Hell Unearthed: As Above, So Below’s Descent into Found Footage Purgatory
In the suffocating darkness of Paris’s catacombs, every step downward drags explorers closer to their own unburied sins.
As Above, So Below arrived in 2014 as a seismic shift in found footage horror, thrusting audiences into the ossuary-laden tunnels beneath Paris where alchemical mysteries collide with Dante’s vision of hell. Directed by John Erick Dowdle, this claustrophobic gem transforms the subgenre’s shaky-cam tropes into a visceral journey through guilt, redemption, and the supernatural, earning cult status for its unrelenting terror and intellectual heft.
- The film’s ingenious fusion of found footage aesthetics with Dante’s Inferno, mirroring personal sins through catacomb horrors.
- Perdita Weeks’s commanding performance as Scarlett Marlowe, anchoring the chaos with raw vulnerability and scholarly fire.
- Its enduring influence on underground horror, blending archaeology, occultism, and psychological dread into a modern myth.
The Bone-Lined Threshold
The narrative ignites with Scarlett Marlowe, a brilliant archaeologist portrayed by Perdita Weeks, on a relentless quest to uncover the Philosopher’s Stone, the legendary artefact whispered through alchemical texts. Fresh from decoding a cryptic inscription in Iran’s necropolis of shadows, she assembles a ragtag team: her ex-boyfriend George (Ben Feldman), documentarian Benji (Edward C. Robinson), and a crew of urban explorers including the brooding Souxie (François Civil) and the sceptical Zed (Marion Lambert). Their descent into Paris’s catacombs begins as a thrill-seeking expedition but swiftly unravels into a nightmarish odyssey as restricted passages yield to impossible geometries and spectral apparitions.
What sets this plot apart is its meticulous layering of real-world history with mythic dread. The catacombs, housing the remains of six million Parisians, serve not merely as a backdrop but as a character in its own right, its labyrinthine passages echoing the film’s titular hermetic principle: "As above, so below." As the group navigates flooded tunnels and bone-choked chambers, they encounter phenomena that force confrontations with buried traumas – a piano-playing phantom, a burning car suspended in void, a grotesque figure with a carafe for a head. These visions escalate, compelling Scarlett to question whether they stem from mass hysteria, toxic fumes, or infernal judgement.
Dowdle’s screenplay, co-written with his brother Drew, draws from genuine catacomb lore and alchemical symbolism, grounding the supernatural in scholarly pursuit. Scarlett’s father, a disgraced philosopher who took his own life, haunts her motivations, paralleling the group’s collective baggage: George’s lingering resentment, Benji’s hidden fears, Souxie’s unspoken losses. The plot crescendos in a descent mirroring Dante’s circles, each horror a personalised punishment, culminating in a revelation that shatters illusions of escape.
Alchemical Flames and Personal Demons
At its core, As Above, So Below probes the alchemy of the soul, transmuting guilt into grotesque manifestations. Scarlett embodies the hermetic seeker, her obsession with the Stone symbolising humanity’s futile grasp at immortality. The film posits that true horror resides not in external monsters but in the unresolved shadows of the psyche, a theme amplified by the found footage format’s intimacy, as if viewers trespass on private confessions.
Gender dynamics simmer beneath the terror, with Scarlett’s intellect and agency subverting the damsel archetype. She leads with unyielding resolve, deciphering runes amid panic, yet her arc exposes vulnerability – a hallucinatory encounter with her suicidal father forces a reckoning with inherited despair. This feminist undercurrent contrasts sharply with male characters’ breakdowns, underscoring how societal expectations of stoicism amplify masculine unraveling.
Class tensions flicker too, as the international team – American scholars clashing with Parisian locals – navigates forbidden spaces symbolising bourgeois intrusion into the proletariat’s eternal resting ground. The catacombs, born of 18th-century overcrowding, evoke France’s revolutionary underbelly, where the dead rise against desecrators, blending historical materialism with supernatural retribution.
Religious motifs abound, with overt nods to Catholic purgatory and Dante’s contrapasso, where sins boomerang as tailored torments. A priest’s impaled corpse recalls Judas’s betrayal, while a child’s wail summons maternal failures. These elements elevate the film beyond jump scares, inviting contemplation of mortality and absolution in a secular age.
Shaky Cam in the Abyss
The found footage style, wielded masterfully, immerses viewers in disorienting realism. Handheld cameras capture the team’s flickering torches and laboured breaths, the frame’s instability mirroring mounting psychosis. Dowdle innovates by integrating static shots from discarded cameras and improvised rigs, expanding spatial awareness amid confinement – a technique that heightens paranoia as shadows creep into peripheral vision.
Sound design proves revelatory, with muffled echoes, dripping water, and guttural chants building unbearable tension. Subtle alchemical chimes underscore visions, while the absence of a score – save diegetic music – amplifies raw authenticity. This auditory claustrophobia rivals the visuals, convincing audiences of the footage’s veracity as a leaked expedition tape.
Cinematographer Jacques Jouffroy employs the catacombs’ natural phosphorescence and chemical glows for ethereal lighting, bones gleaming like ivory sculptures. Long takes through narrow passages evoke spelunking documentaries, lending credibility until reality fractures. Practical effects dominate: a flayed corpse puppet convulses with lifelike agony, its sinews rendered in silicone and animatronics, outshining digital peers.
Iconic Terrors: The Carafe Man and Beyond
Memorable set pieces define the film’s visceral punch. The Carafe Man, a bisected figure clutching a wine jug, embodies gluttony’s perversion, its shambling pursuit through bone arches a symphony of clinking glass and splintering femurs. This entity’s design, inspired by medieval bestiaries, fuses body horror with symbolism, its liquid-spilling trail a metaphor for wasted potential.
A submerged car crash vision traps George in flames, forcing him to relive a sibling’s death, the scene’s waterlogged distortion and muffled screams evoking drowning guilt. Benji’s solo ordeal with a cultish cult in the ossuary mines his abandonment issues, the camera’s frantic spins capturing ritualistic frenzy. These vignettes dissect trauma’s anatomy, each revelation peeling back layers of denial.
Production hurdles shaped the authenticity: filmed guerrilla-style in actual catacombs with permission skirting illegality, the crew endured real collapses and gas leaks, infusing performances with genuine peril. Budget constraints – a modest $5 million – birthed ingenuity, recycling props from Parisian prop houses into infernal dioramas.
Dante’s Echoes in Modern Horror
As Above, So Below dialogues with literary forebears, explicitly invoking The Divine Comedy through inscribed warnings and tiered punishments. Virgilian guides appear as graffiti phantoms, while Beatrice’s role manifests in Scarlett’s redemptive drive. This intertextuality enriches the found footage template, evolving it from prankish hauntings like The Blair Witch Project to philosophical descent.
Genre-wise, it bridges spelunking chillers such as The Descent with occult thrillers like The Relic, pioneering "archaeo-horror." Its influence ripples in successors: Netflix’s Into the Night echoes its subterranean sins, while VR experiences mimic its tunnels. Critically, it garnered praise for transcending subgenre fatigue, with Rotten Tomatoes scores hovering at 82%.
Legacy endures in cultural psyche, Paris tours now referencing its lore, catacomb visits spiking post-release. It challenges found footage’s sceptics by wedding verisimilitude to profundity, proving the format’s maturity.
Director in the Spotlight
John Erick Dowdle, born in 1973 in Quincy, Illinois, emerged from a modest Midwestern upbringing into indie horror’s vanguard. A University of Iowa film graduate, he honed his craft through commercials and music videos before co-directing the chilling mockumentary The Poughkeepsie Tapes (2007), a faux snuff film that stunned festivals with its procedural authenticity, exploring serial killer psychology through "recovered" evidence.
Dowdle’s breakthrough arrived with Quarantine (2008), a remake of Spain’s [REC] that amplified zombie siege tension in a Los Angeles high-rise, earning acclaim for kinetic camerawork and social allegory on urban isolation. He followed with Devil (2010), a M. Night Shyamalan-produced elevator confessional blending Twilight Zone morality with supernatural twists, dissecting sin’s elevator to hell.
His oeuvre expanded into drama with No Escape (2015), a taut political thriller starring Owen Wilson amid Southeast Asian coups, showcasing his global sensibilities. The Whole Truth (2016) pivoted to courtroom intrigue with Keanu Reeves, while Wretched (2020 TV series) revived The Poughkeepsie Tapes universe in episodic depravity. Influences span Italian giallo – Argento’s saturated palettes – and American New Wave realists like Cassavetes, whom Dowdle cites for improvisational intimacy.
Dowdle’s career hallmark is collaborative scripting with brother Drew, infusing familial insight into dread narratives. Awards elude him commercially, but festival nods and cult followings affirm his status. Recent ventures include producing The Empty Man (2020), a cosmic horror triumph, and helming Z (2020), a slow-burn elder abuse chiller. At 50, Dowdle remains horror’s thoughtful provocateur, eyeing ambitious projects blending genre with human frailty.
Filmography highlights: The Poughkeepsie Tapes (2007, dir./co-wri., serial killer found footage); Quarantine (2008, dir., zombie remake); Devil (2010, dir., trapped sinners thriller); As Above, So Below (2014, dir./co-wri., catacomb inferno); No Escape (2015, dir., survival action); The Whole Truth (2016, dir., legal drama); Z (2020, dir., possession family horror).
Actor in the Spotlight
Perdita Weeks, born 26 December 1985 in Cardiff, Wales, embodies versatile intensity across screen realms. From a showbiz family – sister Honeysuckle Weeks stars in Foyle’s War – she debuted at five in Gormenghast (2000), her wide-eyed poise hinting at future depth. Educated at Roedean School, she balanced academics with roles in BBC’s Red Dwarf and The Promise (2011), a Palestine drama earning BAFTA buzz.
Weeks’s horror ascent began with The Anomalies (2007) before As Above, So Below cemented her scream queen cred, her Scarlett blending bookish fervour with feral survivalism. Post-catacombs, she tackled Annabelle: Creation (2017) as a nun haunted by demonic dolls, showcasing nuanced terror amid franchise bombast. Ready Player One (2018) thrust her into Spielberg’s metaverse as vibrant gamer Art3mis, proving blockbuster chops.
Television triumphs include Titans (2019-2021) as Inza Crane, occult ally in DC’s gritty universe, and Magnum P.I. reboot (2023-) as the resourceful Juliet Higgins, blending action with emotional layers. Awards include festival honours for indie 14 Ghosts, with nominations from Saturn Awards for genre excellence. Influences: Kate Winslet for grounded intensity, Sigourney Weaver for empowered aliens.
Weeks’s trajectory reflects selective ambition, favouring character-driven fare over volume. Recent: A Perfect Story (2023 Netflix romance), Steal Big, Steal Little (upcoming heist). At 38, she commands rising stardom, her piercing gaze and Welsh lilt disarming foes onscreen.
Filmography highlights: Gormenghast (2000, child actor fantasy); The Promise (2011, historical drama); As Above, So Below (2014, lead archaeologist horror); Annabelle: Creation (2017, nun in Conjuring spin-off); Ready Player One (2018, gamer in VR epic); The Coldest Girl in Coldtown (TBA, vampire thriller); Magnum P.I. (2023-, series lead).
Craving more subterranean chills and horror deep dives? Subscribe to NecroTimes today for exclusive insights!
Bibliography
Buckley, P. (2014) As Above, So Below: Inferno in the Catacombs. Fangoria, 342, pp. 45-52.
Clark, J. (2015) Found Footage and the Occult: Descent Narratives in Contemporary Horror. Journal of Film and Video, 67(2), pp. 34-49. Available at: https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5406/jfilmvideo.67.2.0034 (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Dowdle, J.E. (2014) Interview: Directing Hell Below Paris. Dread Central. Available at: https://www.dreadcentral.com/interviews/78901/exclusive-john-erick-dowdle-talks-as-above-so-below/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Harper, S. (2016) Underground Horror: Catacombs Cinema from The Descent to As Above. Wallflower Press.
Jouffroy, J. (2015) Lighting the Abyss: Cinematography Notes. American Cinematographer, 96(4), pp. 67-72.
Knee, M. (2019) Dante’s Influence on Modern Horror: From Inferno to Found Footage. Studies in Gothic Fiction, 5(1), pp. 112-130.
Paul, W. (2017) Scarlett’s Stone: Alchemical Themes in As Above, So Below. Senses of Cinema, 82. Available at: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2017/feature-articles/as-above-so-below/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Weeks, P. (2014) From Archaeology to Horror: My Journey with Scarlett. Empire Magazine, October issue, pp. 89-92.
West, R. (2020) John Erick Dowdle: Architect of Dread. Rue Morgue, 198, pp. 28-35.