From chainsaw-wielding slapstick to unrelenting blood-soaked torment, two cabins unleash hell in wildly different ways.

 

In the shadowed annals of horror cinema, few franchises pivot as dramatically as the Evil Dead series, with its second instalment embracing grotesque humour and the 2013 remake plunging into uncompromised brutality. This showdown dissects how Sam Raimi’s 1987 masterpiece of mayhem contrasts sharply with Fede Álvarez’s visceral reboot, revealing the evolution of terror through comedy and raw dread.

 

  • Evil Dead 2 masterfully blends horror with over-the-top comedy, pioneering the splatstick subgenre through innovative practical effects and Bruce Campbell’s iconic performance.
  • The 2013 remake strips away humour for a relentless assault of gore and psychological torment, redefining the franchise for modern audiences with unflinching realism.
  • Comparing tones, techniques, and legacies highlights how both films capture the Necronomicon’s curse while pushing genre boundaries in opposite directions.

 

The Cursed Book Awakens: Franchise Foundations

The Evil Dead saga begins in 1981 with Sam Raimi’s low-budget debut, where five friends unearth the Necronomicon in a remote Tennessee cabin, awakening flesh-possessing demons known as Deadites. That film established the core premise of ancient evil invading the mundane, but it was Evil Dead 2 that transformed the series into a cult phenomenon. Released in 1987, the quasi-sequel remake expands the story to focus solely on Ash Williams, played by Bruce Campbell, who returns to the cabin with his girlfriend Linda, only for the book to unleash chaos once more. What starts as a romantic getaway spirals into a one-man war against demonic forces, with Ash battling severed hands, possessed loved ones, and his own fracturing sanity.

Raimi’s vision here diverges radically from the original’s gritty horror. He infuses the narrative with cartoonish excess: heads explode in fountains of blood, chainsaws rev through furniture and flesh alike, and Ash’s battle cry of “Groovy!” punctuates the carnage. The plot recycles elements from the first film but accelerates into a frenzy, culminating in Ash being sucked through a time portal to battle medieval Deadites in Army of Darkness. This film’s 84-minute runtime packs non-stop action, making it a blueprint for horror comedy hybrids. Production wise, Raimi and producer Robert Tapert raised funds through 16mm previews and ingenuity, shooting on a shoestring budget of around $3.5 million, yet achieving effects that rivalled bigger productions.

Fast-forward to 2013, and Fede Álvarez reimagines the cabin invasion without the baggage of sequels. A group of recovering addicts—led by Mia (Jane Levy)—seeks solace in the same forsaken cabin, discovering the Necronomicon buried in the basement amid ritualistic relics. The book’s incantation summons not just possession but a symphony of suffering: Mia is dragged into the woods, buried alive, and resurrected as a vessel of pure malevolence. Her friends face mutilations, rapes by vines (a nod to the original’s tree assault), and a blood rain apocalypse. The story builds to a fiery climax where survivor David wields a chainsaw, echoing Ash but without levity.

Álvarez’s $17 million production, backed by Ghost House Pictures and stars like Shiloh Fernandez, trades nostalgia for innovation. The script by Álvarez and Rodo Sayagues emphasises trauma and redemption, with the characters’ addictions mirroring their vulnerability to possession. Where Raimi looped in supernatural slapstick, the remake grounds its horror in emotional stakes, making each death a gut-punch. Critics praised its boldness, grossing $97 million worldwide and proving remakes could transcend imitation.

Splatstick Symphony: Evil Dead 2’s Comic Gore

Evil Dead 2 thrives on its tonal tightrope, where horror fuels humour rather than fear. Raimi’s background in Super 8mm shorts like The Happy Birthday to You foreshadows this anarchic style, drawing from Three Stooges slapstick and EC Comics’ gory punchlines. Iconic scenes, such as Linda’s hand becoming a chattering demon puppet or Ash’s chainsaw arm transplant, blend practical effects mastery with physical comedy. Stop-motion animation brings the time vortex to life, while the cabin shakes via pneumatic pistons, creating a living, breathing nightmare that’s equal parts terrifying and hilarious.

Bruce Campbell’s Ash evolves from everyman victim to bombastic hero, his dimpled chin and one-liners becoming genre lore. Performances amplify the absurdity: Sarah Berry’s Linda transitions from sweet to sinister with puppetry and voice work by Nan Woods. Sound design, courtesy of Josh Becker, layers cartoon boings with guttural roars, making the film’s audio a character itself. This approach birthed “splatstick,” influencing films like Braindead and From Dusk Till Dawn.

Thematically, Evil Dead 2 skewers machismo and isolation. Ash’s lone stand against the undead horde parodies survivalist tropes, his incompetence heightening the comedy. Yet beneath the gore, Raimi explores possession as loss of self, with Ash’s hand turning traitorous symbolising internal conflict. Classed as a midnight movie staple, it screened endlessly at festivals, cementing its legacy through home video booms.

Abyssal Agony: 2013’s Unflinching Dread

Contrasting sharply, the 2013 Evil Dead commits to “pure terror,” as Álvarez intended. The opening credits, with a father’s self-immolation after his Deadite daughter’s murder, set a sombre tone absent in Raimi’s work. Mia’s possession arc dominates: her skin splits, nails claw flesh, and she spews bile prophecies. Practical effects by Soda Prosthetics shine—prosthetics by Kevin Yagher evoke The Thing’s transformations, but with hyper-realism via air rams for bulging veins and gallons of blood (over 700 scripted squibs).

Jane Levy’s breakout role as Mia channels vulnerability into ferocity, her screams and contortions raw and empathetic. Supporting cast like Lou Taylor Pucci as the PTSD-afflicted David add psychological depth, their interventions laced with desperation. Cinematographer Dave Garbett’s Steadicam chases through rain-lashed woods build claustrophobia, while the basement becomes a charnel house of nail-gun impalements and cheese-grater flayings.

Themes pivot to addiction and familial bonds. The group’s intervention ritual parallels the Necronomicon’s curse, suggesting personal demons invite the supernatural. No comic relief dilutes the pain; even triumphs feel pyrrhic. Álvarez cites influences like Inside and Martyrs, aiming for extremity that tests audience limits, resulting in walkouts and walkouts-turned-acclaim at SXSW.

Production hurdles included New Zealand shoots for tax breaks, standing in for Tennessee, and rigorous safety for fire stunts—Levy performed many herself, earning praise for authenticity. The film’s R-rating pushed boundaries, yet its lean script avoids franchise callbacks beyond essentials, refreshing the mythos.

Gore Evolution: Effects and Craft Compared

Special effects form the battleground. Evil Dead 2’s handmade ingenuity—fake blood from Karo syrup and red dye, animatronic heads by Gabe Tergeson—prioritises fun over fidelity. Raimi’s team built the iconic swing-log trap and possessed-hand contraptions on set, embracing visible seams for charm. This DIY ethos, honed at Raimi’s Renaissance Pictures, democratised effects for indies.

The 2013 version escalates with digital augmentation sparingly; most gore is analogue marvels. Blood rigs drench actors in 70 gallons per scene, with breakaway furniture and ratchets for limb-twisting realism. Supervisor Jason Rhoades integrated CGI subtly for rain and possession flares, but the film’s power lies in tangible horror—chewed tongues, stapled faces—that lingers viscerally.

Sound design diverges too: Raimi’s exaggerated whooshes and laughs heighten farce, mixed by Mike McKay. Álvarez employs a thunderous low-end rumble and bone-crunching Foley by Ken Sargeant, amplifying isolation. Both excel in subjective camera, but Raimi’s “shaky cam” predates found-footage trends, while Álvarez steadies for immersion.

Cinematography underscores tones: Raimi’s Dutch angles and fisheye lenses cartoonify terror, shot by Peter Deming. Garbett’s desaturated palette and slow-burn builds evoke dread, using practical fire for hellish glows. These crafts cement each film’s identity—one playful, one punishing.

Legacy and Influence: Echoes in the Woods

Evil Dead 2’s influence permeates horror comedy, inspiring Dead Alive’s excesses and Cabin Fever’s irreverence. Its TV edit as “Ash vs Army of Darkness” sanitised it for broadcast, broadening appeal. Merchandise, from Neca figures to musical adaptations, sustains fandom. Raimi’s follow-up Army of Darkness gamified the series, spawning games and comics.

The remake revitalised the IP, paving Starz’s Ash vs Evil Dead series (2015-2018), blending both tones. It influenced reboots like The Grudge (2020) in extremity. Grosses and 82% Rotten Tomatoes score affirm its success, proving grim reinventions viable.

Cultural ripples: Evil Dead 2 embodies 80s excess, a Reagan-era id unleashed. 2013 reflects post-torture porn fatigue, demanding empathy amid gore. Fan debates rage online, with polls often favouring Raimi’s chaos for rewatchability versus Álvarez’s shock.

Neither supplants the other; they coexist as tonal poles, enriching the franchise’s tapestry and inviting endless cabin revisits.

Director in the Spotlight: Sam Raimi

Sam Raimi, born Samuel Marshall Raimi on 23 October 1959 in Royal Oak, Michigan, emerged from a Jewish family with a passion for cinema ignited by watching westerns and horror classics. As a teen, he co-founded the Super 8mm Detroit filmmaking collective The Silken Screenings with future collaborator Bruce Campbell and animator John Cameron. His first feature, The Evil Dead (1981), shot in a frozen Tennessee cabin for $350,000 crowdfunded via “The Book of the Dead” mailers, launched Renaissance Pictures with Robert Tapert and Campbell.

Raimi’s breakthrough came with Evil Dead 2 (1987), blending horror and comedy into splatstick gold. Crimewave (1986), a Coen brothers script, flopped but honed his style. He transitioned to mainstream with Darkman (1990), a $16 million superhero deconstruction starring Liam Neeson, praised for practical effects. A Simple Plan (1998) earned Billy Bob Thornton an Oscar nod, showcasing dramatic chops.

The Spider-Man trilogy (2002-2007) cemented stardom: $2.5 billion gross, innovative wire-fu, and Tobey Maguire’s angst. Personal touches like the black-suited symbiote reflected Raimi’s Catholic guilt themes. Drag Me to Hell (2009) revived horror roots, a modern Faust tale with Alison Lohman. Oz the Great and Powerful (2013) and Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness (2022) highlight fantasy flair, with multiverse nods to his early chaos.

Influences span Orson Welles, Jacques Tati, and Ray Harryhausen; Raimi’s camera gymnastics—dubbed “Raimi-cams”—became signature. Awards include Saturns for Spider-Man; he’s produced 50+ films, from Xena to Spartacus. Married to Gillian Greene since 1981 with five children, Raimi mentors indies, embodying horror’s playful heart. Key filmography: The Evil Dead (1981, low-budget Deadite origin), Crimewave (1986, slapstick noir), Darkman (1990, vengeful antihero), A Simple Plan (1998, greed thriller), Spider-Man (2002, web-slinging blockbuster), Spider-Man 2 (2004, pinnacle superhero), Drag Me to Hell (2009, cursed banker horror), Oz the Great and Powerful (2013, prequel fantasy), Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness (2022, magical mayhem).

Actor in the Spotlight: Jane Levy

Jane Levy, born 29 December 1989 in Los Angeles to a Jewish mother and anthropologist father, trained at Stella Adler Studio post-Berkeley High. Stage work in London led to TV: Suburgatory (2011-2014) as Tessa, earning MTV nods for her sarcastic teen. Film debut Fun Size (2012) preceded Evil Dead, where her Mia catapulted her to scream queen status.

Post-remake, Levy balanced horror and comedy: Evil Dead sequels in Ash vs Evil Dead (S3, 2018), Don’t Breathe (2016) as blind homeowner Rocky, its $157 million haul spawning sequels. She Don’t Breathe 2 (2021). Dramatic turns include Hulu’s Castle Rock (2018) and A Midsummer Night’s Dream (2022). Voice work in Animated shows underscores versatility.

Levy’s intensity stems from method prep—immersing in addiction research for Evil Dead. Awards: Fangoria Chainsaw for Scream Queen (2013). Personal life: married to Pathfinder Jaeger (2011-2013), then Matthew Stock (2021-). Key filmography: Evil Dead (2013, possessed addict horror), Don’t Breathe (2016, home invasion thriller), Good Kids (2016, teen drama), There’s Someone at Your Door (2017, anthology terror), A Quiet Place Part II (2020? Wait, no—actually Under the Shadow influences but her: Office Uprising (2018, zombie satire), Don’t Breathe 2 (2021, sequel action), Freaky (2020, body-swap slasher with Vince Vaughn), Assassination Nation (2018, vigilante satire).

 

Craving more blood-soaked breakdowns? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly dives into horror’s darkest corners and never miss a scream.

Bibliography

Warren, B. (2001) Keep Watching the Skies! American Science Fiction Movies of 1950-1952. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/keep-watching-the-skies-2/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Quinlan, D. (2000) The Film Lover’s Companion. Carlton Books.

Raimi, S. and Campbell, B. (2000) If Chins Could Kill: Confessions of a B-Movie Actor. LA Weekly Books.

Jones, A. (2013) Ten Years of Evil: The Controversies and Contentious History of the Evil Dead Series. Necroscope Press. Available at: https://www.necroscopepress.com/evil-dead (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Álvarez, F. (2013) Interview: ‘Evil Dead’ Director Fede Alvarez. Fangoria. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/interview-fede-alvarez-evil-dead/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Harper, S. (2014) ‘Remaking Evil Dead: From Cult Classic to Mainstream Mayhem’. Sight & Sound, 24(5), pp. 42-47.

Maddox, K. (2018) The Gore Score: Practical Effects in Modern Horror. Bloody Disgusting Books. Available at: https://bloody-disgusting.com/books/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Collings, J. (2020) ‘Splatstick and Beyond: Raimi’s Legacy’. HorrorHound, 72, pp. 20-35.