In 1872 the brigantine Mary Celeste was found drifting in the Atlantic with its crew gone, meals still on the table and the captain’s pipe set aside as if he had only stepped away for a moment. This article examines the documented cases of ghost ships from the 17th century onward, including the Flying Dutchman legend, the Mary Celeste discovery, the Carroll A. Deering incident and later examples such as the Kaz II, while reviewing official inquiries, witness statements and the main explanations that historians and maritime researchers have offered.

The story of the Flying Dutchman begins with a 17th-century account of a Dutch captain named Hendrick van der Decken who refused to turn back during a violent storm off the Cape of Good Hope. According to the tale he swore he would round the cape even if it took until the end of time, and the ship was thereafter condemned to sail without rest. That single act of defiance turned the vessel into a recurring omen whose appearance was said to foretell disaster for any who saw it.

Recorded sightings continued for centuries and often came from trained observers rather than casual passers-by. In 1835 the British survey ship Leven reported a glowing vessel under full sail in calm conditions off South Africa, with figures visible on deck before the image broke apart. Prince George, later King George V, is said to have noted a similar sighting in 1880 while serving as a midshipman on HMS Inconstant. A claimed 1939 encounter by a German U-boat crew added a wartime layer to the record, though the details remain difficult to verify. Many researchers point to the optical effect known as Fata Morgana, in which layers of warm and cold air bend light to produce the illusion of a ship hovering above the horizon. Yet the repeated descriptions of a red glow and crew members who seem to wave for help keep the older interpretation alive in popular discussion.

The Mary Celeste: The Classic Enigma of 1872

The Mary Celeste remains the most thoroughly documented case. On 4 December 1872 the Dei Gratia came across the vessel drifting between the Azores and Portugal. Captain Benjamin Briggs, his wife Sarah, their two-year-old daughter Sophia and seven crew members had left New York ten days earlier bound for Genoa with a cargo of denatured alcohol. No distress signal had been sent and the ship was still under sail when found.

Discovery and Initial Clues

Captain David Morehouse and his men boarded a vessel that showed no structural damage. The cargo was largely intact, although one barrel had been opened. Plates with uneaten food sat in the galley, a sewing machine held partially finished cloth, and the captain’s pipe rested beside his bed. The only lifeboat was missing. A sword found under the bed showed staining that was later judged not to be blood. The last log entry, written nine days before the discovery, recorded calm weather roughly 400 miles from the position where the ship was found. These ordinary details matter because they suggest the departure happened without obvious violence or storm damage.

Investigations and Theories

The formal inquiry held in Gibraltar ruled out mutiny and piracy because no signs of struggle appeared. Later writers suggested alcohol fumes might have prompted the crew to abandon ship in the lifeboat, which then foundered, yet the hatches remained undamaged and the cargo showed no evidence of explosion. Other proposals included a waterspout or sudden seaquake that could have tilted the deck without leaving lasting marks. Arthur Conan Doyle’s 1884 short story J. Habakuk Jephson’s Statement moved the episode into fiction and helped fix the image of a cursed ship in the public mind. The Mary Celeste itself continued trading until it ran aground off Haiti in 1885. The absence of any bodies or wreckage from the lifeboat still leaves the central question open: why would an experienced captain leave a sound vessel in mid-ocean?

Other Haunting Voyages: Carroll A. Deering and Beyond

The five-masted schooner Carroll A. Deering ran aground on Diamond Shoals in January 1921 after sailing from Brazil toward Norfolk. When coastguards reached the wreck they found the rigging cut, the lifeboats gone and the galley cleared of provisions, yet the holds remained untouched. Earlier sightings had placed the ship under bare poles during a storm and then, oddly, under red sails. Government investigators considered rum-runners or mutineers as possible causes, but no conclusive evidence emerged and Captain W.B. Wormell was never seen again. Boarding parties later spoke of an unsettling atmosphere around the stranded hull.

Similar patterns appear in other documented cases. In 1881 the Ellen Austin encountered a derelict in the Sargasso Sea whose boarding party reported doors slamming and shadows moving inside; the vessel disappeared twice and each time returned empty. The MV Joyita, found capsized near Fiji in 1955, showed bloodstains and slashed cushions while its medical cargo had vanished. In 2007 the Australian catamaran Kaz II was located with an open laptop, uneaten food and lifejackets still aboard, yet its three occupants were never found despite calm seas and modern search resources. These repeated details of seaworthy craft, missing boats and undisturbed personal items form a thread that runs across more than a century of records.

Scientific Explanations Versus Paranormal Theories

Maritime specialists note that rogue waves reaching 30 metres can strike without warning and that piracy or insurance fraud have been proven in other disappearances. Isolation, spoiled food or leaking fumes can also affect judgment and lead a crew to abandon a vessel that later proves sound. Ocean currents quickly scatter debris, which explains why so little physical evidence survives. At the same time, paranormal researchers have recorded electronic voice phenomena on replica voyages and note that some sighting clusters exceed what simple mirages would produce. Indigenous accounts from both North American and Polynesian traditions describe spirit vessels that parallel the European stories, suggesting the sea itself may be viewed across cultures as a place where ordinary rules bend.

Cultural Impact and Modern Echoes

The image of the crewless ship has moved from logbooks into opera, painting and cinema, from Coleridge’s Ancient Mariner to the 2002 film Ghost Ship. Contemporary interest continues through drone surveys and satellite tracking of drifting vessels. The Sam Ratulangi PB 1600, found adrift in Indonesian waters in 2009, prompted fresh comparisons with the classic cases. As explored on Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these incidents keep drawing attention because they sit at the edge of what records can confirm and what remains open to interpretation.

Bibliography

Charles Edey Fay, The Story of the Mary Celeste (1942).

Richard A. Gould, Archaeology and the Social History of Ships (Cambridge University Press, 2011).

David F. Ritchie, Ghost Ships: True Stories of the Dead and Derelict (2008).

United States Coast Guard, Report on the Carroll A. Deering (1921 inquiry records).

Gibraltar Vice Admiralty Court, Mary Celeste inquiry transcript (1873).

Brian Hicks, Ghost Ship: The Mysterious True Story of the Mary Celeste (2004).

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Rogue Wave Studies (updated through 2024).

Australian Transport Safety Bureau, Kaz II investigation report (2008).

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289