Frankenstein’s Shadow: Wrestling with Identity and the Essence of Humanity

In the lightning-scarred laboratory where flesh defies death, Frankenstein’s creations force us to confront the fragile boundary between monster and man.

Mary Shelley’s enduring tale of ambition and abandonment has spawned countless iterations across literature, stage, and screen, each probing the precarious nature of identity and the elusive core of humanity. From the Romantic gloom of the original novel to the silver-screen spectacles of Universal’s monster rallies, these stories dissect what it means to be alive, loved, and whole. They challenge us to peer into the creature’s mismatched eyes and recognise fragments of our own fractured selves.

  • The philosophical underpinnings of Shelley’s Frankenstein, drawing from Enlightenment hubris and Romantic individualism to question the soul’s origins.
  • Cinematic evolutions in Universal and Hammer films, where visual language amplifies the creature’s quest for belonging amid societal rejection.
  • Enduring legacy in modern horror, reflecting contemporary anxieties over creation, technology, and the human condition.

Prometheus Unbound: The Novel’s Philosophical Forge

Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, published in 1818, emerges from the stormy intellectual tempests of its era, where scientific daring clashed with moral restraint. Victor Frankenstein, a young Swiss student intoxicated by galvanism and anatomy, assembles a being from scavenged body parts, only to recoil in horror at his handiwork. This act of creation is no mere gothic thrill; it interrogates identity at its rawest. The creature, unnamed and abandoned, embodies the blank slate of humanity, his mind a tabula rasa shaped not by divine spark but by nurture’s cruel absence. Shelley’s narrative unfolds across frozen Arctic wastes and idyllic Swiss valleys, tracing the creature’s evolution from innocent curiosity to vengeful fury. He learns language by eavesdropping on a peasant family, devours literature from Paradise Lost to Plutarch, yet society brands him other, denying him the mirrors of recognition essential to selfhood.

The theme of humanity hinges on relational bonds. Victor’s rejection severs the creature’s tether to creator-father, mirroring Rousseau’s ideas of natural goodness corrupted by civilisation. The creature’s eloquent pleas—”I ought to be thy Adam, but I am rather the fallen angel”—echo Milton’s Satan, blurring lines between victim and villain. Shelley’s own life, marked by the loss of her mother and children, infuses this with personal depth; the creature’s isolation reflects her grappling with motherhood’s failures. Critics have long noted how the novel anticipates existentialism, with the creature’s self-fashioning prefiguring Sartre’s notion of existence preceding essence. Yet Shelley’s genius lies in her refusal of easy answers: identity is not innate but negotiated, fragile as the sutures holding the creature together.

Folklore shadows this innovation. The golem of Jewish mysticism, animated clay craving a soul, and Prometheus’s liver-devouring torment parallel Victor’s overreach. Shelley’s story evolves these myths into a secular parable, stripping divine intervention to expose human frailty. The creature’s humanity flickers in moments of compassion—he spares a child, aids the blind De Lacey—only to be extinguished by pitchfork-wielding mobs. This dialectic of potential and prejudice underscores the novel’s evolutionary thrust: monsters are made, not born.

Lightning and Legacy: Universal’s Monstrous Birth

James Whale’s 1931 Frankenstein translates Shelley’s labyrinthine prose into visceral cinema, amplifying identity’s visual grammar. Boris Karloff’s creature, swathed in Jack Pierce’s iconic flathead makeup and platform boots, lumbers into frame amid angular Expressionist sets, his body a grotesque pastiche demanding our empathy. Whale jettisons much of the novel’s verbosity for silent-era pantomime; the creature’s first words, “Friend,” gasped to a terrified little girl, pierce like a thunderbolt. Here, humanity emerges not in soliloquies but in childlike gestures—the flower he offers, crushed by misunderstanding. The film’s climax, with the creature on the pyre crying “Help,” cements his tragic arc: identity forged in isolation, humanity glimpsed then incinerated.

Production lore reveals Whale’s subversive intent. Fresh from Journey’s End‘s stage success, the openly gay director infused the monster with outsider pathos, drawing from his World War I trench scars. Censorship loomed large; the Hays Code precursors forced the excising of the creature’s dialogue in early cuts, yet Whale’s mise-en-scène—harsh key lights carving Karloff’s face into tragic masks—speaks volumes. Special effects pioneer John P. Fulton engineered the laboratory’s sparking machinery, symbolising Victor’s (Colin Clive) godlike delusion. Pierce’s makeup, layered with cotton, greasepaint, and electrodes, transformed Karloff from everyman to icon, its scars mapping the creature’s psychic wounds. This visual lexicon evolves the myth: identity as patchwork, humanity as performance rejected by the audience of norms.

The sequel, Bride of Frankenstein (1935), escalates the inquiry. Whale’s creature demands a mate—”Alone: bad. Friend for friend”—exposing companionship’s role in self-definition. The blind fiddler’s cottage scene, where music briefly humanises him, contrasts the bride’s (Elsa Lanchester) hiss of revulsion. Her wild hair and bolt neckbands parody femininity, questioning gendered humanity. Whale layers camp irony atop horror, with Dr. Pretorius (Ernest Thesiger) toasting “to a new world of gods and monsters,” a meta-nod to their own fabricated identities.

Hammer’s Crimson Canvas: Resurrection and Rejection

Britain’s Hammer Films revitalised Frankenstein in the 1950s, with Terence Fisher’s The Curse of Frankenstein (1957) starring Peter Cushing as a ruthlessly rational Baron and Christopher Lee as a more articulate creature. Fisher’s Technicolor gore shifts focus to ethics: the Baron’s piecemeal experiments commodify identity, his creature a failed prototype discarded like faulty goods. Lee’s portrayal, with melting makeup revealing the horror beneath, underscores theme’s evolution—humanity as aesthetic viability, judged by surface flaws. The film’s controversy, banned in some territories for its arterial sprays, marked horror’s maturation, confronting identity’s corporeal limits.

Subsequent Hammers like The Revenge of Frankenstein (1958) and Frankenstein Created Woman (1967) innovate: the baron transplants brains, swaps souls, even inhabits a dwarf’s body. In the latter, Susan Denberg’s possessed form explores the monstrous feminine, her vengeance blurring victim and avenger. Fisher’s Catholic-inflected visuals—crucifix shadows, resurrection motifs—frame identity as divine prerogative usurped. These films evolve Shelley’s seed into pulp philosophy, where humanity’s essence resists synthetic replication.

Beyond Hammer, Paul Morrissey’s Flesh for Frankenstein (1973) satirises with 3D impalements, Udo Kier’s baron questing for the perfect Yugoslavian navel to ensure passion. This Yugoslav-Italian co-production grotesques identity into fetish, the creature’s bisected scream literalising existential nausea. Yet amid camp excess, it probes creation’s commodification, echoing modern biotech fears.

Stitched Selves: Special Effects and the Visible Soul

Frankenstein stories thrive on effects that externalise inner turmoil. Pierce’s 1931 design set benchmarks: mortician’s wax for flesh, asphalt for scars, achieving a lumbering 6’5″ from Karloff’s 6’1″. Hammer’s Phil Leakey advanced with latex appliances, allowing Lee’s expressive eyes to convey soulful torment. Kenneth Russell’s Gothic (1986) recreates Shelley’s Villa Diodati storm with practical lightning, hallucinatory births visualising creative identity’s birth pangs. Digital eras, like Victor Frankenstein (2015)’s CG limbs, demystify assembly, shifting emphasis to emotional sutures.

These techniques symbolise theme: the creature’s body, a map of rejected parts, mirrors society’s piecing together of norms. Makeup’s endurance testifies to performance’s role in humanity—Karloff’s stillness under layers humanised the inhuman, proving identity enacted.

Echoes in Eternity: Cultural Ripples and Modern Mutations

Frankenstein’s legacy permeates culture, from Young Frankenstein (1974)’s Mel Brooks parody reclaiming joy in misfit identity to Edward Scissorhands (1990)’s suburban outcast. TV’s Penny Dreadful (2014-2016) weaves the creature into ensemble mythos, his poetry recitals affirming literacy’s humanising power. Contemporary sci-fi like Blade Runner (1982) replicants echo the creature’s pleas, evolving the theme into AI ethics. These mutations affirm Frankenstein’s mythic adaptability: identity as eternal reinvention.

Production hurdles shaped many: Universal’s 1931 budget constraints birthed improvisations, like Karloff’s improvised grunts. Hammer battled BBFC cuts, Fisher’s restraint honing subtlety. Such struggles parallel the creature’s: humanity forged in adversity.

Director in the Spotlight

James Whale, born in 1889 in Dudley, England, to a working-class family, rose through sheer theatrical grit. Invalided from World War I with shellshock, he channelled trauma into directing, helming R.C. Sherriff’s Journey’s End (1929) on stage before Hollywood beckoned. Universal signed him for Frankenstein (1931), his Expressionist flair—tilted cameras, mobile framing—revolutionising horror. Whale’s oeuvre blends sophistication and subversion; The Invisible Man (1933) showcases Claude Rains’s voice as identity’s mask, while Show Boat (1936) musicals reveal his musical theatre roots.

His career peaked then waned amid personal struggles; as an openly gay man in repressive times, Whale retired to paint and mentor. Tragic suicide in 1957 followed dementia’s grip. Filmography highlights: Journey’s End (1930), war drama of trench futility; Frankenstein (1931), monster masterpiece; The Old Dark House (1932), eccentric ensemble horror; The Invisible Man (1933), sci-fi rampage; Bride of Frankenstein (1935), baroque sequel; The Road Back (1937), anti-war sequel; Show Boat (1936), lavish musical; Sinners in Paradise (1938), adventure drama; later works like The Man in the Iron Mask (1939). Whale’s influence endures in Tim Burton’s gothic whimsy and Guillermo del Toro’s pathos-driven monsters.

Actor in the Spotlight

Boris Karloff, born William Henry Pratt in 1887 in East Dulwich, London, to Anglo-Indian heritage, fled privilege for Canadian gold mines and itinerant acting. Silent serials honed his hulking frame before Frankenstein (1931) typecast him gloriously. Karloff’s gentle baritone and expressive eyes humanised the creature, earning eternal fame. He subverted the role in comedies like Arsenic and Old Lace (1944), voiced the Grinch in 1966, and advocated for actors’ rights as Screen Actors Guild founder.

Dying in 1969 from emphysema, Karloff’s warmth pierced horror’s veil. Filmography spans 200 credits: The Criminal Code (1930), breakout prison drama; Frankenstein (1931), iconic creature; The Mummy (1932), brooding Imhotep; The Old Dark House (1932), Morgan the butler; The Ghoul (1933), resurrecting Egyptologist; Bride of Frankenstein (1935), returning monster; The Invisible Ray (1936), mad scientist; Son of Frankenstein (1939), third creature outing; The Mummy’s Hand (1940), Kharis role; Bedlam (1946), asylum tyrant; Isle of the Dead (1945), zombie precursor; Frankenstein 1970 (1958), atomic baron; TV’s Thriller host (1960-62); Targets (1968), meta-horror swan song. His legacy bridges fright and fatherly benevolence.

Craving more mythic terrors? Dive deeper into HORROTICA’s vault of classic horrors and unearth the monsters within.

Bibliography

Botting, F. (1991) ‘Frankenstein’ and the Feminine. In: Frankenstein. Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 102-133.

Frayling, C. (1992) Frankenstein: The First Two Hundred Years. Reel Art Press.

Glut, D.F. (1976) The Frankenstein Catalog: A Complete Filmography of Frankenstein at the Cinema. McFarland & Company.

Hitchcock, P. (2007) Imaginary States: Studies in Cultural Transnationalism. University of Illinois Press.

Lev, P. (2003) The Fifties: Transforming the Screen, 1950-1959. University of California Press.

Poole, R. (2012) ‘The Known and Unknown Mr Karloff’, Sight & Sound, 22(9), pp. 42-46. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-sound (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Shelley, M. (1818) Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus. Lackington, Hughes, Harding, Mavor & Jones.

Skal, D. (1993) The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror. W.W. Norton & Company.

Troyer, J. (2000) ‘The Table, the Crown and the Lady: An English Death and Englishness’, Nineteenth-Century Prose, 27(2), pp. 78-104.

Whale, J. (1931) Frankenstein [Film]. Universal Pictures.