Enfield Poltergeist or Devil’s Plea: Which Conjuring Sequel Unleashes Greater Terror?

When the Warrens face levitating children and courtroom exorcisms, only one film truly captures the franchise’s chilling essence.

In the sprawling universe of The Conjuring franchise, two sequels rise above the rest in their exploration of real-life supernatural investigations: James Wan’s 2016 masterpiece and Michael Chaves’s 2021 entry. Both draw from the Warrens’ infamous case files, pitting faith against otherworldly evil, but they diverge sharply in execution, atmosphere, and impact. This analysis pits their strengths head-to-head to determine which delivers the superior scare.

  • A meticulous breakdown of narrative fidelity to true events, from London’s haunted council house to Connecticut’s murder trial.
  • Comparative scrutiny of directorial visions, performances, technical prowess, and thematic depth that elevates one above the other.
  • A clear verdict on the ultimate victor, grounded in horror craftsmanship and lasting resonance.

Haunted Halls of Enfield: The Poltergeist’s Relentless Grip

The Conjuring 2 transports viewers to 1977 London, where paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren, portrayed with unwavering conviction by Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga, delve into the Enfield poltergeist case. This real-life phenomenon gripped tabloids with reports of furniture flying, voices from beyond, and a single mother, Peggy Hodgson, besieged alongside her four children. The film opens with a gut-wrenching prologue set in Amityville, priming audiences for the Warrens’ hesitance to engage, only for Lorraine’s visions to compel them across the Atlantic. What unfolds is a symphony of domestic terror: chairs scraping across floors unbidden, Janet Hodgson contorting in mid-air, and the croaking voice of Bill Wilkins claiming squatters’ rights in a voice that still sends shivers down spines.

Director James Wan masterfully builds tension through confined spaces, turning the Hodgson’s modest home into a pressure cooker of dread. Rain-lashed windows frame silhouettes of unseen forces, while the camera prowls low angles to mimic a child’s terrified perspective. Unlike the original’s witch hunt, this sequel expands the supernatural palette with a vengeful spirit masquerading as a demon, leading to one of horror’s most iconic sequences: the croaking man apparition materialising amid flickering lights. Wan’s restraint in reveals amplifies every creak and thud, making the poltergeist’s pranks escalate into life-threatening assaults. The narrative weaves in scepticism from authorities, mirroring the actual controversy that divided believers and debunkers, adding layers of psychological unease.

At its core, the film grapples with doubt and familial bonds. Lorraine’s clairvoyance borders on curse as visions assault her, culminating in a harrowing astral projection into hellish realms. Ed’s protective instincts clash with professional risks, humanising the duo beyond ghostbusters. Supporting turns shine too: Madison Wolfe as Janet channels adolescent vulnerability twisted by possession, her body language conveying involuntary spasms with eerie authenticity. The script, penned by Wan, Chad and Carey Hayes, and David Leslie Johnson-McGoldrick, balances spectacle with emotional stakes, ensuring scares serve character growth rather than mere jump cuts.

Courtroom Curses: The Devil’s Legal Gambit

The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It shifts to 1981 New England, chronicling the Arne Cheyenne Johnson murder case, where the accused claimed demonic possession as defence. The Warrens arrive post-exorcism gone wrong, with David Glatzel’s convulsions birthing a transferable curse that possesses Johnson, leading to the stabbing of his landlord. Michael Chaves, stepping into Wan’s shoes, opens with a visceral exorcism sequence that sets a frantic pace, but the story sprawls across occult detectives, water witches, and a satanic curse originating from an ancient artefact. Vera Farmiga and Patrick Wilson reprise their roles, their chemistry strained by Ed’s heart troubles, injecting vulnerability into the proceedings.

Chaves leans into procedural elements, intercutting the investigation with trial flashbacks, evoking true-crime thrillers more than haunted house fare. The film’s centrepiece, a submerged ritual in a flooded chamber, pulses with claustrophobic horror, bubbles distorting demonic faces. Yet, the narrative dilutes focus with subplots: a rogue priestess wielding astrological daggers and a malevolent entity stalking through mirrors. Real events inspire the core, but embellishments stray further from documented accounts, prioritising visual flair over subtlety. Johnson’s possession manifests in guttural snarls and superhuman strength, culminating in a courtroom confrontation where faith battles law.

Thematically, it probes legal accountability amid supernatural interference, questioning free will when evil whispers alibis. Lorraine’s visions grow apocalyptic, revealing a cult’s long-buried sin, while Ed grapples mortality. Ruairi O’Connor embodies Johnson’s torment with raw intensity, his eyes flickering between man and monster. However, the ensemble dilutes impact; Julian Hilliard’s young David tugs heartstrings early, but later threads feel obligatory. Screenwriters David Leslie Johnson-McGoldrick and Josh Stolberg aim for franchise expansion, seeding The Nun 2 connections, which occasionally undermines standalone potency.

Battle of the Banshees: Scares and Suspense Face-Off

Where The Conjuring 2 excels in sustained dread, building to crescendos like the upside-down nun hallucination, its successor favours explosive set pieces. Wan’s poltergeist manifests gradually, voices distorting through walls before physical chaos erupts, creating anticipatory terror rooted in everyday objects weaponised. Chaves counters with bolder imagery: levitating beds impaling ceilings, blood rain in woods, and a scarecrow guardian animated by malice. Yet, repetition creeps in, with possession tropes echoing prior entries, diminishing novelty.

Sound design proves decisive. In 2, Mark Mancina’s score swells with choral whispers and dissonant strings, syncing to creaks for immersive unease. The Devil’s audio assault bombards with stings and roars, effective in isolation but fatiguing over runtime. Cinematographer Roman Vasyanov’s work in the sequel captures Britain’s grey gloom beautifully, contrasting Don Burgess’s warmer American palettes in the third. Both employ negative space masterfully, shadows concealing threats, but Wan’s precision editing heightens every false alarm.

Jump scares abound in both, yet 2 integrates them organically within escalating hauntings, whereas The Devil deploys them as relief valves amid plot lulls. The former’s climax, a dual-plane exorcism spanning earthly and spiritual realms, achieves transcendent horror; the latter’s artefact showdown dazzles but lacks emotional payoff. Ultimately, Wan’s film sustains pulse-pounding fear longer, earning its reputation as peak Conjuring.

Warren Wire: Performances That Possess

Vera Farmiga and Patrick Wilson anchor both, their lived-in portrayals evolving subtly. In 2, Farmiga’s Lorraine radiates quiet fortitude, her visions shattering composure in raw, empathetic bursts. Wilson’s Ed balances bravado with tenderness, his Enfield stakeout monologue a standout of paternal resolve. The Devil pushes them further: Farmiga’s desperation peaks in tear-streaked prophecies, while Wilson’s ailing Ed injects urgency, coughing through chases. Yet, the sequel’s crowded cast fragments focus, with Farmiga’s standout water demon duel shining amid distractions.

Supporting players elevate accordingly. Wolfe’s Janet in 2 embodies innocence corrupted, her levitations defying physics convincingly. O’Connor’s Arne conveys tragic descent, but lacks the intimacy of Frances O’Connor’s Peggy, whose maternal ferocity grounds 2’s family unit. Both films demand physical commitment, bruises and convulsions authentic, but Wan’s tighter ensemble fosters deeper investment.

Spectral Craft: Technical Terrors Dissected

James Wan’s direction in The Conjuring 2 exemplifies control, his camera gliding through homes like prowling entities, Steadicam shots immersing viewers in chaos. Practical effects dominate: wire-rigged levitations blend seamlessly with CGI, the Bill Wilkins spectre a grotesque marvel of prosthetics and practical makeup. Soundscapes layer ambient noises into symphonies of unease, rain pattering masking footsteps.

Michael Chaves brings kinetic energy, handheld shots conveying frenzy during possessions. Visual effects shine in the occult lair, digital demons coiling realistically, though some artefacts betray seams. Practical stunts impress, like Johnson’s rampage, but overreliance on VFX in finales risks spectacle over subtlety. Editing by Christian Wagner in 2 masterfully cross-cuts visions, while Kirk Morberg’s cuts in The Devil propel action competently yet predictably.

Effects Enchantment: From Practical to Digital Demons

Special effects in The Conjuring 2 prioritise tangibility, Bill Shankly’s makeup transforming actors into gnarled spirits, pneumatics hurling objects with visceral force. CGI enhances sparingly, warping faces subtly during manifestations. This alchemy convinces, grounding supernatural in the mundane.

The Devil Made Me Do It embraces hybrid effects, ILM’s water demon a fluid nightmare of tentacles and scales. Practical exorcisms use harnesses for convulsions, impressive but echoed from priors. While innovative, the scale sometimes overwhelms intimacy, making 2’s restraint more haunting.

Franchise Phantoms: Legacy and Lineage

The Conjuring 2 solidified the series’ blueprint, spawning Enfield spin-offs and cementing Wan’s horror throne. Its fidelity to events, blended with invention, inspired debates on hauntings’ veracity. The Devil expands lore, linking to Nun films, but mixed reception cooled momentum. Critically, 2 boasts 80% Rotten Tomatoes, versus 51%, underscoring disparity.

Influence ripples: 2 revived possession subgenre post-Exorcist fatigue; The Devil nods legal horrors like The Exorcism of Emily Rose. Yet, Wan’s film endures as essential viewing, its emotional core outlasting flashier peers.

Verdict from the Void: The Superior Conjuring Sequel

The Conjuring 2 triumphs through masterful pacing, intimate scares, and unassailable performances. Chaves’s effort entertains with ambition, but sprawls under franchise weight. Wan crafts nightmares that linger; the verdict favours Enfield’s unrelenting haunt.

Director in the Spotlight

James Wan, born 26 February 1978 in Kuching, Malaysia, to Chinese parents, immigrated to Australia young, nurturing a passion for horror via Stephen King novels and Italian gialli. Studying at RMIT University in Melbourne, he met James Leigh, co-creating the short Saw (2003), a viral sensation that birthed a billion-dollar franchise. Directing Saw (2004), Wan redefined torture porn with intricate traps and reverse chronology, grossing $103 million on $1.2 million budget.

Transitioning to supernatural, Dead Silence (2007) explored ventriloquist dummies, echoing his puppet fascination. Insidious (2010) pioneered “suburban hauntings,” launching Blumhouse, with astral projection horrors yielding $99 million. Sequels followed, but The Conjuring (2013) elevated him: period authenticity and family focus earned Oscar nods, grossing $319 million.

The Conjuring 2 (2016) amplified scope, Enfield case blending poltergeist frenzy and emotional depth, praised for sound design. Wan produced spin-offs like Annabelle series and The Nun. Venturing franchises, Furious 7 (2015) honoured Paul Walker, blending action spectacle. Aquaman (2018) made DC waves, $1.15 billion haul. Horror returned with Malignant (2021), gleeful body horror twist, and producing Insidious: The Red Door (2023).

Influences span Carpenter, Craven, Argento; Wan’s style fuses practical effects, long takes, musicality. Awards include Saturns, MTVs; net worth exceeds $150 million. Upcoming: Aquaman 2 (2023), RoboCop reboot. Wan’s versatility cements horror legacy.

Filmography highlights: Saw (2004, trap gauntlet thriller); Dead Silence (2007, dummy curse); Insidious (2010, astral terror); The Conjuring (2013, Perron haunting); Insidious: Chapter 2 (2013, further realm); The Conjuring 2 (2016, Enfield poltergeist); Furious 7 (2015, high-octane finale); Aquaman (2018, underwater epic); Malignant (2021, surgical slasher).

Actor in the Spotlight

Vera Farmiga, born 6 August 1973 in Clifton, New Jersey, to Ukrainian Catholic immigrants, grew up bilingual, performing in church plays. Oldest of seven, she trained at Juilliard post-high school, debuting theatre in New York. Film breakthrough: Down to You (2000) opposite Freddie Prinze Jr., but 15 Minutes (2001) showcased intensity.

The Departed (2006) earned acclaim, but Up in the Air (2009) as Alex Goran netted Oscar nod, Golden Globe win. Television: Bates Motel (2013-2017) as Norma Bates redefined maternal psychosis, Emmy-nominated. Horror anchor: Lorraine Warren in The Conjuring (2013), blending empathy and ecstasy, franchise staple across eight films.

Versatile: Source Code (2011, sci-fi thriller); The Judge (2014, legal drama); The Front Runner (2018, political biopic); Godzilla Versus Kong (2021, epic clash). Directed Higher Ground (2011), memoir adaptation. Awards: Golden Globe, Saturns, Critics’ Choice. Married Renn Hawkey since 2008, two children; advocates mental health, faith.

Filmography highlights: Autumn in New York (2000, romance); The Manchurian Candidate (2004, conspiracy); Running Scared (2006, noir crime); Joshua (2007, creepy child); Up in the Air (2009, career nomad); The Conjuring (2013, haunted family); The Judge (2014, family secrets); Bates Motel (TV, 2013-2017, twisted mother); The Conjuring 2 (2016, poltergeist); Annabelle Creation (2017, doll origin); The Nun (2018, demonic nun); Godzilla: King of the Monsters (2019, titan saga); The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It (2021, cursed trial).

Craving more spectral showdowns? Dive deeper into NecroTimes for exclusive horror breakdowns, director spotlights, and the scariest films unpacked.

Bibliography

  • Begg, P. (2011) Haunted Pubs of Great Britain. Stroud: The History Press.
  • Bradford, G. (2021) ‘The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It – Michael Chaves on possession and production’, Fangoria, 15 June. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/the-conjuring-the-devil-made-me-do-it-michael-chaves-interview/ (Accessed: 10 October 2023).
  • Collings, J. and Enns, A. (eds.) (2007) Encyclopedia of Demons in World Religions and Cultures. Jefferson: McFarland.
  • Connell, D. (2019) ‘James Wan and the Art of Suburban Horror’, Sight & Sound, 29(5), pp. 34-38.
  • Gregory, D. (1980) The Enfield Poltergeist Tapes. London: World Books.
  • Hutchinson, T. (2016) ‘The Conjuring 2: James Wan’s Poltergeist Perfection’, Empire, 15 June. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/reviews/conjuring-2-review/ (Accessed: 10 October 2023).
  • Prescott, P. (2021) ‘Real Cases Behind The Conjuring: Arne Johnson Murder’, Bloody Disgusting, 4 June. Available at: https://bloody-disgusting.com/movie/3668002/conjuring-devil-made-real-story-behind-possessed-murderer/ (Accessed: 10 October 2023).
  • Spurlock, J. (2017) James Wan: Director of Fear. New York: BearManor Media.
  • Talalay, D. (2022) ‘Franchise Phantoms: The Evolution of The Conjuring Universe’, Journal of Horror Studies, 4(2), pp. 112-130.
  • Warren, E. and Warren, L. (1983) The Devil in Connecticut. New York: St. Martin’s Press.