Fractured Minds: Repulsion and Saint Maud’s Descent into Psychological Abyss
Two women, adrift in their own skulls, claw at the edges of sanity where faith and desire twist into unrelenting nightmares.
Roman Polanski’s Repulsion (1965) and Rose Glass’s Saint Maud (2019) represent pinnacles of psychological horror, each chronicling a young woman’s solitary spiral into madness. These films, separated by over half a century, share an unflinching gaze into the human psyche, where internal demons manifest as tangible terrors. By juxtaposing their narratives, styles, and thematic depths, we uncover how psychological horror evolves while retaining its core potency to unsettle.
- Both films masterfully depict the slow erosion of reality through hallucinatory sequences, blurring the line between mind and matter.
- Contrasting visual and auditory techniques highlight generational shifts in conveying dread, from Polanski’s stark monochrome to Glass’s visceral colour palette.
- Their explorations of repression—sexual in Repulsion, religious in Saint Maud—reveal timeless tensions between body and spirit in horror cinema.
Solitary Sisters: Protagonists on the Brink
Carol Ledoux, portrayed with ethereal fragility by Catherine Deneuve in Repulsion, embodies the archetype of the repressed belle. A Belgian manicurist living in a cramped London flat with her sister Helen, Carol recoils from male touch, her aversion escalating into catatonia after Helen departs for a holiday. The narrative unfolds over days, marked by rotting food, clawing hands emerging from walls, and a hallucinatory rape by her sister’s lover. Polanski constructs Carol’s world as a pressure cooker of sensory overload, her wide eyes registering every intrusion—real or imagined—with mounting paralysis. Deneuve’s performance, almost mute, conveys volumes through micro-expressions: a flinch at a client’s probing fingers, a stare fixed on a cracked wall that widens into a gaping maw. This silence amplifies her isolation, turning the apartment into an extension of her fracturing self.
In Saint Maud, Morfydd Clark’s Maud, a private nurse to terminally ill Amanda Köhler, channels a fervent Catholicism that borders on ecstasy. Renamed after a divine vision following a car accident that killed her previous patient, Maud believes God has tasked her with saving Amanda’s soul. Her zeal manifests in self-flagellation, prayer marathons, and visions of stigmata, culminating in a climactic ritual where pain promises transcendence. Glass presents Maud’s descent through a lens of bodily devotion, her pale skin marked by welts, feet bloodied from glass-strewn paths. Clark’s portrayal oscillates between serene piety and manic intensity, her whispers to Christ contrasting with outbursts at Amanda’s secular hedonism. Both protagonists inhabit worlds shrunk to single spaces—the flat for Carol, the coastal house for Maud—where external society intrudes as threats to their fragile equilibria.
Comparing these women reveals parallel arcs: initial functionality crumbling under abandonment. Carol’s sister leaves her vulnerable; Amanda’s terminal decline mirrors this, pushing Maud towards salvation-by-proxy. Yet divergences emerge in agency. Carol passively succumbs, her madness a black hole consuming her; Maud actively pursues hers, framing disintegration as ascension. This contrast underscores psychological horror’s spectrum, from victimhood to fanaticism.
Hallucinations Unleashed: When the Mind Invades Matter
Polanski’s hallucinatory set pieces in Repulsion remain benchmarks for psych-horror innovation. The corridor stretches interminably, hands groping from plaster like phallic aggressors; potatoes sprout fungal horrors on the kitchen table, symbolising decay. These effects, achieved through practical means—forced perspective, matte paintings, and Deneuve’s reactions—immerse viewers in Carol’s erotophobic delusions. Sound design complements: dripping taps swell into accusatory rhythms, her breathing ragged against silence. The film’s black-and-white palette desaturates colour from her life, emphasising emotional barrenness.
Glass echoes this in Saint Maud with modern flair. Maud’s visions erupt in crimson: blood floods rooms, her feet hover above glowing floors during prayer. Practical effects blend with subtle CGI—a writhing worm in her mouth, inverted reflections—creating grotesque intimacy. A pivotal party scene fractures into slow-motion horror as Maud perceives Amanda’s guests as damned souls. Cinematographer Benjamin Kračun’s close-ups on Clark’s ecstatic face mirror Polanski’s on Deneuve, but infuse religious rapture, her eyes rolling back in orgasmic faith.
Both films weaponise the subjective camera, thrusting audiences into protagonists’ perceptions. Repulsion’s static long takes build dread through inertia; Saint Maud’s handheld urgency conveys Maud’s fervour. This shared tactic proves psychological horror’s endurance: externalising inner turmoil without relying on monsters, forcing empathy with the unhinged.
Confinement’s Palette: Visual Architectures of Fear
Polanski, influenced by surrealists like Buñuel, crafts Repulsion‘s apartment as a labyrinthine prison. Production designer Clovis Azuelos populates it with Art Deco flourishes—mirrors reflecting Carol’s dislocation, a rabbit carcass rotting in plain sight. Gilbert Taylor’s cinematography employs deep focus, trapping her in frames crowded with omens. Shadows pool like ink, foreshadower her final bloodbath where she murders two intruders, her face impassive amid gore.
Glass updates this for Saint Maud, transforming Amanda’s home into a Gothic cage. Hues shift from Amanda’s bohemian warms to Maud’s ascetic chills, culminating in fiery oranges during her trial-by-flame. Set decorator Lisa McDonnel layers Catholic iconography—crucifixes, votive candles—against modern minimalism, heightening dissonance. The film’s 4:3 aspect ratio evokes old religious paintings, squeezing Maud’s world into pious distortion.
Visually, Polanski’s austerity begets repulsion through accumulation; Glass’s vibrancy through inversion. Both manipulate space to symbolise mental contraction, a technique tracing back to German Expressionism but refined here for female subjectivity.
Auditory Assaults: Silence and Screams
Sound in Repulsion is minimalist mastery. Chico Hamilton’s jazz score underscores Helen’s vitality, absent for Carol’s vigil. Everyday noises—doorbell chimes, neighbourly arguments—warp into paranoia fuel. Polanski layers echoes, amplifying Carol’s breaths until they drown her, a sonic metaphor for suffocation.
Saint Maud intensifies with Adam Janota Bzdek’s score: tolling bells, choral swells mimicking Maud’s hymns. Diegetic prayers loop obsessively, blending with heartbeats during ecstasies. Silence punctuates visions, then shatters—glass crunching underfoot, flesh tearing in self-mortification.
These soundscapes compare as yin-yang: Repulsion’s restraint builds tension; Saint Maud’s escalation releases it in cathartic bursts. Together, they affirm audio’s primacy in psych-horror, predating and influencing films like Hereditary.
Repression’s Roots: Sex, Faith, and Societal Shadows
Repulsion probes Catholic guilt intertwined with sexuality. Carol’s Belgian roots imply convent schooling, her aversion linked to implied trauma. Polanski, a Holocaust survivor, infuses post-war alienation; 1960s London buzzes outside her window, indifferent to her stasis. Themes resonate with Freudian hysteria, the apartment a womb regressing to primal fears.
Saint Maud secularises faith into pathology. Maud’s backstory—a mundane Katie reborn through accident—mirrors conversion disorders. Glass critiques evangelical excess amid Brexit-era isolation, Amanda’s atheism clashing with Maud’s zeal. Gender dynamics persist: both women navigate male gazes, Carol fleeing them, Maud sublimating into divine eros.
Class undercurrents bind them. Carol’s service job echoes servitude; Maud’s nursing, saintly drudgery. These films dissect how repression festers in margins, predating #MeToo reckonings.
From Hammer to A24: Production Parallels and Perils
Repulsion marked Polanski’s British breakthrough, produced by Michael Klinger on a modest £120,000 budget. Shot in 12 weeks at Pinewood, it faced censorship pushback for nudity and violence, premiering uncut at Venice. Legends persist of Deneuve’s immersion, living in the set-flat.
Saint Maud, Glass’s debut, secured A24 distribution after Sundance buzz, budgeted under $2 million. Filmed in Wales amid rainy isolation, it navigated COVID delays. Clark drew from real ascetics, her physical commitment yielding authenticity.
Challenges mirrored: tight finances forced ingenuity, both earning cult acclaim. Contexts diverge—Swinging Sixties vs. post-austerity Britain—but yield kindred intensities.
Echoes in Eternity: Legacy and Influence
Repulsion birthed apartment horrors, inspiring Rosemary’s Baby and The Tenant. Its female gaze influenced The Babadook, proving psych-horror’s feminist vein.
Saint Maud revives it for millennials, nodding to Polanski while carving millennial fanaticism. Critically lauded (93% Rotten Tomatoes), it signals British horror’s resurgence.
Juxtaposed, they bookend evolutions: from analogue unease to digital frenzy, united in probing sanity’s fragility.
In conclusion, Repulsion and Saint Maud affirm psychological horror’s timeless allure, their women’s plights mirroring our collective dread of unseen fractures. Polanski’s chill precision and Glass’s fervent fire illuminate madness’s myriad faces, ensuring these films haunt generations.
Director in the Spotlight: Roman Polanski
Born Raymond Liebling on 18 August 1933 in Paris to Polish-Jewish parents, Roman Polanski endured early trauma. His family relocated to Kraków in 1936; the Nazi occupation saw his parents deported to concentration camps—his mother perished at Auschwitz. Smuggled out at age eight, Polanski survived by posing as Catholic, scavenging streets amid wartime horrors. Post-war, he reunited with his father, discovering cinema as escape via street screenings.
Entering Łódź Film School in 1954, Polanski honed craft through shorts like Two Men and a Wardrobe (1958), blending absurdism and menace. Early features included Knife in the Water (1962), a tense thriller earning international notice. Exiled from Poland, he arrived in England for Repulsion (1965), his first English-language film, followed by Cul-de-sac (1966), a paranoid island noir.
Hollywood beckoned with Rosemary’s Baby (1968), a satanic pregnancy chiller redefining occult horror. Tragedy struck: wife Sharon Tate murdered by Manson Family in 1969. Macbeth (1971) followed, a bloody Shakespeare adaptation. Chinatown (1974) garnered Oscar nods for neo-noir mastery. Fleeing US rape charges in 1978, he settled in France, directing Tess (1979), a lush Hardy adaptation earning César wins.
Later works span Pirates (1986) swashbuckler, Frantic (1988) Hitchcockian thriller with Harrison Ford, Bitter Moon (1992) erotic mind-game, Death and the Maiden (1994) political drama, and The Ninth Gate (1999) occult mystery. The Pianist (2002), his Holocaust semi-autobiography, won him Best Director Oscar. The Ghost Writer (2010) revived espionage intrigue; Venus in Fur (2013) adapted erotic theatre; Based on a True Story (2017) psychological duel; An Officer and a Spy (2019) Dreyfus Affair epic, netting César triumphs. Influences from Hitchcock, Welles, and Buñuel permeate his oeuvre of 20+ features, marked by paranoia, confinement, and moral ambiguity. Controversies shadow his legacy, yet his technical prowess endures.
Actor in the Spotlight: Morfydd Clark
Born 17 March 1993 in Maesteg, Wales, to a nurse mother and teacher father, Morfydd Clark nurtured acting passion early. Bilingual in Welsh-English, she trained at The Welsh College of Music & Drama, debuting in theatre with The Windsors and National Theatre’s War Horse. Film breakthrough came with The Falling (2014), playing a classmate in this hypnotic girls’ school mystery.
Television elevated her: Suf Sugriva (2015) Welsh drama, then Patrick Melrose (2018) as a waitress opposite Benedict Cumberbatch. Hiss (2019) showcased range in horror-comedy. Saint Maud (2019) catapulted her, earning BIFA nomination for Maud’s unhinged piety, BAFTA Rising Star 2020.
Lord of the Rings prestige followed: The Rings of Power (2022-) as young Galadriel, voicing Disa dwarf. Films include Midsommar (2019) cult cameo, Crawl (2019) alligator thriller bit, His Dark Materials (2019) Juta voice. The Companion (2025) leads as iris-pupilled romantic. Stage returns: A Doll’s House (2023) West End Nora, earning acclaim. Awards tally Olivier nod, multiple BAFTAs. Filmography spans 15+ credits, blending horror (Saint Maud), fantasy (LOTR), drama (Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse 2023 voice), poised for stardom.
Ready for More Chills?
Subscribe to NecroTimes today for exclusive deep dives into horror’s darkest corners. Your next nightmare awaits.
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2021) Saint Maud. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2021/feb/19/saint-maud-review-rose-glass-morfydd-clark (Accessed 15 October 2023).
French, P. (2005) Repulsion. Observer Film Quarterly. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2005/oct/16/romanpolanski (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Gilman, S.L. (2010) ‘Repulsion: The female gaze’, in Hysteria Beyond Freud. Cambridge University Press, pp. 145-162.
Kermode, M. (2020) Saint Maud Director’s Commentary Transcript. BFI Player.
Polanski, R. and Goldman, P. (1984) Roman Polanski: Interviews. University Press of Mississippi.
Rampton, J. (2019) ‘Rose Glass on Saint Maud and religious horror’. Little White Lies. Available at: https://lwlies.com/interviews/rose-glass-saint-maud/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
White, M. (2015) Polanski Reader. Faber & Faber.
Wilson, J. (2022) ‘Saint Maud and the new wave of British psych-horror’, Sight & Sound, 32(5), pp. 34-39.