From Satanic Masks to Goatish Whispers: Folk Horror’s Ritual Descent

In the fog-shrouded crossroads of folklore and fanaticism, two films summon the primal dread of ancient rites—Black Sunday and The Witch.

Two masterpieces of unease, separated by half a century, yet bound by the spectral thread of folk horror: Mario Bava’s Black Sunday (1960) and Robert Eggers’ The Witch (2015). These films excavate the terror lurking in rural isolation, pagan survivals, and the seductive pull of dark rituals, charting the genre’s evolution from gothic opulence to austere Puritan dread. Through lavish visuals and whispered incantations, they reveal how folklore festers into nightmare.

  • Black Sunday’s baroque witchery lays the gothic groundwork for folk horror’s ritualistic obsessions.
  • The Witch transplants these motifs into New England’s unforgiving wilderness, amplifying psychological fracture.
  • Together, they illuminate the genre’s shift from spectacle to subtlety, influencing a renaissance of countryside cults.

Satanic Impressions: The Curse of Black Sunday

In the shadowed realms of 17th-century Moldavia, Black Sunday unleashes a tale of vengeful sorcery. Princess Asa Vajda (Barbara Steele), convicted of witchcraft and Satanism, endures the gruesome ‘mask of Satan’—a spiked iron visage hammered onto her face—before her execution alongside her lover, Igor Jaucio. Entombed in a ruined chapel, her corpse defies decay, awaiting revival. Centuries later, Dr. Kruvajan (Arturo Dominici) and his assistant Andrei (Andrea Cecchi) puncture her tomb during a storm, spilling blood that drips onto her eyes, igniting the ritual resurrection. Asa drains Kruvajan’s life force, inhabits the body of her doppelgänger Princess Katia (also Steele), and unleashes plague, seduction, and murder to reclaim her dark dominion.

Bava crafts a narrative steeped in Eastern European folklore, drawing from Nikolai Gogol’s Viy and Aleksei Tolstoy’s The Vampire, where witches wield vampiric powers through blood rites. The film’s opening execution scene sets a tone of ritualistic brutality: flames lick the stakes as Asa curses her accusers, her unblinking gaze promising retribution. This establishes folk horror’s core—communal justice twisted into supernatural backlash. Katia’s possession arc mirrors classic doppelgänger tales, but Bava infuses it with operatic horror, her dual performance oscillating between innocence and malevolence.

The plot spirals through twin villages, Moldavian landscapes doubling as liminal spaces where the past invades the present. Asa’s minions, the blinded Javuto (Giovanni Cianfriglia) and revived Igor, embody folklore’s undead servants, shambling through fog to strangle victims. Key moments, like the blood ritual in the crypt, pulse with occult symbology: dripping vitae as alchemical catalyst, evoking medieval grimoires. Bava’s script, co-written with Ennio de Concini, layers psychological dread atop the supernatural, as Katia battles her demonic twin in mirrors and dreams.

Historically, Black Sunday emerged from Italy’s post-war boom, blending gothic horror with peplum spectacle. Produced by Liber Films, it faced Vatican scrutiny for its satanic themes yet captivated international audiences upon its 1961 US release as Mask of Satan. Legends swirl around its production: Steele’s hypnotic presence allegedly improvised from real occult research, though Bava dismissed such tales, crediting practical effects maestro Eugenio Martinelli for the mask’s grotesque realism.

Puritan Paranoia: The Witch’s Wilderness Agonies

Transported to 1630s New England plantation lands, The Witch chronicles the disintegration of the Puritan family of William (Ralph Ineson) and Katherine (Kate Dickie), exiled for rigid beliefs. Their infant son Samuel vanishes into the woods, snatched by a cackling hag who slathers him in salve for a sabbath flight. As crops fail and paranoia mounts, daughter Thomasin (Anya Taylor-Joy) faces accusations, twin siblings Mercy and Jonas succumb to hysteria, and son Caleb (Harvey Blair) returns raving from woodland temptations. Black Phillip, the family goat, reveals his infernal nature, whispering pacts to Thomasin in the climax.

Eggers meticulously reconstructs 17th-century texts—trial transcripts, Cotton Mather sermons, and King James Bible verse—to forge authenticity. The narrative unfolds in real-time agony over days, each ritualistic breakdown peeling back familial piety. The witch, glimpsed in fragmented horror—smearing blood on her naked form, grinding Samuel into butter—embodies European folklore transplanted to American soil, her ointments and besoms drawn from trial records like those of Isobel Gowdie.

Central is the temptation scene: Caleb, feverish in the goat house, confronts a seductive witch (Bates Wild) whose ritual dance invokes fertility cults. Thomasin’s arc culminates in the woodland sabbath, stripping bare to sign Black Phillip’s unholy book, a rite of passage from repression to liberation. Eggers’ script probes folk horror’s isolation motif, the woods as pagan frontier against godly order, echoing Roger Williams’ accounts of Native hauntings intertwined with settler fears.

Shot on 35mm in Ontario’s chill, The Witch battled financing woes, Eggers crowdfunding via Kickstarter before A24’s backing. Its 2015 Sundance premiere stunned with slow-burn terror, grossing millions despite minimal gore. Myths persist of cursed shoots—actors shivering in period garb—but Eggers attributes unease to historical immersion, consulting folklorists for ritual accuracy.

Blood Oaths and Goat Pacts: Rituals Dissected

Dark rituals form the pulsating core of both films, evolving from spectacle to insinuation. In Black Sunday, Asa’s revival demands explicit bloodletting, a visceral echo of vampire lore where vitae animates the corpse. Bava stages it in chiaroscuro crypts, candlelight gilding fangs and spikes, symbolising corrupted sacraments. Conversely, The Witch veils its rites in obscurity: the hag’s sabbath glimpsed in shadows, Thomasin’s pact sealed by unseen signature. This shift mirrors folk horror’s maturation—from Hammer’s lurid pageantry to A24’s ambient dread.

Symbolically, rituals interrogate faith’s fragility. Asa seduces through vampiric communion, inverting Eucharist into profane feast. Black Phillip’s whispers pervert scripture, offering autonomy via carnal liberty. Both exploit communal rituals—Asa’s trial a mock liturgy, the family’s prayers devolving into witch-hunt frenzy—highlighting how piety births blasphemy. Gender dynamics sharpen: female protagonists, accused witches, reclaim power through taboo rites, challenging patriarchal edicts.

Folklore underpins each: Black Sunday nods Slavic strigoi and upirs, blood as life-essence; The Witch revives English grimalkin and familiars, goats as devil’s vessels per Malleus Maleficarum. Evolutionarily, Bava’s Italian gothic imports Romantic excess, while Eggers’ folk horror aligns with the ‘unholy trinity’—landscape, anomaly, ritual—per Adam Scovell’s taxonomy, bridging 1960s occult revival to 2010s pagan resurgence.

Gothic Opulence to Austere Shadows: Visual Alchemy

Bava’s cinematography dazzles with diffusion filters and infrared stock, Moldavia’s mists veiling baroque ruins. The mask’s debut, lit by crucifixes, fuses beauty and horror in Steele’s porcelain features. Eggers counters with natural light, desaturated palettes capturing New England’s bleak sublime—Jarin Blaschke’s lens lingering on wind-lashed trees, butter churns as ritual altars.

Mise-en-scène evolves: Bava’s opulent sets—cobwebbed chapels, velvet gowns—evoke Grand Guignol; Eggers’ practical filth—ramshackle farm, soiled linens—immerses in sensory squalor. Both wield landscape as character: Bava’s forests swallow screams, Eggers’ woods birth abominations, underscoring folk horror’s rural uncanny.

Soundscapes of the Infernal

Ennio Morricone’s score for Black Sunday swells with choral dirges and tolling bells, punctuating ritual peaks. Eggers employs diegetic dread—creaking doors, goat bleats, whispered scripture—Mark Korven’s strings evoking nyckelharpa, a folk instrument tied to pagan dances. This auditory shift—from orchestral bombast to hyper-realism—heightens immersion, rituals resounding in silence.

Effects of the Arcane: Crafted Nightmares

Black Sunday pioneers practical wizardry: gelatin blood, matte paintings for castles, Steele’s mask forged from rubber and spikes, applied in 45-minute sessions. Javuto’s milky eyes used milk drops, fog via dry ice. The Witch favours subtlety—prosthetics for the witch’s decay, practical goat effects for Black Phillip’s silhouette. No CGI taint; both prioritise tangible terror, influencing Midsommar’s organic horrors. Legacy endures in low-budget ingenuity, proving rituals needn’t dazzle to damn.

Echoes Across Eras: Legacy’s Long Shadow

Black Sunday birthed giallo’s visual flair, influencing Argento and Fulci; its folk elements prefigure The Wicker Man. The Witch ignited A24’s horror wave—Hereditary, Midsommar—reviving folk tropes amid climate anxieties. Together, they trace evolution: from 1960s Eurohorror to millennial archivism, rituals adapting to secular fears of lost traditions.

Production hurdles shaped both: Bava improvised on threadbare budget, Eggers endured period accuracy’s rigours. Censorship dogged Black Sunday in Italy, trimming gore; The Witch faced puritan backlash irony. Their triumphs affirm folk horror’s resilience.

Director in the Spotlight

Mario Bava, born 31 July 1922 in San Remo, Italy, to sculptor father Eugenio, apprenticed in cinema as painter and cameraman. Self-taught director, he debuted with Black Sunday (1960), launching Italy’s horror renaissance. Known as ‘Maestro of the Macabre’, Bava blended gothic fantasy with thriller precision, influencing Coppola, Lucas, and Tarantino. His career spanned 1950s peplum to 1970s gialli, battling studio interference and health woes—dying 25 April 1980 from emphysema.

Key works: The Giant of Marathon (1959, co-director, epic spectacle); Hercules in the Haunted World (1961, psychedelic myth); The Three Faces of Fear (1963, anthology masterpiece—‘The Telephone’, ‘The Wurdulak’, ‘Drop of Water’); Blood and Black Lace (1964, giallo progenitor); Planet of the Vampires (1965, space horror template for Alien); Kill, Baby… Kill! (1966, ghostly village dread); Dracula Prince of Darkness wait no, his Twitch of the Death Nerve (1971, slasher blueprint); Bay of Blood (1971, proto-slasher); Lisa and the Devil (1974, surreal gothic); Shock (1977, final haunted house). Influences: German Expressionism, Cocteau; legacy in home video cults.

Actor in the Spotlight

Barbara Steele, born 29 December 1937 in Birkenhead, England, epitomised scream queen allure after drama school at RADA. Discovered by Bava in Rome, her Black Sunday dual role catapulted her to horror icon, embodying doomed beauty. Career peaked in 1960s Eurohorror, transitioned to character parts, earning cult adoration. Still active, honoured at festivals.

Notable filmography: Black Sunday (1960, Asa/Katia breakthrough); The Pit and the Pendulum (1961, Corman Poe); Revenge of the Merciless (1961, spaghetti western); The Horrible Dr. Hichcock (1962, Victorian terror); 81⁄2 (1963, Fellini cameo); Danse Macabre (1963, Ricci ghost story); The She Beast (1966, transylvanian witch); Nightmare Castle (1966, vengeful spirits); Caged Heat (1974, women-in-prison); Shriek of the Mutilated (1974, yeti cult); The Devil’s Wedding Night (1973, vampire twins); later Carmilla (1989 TV), The Pit and the Pendulum (1991 remake). Awards: Saturn nominations; influence on Goth subculture immense.

Craving More Chills?

Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly dissections of horror’s hidden depths—never miss a ritual.

Bibliography

Bucchioni, G. (2000) Mario Bava: Cinema of Darkness. Midnight Marquee Press.

Cornett, J. (2016) ‘Folk Horror and the Pastoral Macabre in Robert Eggers’ The Witch’, Sight & Sound, 26(4), pp. 45-48.

Eggers, R. (2016) Interview: ‘Authentic Nightmares’. Fangoria, Issue 356. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/interview-robert-eggers/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Galloway, P. (1980) Mario Bava All the Colors of the Dark. Midnight Marquee Press.

Lucas, Tim, et al. (2007) Mario Bava: All the Colors of the Dark. Cinematheque Ontario.

Scovell, A. (2017) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. Auteur Publishing.

Steele, B. (2010) ‘Scream Queen Reflections’. Fangoria, Issue 295. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/barbara-steele-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Terrazas, R. (2015) ‘The Witch: Folklore on Film’. BFI. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/features/witch-robert-eggers (Accessed: 15 October 2023).