In the spring of 1589, a midwife named Anna Ebeler stood before a court in Trier, Germany, soaked and shaking after hours of repeated submersion. She had been bound to a stool and lowered into a river again and again until her body gave out. What followed was not a measured inquiry but a flood of names, places, and impossible details that would send dozens more to the stake. Her story captures the grim reality of water torture during the witch trials, a practice that turned fear of drowning into a tool for extracting confessions across Europe.
This article looks at the water-based methods used in those trials, the historical conditions that made them seem acceptable, and the way they affected both the people accused and the societies that employed them. It traces the techniques from England to the continent, examines specific cases, and considers why these ordeals persisted for so long before fading under changing legal standards.
The Historical Backdrop of Witch Hunts
The witch trials took hold during a period of repeated crises that left communities searching for explanations. The Black Death had already thinned populations and frayed social bonds. Religious divisions after the Reformation added fresh layers of suspicion, while the printing press spread stories of demonic activity faster than ever before. Into this unsettled climate came the 1487 Malleus Maleficarum, written by Heinrich Kramer, which laid out procedures for identifying and questioning suspected witches. The manual treated torture as a legitimate step toward uncovering pacts with the devil, and courts from Scotland to Spain adopted similar approaches.
Water torture gained popularity because it was inexpensive, left few obvious marks, and produced the kind of detailed statements that courts could treat as voluntary. By the late sixteenth century, regions such as the Holy Roman Empire saw intense outbreaks of panic. In Trier between 1581 and 1593, more than three hundred people were executed after trials that routinely included water ordeals. In England during the 1640s, Matthew Hopkins, known as the Witchfinder General, ordered the swimming test on numerous suspects, binding them and placing them in ponds to see whether they would float.
These practices drew on older customs, including the Roman supplicium aquae, but were reframed through Christian ideas about baptism and purity. Inquisitors claimed that a true witch would reject holy water, a notion that gave the ordeal a veneer of divine authority. In practice, the tests often ended in death from shock or inhaled water, and the results were interpreted to fit the accusation regardless of outcome.
Water Torture Methods Employed in Witch Trials
Across different regions, interrogators relied on the same basic principle: using the terror of drowning to break down resistance and produce names of supposed accomplices. The methods varied in equipment but shared the goal of forcing confessions that could then justify further arrests.
The Ducking Stool and Swimming Test
In England and Scotland the ducking stool, originally used to punish scolds, was adapted for witchcraft cases. The accused was strapped to a seat fixed to a long pole and lowered into a river or pond. Sessions could last from a few minutes to much longer, with brief pauses to revive anyone who lost consciousness. In 1612, Agnes Sampson endured repeated duckings in Scotland before she spoke of storms connected to King James VI. Her statements spared her from burning at first but did not prevent her eventual execution.
The swimming test, favored by Hopkins, required victims to be bound with arms crossed to legs and then floated. Any buoyancy was taken as proof that the water had rejected them. Parish records from Essex in 1645 list twenty-three women subjected to this test; nine floated and were later hanged. The logic rested on the idea that baptismal water would no longer accept someone who had renounced it, yet the posture itself often kept a person afloat regardless of guilt or innocence.
The Tormenta de Agua: Forced Ingestion
On the continent, Spanish and German courts used a method called tormenta de agua. A funnel was forced into the mouth and held in place while water was poured steadily, sometimes in large quantities. The stomach would swell, triggering vomiting and spasms as water reached the lungs. Accounts from the Würzburg trials of 1626 to 1629 describe a baker’s wife named Maria who confessed to using devilish bread after two such sessions. The Malleus Maleficarum advised withholding food beforehand to increase the victim’s distress. Some variants combined the funnel with the strappado, hoisting the person by the wrists before lowering the head into a vat of water.
Advanced Variants and Prolongation Techniques
In Bamberg under Prince-Bishop Johann Georg II Fuchs von Dornheim, interrogators developed a water chair that held the victim while cold water dripped onto the face without full submersion. This approach foreshadowed later techniques that simulated drowning. Thumbscrews or leg vices were often applied at the same time to limit movement. Sessions might be repeated daily, sometimes as many as ten times, until a confession emerged or the person died. Initial dunkings of thirty seconds could extend to five minutes or more. Salt water or urine was occasionally added to increase discomfort, and blindfolds were used to heighten disorientation. The resulting statements frequently included elaborate descriptions of sabbaths, familiars, and crop damage, which courts recorded as evidence without questioning the circumstances under which they were obtained.
Notable Witch Trials Featuring Water Torture
The Trier trials remain one of the clearest examples of how water torture could drive an entire region into mass accusation. More than three hundred and sixty-eight people confessed under these conditions, naming thousands of others. Anna Ebeler’s account of aerial sabbaths came after repeated sessions on the water stool, and she was executed in 1589. Public dunkings drew crowds that treated the spectacle as proof of justice being served.
In the Loudun trials of 1634 in France, Urbain Grandier faced accusations that involved water ordeals applied to supposed accomplices. Sister Jeanne des Anges, one of the main accusers, was reportedly tested in private, with her reactions interpreted as signs of possession. Although Grandier was burned, the confessions extracted through water methods helped widen the scope of the purge. Colonial America saw echoes of the practice as well. In Virginia in 1706, Grace Sherwood survived three submersions and was imprisoned rather than executed, becoming known locally as the Witch of Pungo. Salem relied more on spectral testimony, yet the underlying willingness to accept ordeal results lingered in earlier cases.
The water closed over my head, and in that darkness, I saw the devil they sought in me. — Attributed to a Bamberg victim in trial transcripts.
The Psychology of Water Torture
The effectiveness of these methods came from the body’s immediate response to the threat of drowning. Panic sets in quickly, breathing becomes rapid, and lack of oxygen can produce hallucinations that interrogators then shaped into demonic visions. Cold water adds a sharp constriction of blood vessels and a racing heartbeat. Over repeated cycles, the physical strain can lead to organ damage. On a psychological level, the ordeal creates a sense of helplessness, especially when the victim is told that survival or sinking proves guilt. Modern research on simulated drowning shows high rates of false confession under similar pressure, a pattern that matches the way one broken statement in a witch trial could trigger dozens more accusations.
Those who carried out the torture often justified their actions through a belief that they were saving souls or protecting the community. Writers such as Nicolas Remy, author of Daemonolatreia, recorded hundreds of executions while framing the process as necessary cleansing. This form of moral distancing allowed ordinary officials to continue practices that would otherwise have been recognized as simple cruelty.
The Decline and Legacy of These Practices
By the mid-eighteenth century, Enlightenment arguments against torture gained ground. Cesare Beccaria’s 1764 work On Crimes and Punishments highlighted the unreliability of statements obtained through pain. The last major European trials, including one in Poland in 1776, moved away from water ordeals as legal reforms took hold. By 1782 the Holy Roman Empire had repealed its witchcraft statutes. Water-based interrogation did not disappear entirely; similar methods appeared in later centuries under different political regimes and resurfaced in post-2001 detention practices. Memorials such as the witch fountain in Trier now mark the sites of these trials, and historians estimate between forty thousand and sixty thousand deaths across the entire period of the hunts. Scholars including Brian Levack have noted that roughly eighty percent of the victims were women, underscoring how economic pressures and gender bias shaped who was most often targeted.
At Dyerbolical we have examined how these episodes fit into broader patterns of fear-driven justice. The water ordeals show what happens when legal systems accept pain as a path to truth and how difficult it becomes to stop the cycle once it begins.
Bibliography
Brian P. Levack, The Witch-Hunt in Early Modern Europe (4th ed., Routledge, 2016).
Heinrich Kramer, Malleus Maleficarum (1487, modern translation by Christopher S. Mackay, Cambridge University Press, 2006).
William Monter, Witchcraft in France and Switzerland (Cornell University Press, 1976).
James Sharpe, Instruments of Darkness: Witchcraft in Early Modern England (University of Pennsylvania Press, 1996).
Gerhard Schormann, Hexenprozesse in Deutschland (Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1981).
John Demos, Entertaining Satan: Witchcraft and the Culture of Early New England (Oxford University Press, 1982).
Cesare Beccaria, On Crimes and Punishments (1764, translation by David Young, Hackett, 1986).
Records of the Essex Witch Trials, 1645, preserved in the Essex Record Office.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
