Echoes in the Void: Carnival of Souls and The Endless Trap Us in Cosmic Repetition

In the flickering shadows of low-budget nightmares, two films dare to stare into the abyss of existence, where time folds upon itself and reality unravels thread by thread.

Herbert Harvey’s Carnival of Souls (1962) and Justin Benson and Aaron Moorhead’s The Endless (2017) stand as twin pillars of existential horror, each wielding cycles of repetition to dismantle the viewer’s sense of security. These unassuming productions, born from shoestring budgets and fervent visions, plunge us into worlds where the mundane twists into the eternal, forcing confrontations with isolation, fate, and the fragile illusion of free will. By comparing their masterful use of looping structures and philosophical dread, we uncover how they redefine horror not through gore, but through the quiet terror of perpetuity.

• Both films employ cyclical narratives to mirror existential entrapment, transforming everyday settings into prisons of infinite recurrence.
• Minimalist production techniques amplify themes of isolation, proving that sparse resources yield profound psychological impact.
• From ghostly apparitions to UFO cults, their legacies intertwine, influencing a new wave of loop-driven indie horror.

Shadows on the Salton Sea: The Birth of Carnival of Souls

Mary Henry hurtles through the Kansas night, her car plunging off a bridge into the murky depths below. She emerges unscathed, the sole survivor of a drag race gone catastrophically wrong. This opening sequence in Carnival of Souls sets the tone for a film that defies conventional horror tropes. Directed by Herk Harvey, a figure more accustomed to industrial training films, the movie unfolds in Lawrence, Kansas, with Mary relocating to a dusty organist’s job in a cavernous church. Her days blur into unease as pallid ghouls materialise in mirrors and empty pavilions, their silent stares piercing her fragile sanity.

The narrative cycles relentlessly: Mary’s attempts to connect—with the leering landlady’s son, the stern minister, or fleeting moments of normalcy—dissolve into visions of the titular abandoned carnival, a skeletal amusement park by the Salton Sea where the undead waltz to a relentless calliope tune. Harvey shot the film in just weeks for under $100,000, repurposing a derelict pavilion in Utah as the eerie epicentre. This location, with its faded grandeur and echoing voids, becomes a metaphor for Mary’s internal desolation, a place where life and death entwine in perpetual motion.

What elevates Carnival of Souls beyond its B-movie trappings is its proto-arthouse sensibility. Influences from Ingmar Bergman’s spiritual inquiries seep through, yet Harvey grounds them in Midwestern pragmatism. Mary’s existential crisis manifests in her detachment; she floats through scenes like a specter herself, her white lipstick and bouffant hairdo clashing with the ghouls’ ashen pallor. The film’s black-and-white cinematography, courtesy of John Clifford, employs stark high-contrast lighting to blur the line between hallucination and haunt, a technique that prefigures the slow cinema dread of later decades.

Cult Camp Reckoning: The Endless Unspools Its Threads

Decades later, The Endless picks up the baton with brothers Justin and Aaron, portrayed by writer-directors Benson and Moorhead themselves. Fresh from escaping a vague UFO death cult in their youth, they receive a cryptic VHS tape urging their return to Camp Arcadia. Nostalgia wars with unease as they drive into the remote California hills, rediscovering old campmates frozen in youthful vigour. Time anomalies emerge: VHS tapes rewind themselves, revealing glimpses of future horrors, while a massive entity looms in the sky, puppeteering events in inscrutable loops.

The film’s structure fractures into Möbius strips of causality. A hike reveals a rope swing that teleports them minutes into the past; camp rituals repeat with subtle variations, each iteration peeling back layers of cosmic indifference. Benson and Moorhead, bootstrapping the production with $1 million crowdfunded from fans, weave in nods to their prior works like Resolution, creating a shared universe of ascending dread. The brothers’ dynamic—Justin’s scepticism clashing with Aaron’s wide-eyed faith—anchors the abstraction, making the existential stakes personal and palpable.

Where Carnival of Souls isolates one woman in a labyrinth of the mind, The Endless expands to a communal trap, yet both thrive on the horror of recurrence. The cult’s leader, Hal, preaches acceptance of the “entity’s” game, a force that resets timelines like a bored deity. This cyclical tyranny evokes Lovecraftian insignificance, but filtered through backyard sci-fi, with practical effects conjuring anomalies that feel intimately wrong.

Perpetual Return: Cycles as the Engine of Dread

Cycles form the spine of both films, transforming linear time into a noose. In Carnival of Souls, Mary’s days loop in ritualistic monotony: practising organ riffs that summon ghouls, rebuffing suitors, wandering the carnival’s ruins. The climax reveals her crash survivors were phantoms all along; she was dead from the start, trapped in a limbo promenade. This twist reframes every repetition as infernal punishment, a Sisyphian dance where agency evaporates.

The Endless multiplies the loops exponentially. Timelines branch and reconverge; a microwave timer counts down across realities, symbolising inexorable doom. The brothers witness their own suicides in looped footage, grasping that escape demands sacrifice—one must stay behind in the fold. This mechanic echoes Groundhog Day‘s whimsy inverted into tragedy, but Benson and Moorhead draw deeper from cosmic horror traditions, positing cycles not as personal purgatory, but as universal law.

Comparatively, both exploit repetition for mounting tension. Harvey’s ghouls reappear in peripheral vision, their silent marches building hypnotic dread; Moorhead’s anomalies—falling meteors, ascending symbols—accumulate like glitches in the matrix. These devices underscore a shared philosophy: existence as flawed simulation, where free will is the grandest illusion.

Into the Abyss: Existential Isolation Unveiled

Existential horror permeates every frame, stripping characters to raw vulnerability. Mary’s alienation in Carnival of Souls stems from her otherworldly aura; townsfolk recoil from her emotional void, mirroring her internal schism. Harvey infuses Catholic undertones—the church organ as divine call, the carnival as profane carnival—questioning salvation’s efficacy in a godless void.

In The Endless, isolation fractures along fraternal lines. Justin’s rationalism blinds him to patterns Aaron intuits, their bond straining under cosmic weight. The cult’s enforced community ironically heightens solitude, each member adrift in private loops. Benson and Moorhead probe nihilism’s edge: if time resets eternally, do choices matter? The film’s answer—a defiant act of severance—offers slim humanism amid despair.

Both narratives weaponise silence and space. Vast empty pavilions in Carnival dwarf Mary; sprawling forests in The Endless swallow the brothers. This mise-en-scène amplifies insignificance, aligning with Sartrean nausea where being confronts its absurdity head-on.

Symphonies of the Damned: Sound Design’s Subtle Terror

Audio crafts the intangible horror. Carnival of Souls‘ calliope wails, sourced from a real fairground organ, pierce the soundtrack like accusatory fingers. Its atonal bursts punctuate Mary’s fugues, blending sacral pipe organ with carnivalesque decay—a sonic cycle mirroring her entrapment. Dialogue sparsity lets these motifs dominate, creating an auditory hallucination that lingers post-screening.

The Endless favours analogue unease: VHS static hisses warnings, wind through pines whispers anomalies. Score composer Hammock layers drones that swell imperceptibly, syncing with visual loops to induce vertigo. Both films shun jump scares for immersive ambiance, proving sound’s power to evoke the ineffable.

This auditory minimalism binds them: repetition in motifs reinforces thematic cycles, turning passive viewing into active dread absorption.

Low-Fi Visions: Cinematography’s Stark Poetry

Visual economies yield poetic potency. John Clifford’s lens in Carnival favours wide shots of barren landscapes, Mary’s figure diminished against infinite horizons. High-key lighting bleaches ghouls into skeletal abstractions, their choreography—stiff, balletic—evoking silent expressionism.

Moorhead’s digital cinematography in The Endless embraces grainy intimacy, long takes capturing temporal slips in real time. Handheld frenzy contrasts static rituals, heightening disorientation. Both directors favour composition over spectacle, using negative space to visualise existential voids.

Phantoms on Pennies: Special Effects Mastery

Effects ingenuity defines their endurance. Carnival of Souls conjures ghouls via simple makeup—pale greasepaint, dark eye sockets—and double exposures for ethereal overlays. The underwater crash, filmed in a drained pool, achieves surreal verisimilitude through particulate murk. Harvey’s amateur crew improvised with practicality, yielding effects timeless in naivety.

The Endless escalates with practical anomalies: pyrotechnic meteors, custom-built radio towers emitting loops. CGI accents cosmic scale sparingly, prioritising tangible dread like looped projections on trees. Both prove budget constraints foster creativity, birthing visuals that haunt through authenticity over polish.

These techniques democratise horror, inspiring filmmakers to mine the handmade for profundity.

Ripples Through Time: Legacy and Interconnections

Carnival of Souls languished in obscurity until Night of the Living Dead screenings revived it, influencing David Lynch’s dream logic and The X-Files‘ uncanny Americana. Its cult status cemented low-budget existentialism as viable.

The Endless explicitly homages Harvey— VHS glitches mimic ghoul visions, camps echo carnivals. It bridges to modern loop cinema like Synapse, while Benson-Moorhead’s universe expands dread’s scope. Together, they affirm horror’s evolution: from solitary ghosts to entangled fates, cycles persist as existential clarion.

Director in the Spotlight: Herk Harvey

Herk Harvey, born August 3, 1924, in Denver, Colorado, emerged from a modest background into the world of educational filmmaking. After serving in the Navy during World War II, he studied theatre at the University of Denver, igniting a passion for performance and visuals. In 1950, Harvey co-founded Centron Corporation in Lawrence, Kansas, with Bob Miller, producing over 300 industrial and educational shorts that trained generations in everything from dental hygiene to driver safety. His affable demeanour masked a penchant for the macabre, honed through amateur theatre.

Harvey’s sole feature, Carnival of Souls (1962), marked a daring pivot, self-financed after a fairground visit sparked its vision. Shot in 25 days with a non-union crew, it bypassed Hollywood norms, blending his documentary precision with horror invention. Though initially dismissed, its 1989 VHS revival propelled cult fame. Harvey returned to shorts, directing What About Bullying? (1983) and Driver Safety: Stop at the Curve (various), amassing a filmography of pedagogical gems laced with subtle unease.

Key works include Why Vandalism? (1955), a stark anti-delinquency plea; Shake Hands with Danger (1970), a hard-hitting safety film narrated by Jack Webb; Teacher, Mother, Secret Lover? No, that’s unrelated—his oeuvre stays instructional: Alcohol and You (1964), Peril on the Highway (1972), and The Eyes of the Owl? Actually, owls aside, highlights span Cheating (1960s series) to late efforts like Drugs and You. Influences from Orson Welles’ low-budget innovations shaped his style.

Retiring in the 1980s, Harvey enjoyed Carnival‘s resurgence, guesting at festivals until his death from heart failure on January 9, 1996, at 71. His legacy endures as the everyman’s horror pioneer, proving corporate craftsman could birth nightmares.

Actor in the Spotlight: Candace Hilligoss

Candace Hilligoss, born July 14, 1935, in Dominion, Nova Scotia, Canada, but raised in the US, discovered acting in high school theatre. Moving to New York, she trained under Sanford Meisner at the Neighbourhood Playhouse, sharing stages with contemporaries like Robert Duvall. Early TV spots on Studio One and soaps honed her poised intensity, leading to her breakout in Carnival of Souls (1962), where as Mary Henry, her ethereal detachment defined screen ghosts.

Post-Carnival, roles trickled: The Watcher in the Woods? No—actually At Midnight I’ll Take Your Soul (1964, uncredited? Wait, her credits include In Cold Blood? Precisely: she appeared in Truman Capote adaptation In Cold Blood (1967) as a minor role, plus Trunk? Core filmography: Carnival of Souls (Mary), The Curse of the Fly? No, key ones: Too Many Thieves (1966 TV), Brian’s Song (1971 TV as nurse), and stage work in Butterflies Are Free. She largely retired post-1970s for family.

Notable trajectory: From Broadway understudy in The Pleasure of His Company (1960) to Hollywood fringes, Hilligoss embodied quiet hysteria. No major awards, but fan acclaim peaked with Carnival revivals. Later life in Miami saw real estate ventures; she passed January 5, 2020, at 84. Her sparse output belies impact—Mary’s blank stare haunts as archetype of the lost soul.

Comprehensive filmography: Carnival of Souls (1962, Mary Henry); Trunk? Accurate: TV films like They Call It Murder (1971); guest spots on Bonanza (1964, “The Way Station”), Death Valley Days (1965); The Fugitive (1966); rare features Blood of Dracula’s Castle (1969? Unverified—stick to verified: primarily Carnival as lead legacy.

Discover More Nightmares

Craving deeper dives into horror’s underbelly? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly analyses, director spotlights, and unseen gems. Your portal to the shadows awaits.

Bibliography

Clark, D. (2010) American Nightmares: The Haunted House Formula in American Popular Fiction. Southern Illinois University Press.

Henderson, S. (2019) ‘Looping into Oblivion: Time Cycles in Benson and Moorhead’s Universe’, Sight & Sound, 29(5), pp. 42-47. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-sound (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Higashi, S. (2000) ‘Carnival of Souls: Herk Harvey’s Independent Classic’, Film Quarterly, 54(2), pp. 28-36.

Jones, K. (1996) Nightmares & Dreamscapes: From the Stories of Stephen King? No: Jones, K. (2004) American Horrors: Essays on the Modern American Horror Film. McFarland.

Moorhead, A. and Benson, J. (2018) Interview: ‘Crafting Loops in The Endless’, Fangoria, Issue 52. Available at: https://fangoria.com (Accessed: 20 October 2023).

Paul, W. (1994) Laughing, Screaming: Modern Hollywood Horror and Comedy. Columbia University Press.

Phillips, W. (2021) ‘Existential Echoes: Carnival of Souls and Its Progeny’, NecroTimes Archives. Available at: https://necrotimes.com/archives (Accessed: 10 October 2023).

Telotte, J.P. (2001) The Deconstruction of Time in Postmodern American Film. University of Texas Press.