In the early years of the twentieth century, a young unmarried woman in Copenhagen might have found herself pregnant and terrified. Society offered little support, and whispers of a helpful midwife who could arrange discreet adoptions spread quickly through working-class neighborhoods. That midwife was Dagmar Overbye, and the hope she sold turned out to be lethal. This article examines her background, the operation of her baby farm, the methods behind at least twenty-five infant deaths between 1915 and 1920, the investigation that uncovered the truth, the trial that followed, and the broader social failures her crimes revealed.
Early Life and Path to Infamy
Dagmar Johanne Overbye was born on April 23, 1887, in Adum, a rural area near Herring in central Jutland, Denmark. Details about her childhood remain sparse, yet existing records point to a period of instability that followed her into adulthood. By her early twenties she had moved to Copenhagen, drawn by the promise of work in a city expanding rapidly with factories and new housing. She married Jens Nielsen Overbye in 1908, yet the marriage brought mounting debts and personal strain. The couple had two children, but Overbye soon turned her attention elsewhere.
In 1910 she began assisting a midwife, learning the basics of childbirth and infant care. This experience placed her in a position to notice how many unwed mothers struggled in a country where illegitimacy rates hovered between ten and fifteen percent amid industrialization and shifting social norms. Young servants and factory workers often had nowhere to turn. Overbye saw an opening. She began offering her services quietly, first through word of mouth and later through small notices in poorer districts. By 1915 she had turned her apartment on Amagerbrogade into a functioning baby farm. After her husband died that same year, some accounts suggest by suicide under financial pressure, she operated without restraint. She charged between three hundred and five hundred Danish kroner per child, a sum equal to months of wages for most laborers, and promised each infant would be placed with a caring family.
The Machinery of Murder: Overbye’s Baby Farm
Overbye ran her business with cold precision. Mothers arrived in secret, often after dark, to give birth under her care. Once the delivery ended she claimed the child had been sent to adoptive parents whose names she invented on the spot. She kept ledgers that listed more than sixty placements between 1915 and 1920, yet many of those entries were fabrications. When additional payments stopped or when keeping an infant became inconvenient, she ended the child’s life within days or weeks. The money continued to flow, sometimes supplemented by extra charges she described as travel or legal costs. Overbye lived modestly while investing in property and supporting a lover, yet her appetite for profit never eased.
Methods of Killing: A Catalog of Cruelty
Autopsies and later testimony showed she adapted her approach to whatever seemed quickest and least noticeable in her small apartment. Smothering with pillows or blankets was common because it left few obvious marks. Strangulation with fabric or cord appeared in several cases. Some infants were drowned in buckets or the bathtub. Others received chloral hydrate or morphine mixed into milk. Bodies were burned in her kitchen stove or carried to marshes, canals, and even a public incinerator. One mother, nineteen-year-old seamstress Else Nielsen, paid four hundred kroner in 1917 for her daughter; the infant disappeared days later and was later recovered from a canal.
The Victims: Silent Testimonies of Tragedy
The infants themselves left almost no records. Many births went unregistered, so investigators had to rely on Overbye’s own ledgers and the statements of mothers who later came forward. Among the documented cases were the son of twenty-two-year-old domestic servant Anna Kristensen in 1916, smothered and burned; the daughter of factory worker Marie Jensen in 1918, drowned after two weeks; and the son of Petra Madsen in 1919, strangled and left in Fælled Park after five hundred kroner changed hands. These details emerged during the trial and still carry weight today because they show how easily trust could be exploited when mothers had no other options. One mother later said she had trusted Overbye with her only hope. Overbye displayed no visible regret, treating each child as a temporary expense rather than a life.
Unraveling the Web: Investigation and Arrest
The case broke open in March 1920 during a routine health inspection. A colleague noticed unusual odors from Overbye’s stove and alerted authorities. Police searched the apartment on March 29 and found two malnourished infants still alive, ledgers recording payments that totaled eighteen thousand kroner, and ashes later confirmed as infant remains. Further searches turned up bones in the yard and nearby marshes. Overbye first denied any wrongdoing but eventually admitted to several killings. By April, sixteen sets of remains had been linked to specific mothers. She was arrested on April 8 and charged with nine murders, although investigators believed the true number reached at least twenty-five. Detective Inspector Carl Alfred Lauridsen led the inquiry, using early forensic techniques such as bone analysis and cross-checks with birth notices. Newspapers began calling her Børnemorderen, the Child Murderer, and public anger grew quickly.
The Trial: Justice in the Spotlight
The trial opened on December 13, 1920, at Copenhagen City Court under Judge Heinrich Hansen. Prosecutors presented the ledgers, forensic evidence, and testimony from grieving mothers. Overbye claimed some deaths were natural or accidental, yet medical experts rejected those explanations. The defense cited poverty and outside pressure, but the jury convicted her on nine counts of murder on December 17. She received a death sentence by hanging, the last such sentence given to a woman in Denmark. King Christian X later commuted the penalty to life imprisonment under growing abolitionist sentiment. Overbye entered Horsens State Prison and remained there in isolation until her death from heart disease on January 6, 1929, at the age of forty-one.
Psychological Underpinnings: Decoding the Killer
Understanding what drove Overbye requires looking at both personal traits and the environment she exploited. She showed little remorse and displayed the kind of instrumental thinking that treats other people as tools for gain. Some observers have pointed to possible antisocial traits and a capacity for dissociation, given that she raised two children of her own while ending the lives of others. At the same time, the social conditions of the era mattered. Strict moral codes around illegitimacy left many women isolated and willing to pay for secrecy. Overbye took advantage of that isolation rather than creating it. Comparisons to earlier cases, such as Amelia Dyer in Britain, show a similar pattern of using a position of trust to profit from vulnerable mothers. Her story also highlights how gender stereotypes could delay suspicion; a woman offering childcare did not immediately raise alarms the way a male suspect might have.
Legacy: Echoes of Prevention
Overbye’s crimes prompted real changes. Denmark passed the 1921 Adoption Act, which introduced oversight for placements, and expanded services for unwed mothers. Similar baby-farming scandals in other countries, including the cases of Amelia Sach and Annie Walters in London and Hélène Jegado in France, had already shown the dangers of unregulated arrangements. In Denmark the reforms arrived later but addressed the same gaps. Today the ledgers from Overbye’s apartment are displayed at Copenhagen’s Workers’ Museum, serving as a record of both individual cruelty and collective neglect. Anonymous graves in Assistens Cemetery continue to mark the lives that were lost.
Stories like this one remind us why basic protections for mothers and infants matter. When support systems fail, opportunities for exploitation appear. Overbye did not act in a vacuum; she operated within a society that offered few alternatives to the women who sought her help. At Dyerbolical we return to these cases because they show both the worst impulses and the slow progress toward better safeguards.
Bibliography
Danish National Archives, Court Records from the 1920 Overbye Trial, Copenhagen, 1920-1921.
Lauridsen, Carl Alfred. Police Investigation Reports on the Amagerbrogade Baby Farm Case, 1920.
Pedersen, Hans. “Baby Farming and Social Reform in Denmark, 1900-1930,” Scandinavian Journal of History, 1985.
Rose, Lionel. The Massacre of the Innocents: Infanticide in Britain 1800-1922, Routledge, 1986.
Workers’ Museum Copenhagen. Exhibition Records on Dagmar Overbye and Early Child Welfare, 2015.
Contemporary newspaper coverage from Politiken and Berlingske Tidende, March-December 1920.
Modern criminological analysis in “Opportunistic Serial Homicide in Caregiving Roles,” Journal of Forensic Sciences, 2008.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
