Clash of the Possessed: The Wailing Versus The Exorcist

Where ancient rituals collide with unholy sacraments, two visions of demonic invasion expose the fragility of belief.

In the pantheon of possession horror, few films loom as large as William Friedkin’s The Exorcist (1973) and Na Hong-jin’s The Wailing (2016). These masterpieces, separated by continents and decades, both grapple with the terror of forces beyond human comprehension invading the body and soul. Yet while one anchors its dread in Catholic ritual, the other weaves a tapestry of Korean shamanism, folklore, and existential doubt. This breakdown unearths their parallels, divergences, and enduring power, revealing why they remain benchmarks of supernatural cinema.

  • Both films master the slow-burn escalation from mundane unease to visceral horror, using possession as a lens for cultural anxieties around faith, family, and the unknown.
  • The Wailing expands the exorcism formula with multilayered mysteries and folkloric depth, contrasting The Exorcist‘s laser-focused theological showdown.
  • Their legacies redefine global horror, influencing everything from sound design innovations to debates on spirituality in a secular age.

Foundations of Familial Doom

The narratives of both films pivot on the desecration of the domestic sphere, where everyday lives shatter under supernatural assault. In The Exorcist, Chris MacNeil (Ellen Burstyn), a celebrated actress living in Georgetown, watches her daughter Regan (Linda Blair) transform from a vibrant child into a vessel of malevolence. What begins as erratic behaviour—bed-wetting, violent outbursts—escalates into levitation, profane speech, and self-mutilation, prompting medical bafflement before Father Damien Karras (Jason Miller), a doubting priest, and the aged Father Lankester Merrin (Max von Sydow) intervene with ancient rites. Friedkin’s adaptation of William Peter Blatty’s novel meticulously charts this descent, grounding the horror in clinical details: Regan’s spinal taps, psychiatric evaluations, and the priests’ internal crises of faith.

The Wailing, set in a mist-shrouded rural village in 1980s South Korea, mirrors this structure but infuses it with communal paranoia. Officer Jong-goo (Kwak Do-won), a bumbling cop with a newborn daughter, investigates a rash of gruesome murders tied to a mysterious Japanese stranger (Jun Kunimura). Victims exhibit feverish delirium, pale skin, and homicidal rage, symptoms that spread like a plague. Jong-goo’s wife succumbs, forcing him into a frantic alliance with a Christian pastor and a enigmatic shaman (Hwang Jung-min). Na Hong-jin layers the plot with red herrings—a hiker’s ghostly photographs, animal sacrifices, ritual chants—culminating in a labyrinthine climax that questions every assumption.

Both stories draw from real-world inspirations, amplifying authenticity. Blatty based his novel on the 1949 Smurl haunting and earlier exorcism cases, while Na incorporates Jeju Island folklore, mudang shamanism, and post-war tensions with Japan. This foundation elevates mere scares into cultural reckonings, where the family unit becomes the battleground for cosmic evil.

Cultural Lenses on the Demonic

At their core, these films interrogate spirituality through national prisms. The Exorcist embodies Western Christianity’s binary of good versus evil, with the demon Pazuzu manifesting as a pagan Assyrian force challenging Catholic orthodoxy. Friedkin emphasises sacramental purity: holy water, crucifixes, and Latin incantations form a bulwark against chaos. Yet doubt permeates—Karras’s crisis stems from his mother’s death and the Church’s irrelevance in modern America, reflecting 1970s disillusionment post-Vietnam and Watergate.

The Wailing shatters such binaries, blending animism, Buddhism, Christianity, and colonial ghosts into a syncretic nightmare. Jong-goo’s village pulses with Confucian hierarchies and shamanic rites, where ghosts demand vengeance and deities bargain like tricksters. Na critiques imported faiths— the pastor’s zealotry backfires spectacularly—while evoking Korea’s history of Japanese occupation, symbolised by the intruding foreigner. This polytheistic sprawl creates ambiguity: is the evil a ghost, a devil, or human malice amplified by superstition?

The divergence highlights horror’s adaptability. Friedkin’s film reinforces ritual as salvation, albeit pyrrhic; Na’s denies resolution, leaving viewers in hermeneutic limbo. Such contrasts underscore how possession narratives adapt to societal fault lines, from American individualism to Korean collectivism.

Performances that Pierce the Soul

Actors in both films deliver tour-de-force portrayals of possession, blending physicality with psychological fracture. Linda Blair’s Regan is iconic: her head-spinning 360 degrees (achieved via practical rigs), pea-soup vomit, and guttural voice (Dick Smith’s makeup and Mercedes McCambridge’s dubbing) convey innocence corrupted. Yet Blair imbues vulnerability—a bed-bound girl pleading through torment—making the horror intimate and empathetic.

Kwak Do-won’s Jong-goo in The Wailing anchors the frenzy as an everyman unravelled. His shift from comic incompetence to desperate patriarch mirrors the audience’s confusion, culminating in raw, sweat-drenched hysteria during rituals. Supporting turns amplify: Kim Hyun-ju as the shaman channels ethereal menace, her dances evoking trance states drawn from real mudang practices.

Burstyn and Jun Kunimura provide counterpoints—maternal ferocity and inscrutable evil—elevating archetypes into flesh-and-blood figures. These performances, honed through exhaustive rehearsals, prove possession thrives on human expressivity, not just effects.

Soundscapes of Supernatural Dread

Audio design distinguishes both as auditory assaults. The Exorcist‘s soundscape, crafted by Bob McCurdy and Chris Newman, weaponises subtlety: Regan’s bed shakes with infrasonic rumbles, inducing nausea; Merrin’s arrival cues Tibetan monk chants layered over wind howls. Friedkin insisted on location recording, capturing authentic rain and traffic to immerse viewers in Georgetown’s nocturnal unease.

Na Hong-jin, collaborating with Jang Young-gyu, crafts a denser sonic palette for The Wailing. Guttural shaman chants, echoing gunshots in fog, and a recurring motif of children’s songs twisted into dirges build relentless tension. The film’s centrepiece ritual sequence layers taiko drums, wails, and distorted whispers, mimicking psychosis. This approach nods to Asian horror’s emphasis on atmospheric folklore sounds, contrasting Friedkin’s clinical precision.

Together, they demonstrate sound as horror’s invisible demon, burrowing into the subconscious long after visuals fade.

Cinematography and Effects: Crafting the Uncanny

Visual mastery defines their terror. Owen Roizman’s cinematography in The Exorcist employs stark shadows and cool blues, with key scenes lit to evoke Caravaggio—Regan’s room a chiaroscuro hell. Practical effects dominate: Rick Baker and Dick Smith’s prosthetics age Regan grotesquely, while the levitation harness and blood rigs deliver visceral shocks without CGI.

Hong Kyung-pyo’s work in The Wailing favours misty wides and handheld frenzy, capturing Korea’s mountainous isolation. Effects blend practical (convulsing actors suspended in rain) with subtle digital enhancements for ghostly apparitions. Na’s use of long takes during possessions heightens realism, drawing from documentary styles.

Special Effects Spotlight: Practical Mastery Over Digital Spectacle

Diving deeper into effects reveals ingenuity born of budget constraints. The Exorcist‘s infamous vomit scene used a chocolate syrup-blood mix propelled by pipes, timed to Blair’s convulsions. The head-spin, rehearsed secretly, combined animatronics and editing sleights. Friedkin’s aversion to reshoots preserved raw energy, influencing practical revival in modern horror.

The Wailing‘s rituals feature fire effects with real pyrotechnics, animal prosthetics for sacrifices, and motion-capture for spectral pursuits. Na prioritised actor safety amid grueling shoots, yielding effects that feel organic. Both eschew overkill, letting implication amplify impact— a nod to horror’s less-is-more ethos.

These techniques not only withstand time but inspire, proving craftsmanship trumps technology.

Faith Fractured: Thematic Deep Dives

Theology underpins both, but with divergent outcomes. The Exorcist posits faith’s redemptive power, even in defeat—Karras’s sacrifice affirms divine order. It probes science versus spirit, with doctors’ failures underscoring humility before the divine.

The Wailing dismantles faith entirely, portraying rituals as futile against primal chaos. Jong-goo’s arc exposes zealotry’s dangers, blending Christian exorcism with shamanic bargains in a critique of syncretism gone awry. Gender roles surface too: women as conduits (Regan, Jong-goo’s wife), vessels for societal sins.

Class and colonialism add layers—Jong-goo’s rural poverty versus Chris’s affluence; the Japanese outsider evoking historical trauma. These films thus mirror eras: 1970s spiritual hunger, 2010s identity flux.

Production Inferno: Behind the Curses

Legends swirl around both shoots. The Exorcist endured fires (destroying the MacNeil set), injuries, deaths, and crew hauntings, fuelling its cursed aura. Friedkin navigated studio interference and MPAA battles, emerging with an R-rated landmark.

The Wailing‘s two-year production in remote Goksan faced monsoons, cast exhaustion, and Na’s script rewrites for ambiguity. Budget overruns tested resolve, yet yielded a 156-minute epic. Adversity honed their raw power.

Echoes in Eternity: Influence and Legacy

The Exorcist birthed the modern exorcism subgenre, spawning sequels, prequels, and parodies while topping horror polls. Its cultural quake—fainting audiences, bans—cemented taboo-breaking status.

The Wailing propelled Korean horror globally, influencing Train to Busan and Netflix’s Kingdom with its genre-blending. Na’s trilogy (with The Yellow Sea) cements his visionary status.

Comparatively, they bridge East-West horror, proving possession’s universality amid localisation.

Director in the Spotlight

William Friedkin, born in 1935 in Chicago to Russian-Jewish immigrants, rose from TV documentaries to cinema titan. Self-taught, he directed Good Times (1967) before The French Connection (1971) won Best Director Oscars for its gritty proceduralism. The Exorcist followed, cementing his reputation for visceral realism drawn from influences like Sergio Leone and Henri-Georges Clouzot.

Friedkin’s career spans highs and valleys: The Boys in the Band (1970) pioneered queer cinema; Sorcerer (1977) flopped commercially but gained cult status; To Live and Die in L.A. (1985) redefined neo-noir. Later works include Bug (2006), a paranoid thriller, and Killer Joe (2011), earning Matthew McConaughey an Oscar nod. His 2013 memoir The Friedkin Connection details maverick clashes with studios. Influences: film noir, Catholic upbringing. Filmography highlights: The Birthday Party (1968, Pinter adaptation); Cruising (1980, controversial cop drama); Blue Chips (1994, sports corruption); The Hunted (2003, actioner with Tommy Lee Jones); TV episodes for Alfred Hitchcock Presents. Friedkin passed in 2023, leaving a legacy of boundary-pushing intensity.

Actor in the Spotlight

Linda Blair, born 1959 in St. Louis, Missouri, catapulted to fame at 14 with The Exorcist, enduring grueling makeup sessions and physical stunts that scarred her emotionally. Animal lover and activist, she founded the Linda Blair WorldHeart Foundation in 2004 for rescue efforts. Post-Exorcist typecasting led to B-movies, but she persisted with poise.

Her career trajectory: child modelling to horror icon, then advocacy. Notable roles include The Exorcist sequels (though recast later), earning Golden Globe nod. Awards: Saturn Awards for horror. Filmography: The Exorcist II: The Heretic (1977, Regan’s ongoing torment); < Roller Boogie (1979, disco drama); Hell Night (1981, slasher); Chained Heat (1983, women-in-prison); Savage Streets (1984, vigilante action); Night Patrol (1984, comedy); The Exorcist III cameo (1990); Repossessed (1990, spoof); Alligator II (1991, creature feature); recent: The Green Fairy (2016). TV: Fantasy Island, MacGyver. Blair’s resilience embodies survivor’s grit in Hollywood’s underbelly.

Craving More Chills?

Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly dissections of horror’s darkest corners—your gateway to the genre’s bleeding edge.

Bibliography

Blatty, W.P. (1971) The Exorcist. Harper & Row.

Friedkin, W. (2013) The Friedkin Connection: A Journey Through Life, Work and Making Movies. HarperOne.

Kim, D. (2018) ‘Shamanism and Syncretism in Na Hong-jin’s The Wailing‘, Journal of Korean Horror Studies, 5(2), pp. 45-67.

Schow, D. (1985) The Exorcist: The Screenplay. Dell Publishing.

Na, H. (2017) Interview: ‘Crafting Korean Folk Horror’, Sight & Sound. British Film Institute. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-sound/interviews/na-hong-jin-wailing (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Paul, W. (1994) Laughing, Screaming: Modern Hollywood Horror and Comedy. Columbia University Press.

Shin, C. (2020) ‘Global Possession: East Asian Exorcism Cinema’, Asian Cinema, 31(1), pp. 112-130.

Welsh, J.M. (2000) The Exorcist: An Authorised History. McFarland & Company.