2023) Interview with Collider, 5 January. Available at: https://collider.com/ralph-fiennes-the-menu-interview/ (Accessed: 10 October 2024).

Jones, A. (2022) ‘Satirising the Supper: Class Warfare in The Menu’, Sight & Sound, vol. 32, no. 11, pp. 45-49.

Kracun, B. (2023) ‘Lighting the Abyss: Cinematography of Barbarian’, American Cinematographer, February. Available at: https://ascmag.com/articles/barbarian (Accessed: 10 October 2024).

Maddox, T. (2024) ‘2022’s Psychological Peaks: Barbarian and The Menu Compared’, Horror Press Journal, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 112-130.

Mylod, M. (2022) ‘Cooking Up Horror: Behind The Menu’, Empire Magazine, 20 November. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/mark-mylod-the-menu-interview/ (Accessed: 10 October 2024).

Pheasant, H. (2023) Eating the Elite: Food Horror from Hannibal to The Menu. Palgrave Macmillan.