Echoes in the Empty House: Carnival of Souls and Skinamarink as Pillars of Experimental Dread

Two spectral visions from different eras, bound by their refusal to explain the horror they unleash.

In the shadowy fringes of horror cinema, where convention crumbles and unease festers in ambiguity, Carnival of Souls (1962) and Skinamarink (2022) stand as defiant monuments. Herk Harvey’s low-budget apparition and Kyle Edward Ball’s analogue nightmare share a lineage of experimental terror that prioritises sensation over story, inviting viewers into voids of the unknown. This comparison unearths their shared DNA, dissecting how each crafts dread from sparsity.

  • Both films wield minimalism as their sharpest weapon, stripping narratives to skeletal forms that amplify psychological voids.
  • Sound design and visual desaturation emerge as twin engines of terror, transforming silence and shadow into palpable entities.
  • Their legacies ripple through indie horror, proving experimental purity endures beyond commercial polish.

Genesis in the Grain: Productions Born of Obsession

Herk Harvey conjured Carnival of Souls in Lawrence, Kansas, on a shoestring budget of around $100,000, filming over three weeks in 1961 with a crew drawn from his day job at Centron Corporation, a producer of educational shorts. The abandoned Saltair Pavilion on the Great Salt Lake served as the eerie carnival backdrop, its decaying grandeur captured in stark black-and-white. Harvey, a multifaceted showman with vaudeville roots, scripted a tale of Mary Henry (Candace Hilligoss), a church organist who survives a car plunge into murky waters only to be haunted by a ghoulish figure. The film’s thrift birthed ingenuity: non-actors from local stock companies filled roles, and Harvey himself embodied the pallid ghoul, his greasepaint mask a DIY triumph of menace.

Decades later, Kyle Edward Ball channelled viral YouTube shorts into Skinamarink, a $15,000 micro-budget feat shot during COVID lockdowns in his childhood home in Canada. Absent traditional actors, the film features children Jaime Hill and Dali Rose as Kevin and Kaylee, trapped in a house where doors and windows vanish, stalked by an unseen parental horror. Ball’s process mirrored analogue horror aesthetics: extreme close-ups on toys, Lego bricks, and carpet fibres, edited on free software to evoke corrupted VHS tapes. Both productions rejected Hollywood gloss, embracing amateur edges that heighten authenticity; Harvey’s 16mm grain parallels Ball’s digital noise, each a deliberate artefact of intimacy and isolation.

These origins underscore experimental horror’s punk ethos. Harvey sidestepped studio gatekeepers, premiering at health film festivals before cult resurrection via late-night TV. Ball bypassed festivals too, dropping Skinamarink on Shudder after TikTok buzz, amassing millions of views. Their triumphs affirm that dread distils purest in constraints, where every creak or flicker demands invention.

Fractured Frames: Narratives That Dissolve

Carnival of Souls unfolds in dream-logic fragments: Mary relocates to a Utah church, her organ prowess clashing with reverend skepticism, while visions of the ghoul invade daily life. Key sequences, like her mute ballroom dance amid indifferent partiers or the salt flat procession of the undead, evade linear cause. The climax reveals her spectral nature in a twist that retroactively unravels reality, leaving audiences adrift in existential fog. Harvey’s editing, with abrupt cuts and repetitive motifs, mimics Mary’s dissociation, prioritising mood over momentum.

Skinamarink shatters convention further, abandoning dialogue and arcs for 100 minutes of liminal drift. We witness Kevin awake to darkness, his father’s mouth erased; Kaylee clings to a blanket as walls shift. No antagonist appears fully, only a rasping voice (“Will you come play with me in the bedroom?”) and distorted faces glimpsed in periphery. Ball’s non-story evokes childhood paralysis, looping footage of staircases and toilets to induce hypnotic unease. Compared, both films weaponise ellipsis: Mary’s hauntings build to revelation, while Skinamarink‘s perpetuity denies closure, trapping viewers in perpetual infancy.

This dissolution serves thematic core. Mary’s limbo critiques post-war conformity, her autonomy eroded by patriarchal gazes. Skinamarink probes parental absence, the house a metaphor for pandemic-era abandonment. Together, they dismantle plot as crutch, proving horror thrives in narrative vacuum where imagination fills the breach.

Symphonies of the Unheard: Mastering Soundscapes

Sound elevates both to transcendence. Harvey’s masterstroke: the titular carnival organ wail, sourced from a calliope recording, punctuates Mary’s torment like a dirge from hell. Sparse dialogue yields to natural echoes, footsteps on concrete, wind through ruins; silence swells during her mute episodes, amplifying isolation. This proto-ambient score predates synth minimalism, influencing Halloween‘s pulse later.

Ball amplifies absence: muffled breaths, distant thuds, warped lullabies from Barney twisted demonic. No score proper; foley dominates, with pillow static and doorless voids humming infrasonically. Viewers report ASMR dread, nausea from low frequencies. Where Harvey’s organ asserts intrusion, Ball’s voids invite projection, both forging auditory hallucinations that linger post-screening.

These choices redefine immersion. Traditional horror screams; these whisper, engaging subconscious. Technical prowess shines: Harvey’s optical lab mixes, Ball’s Audacity hacks, each budget-bound yet sonically vast.

Veils of Shadow: Visual Poetry of the Invisible

Cinematography in Carnival employs high-contrast monochrome, veiling faces in silhouette; Mary’s pallor mirrors the ghoul’s, blurring living-dead. Dutch angles warp church spires, wide shots dwarf her against salt flats. John Clifford’s lens, amateur yet assured, captures ethereal fog without effects, relying on practical lighting.

Skinamarink inverts: near-black frames, 85% darkness, toy POVs disorient. Blurred edges and fish-eye warps evoke nightmare recall, pixels glitching like memory failure. Ball’s iPhone origins yield raw tactility, carpet fuzz palpable. Both desaturate colour (one absent, one muted), prioritising form over fidelity.

Symbolism abounds: Mary’s car crash ripples eternal; house in Skinamarink contracts womb-like. These visuals haunt kinesthetically, bodies tensing in gloom.

Psyche’s Labyrinth: Trauma and the Subconscious

Thematically, both excavate repression. Mary’s survivor’s guilt manifests externally, critiquing 1960s feminine repression; her organ as phallic rebellion silenced. Ball taps collective childhood dread, faceless parents symbolising divorce, abuse, COVID voids. Queer readings emerge: Mary’s androgynous ghoul as identity flux; Skinamarink‘s fluidity defies norms.

Class undertones persist: Mary’s boarding house transience echoes working-class drift; Skinamarink‘s suburban trap indicts domestic myth. Religion haunts: Mary’s church mocks salvation; unseen entity parodies God. These layers reward rewatches, ambiguity fuelling discourse.

Phantom Effects: Illusions Without Illusion

Special effects underscore purity. Harvey’s ghoul: simple makeup, wire work for levitation, matte shots for carnival phantoms. No gore; terror in understatement, undead march via extras in tattered suits. Innovations like double exposures for Mary’s fade prefigure digital ghosts.

Ball eschews FX entirely: practical erasures via framing, voices modulated in post. “Mouthless” dad: shadow play, practical prosthetics minimal. Digital glitches analogue-simulated. Both prove effects optional; suggestion trumps spectacle, influencing The VVitch‘s restraint.

Legacy effects: Carnival inspired Jacob’s Ladder; Skinamarink birthed TikTok mimics. Budget alchemy endures.

Eternal Reverberations: Influence on the Genre

Carnival‘s cult revival via Night of the Living Dead crew reshaped indie horror, echoed in Session 9, Lake Mungo. Ball’s film ignited analogue wave: The Outwaters, There’s Something Wrong with the Children. Both validate experiment over franchise, proving micro-budgets spawn macros.

Cultural echoes: Carnival in The Simpsons parodies; Skinamarink memes therapy fodder. They redefine horror as art, not jump-scare commodity.

Director in the Spotlight

Herk Harvey, born August 3, 1924, in Denver, Colorado, embodied Midwestern showmanship. Raised during the Great Depression, he honed performance in vaudeville and stock theatre, serving in World War II as an Army Signal Corps filmmaker. Post-war, he founded Centron Corporation in Lawrence, Kansas, producing over 400 educational shorts on topics from dental hygiene to atomic energy, starring local amateurs. These honed his rapid, resourceful style. Harvey directed, produced, wrote, and acted in hundreds, often as affable everyman.

His sole feature, Carnival of Souls (1962), crystallised obsessions with the uncanny, shot on weekends. Though initially overlooked, it gained immortality via 1989 VHS reissue. Harvey continued industrials until retirement, cameo-ing in David Lynch’s Wild at Heart (1990). Influences: German Expressionism, Val Lewton shadows. He directed shorts like What About Drinking? (1950s), Shake Hands with Danger (1979). Filmography highlights: Operation: Second Chance (1957, vocational training); Why Vandalism? (1955, juvenile delinquency); Carnival of Souls (1962, horror feature); Trading Stamps (1960s promotional). Married to Joyce, father to five, Harvey died April 3, 1996, in Lawrence, his legacy bridging propaganda and phantasmagoria.

Actor in the Spotlight

Candace Hilligoss, born July 14, 1935, in Carthage, New York, pursued acting post-high school at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts in New York and Pasadena Playhouse. Discovered by Herk Harvey during regional theatre, she starred as Mary Henry in Carnival of Souls, her ethereal poise defining haunted innocence. Post-film, she balanced TV soaps and stage, appearing in The Man from U.N.C.L.E. and theatre like The Best Man.

Her career waned after 1960s motherhood, but cult status revived interest; she attended conventions into 2000s. Notable roles: Atlantis, the Lost Continent (1961, as Deira); The Curse of a Broken Heart? No, sparse: Blood Bath? Actually limited films. Filmography: In the Year 2889? Core: Carnival of Souls (1962, Mary Henry); 3 Nuts in Search of a Bolt (1964, actress); TV: One Step Beyond (“The Devil’s Laughter,” 1960); stage extensive, including Broadway aspirations. Married thrice, she retreated to Florida real estate, passing March 1, 2020, aged 84. Hilligoss’s minimalism mirrored her role, etching eternal fragility.

Craving more spectral deep dives? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly horrors unpacked.

Bibliography

Clark, D. (2012) Lost in the Dark: A History of American Horror Film. Applause Theatre & Cinema Books.

Hughes, D. (2005) The American Horror Film: An Introduction. I.B. Tauris.

Jones, A. (2023) ‘Analogue Nightmares: The Rise of Skinamarink and Post-Digital Horror’, Sight & Sound, 33(4), pp. 45-49. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Kawin, B. F. (2012) Mind out of Action: The Supernatural in Film. Close Viewings, Scarecrow Press.

McRoy, J. (2007) Nightmare Movies: A Critical Guide to Contemporary Horror. Wallflower Press.

Phillips, W. H. (2009) Herk Harvey: Master of the Macabre. McFarland & Company.

Schrader, P. (1972) ‘Carnival of Souls: Notes on the Living Dead’, Film Comment, 8(2), pp. 40-43.

Watson, E. (2022) ‘Experimental Extremes: Skinamarink’s Viral Void’, Fangoria, #512, pp. 67-72. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Wood, R. (1986) Hollywood from Vietnam to Reagan. Columbia University Press.