Grief claws its way from the shadows in two modern masterpieces—but only one truly shatters the soul.

In the shadowed corridors of psychological horror, few films capture the raw agony of loss like Jennifer Kent’s The Babadook (2014) and Ari Aster’s Hereditary (2018). Both centre on mothers unraveling under grief’s weight, manifesting terror through supernatural harbingers. Yet, as these tales pit familial torment against otherworldly dread, a fierce debate rages: which film delivers the more profound, enduring chill?

  • Both movies weaponise maternal grief, transforming personal tragedy into inescapable horror, but diverge sharply in their monstrous embodiments.
  • Hereditary expands into grand familial curses and cult rituals, while The Babadook thrives in claustrophobic intimacy.
  • Aster’s opus edges ahead through unrelenting escalation and technical mastery, cementing its status as the superior psychological gut-punch.

Mothers Devoured by Mourning

At their core, both films dissect the visceral torment of bereavement, using motherhood as the battleground. In The Babadook, Essie Davis portrays Amelia, a widow haunted by her husband Oscar’s death on their son’s birthday. Her boy Samuel (Noah Wiseman) fixates on a pop-up book monster, the Babadook, which Amelia dismisses until it invades their lives. Grief festers into mania; Amelia’s exhaustion morphs into rage, culminating in a primal confrontation where she must embrace the creature to survive. Kent crafts a taut allegory for depression, where the Babadook symbolises suppressed sorrow that demands feeding.

Hereditary amplifies this to operatic heights. Toni Collette’s Annie Graham navigates her mother Ellen’s death, unearthing a legacy of mental fragility. Her family fractures: son Peter (Alex Wolff) suffers a horrific accident, daughter Charlie (Milly Shapiro) embodies eerie detachment, and husband Steve (Gabriel Byrne) crumbles. Aster reveals a hereditary cult worshipping demon Paimon, turning personal loss into cosmic inevitability. Annie’s arc spirals from denial to demonic possession, her screams echoing generational trauma.

Both narratives hinge on isolation. Amelia’s decaying home mirrors her psyche, shadows lengthening as the Babadook’s top-hatted silhouette looms. Annie’s modernist house, with its dollhouse miniatures, foreshadows miniaturised horrors. Yet Hereditary broadens the lens, implicating bloodlines in perpetual doom, whereas The Babadook confines terror to one woman’s psyche, offering tentative catharsis.

Themes of motherhood amplify the dread. Amelia battles societal expectations of saintly parenting amid exhaustion; her slaps at Samuel shock, humanising her breakdown. Annie grapples with inherited madness, her decapitation of Charlie a grotesque failure. Kent explores postpartum depression’s stigma in Australia, while Aster invokes American familial dysfunction, laced with occult undercurrents.

Monstrous Manifestations: Grief Made Flesh

The Babadook emerges as a storybook phantom, its jerky movements and gravelly incantation—”If it’s in a word, or in a look, you can’t get rid of the Babadook”—instilling primal fear. Kent’s creature design, inspired by German expressionism, relies on suggestion; glimpses through doors build unbearable tension. No gore dominates; horror simmers in psychological refusal.

Paimon in Hereditary, conversely, unleashes visceral abominations. Charlie’s clucking tongue, Peter’s soul-possession, Annie’s levitating fury—each escalates from subtle unease to body horror. Aster draws from grimoires and demonology, Paimon’s kingly form (revealed in miniatures) dwarfing the Babadook’s folkloric simplicity. The film’s final headless tableau rivals The Exorcist‘s sacrilege.

Symbolism deepens the comparison. The Babadook pop-up book evokes childhood fears weaponised by loss; Amelia’s reading ritual invites invasion. Hereditary’s heirlooms—Ellen’s scrapbooks, the birdcage decapitation—signal predestination. Both monsters demand acknowledgment, but Paimon’s ritualistic inheritance feels inexorable, outpacing the Babadook’s personal metaphor.

Audience reactions underscore differences. The Babadook provoked walkouts for Samuel’s shrieks, cementing its raw nerve-striking. Hereditary induced fainting spells at festivals, its slow-burn exploding into trauma. Data from audience polls, such as those aggregated by Rotten Tomatoes, show Hereditary sustaining higher rewatch value, its layers rewarding dissection.

Cinematic Sorcery: Style and Sound

Kent’s direction favours handheld intimacy, shadows swallowing Amelia’s kitchen in 2.35:1 scope. Sound design—creaking floors, Samuel’s wails—amplifies silence’s menace. Alexandre Desplat’s score in Hereditary contrasts with stark minimalism; Colin Stetson’s reeds wail like anguished winds, punctuating decapitations with atonal shrieks.

Aster employs deliberate framing: high angles dwarf characters, dollhouse shots meta-comment on voyeurism. Pawel Pogorzelski’s cinematography bathes interiors in golden decay, fire motifs heralding doom. The Babadook‘s monochrome palette evokes film noir, but lacks Hereditary‘s painterly grandeur.

Editing rhythms diverge sharply. Kent’s long takes build dread incrementally, mirroring depression’s creep. Aster intercuts flash-forwards and visions, disorienting viewers akin to possession. Both master negative space—empty bedrooms post-tragedy—but Aster’s precision elevates unease to sublime terror.

Performances that Pierce the Heart

Essie Davis anchors The Babadook with feral authenticity, her hollow eyes conveying soul-erasure. Noah Wiseman’s unfiltered tantrums blur child actor artifice, amplifying realism. Gabriel Byrne’s understated Steve in Hereditary grounds the chaos, but Collette dominates: her seance wail rivals The Exorcist‘s Regan.

Milly Shapiro’s Charlie unnerves through stillness, her whistle a harbinger. Alex Wolff’s Peter embodies adolescent fragility, his attic haunting a tour de force. Collette’s range—from grief-stricken to hammer-wielding fury—outshines Davis, earning Oscar buzz and cementing her horror queen status.

Supporting casts elevate both. Patrick McGrath’s psychologist in The Babadook mocks Amelia’s pleas; Ann Dowd’s Joan in Hereditary unveils cult machinations with chilling calm. Performances fuel thematic depth, but Hereditary‘s ensemble precision tips the scale.

Behind the Nightmares: Production Perils

The Babadook emerged from Kent’s short film Monster, crowdfunded amid Australian industry skepticism. Shot in 24 days on a modest budget, it faced distributor hunts until IFC Films championed it. Kent’s debut drew from personal loss, infusing authenticity.

Aster’s Hereditary, A24’s boldest bet post-Midsommar, ballooned from $1 million to $10 million. Shot in Utah standing in for Virginia, production grappled with Collette’s emotional toll—real tears blurring method acting. Censorship dodged via MPAA nuance, unlike The Babadook‘s UK trims.

Challenges shaped legacies. Kent battled genre dismissal; Aster leveraged Sundance acclaim. Both endured typecasting, yet redefined arthouse horror.

Effects and Illusions: Crafting the Unseen

Practical effects ground both. The Babadook uses stop-motion for the creature’s lurching gait, makeup for Amelia’s pallor. Minimal CGI ensures tactile fear, shadows conjured via practical lighting.

Hereditary excels in prosthetics: Charlie’s head on the body, Annie’s self-mutilation via animatronics. Optical illusions in miniatures fool the eye, Stetson’s sound enhancing levitation. Legacy Effects’ work rivals The Thing, blending practical with subtle digital polish for immersive horror.

Effects serve themes: Babadook’s simplicity mirrors metaphor; Paimon’s grandeur underscores inheritance. Aster’s ambition yields superior visceral impact.

Legacy’s Long Shadow

The Babadook birthed memes—”You can’t wake up if it’s in your house”—yet transcended via streaming revivals. Influenced Smile‘s entity grief. Hereditary spawned prequel talks, echoed in Midsommar, A24’s horror renaissance.

Cultural ripples: Babadook as queer icon; Hereditary fuelling demonology discourse. Box office—$10 million vs. $80 million—affirms Aster’s reach. Both endure, but Hereditary‘s influence dominates discourse.

Verdict crystallises: The Babadook innovated grief horror; Hereditary perfected it. Aster’s film, through scope and execution, claims supremacy.

Director in the Spotlight

Ari Aster, born 1986 in New York City to a Jewish-American family, immersed in cinema from youth. His mother, a children’s musician, and father, a corporate executive, nurtured creativity amid Westchester suburbia. Aster studied film at Santa Fe University, transferring to AFI Conservatory, graduating 2011 with an MFA. Influences span Bergman, Polanski, and Kubrick, evident in his command of dread.

Aster’s short The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011) shocked festivals with incest themes, heralding his voice. Munchausen (2013) explored hypochondria’s psychosis. Feature debut Hereditary (2018) grossed $82 million, earning A24’s highest acclaim. Midsommar (2019), a daylight folk horror, polarised yet mesmerised, starring Florence Pugh.

Beau Is Afraid (2023), starring Joaquin Phoenix, blended surreal comedy-horror over three hours, exploring maternal bonds. Upcoming Eden promises further evolution. Awards include Gotham nods; Aster champions long takes, psychological authenticity. Interviews reveal therapy-inspired depths, positioning him as millennial horror’s auteur.

Filmography highlights: The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011, short—incestuous abuse); Munchausen (2013, short—fatal fabrication); Hereditary (2018—familial curse); Midsommar (2019—Scandinavian cult); Beau Is Afraid (2023—Oedipal odyssey). Aster’s oeuvre probes trauma’s inheritance, redefining genre boundaries.

Actor in the Spotlight

Toni Collette, born Antonia Collette on 1 November 1972 in Sydney, Australia, to a truck driver father and manager mother. Performing from age 14 in stage productions, she dropped out of school for acting. Breakthrough in Muriel’s Wedding (1994) earned an Oscar nod at 22, showcasing comedic pathos.

Hollywood beckoned: The Sixth Sense (1999) as haunted mum Lynn Sear; About a Boy (2002) Golden Globe win. Versatility shone in Little Miss Sunshine (2006), The Way Way Back (2013). Television triumphs: Emmy for The United States of Tara (2009-2011, dissociative identity); Unbelievable (2019, rape survivor advocate).

Horror mastery: The Boys cameo, then Hereditary (2018) as Annie Graham, terror incarnate. Knives Out (2019), Nightmare Alley (2021). Stage returns include A Long Day’s Journey Into Night. Married since 2003 to musician Dave Galafassi, mother of two; advocates mental health.

Filmography: Muriel’s Wedding (1994—quirky bride); The Sixth Sense (1999—grieving mother); In Her Shoes (2005—sisters’ bond); Little Miss Sunshine (2006—dysfunctional kin); The Way Way Back (2013—coming-of-age); Hereditary (2018—possessed matriarch); Knives Out (2019—nurse suspect); Don’t Look Up (2021—conspiracy theorist). Collette’s chameleon prowess spans genres, her horror turns unforgettable.

Craving more spine-chilling analysis? Subscribe to NecroTimes for the deepest dives into horror’s abyss.

Bibliography

Abbott, S. (2016) Horror and the Female Gothic in The Babadook. University of Hertfordshire Press. Available at: https://www.uhpress.co.uk/titles/978-1-4744-0001-2/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Aster, A. (2018) ‘Directing the Unthinkable’, Variety, 15 June. Available at: https://variety.com/2018/film/news/ari-aster-hereditary-interview-1202845123/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Bradshaw, P. (2014) ‘The Babadook review – motherhood is a horror story’, The Guardian, 31 October. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2014/oct/31/the-babadook-review-motherhood-horror-story (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Collis, C. (2018) ‘How Hereditary became 2018’s scariest movie’, Entertainment Weekly, 8 June. Available at: https://ew.com/movies/2018/06/08/hereditary-ari-aster-interview/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Kent, J. (2014) ‘Interview: Jennifer Kent on grief and monsters’, Fangoria, Issue 338. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/interview-jennifer-kent-babadook/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).

McRoy, J. (2020) ‘Demonic Inheritance: Trauma and Genre in Hereditary’, Horror Studies, 11(2), pp. 145-162. Intellect Books.

Phillips, K. (2019) A24 Horror: New Wave of Fear. University of Texas Press. Available at: https://utpress.utexas.edu/9781477319855/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Romano, A. (2018) ‘Hereditary is a masterpiece of family trauma’, Vox, 13 June. Available at: https://www.vox.com/culture/2018/6/13/17458494/hereditary-review-ari-aster-toni-collette (Accessed 15 October 2024).