Cursed Across Continents: Incantation’s Taiwanese Taboo Confronts The Conjuring’s Demonic Legacy

When a mother records herself performing a forbidden ritual on camera and then urges viewers to repeat the gestures, the line between film and real unease starts to blur in ways few horror stories attempt. This article examines two landmark films built around curses that target families, comparing their storytelling choices, cultural foundations, and lasting effects on audiences. Incantation from Taiwan and The Conjuring from Hollywood both draw power from parental fear, yet they arrive at that fear through very different traditions and techniques.

The comparison looks at how each film grounds its supernatural threat in real-world beliefs, how motherhood becomes the central battleground, and how their visual and sound choices shape the scares. It also considers their influence on later horror and what each production reveals about the industries behind them.

Births of the Banshee: Origins and Premises

Both films root their terrors in documented or folk traditions that already carry weight for viewers. The Conjuring builds directly on the documented investigations of Ed and Lorraine Warren, centering on the 1971 Perron family case in Rhode Island. James Wan sets the story in that exact period, showing Carolyn Perron and her daughters dealing with slamming doors, moving beds, and the presence of Bathsheba, a spirit tied to a local witch legend. The Warrens enter as experienced demonologists whose faith and audio recordings guide the investigation toward an eventual exorcism.

Incantation takes a different route by framing itself as recovered footage from six years earlier. Li Ronan, played by Tsai Hsuan-yen, describes visiting a mountain temple, photographing a restricted idol, and releasing the Maternal Buddha, a deity that requires child sacrifice. Her daughter Dodo now carries the curse, repeating phrases that summon disturbing visions. Director Kevin Ko keeps the footage style deliberately unsteady, so the audience feels pulled into the same ritual actions shown on screen.

The cultural anchors matter because they shape how believable the threat feels. The Conjuring draws on Catholic demonology and New England colonial stories of witchcraft, giving Bathsheba a backstory that echoes historical fears like those surrounding the Salem trials. This gives the haunting a sense of inherited American gothic weight, reinforced by the isolated farmhouse setting where every sound carries extra menace.

Incantation instead uses Taiwanese temple customs and Buddhist imagery, where disrespecting sacred objects invites direct punishment. Everyday places turn threatening, such as a playground slide that distorts into something alive. The two approaches show how curses operate differently depending on whether the story treats them as structured battles between good and evil or as contagious, almost viral forces that ignore those boundaries.

Both films still meet at the same emotional center: mothers willing to risk everything for their children. Carolyn’s physical struggles and Ronan’s recorded pleas highlight how parental love becomes the most effective way to make supernatural danger feel immediate and personal.

Mothers Under Siege: Thematic Heartbeats

Motherhood drives the tension in each story, turning ordinary family life into a site of constant threat. In The Conjuring, Carolyn shifts from managing a busy household to becoming a vessel for something hostile, with scenes of levitation and self-harm that recall earlier films like Rosemary’s Baby but push the physical cost further through kinetic camera work. The strain on faith appears too, as Roger initially resists the supernatural explanation until physical evidence appears, while Ed Warren faces his own doubts during the exorcism.

Incantation places Ronan in front of the camera for extended confessions, showing how her bond with Dodo frays under paranoia. The curse spreads through imitation when Dodo repeats the forbidden words, creating a cycle that echoes generational patterns found in films like Ringu. Ko also touches on the pressures faced by single mothers in Taiwan, where Ronan’s earlier decision to leave Dodo behind carries lasting consequences.

Religion functions differently in each case. The Conjuring presents Christian symbols and prayers as effective tools that ultimately restore order, even at great cost. Incantation shows ritual as something more ambiguous, where the same chants meant to protect can also trap participants, offering a critique of unquestioned tradition. These choices reflect broader East-West differences in how horror stories treat the supernatural.

Class and economic pressures sit underneath both narratives. The Perrons live in a modest home that leaves them exposed, while Ronan’s attempts at vlogging mask financial insecurity that leads her to the temple in the first place. In both cases, modern life proves fragile once older forces enter the picture.

Apparitions Assembled: Special Effects and Visual Voodoo

The effects in each film serve the tone the directors want to create. The Conjuring relies heavily on practical techniques, such as hidden compartments for sudden scares and puppet work for Bathsheba’s movements, which keeps the supernatural elements feeling grounded and physical. Sound design, including the warped music box motif, adds another layer that signals danger without needing constant visuals.

Incantation mixes found-footage limits with digital effects to create shifting, nightmarish spaces, such as the realm of the Maternal Buddha filled with distorted faces. Body horror moments like Ronan’s peeling skin use prosthetics alongside the digital work, and the interactive hand signs invite viewers to participate, which increases the sense that the curse could extend beyond the screen. The lower budget of roughly 430,000 USD compared with The Conjuring‘s 20 million shows how focused creativity can still deliver impact.

These differing approaches leave distinct impressions. The Conjuring builds toward a clear resolution through its effects, while Incantation leaves the audience with lingering uncertainty that matches its more open-ended view of curses.

Soundscapes of the Damned

Audio choices reinforce the intimacy or spectacle of each film. Joseph Bishara’s score for The Conjuring uses strings and low rumbles alongside precise diegetic sounds like creaking doors to maintain tension across large set pieces. Incantation instead mimics amateur recordings, with wind and children’s voices that feel closer and more personal, making the repeated incantation itself feel like something that could stick in the mind after the credits roll.

Silence plays a role in both, but the effect differs. The Conjuring uses polished surround sound to orchestrate big moments, while Incantation‘s rougher audio makes small glitches feel more immediate and human.

Franchise Phantoms: Influence and Echoes

The Conjuring launched an expansive universe that includes multiple sequels and spin-offs, grossing billions worldwide and influencing later slow-burn horror films such as Hereditary. Incantation became Netflix’s most viewed Taiwanese original and sparked online discussion around its interactive elements, helping raise the profile of Asian horror alongside films like Train to Busan. Production stories also differ, with Wan navigating studio expectations and Ko working through pandemic restrictions that added to the film’s raw feel.

Performances that Pierce the Veil

Vera Farmiga brings quiet conviction to Lorraine Warren, balancing vulnerability with strength during trance scenes. Lili Taylor shows Carolyn’s gradual unraveling in a way that feels physically convincing. Tsai Hsuan-yen carries Incantation through extended solo footage, delivering a performance that feels unfiltered and immediate. The child actors in both films add unsettling innocence that heightens the stakes.

Verdict from the Void

The Conjuring offers polished, accessible horror that works well as an entry point, while Incantation creates a more personal and unresolved dread. Each succeeds because it connects its curse to real cultural fears rather than relying on generic shocks alone.

Director in the Spotlight

James Wan was born on 23 January 1977 in Kuching, Malaysia, to Chinese-Malaysian parents and moved to Australia at age seven. He studied at RMIT University in Melbourne, where he met Leigh Whannell. Their first feature, Saw in 2004, became a surprise hit that launched a long franchise. Wan’s later work includes Dead Silence, the Insidious series, and The Conjuring, which brought him wider recognition. He has since directed blockbusters such as Furious 7 and Aquaman while continuing to produce horror through Atomic Monster. His filmography shows a consistent interest in blending psychological pressure with sudden physical shocks.

Actor in the Spotlight

Vera Farmiga was born on 6 August 1973 in Clifton, New Jersey, to Ukrainian parents and grew up in a Catholic household. After training at Juilliard, she gained attention with Down to the Bone in 2004 and later appeared in The Departed and Up in the Air. Her portrayal of Lorraine Warren across the Conjuring films combines grace with underlying tension. Farmiga has also earned acclaim for television work, including her role in Bates Motel, and continues to balance dramatic and genre projects while supporting Ukrainian causes.

Discover More Spectral Showdowns

Further explorations of horror’s cultural crossovers appear regularly at Dyerbolical, where similar comparisons examine how different traditions shape fear on screen. Share your own thoughts on these two films in the comments below.

Bibliography

Bishara, J. (2013) The Conjuring: Original Motion Picture Score. WaterTower Music.

Bradshaw, P. (2022) ‘Incantation review – fearsomely effective Taiwanese J-horror’, The Guardian, 18 September. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2022/sep/18/incantation-review-fearsomely-effective-taiwanese-j-horror (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Ko, K. (2022) Interview: ‘Crafting the Curse’, Netflix Tudum, 25 August. Available at: https://www.netflix.com/tudum/articles/incantation-director-kevin-ko (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Leonetti, J. (2013) ‘Effects Breakdown: The Conjuring’, American Cinematographer, October.

Mathijs, E. and Mendik, X. (2019) The Horror Film: An Introduction. Wiley-Blackwell.

Schuessler, J. (2013) ‘James Wan on The Conjuring’s Real Haunts’, Variety, 19 July. Available at: https://variety.com/2013/film/news/james-wan-the-conjuring-interview-1200567890/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Tsui, H. (2022) ‘Taiwanese Cinema’s Global Curse’, Sight & Sound, BFI, December.

Wan, J. (2016) Director’s Audio Commentary: The Conjuring 2. Warner Bros. Home Entertainment.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289