From Inky Shadows to Crimson Dreams: Tracing Visual Horror in Black Sunday and Suspiria

Two Italian-inflected visions of witchcraft and madness, separated by decades, redefine how horror paints its nightmares on screen.

Mario Bava’s 1960 masterpiece Black Sunday and Luca Guadagnino’s 2018 reimagining of Suspiria stand as pillars in the temple of visual horror. The former, a gothic chiller steeped in Eastern European folklore, unleashes terror through stark monochrome contrasts, while the latter transforms Dario Argento’s psychedelic original into a brooding, saturated symphony of blood and movement. This comparison uncovers their shared obsession with the image as weapon, charting how horror’s visual language evolved from Bava’s economical shadows to Guadagnino’s opulent palettes.

• Black Sunday’s black-and-white mastery establishes gothic horror’s blueprint for dread through light and shadow.
• Suspiria remake expands this legacy with hyper-saturated colours, dance, and architecture to evoke modern unease.
• Together, they illustrate horror’s visual progression from restraint to excess, influencing generations of filmmakers.

Gothic Phantoms in Monochrome: Black Sunday’s Visual Birth

In Black Sunday, released as La maschera del demonio in Italy, Mario Bava conjures a world where every frame drips with impending doom. The story centres on Asa Vajda, a 17th-century Moldavian princess and satanist, executed alongside her lover Javutich by having metal masks hammered onto their faces. The narrative leaps to 1860, when Professor Kruvajan and his assistant Andros nick Asa during an exhumation, unleashing her vengeful spirit. She possesses Kruvajan’s daughter Katia, sparking a chain of murders marked by hypnotic eyes and strangulation. Barbara Steele embodies both Asa and Katia, her dual performance a visual anchor amid fog-shrouded castles and candlelit crypts.

Bava’s black-and-white cinematography, shot on a shoestring budget, transforms limitation into artistry. High-contrast lighting carves faces into masks of anguish, with deep shadows pooling like ink in corners. The opening execution scene sets this tone: flames flicker against the princess’s pale skin, the mask’s spikes glinting as they pierce flesh off-screen. Sound design amplifies the visuals, but it is the composition that lingers, faces framed symmetrically against vaulted arches, evoking Renaissance paintings twisted into horror.

The film’s visual economy stems from its production: Bava, doubling as cinematographer, used fog machines rented for another film and makeshift sets. Yet this restraint heightens terror. Asa’s resurrection, her eyes burning through cobwebs, relies on slow dissolves and superimposed flames, practical effects that feel eternal. Compared to Hammer’s lurid colour horrors of the era, Black Sunday proves monochrome superior for psychological depth, shadows suggesting unseen horrors rather than revealing them.

Steele’s face becomes the canvas, her arched eyebrows and full lips contorting from innocence to malevolence. Close-ups dominate, irises dilating like black holes, pulling viewers into the curse. This intimacy prefigures giallo’s obsession with the female form as both victim and villain, a thread Argento would weave tighter.

Suspiria’s Remade Inferno: Colour as Carnage

Luca Guadagnino’s Suspiria (2018) transplants Argento’s 1977 fever dream to 1977 Berlin, amid terrorist unrest. Susie Bannion (Dakota Johnson), an American dancer, joins the prestigious Tanz Akademie, unwittingly entering a coven led by Madame Blanc (Tilda Swinton). As rituals unfold, bodies contort and explode in gore, revealing a matriarchal conspiracy. The film culminates in a ritualistic apocalypse, blending dance rehearsals with invocations, scored by Thom Yorke’s throbbing electronics.

Where Bava shunned colour, Guadagnino drowns in it. Interiors glow with bruised purples, arterial reds, and sickly yellows, fabrics and wallpapers saturated to claustrophobic excess. The dance studio’s mirrors multiply bodies into infinity, reflections fracturing as limbs snap during a centrepiece sequence where a dancer’s body inverts grotesquely. Cinematographer Sayombhu Mukdeeprom employs wide-angle lenses to distort space, walls leaning like flesh folding inward.

Production drew from Berlin’s divided history, filming in disused department stores and Soviet-era bunkers. This authenticity grounds the supernatural: rain-slicked streets reflect neon, paralleling the academy’s inner turmoil. Dance becomes visual metaphor, bodies whipping through air in balletic violence, echoing the witches’ power. Johnson’s Susie evolves from naive outsider to avenging force, her movements captured in long takes that build rhythmic dread.

Swinton’s triple role, including the aged Mater Suspiriorum, showcases transformative makeup and prosthetics, faces sagging like melted wax. These visuals evolve Bava’s possession trope, replacing hypnotic stares with choreographed ecstasy, horror emerging from communal ritual rather than solitary curse.

Shadows to Spectrum: The Evolution of Colour in Terror

Black Sunday predates colour’s horror dominance, its monochrome forcing imagination into voids. Bava layered gels over lights for subtle hues in black-and-white, hinting at blood’s gleam without spilling it. This restraint influenced Italian horror’s transition to giallo, where Argento’s original Suspiria exploded in primaries: greens like poisoned ivy, blues of drowned flesh.

Guadagnino nods to this lineage but subverts it, muting Argento’s Day-Glo for earthier tones that evoke decay. Reds dominate death scenes, blood mingling with lipstick and menstrual flows, symbolising feminine power unbound. This marks evolution: Bava’s colour absence builds universality, timeless as folklore; Guadagnino’s excess ties horror to era-specific anxieties, like post-war guilt and feminism’s fractures.

Both films use colour symbolically—Asa’s white gown stains metaphorically, Suspiria’s cloaks shift from blue calm to red fury. Yet Guadagnino’s digital grading allows precision Bava lacked, pixels pulsing like heartbeats. This shift reflects technology’s role: film stock’s grain in Black Sunday adds texture, CGI-enhanced practicals in Suspiria permit impossible anatomies.

Illuminating Dread: Lighting’s Lethal Precision

Bava’s lighting, often single-source key lights, sculpts actors like statues. Kruvajan’s study bathes in sidelight, half-faces emerging from dark, evoking chiaroscuro masters like Caravaggio. This technique amplifies Steele’s duality, light cleaving innocence from evil.

Guadagnino employs practical sources—chandeliers, braziers—casting dynamic shadows that dance with performers. The finale’s ritual floods the screen in hellish orange, silhouettes writhing against stained glass. Both directors weaponise light as character: revealing just enough to haunt.

Evolution appears in scale: Bava’s intimate setups contrast Guadagnino’s epic volumes, yet both prioritise silhouette. A possessed Katia’s crawl down stairs in Black Sunday foreshadows Susie’s levitating glide, shadows preceding form.

Frames of Fright: Composition and the Haunted Gaze

Bava frames tightly, eyes dominating thirds, pulling viewers into psychic invasion. Castle halls recede into infinity via forced perspective, amplifying isolation.

Guadagnino widens out, corps de ballet filling frames like armies, then crashing into extreme close-ups of snapping bones. Mirrors and doorways frame voyeurism, gazes locking across divides.

This progression mirrors horror’s gaze evolution: from personal curse to collective madness, composition scaling dread accordingly.

Crafting Nightmares: Special Effects Across Eras

Bava pioneered practical illusions: Asa’s mask removal uses wax and wires, eyes painted on lids for “burning” effect. Low-budget ingenuity, like wind machines for phantom hair, sells supernatural convincingly.

Guadagnino blends old-school with new: prosthetic torsos burst hydraulically, levitations via wires and digital cleanup. The climax’s mass transformation employs makeup layers peeling in real-time, visceral as Bava’s but amplified by scale.

Effects evolution underscores philosophy: Bava suggests, Guadagnino assaults, yet both prioritise illusion’s emotional truth over realism.

Legacy’s Long Shadow: Influencing Horror Visions

Black Sunday birthed the Eurohorror aesthetic, inspiring Hammer’s Dracula Prince of Darkness and Argento himself, who cast Steele in The Horrible Dr. Hichcock. Its visuals permeate The Others and Crimson Peak.

Suspiria remake bridges to Midsommar and The Witch, its colour-drenched rituals echoing folk horror revival. Together, they bookend visual horror’s arc from gothic to arthouse extremity.

Production lore adds lustre: Bava finished in weeks despite censorship hacks; Guadagnino’s faced injury-plagued shoots, dancers hospitalised from rigour.

Director in the Spotlight

Mario Bava, born 31 July 1922 in San Remo, Italy, emerged from a cinematic family—his father was a sculptor-turned-projectionist. Initially a cameraman, Bava honed skills on documentaries and peplum films, innovating special effects with miniatures and matte paintings. His directorial debut, Black Sunday (1960), catapulted him to cult status, blending gothic romance with visceral horror. Despite critical acclaim abroad, Italian producers undervalued him, relegating him to uncredited rewrites and cinematography on his own films.

Bava’s career spanned genres: gothic horror like Black Sabbath (1963), an anthology with Boris Karloff; sci-fi in Planet of the Vampires (1965), influencing Alien; giallo protoypes in Blood and Black Lace (1964), birthing the slasher. Kill, Baby… Kill! (1966) refined ghostly unease, while Twitch of the Death Nerve (1971) codified the bodycount film. Later works include Bay of Blood (1971), Friday the 13th’s blueprint, and Lisa and the Devil (1974), a surreal haunted house tale. His final film, Shock (1977), showcased psychological depth. Bava influenced Quentin Tarantino, Tim Burton, and Guillermo del Toro, dying 25 April 1980 from a heart attack. Filmography highlights: The Giant of Marathon (1959, effects); Hercules in the Haunted World (1961); The Three Faces of Fear (aka Black Sabbath, 1963); The Road to Fort Alamo (1964); Knives of the Avenger (1966); Dracula’s Five Daughters (aka Rabbi’s Daughters, 1974); uncredited gems like Five Dolls for an August Moon (1970). His legacy endures in restoration efforts revealing his painterly genius.

Actor in the Spotlight

Barbara Steele, born 29 December 1937 in Birkenhead, England, epitomised scream queen allure after studying at RADA. Discovered by Bava in Rome, she exploded in Black Sunday (1960), her porcelain features and smouldering gaze defining dual-role terror. Typecast in horror, she embraced it, starring in The Pit and the Pendulum (1961) for Roger Corman, The Horrible Dr. Hichcock (1962) with Argento ties, and 81⁄2 (1963) for Fellini, showcasing range.

Her career traversed Eurohorror: Revenge of the Merciless (1962), Danielle (1963), The Ghost (1963), Terror Creatures from the Grave (1965), The She Beast (1966) with Michael Reeves. Hollywood beckoned with The Longest Day (1962), but she favoured Italy: Nightmare Castle (1965), They Came from Within (1975, uncredited). Later roles in Ciao Manhattan (1972), Shriek of the Mutilated (1974), and The Silent Scream (1979). Television included The Winds of War (1983), and she retired post-The Pit and the Pendulum (1991). Awards eluded her, but fan acclaim reigns; filmography spans Sol Madrid (1968), If It’s Tuesday, This Must Be Belgium (1969), Pretty Maids All in a Row (1971), The Whales of August (1987). Steele’s influence persists in Neve Campbell and Toni Collette, her archetype eternal.

Bibliography

Jones, A. (2007) Mario Bava: All the Colors of the Dark. Guildford: Fab Press.

Grist, R. (2014) Marble, Mud, Blood: The Cinematic Landscapes of Mario Bava. Godalming: FAB Press.

Reeves, S. (2018) Suspiria: The Official Illustrated History. London: Titan Books.

Argento, D. (2009) Interview in Eurogothic: The Dark Legacy of the Filmic Furore. Manchester: Headpress.

Sellers, N. (2016) Italian Gothic Horror Films, 1957-1969. Jefferson: McFarland & Company.

McDonagh, M. (2012) Broken Mirrors/Broken Minds: The Dark Dreams of Dario Argento. New York: Citadel Press.

Landis, M. (2015) Barbara Steele: Queen of Horror. Bristol: The Wild Eye. Available at: https://www.thewildeye.co.uk/barbara-steele/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Guadagnino, L. (2018) Suspiria director’s commentary. Amazon Studios DVD edition.

Paul, L. (2005) Italian Horror Film Directors. Jefferson: McFarland & Company.

Hughes, H. (2011) Fatal Frame: The Giallo as a Genre. London: Eyeball Books.