Flaying the Facade: A Body Horror Dialogue Between Eyes Without a Face and Raw

In the shadowed corridors of French cinema, two films strip away the skin to reveal the raw terror of transformation and desire.

 

Georges Franju’s Eyes Without a Face (1960) and Julia Ducournau’s Raw (2016) stand as twin pillars of body horror, each peeling back layers of flesh to expose the fragility of identity. Decades apart yet bound by a visceral fascination with the mutable human form, these films confront viewers with the grotesque beauty of bodily violation. Franju’s poetic surgical nightmare dialogues hauntingly with Ducournau’s carnal coming-of-age frenzy, inviting a comparative gaze that uncovers shared obsessions with consumption, femininity, and the monstrous within.

 

• Both films centre on young women whose bodies become battlegrounds for forbidden hungers, transforming personal trauma into universal dread.
• Franju employs clinical detachment and surreal elegance, while Ducournau unleashes primal, sensory chaos, highlighting evolutions in body horror aesthetics.
• Their legacies ripple through modern cinema, influencing a lineage of films that equate physical alteration with psychological rupture.

 

Surgical Shadows: The Ethereal Dread of Eyes Without a Face

Franju’s masterpiece unfolds in a sterile Parisian laboratory where Dr. Génessier, a renowned surgeon played with chilling precision by Pierre Brice, labours to restore his daughter Christiane’s face, ravaged in a car accident he caused. Christiane, portrayed by the luminous Edith Scob, wanders the opulent family estate masked in an uncanny plaster visage that conceals her scarred reality. Her father’s illicit quest leads him to kidnap young women, whose faces he harvests in midnight operations, only for the grafts to reject in festering failure. The narrative builds through a series of abductions, executed by his devoted assistant Louise, a Haitian woman marked by her own facial disfigurement, blending colonial undertones with gothic melodrama.

The film’s power resides in its restraint. Franju, drawing from the 1959 novel by Jean Redon, crafts a tone of balletic horror, where the infamous face-transplant scene—lit by harsh surgical lamps and accompanied by a scalpel’s whisper—transcends gore into something operatic. Christiane’s mask, a blank porcelain shell evoking mannequins and ghosts, symbolises the erasure of self, a motif Franju amplifies through her caged doves, mirroring her own imprisonment. As pigeons flutter against bars, her eyes plead through the void, a silent indictment of paternal hubris.

Production whispers add layers: shot in just three weeks on a shoestring budget, Eyes Without a Face initially shocked audiences at its Venice premiere, prompting walkouts before critics hailed its artistry. Banned in Britain until 1965, it navigated censorship by veiling explicitness in poetry, a tactic Franju honed from his documentary roots, including the unflinching Blood of the Beasts (1949), which juxtaposed slaughterhouse realities with human vanity.

Carnal Awakening: The Feverish Pulse of Raw

Ducournau’s debut catapults us into the brutal hazing rituals of a veterinary school, where Justine, a timid freshman raised vegetarian by her family, endures a rite involving raw rabbit kidney. Garance Marillier’s riveting portrayal captures Justine’s descent as this forbidden meat awakens an insatiable cannibalistic urge. Her body rebels in grotesque eruptions—rashes, bleeding gums, hallucinatory visions—culminating in acts of flesh-devouring that strain sisterly bonds with the rebellious Alexia and unearth buried family secrets.

The plot accelerates through Justine’s physical metamorphosis: fingers gnawed to bone, lips torn in frenzied bites, all rendered with unflinching intimacy. Ducournau, a veterinary pathology student herself, infuses authenticity into the film’s corporeal focus, where bodily fluids and textures dominate the screen. A pivotal party sequence, drenched in strobe lights and sweat, escalates into auto-cannibalism, blending eroticism with revulsion as Justine licks her own wounds.

Filmed in Belgium with a young cast, Raw premiered at Toronto in 2016 amid fainting spectators, its Sundance buzz propelled by word-of-mouth tales of nausea. Ducournau scripted it as a metaphor for adolescent appetites, drawing from her film school experiences where peer pressure mirrored the school’s savagery. The film’s feminist edge sharpens through Justine’s empowerment via monstrosity, subverting virgin/whore dichotomies prevalent in earlier horror.

Identity’s Bloody Canvas: Femininity Under the Knife

Central to both films is the female body as site of violation and rebirth. Christiane’s pursuit of wholeness through transplantation interrogates beauty standards, her masked existence a critique of societal facades where women are valued for surfaces. Franju’s Christiane embodies passive victimhood, her agency flickering only in fleeting rebellions like freeing the birds, underscoring mid-century constraints on female autonomy.

Justine, conversely, seizes monstrosity as liberation. Her cannibalism evolves from imposed ritual to chosen indulgence, a devouring of patriarchal norms—family hypocrisy, institutional bullying—through literal consumption. Where Christiane’s horror is imposed externally by fatherly science, Justine’s blooms internally, a hormonal insurrection that Ducournau likens to puberty’s chaos.

This contrast illuminates body horror’s gender politics. Franju’s film, rooted in post-war France’s medical ethics debates post-Nuremberg, reflects anxieties over scientific overreach and feminine fragility. Ducournau’s, amid #MeToo precursors, weaponises the body against oppression, her protagonist’s scars becoming badges of defiance rather than shame.

Visceral Techniques: From Scalpel to Sinew

Franju’s effects pioneer subtlety over spectacle. The transplant sequence, achieved with practical prosthetics and clever editing, avoids bloodletting; instead, a dog’s howl substitutes for screams, heightening unease through suggestion. Cinematographer Eugen Schüfftan’s chiaroscuro bathes the chateau in milky fogs, aligning the film with poetic realism traditions of Cocteau.

Ducournau favours immersion. Practical makeup by Parisian artists Pierre-Olivier Persin crafts Justine’s peeling skin and protruding bones, while Jim Williams’ throbbing score syncs with flesh-ripping sounds. A leg-shaving scene escalates into abrasion horror, close-ups privileging texture—goosebumps, razor nicks—evoking Cronenberg’s somatic obsessions yet infused with Ducournau’s fleshy eroticism.

Both eschew CGI, grounding terror in the tangible. Franju’s restraint influenced The Skin I Live In (Almodóvar, 2011), while Raw‘s boldness echoes Titane (Ducournau, 2021), her follow-up amplifying automotive body horror.

Consumption as Communion: Hunger’s Monstrous Metaphor

Dining motifs unite the duo. Christiane’s doves symbolise purity devoured by necessity, paralleling the kidnapped women’s fates. Génessier’s feasts amid failure underscore hubris, his calm dissecting hands a perversion of nourishment.

Raw literalises appetite. Justine’s kidney sparks a chain: finger-nibbling, sibling feasts, climaxing in familial reckoning. Cannibalism here metabolises repression—vegetarianism as denial—into explosive authenticity, Ducournau framing it as queer awakening, with Justine-Alexia tensions pulsing erotically.

This shared devouring critiques inheritance: Christiane inherits disfigurement from paternal guilt, Justine cannibalistic traits from kin. Both posit the body as archive of generational sins, horror arising when suppressed urges surface.

Legacy’s Lingering Scars: Echoes in Extremes

Eyes Without a Face birthed the face-transplant subgenre, inspiring Jess Franco’s lurid riffs and Pedro Almodóvar’s surgical obsessions. Its influence permeates The Face of Another (Abe, 1966), exploring masked psyches.

Raw ignited female-led body horror renaissance, paving for Relic (Shortland, 2020) familial decays. Ducournau’s Palme d’Or for Titane cements her vanguard status.

Together, they bookend French extremity cinema, from nouvelle vague peripheries to post-millennial provocations, proving body horror’s endurance in probing selfhood.

Production hurdles enrich lore: Franju battled producers over tone, excising gore; Ducournau managed set vomits with ginger ale remedies, her commitment yielding authenticity.

Director in the Spotlight: Georges Franju

Georges Franju, born in 1912 in Fougères, France, emerged from a provincial Catholic upbringing to co-found the avant-garde Cinepan club in 1935 with Henri Langlois, precursor to Cinematheque Française. Rejecting narrative cinema initially, he honed documentary craft, his 1949 Blood of the Beasts shocking with abattoir footage juxtaposed against suburban banality, establishing his eye for horror in the mundane. Influences spanned Méliès’ fantasy, Soviet montage, and surrealists like Buñuel, whom he assisted early.

Transitioning to features, Franju directed The Sin of Father Mouret (1950), adapting Zola with ethereal visuals. Eyes Without a Face (1960) marked his horror pinnacle, blending poetry and revulsion. Subsequent works included Judex (1963), a Feuillade homage, and Thomas l’imposteur (1965), literary adaptations showcasing stylistic rigour.

Later career embraced television and shorts, with Nuits rouges (1974) reviving Judex in thriller mode. Franju’s oeuvre, spanning 20 features and dozens of shorts, championed marginalised voices, critiquing modernity’s dehumanisation. Knighted in arts, he died in 1987, legacy enduring via restored prints and scholarly reverence for his fusion of beauty and brutality.

Filmography highlights: Le Sang des bêtes (1949, documentary on slaughter); The Keepers of the Night (1953, poetic crime); Eyes Without a Face (1960, body horror landmark); Judex (1963, serial homage); Shadowman (1971, animation hybrid); Nuits rouges (1974, mystery thriller).

Actor in the Spotlight: Edith Scob

Edith Scob, born Édith Jacqueline in 1937 Paris, trained at prestigious Conservatoire National Supérieur d’Art Dramatique, debuting onstage before cinema claimed her. Discovered by Franju at 17, her masked role in Eyes Without a Face (1960) etched an iconic image, her expressive gaze conveying volumes through porcelain impassivity. Post-film, she navigated theatre, voicing characters in animations while selective in screen roles.

Reuniting with Franju in Thérèse Desqueyroux (1962), Scob’s career bloomed in art-house: Louis Malle’s Vive la sociale! (1983), Raul Ruiz’s labyrinthine L’hypothèse du tableau volé (1978). International acclaim arrived with The Lovers on the Bridge (1991), her luminous beggar captivating alongside Juliette Binoche.

Later triumphs included David Cronenberg’s Videodrome (1983) cameo and Holy Motors (2012), Leos Carax’s surreal odyssey showcasing her chameleon versatility. Awards accrued: César nominations, Venice honours. Scob embodied quiet intensity, influences from Bette Davis to silent divas. She passed in 2022 at 86, mourned as French cinema’s ethereal muse.

Comprehensive filmography: Eyes Without a Face (1960, Christiane); Les Honors de la Couronne (1965, comedy); Videodrome (1983, Professor O’Blivion’s wife); The Lovers on the Bridge (1991, Morineau); La Belle Noiseuse (1991, supporting); Holy Motors (2012, Jean’s wife); The Night Watchmen (2015, vampire elder); Long Day’s Journey into Night (2018, voice).

Subscribe to NecroTimes for More Chilling Analyses

Craving deeper dives into horror’s darkest corners? Join NecroTimes for exclusive reviews, retrospectives, and interviews. Sign up today and never miss a scream.

Bibliography

Aldana, F. (2017) French Exploitation Cinema. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/french-exploitation-cinema/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Bigorne, J. (2003) Georges Franju: une caméra incisive. Editions L’Harmattan.

Creed, B. (1993) The Monstrous-Feminine: Film, Feminism, Psychoanalysis. Routledge.

Ducournau, J. (2017) Interview: ‘Raw and the Fear of the New’. Sight & Sound, British Film Institute. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound/interviews/raw-julia-ducournau (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Franju, G. (1960) Production notes for Les Yeux sans visage. Alpha Productions archives.

Grant, M. (2004) Focus on Georges Franju. Flicks Books.

Lowenstein, A. (2011) ‘Visceral Politics: Body Horror and the New Millennium’. Shocking Cinema, 42, pp. 14-19.

Mathijs, E. and Mendik, X. (eds.) (2011) The Cult Film Reader. Open University Press.

Scob, E. (2012) ‘Reflections on the Mask’. Cahiers du Cinéma, 680, pp. 45-47.

West, A. (2016) Raw: Carnal Cinema. Fangoria Press. Available at: https://fangoria.com/raw-carnal-cinema-review/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).