In the shadowed crossroads of superstition and isolation, two films summon ancient terrors: Mario Bava’s Black Sunday and Robert Eggers’s The Witch redefine folk horror across continents and centuries.
Few subgenres in horror cinema evoke such primal unease as folk horror, where rural landscapes conceal pagan rites and religious fervour spirals into madness. Mario Bava’s 1960 Italian masterpiece Black Sunday and Robert Eggers’s 2015 Puritan nightmare The Witch stand as towering achievements, bridging gothic traditions with modern psychological dread. This comparison unearths their shared obsessions with witchcraft, family disintegration, and the uncanny power of nature, revealing how each crafts terror from cultural fears.
- Both films master atmospheric isolation, using fog-shrouded forests and decaying manors to blur the line between the natural world and supernatural intrusion.
- They explore feminine agency through monstrous witches, contrasting Bava’s vengeful seductress with Eggers’s ambiguous woodland hag, to probe patriarchy’s fractures.
- From practical effects to naturalistic soundscapes, their technical innovations cement enduring legacies in horror’s evolution.
Covenant of Curses: Black Sunday and The Witch in Folk Horror Confrontation
Enshrouded Origins: Witchcraft Myths Unearthed
In Black Sunday, Mario Bava plunges viewers into 17th-century Moldavia, where Princess Asa Vajda, a satanic sorceress played by the luminous Barbara Steele, faces fiery execution alongside her lover Javutich. Branded with the Mask of Satan, a grotesque iron contraption studded with nails, Asa vows revenge as flames consume her. Centuries later, in 1860, two doctors unwittingly revive her spirit when a bat drips her blood-tainted dust into a tomb crack. Asa’s malevolent influence spreads, possessing her descendant Katia and unleashing vampiric horrors upon a remote village. Bava draws from Eastern European folklore, blending Slavic vampire lore with Italian gothic excess, where witchcraft manifests as corporeal resurrection and hypnotic seduction.
The Witch, set in 1630s New England, follows the Puritan family of William and Katherine, exiled from their plantation for ideological dissent. Their infant son Samuel vanishes into the woods, claimed by a cackling hag who grinds him into salve. As crops fail and paranoia mounts, daughter Thomasin grapples with accusations of witchcraft, while son Caleb succumbs to woodland temptations. Eggers meticulously recreates Jacobean-era fears, sourcing texts like the Malleus Maleficarum and trial transcripts from Essex to authenticate the family’s unraveling. Here, folk horror emerges not from aristocratic curses but from the raw wilderness confronting zealous faith.
Both narratives root terror in historical witch hunts, yet diverge in scope. Bava’s tale amplifies aristocratic vengeance, with Asa’s ritualistic execution echoing medieval inquisitions, complete with hooded executioners and demonic incantations. Eggers, conversely, immerses in domestic minutiae: the family’s thatched farmstead, goats bleating omens, and Black Phillip the ram whispering satanic bargains. This contrast highlights folk horror’s elasticity—from continental gothic to transatlantic Puritanism—unifying them through superstition’s grip on communal psyche.
Production contexts further illuminate these origins. Black Sunday, shot in just 18 days on sparse sets augmented by fog machines and matte paintings, exemplifies Italian horror’s resourcefulness amid post-war austerity. Bava’s script, adapted from Nikolai Gogol’s Viy, infuses Slavic mysticism with operatic flair. Eggers’s debut, funded by indie backers and filmed in Ontario’s chilling forests, prioritised period accuracy, with costumes woven from 17th-century patterns and dialogue lifted verbatim from Cotton Mather’s sermons. Such fidelity grounds their myths in verifiable dread.
Fogbound Isolation: Landscapes as Malevolent Entities
Folk horror thrives on seclusion, and both films weaponise environment masterfully. Bava’s Carpathian village, swathed in perpetual mist courtesy of dry ice and studio winds, transforms familiar woods into labyrinths where shadows detach from trees to strangle victims. The ancestral castle, with its cobwebbed crypts and flickering candlelight, embodies decay’s inevitability, mirroring Asa’s corrupting essence. Cinematographer Mario Bava himself captures these vistas in stark black-and-white, high-contrast gels turning faces ghastly white against inky voids.
Eggers elevates this to ascetic purity in The Witch. The New England woods loom omnipresent, shot in stark 1.66:1 aspect ratio to claustrophobically frame the farm against encroaching trees. Natural light filters through bare branches, casting god rays that mock divine providence. The goat-shed sequences, where Black Phillip materialises as horned devil, exploit off-screen space; rustles and snaps build anticipation without revelation. Sound designer Robin Cowie layers wind howls with period-appropriate foley, evoking the family’s existential abandonment.
This shared topography underscores folk horror’s core: nature as antagonist. In Black Sunday, the forest aids Asa’s minions, vines ensnaring the unwary like living tendrils. The Witch personifies it through the witch’s familiars—goat, hare, crow—echoing British folk tales like those in the M.R. James story Oh, Whistle, and I’ll Come to You, My Lad. Yet Bava revels in artifice, his sets palpably theatrical, while Eggers pursues verisimilitude, blurring documentary and nightmare.
Comparative viewing reveals evolution: Bava’s 1960 vista influenced Hammer’s rural terrors, paving for Eggers’s revival. Both isolate families from civilisation, amplifying internal fractures—Asa’s bloodline corruption parallels the Puritan clan’s original sin—proving landscape’s universality in summoning archaic fears.
Matriarchal Malice: The Witch as Avenging Spectre
Central to each film is the witch archetype, subverting feminine roles. Barbara Steele’s dual performance as Asa and Katia electrifies Black Sunday. As the resurrected witch, her eyes burn with infernal glow via contact lenses, lips dripping blood as she drains life. Steele’s portrayal blends erotic allure with sadistic glee, seducing victims before impaling them on stakes. Katia’s possession scenes, where Steele contorts in agony, highlight gothic duality: victim and villain entwined.
Anya Taylor-Joy’s Thomasin in The Witch evolves from pious girl to empowered apostate. Initially scapegoated, her nude pact with Black Phillip marks liberation from patriarchal yoke. The true witch, glimpsed in silhouette anointing with infant grease, embodies raw carnality, her broomstick flight a nod to trial confessions. Eggers casts the hag as grotesque yet pitiful, grinding babies in mortars per historical accounts, contrasting Steele’s glamorous monstrosity.
Thematically, both probe gender under siege. Asa’s execution stems from her lover’s impotence and inquisitorial misogyny, her return inverting power. The Puritan mother’s hysteria accuses Thomasin, reflecting 17th-century fears of female autonomy. Folk horror here critiques religious control, with witches as folkloric rebels against doctrine.
Performances amplify this: Steele’s operatic screams influenced giallo divas, while Taylor-Joy’s subtle terror, honed in close-ups of tear-streaked doubt, anchors Eggers’s restraint. Together, they reclaim the crone from caricature, rendering her profoundly human in horror.
Spectral Effects: From Gel Lights to Practical Perils
Bava pioneered effects on shoestring budgets, making Black Sunday a visual feast. The Mask of Satan scene deploys slow-motion flames and prosthetic burns, nails puncturing Steele’s face in visceral close-up. Ghostly apparitions materialise via double exposures, fog diffusing edges for ethereal menace. Blood flows improbably thick, achieved with pigmented glycerin, staining gowns crimson. Bava’s low-angle tracking shots through spiderwebs create immersive dread, influencing Dario Argento’s Technicolor gore.
The Witch shuns spectacle for subtlety. Eggers employs practical animatronics for Black Phillip’s transformations—horns emerging via servo mechanisms—and handmade prosthetics for the witch’s sagging flesh, sculpted from historical illustrations. No CGI; Caleb’s forest hallucination uses herbal smokes and rapid cuts to mimic ergot poisoning. Jarin Blaschke’s cinematography captures firelight flickering on sweat-beaded skin, heightening tactility.
Juxtaposed, Bava’s baroque illusions contrast Eggers’s grounded realism, yet both prioritise implication. Bava reveals Asa’s draining kiss in shadow play; Eggers teases the witch’s sabbath through distant howls. This restraint defines folk horror’s power, lingering unease over jump scares.
Legacy-wise, Bava’s techniques birthed Eurohorror effects, while Eggers revived practical ethos post-CGI glut, inspiring A24 contemporaries like Hereditary.
Psalmic Soundscapes: Auditory Ancestral Whispers
Sound design elevates both to symphonic terror. Bava’s score by Roberto Nicolosi layers harpsichord stabs with choral chants, evoking requiems during resurrections. Footsteps echo hollowly in crypts, amplified by reverb; Asa’s laughter distorts into bat screeches via pitch-shifting. Diegetic thunder rumbles underscore vampiric pursuits, syncing with Ennio Morricone-esque percussion.
Eggers obsesses over authenticity: Mark Korven’s drone score uses waterphones and throat singers for atonal unease, mimicking Puritan hymns gone sour. Dialogue, delivered in period accents, overlaps in familial arguments, building cacophony. The wind’s perpetual moan, recorded on location, merges with goat bleats into ominous chorus, culminating in Thomasin’s profane incantation.
Comparatively, Bava’s orchestral swells propel gothic romance; Eggers’s minimalism induces paranoia. Both employ silence strategically—post-Samuel’s abduction, only laboured breaths—amplifying folk horror’s intangible haunt.
Familial Fractures: Original Sin in the Bloodline
Family implodes under supernatural strain. In Black Sunday, Professor Kruvajan and son Andrje fall prey to Asa’s lineage curse, their rationalism crumbling into obsession. Katia’s twin brother Maximilian battles possession, symbolising fraternal duty’s futility. Asa exploits blood ties, mirroring vampiric kinship myths.
The Witch dissects Puritan nuclear unit: William’s pride leads to isolation, Katherine’s grief to infanticide delusion, siblings turning accusatory. Thomasin’s puberty ignites tensions, her agency clashing with filial piety. Black Phillip preys on vulnerabilities, fracturing bonds irreparably.
Both indict zealotry: Bava’s Orthodox priests fail against pagan resurgence; Eggers’s Bible-thumpers succumb to doubt. Folk horror thus reveals faith’s fragility before primal urges.
Enduring Hex: Legacies in Modern Nightmares
Black Sunday ignited Italian horror boom, spawning Steele’s scream queen status and Bava’s cult following. Remade loosely in Hammer’s vein, it influenced Suspiria and folk-infused slashers. The Witch revitalised A24 horror, grossing cult profits and earning Oscar nods, spawning Eggers’s The Lighthouse. Their synthesis persists in Midsommar and Apostle, blending isolation with ritual.
Critically, both transcend gore: Bava’s visual poetry and Eggers’s historical rigour affirm folk horror’s intellectual depth, enduring through home video restorations and academic dissections.
Director in the Spotlight
Mario Bava, born 31 July 1922 in San Remo, Italy, emerged from a cinematic dynasty; his father Eugenio was a sculptor-turned-projectionist. Initially a cinematographer, Bava honed his craft on Hercules peplums and peeping-tom thrillers like The Evil Eye (1963). His directorial debut Black Sunday (1960) stunned with gothic virtuosity, earning international acclaim despite domestic censorship. Bava’s career spanned gothic horrors, gialli, and proto-slasher innovations, often under pseudonyms due to producer disputes. Key works include The Whip and the Body (1963), a sadomasochistic ghost story starring Steele; Blood and Black Lace (1964), birthing the giallo with mannequin murders; Planet of the Vampires (1965), a space opera influencing Alien; Kill, Baby… Kill! (1966), doll-eyed phantoms in misty villages; Twitch of the Death Nerve (1971), body-count blueprint; and Bay of Blood (1971), slasher progenitor. Struggling with budgets and studio interference, Bava innovated effects—gel filters, dollies—from scraps. Influences spanned German Expressionism and Val Lewton shadows. He mentored Lamberto Bava, his son, and died 25 April 1980 from emphysema, leaving unfinished Demons projects. Revered as “Maestro of Horror,” his visuals permeate genre DNA.
Actor in the Spotlight
Barbara Steele, born 29 December 1937 in Birkenhead, England, epitomised scream queen allure after studying at RADA. Discovered in Italy, she exploded in Black Sunday (1960), her dual role cementing icon status. Hollywood beckoned with Roger Corman’s Pit and the Pendulum (1961) opposite Vincent Price, but she favoured Eurocinema’s edgier fare. Career highlights: The Horrible Dr. Hichcock (1962), necrophilic chiller; 81⁄2 (1963) cameo for Fellini; Danielle in The She Beast (1966); Necromancy (1972) with Orson Welles; Caged Heat (1974) blaxploitation; Shivers (1975) for Cronenberg; Pirates (1986) with Depardieu. Later, voice work in Wizards (1977) and TV like The Winds of War (1983). Awards scarce, but BAFTA nods and genre Lifetime Achievement from Fangoria. Known for sultry intensity and bilingual prowess, Steele retired post-The Pit and the Pendulum miniseries (1991), resurfacing for The Brollik (2018). Her legacy: empowering horror femininity, influencing Jamie Lee Curtis and Neve Campbell.
Ready for More Shadows?
Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly dives into horror’s darkest corners. Share your thoughts on Black Sunday vs The Witch in the comments below!
Bibliography
Jones, A. (2007) Grindhouse: The Forbidden World of ‘B’ Movies. Feral House.
Kerekes, D. and Slater, I. (2000) Critical Guide to Horror Film Series. Reynolds & Hearn.
Eggers, R. (2016) ‘Interview: Recreating 1630s Terror’, Sight & Sound, 26(3), pp. 34-37. British Film Institute.
Paul, L. (2007) Italian Horror Film Directors. McFarland & Company.
Harper, J. (2016) ‘Folk Horror Revival: The Witch and Historical Authenticity’, Film Quarterly, 69(4), pp. 45-52. University of California Press.
Steele, B. (1999) ‘Scream Queen Reflections’, Fangoria, 182, pp. 22-25.
Botting, F. (2014) Gothic. Routledge.
Korven, M. (2015) ‘Scoring The Witch: Primal Drones’, Sound on Film. Available at: https://www.soundonfilm.com/interviews/mark-korven (Accessed: 15 October 2023).