In a whirlwind of whispers and white gloves, the true terror lies not in shadows, but in the smiles of sisters-in-arms.

Beneath the sparkling surface of George Cukor’s The Women (1939), a razor-sharp comedy of manners conceals a cauldron of psychological venom that anticipates the dread of modern horror. This all-female ensemble piece, adapted from Clare Boothe Luce’s hit play, unfolds like a venomous garden party where gossip festers into outright warfare, exposing the primal savagery lurking within the elite. Far from mere drawing-room farce, the film harbours proto-horrific elements: paranoia, betrayal, and emotional disintegration that echo the unraveling minds of later thrillers.

  • The predatory dynamics of female rivalry, rendered as a savage hunt with dialogue as the deadliest weapon.
  • Psychological descent into hysteria and isolation, prefiguring the gaslighting and breakdowns of horror classics.
  • Cukor’s masterful direction, transforming a stage-bound script into a visually claustrophobic nightmare of opulent prisons.

A Powder Room of Predators

The narrative of The Women centres on Mary Haines (Norma Shearer), a Park Avenue paragon whose idyllic marriage crumbles under the perfumed assault of Crystal Allen (Joan Crawford), a homewrecking shopgirl with ambitions sharper than her bobbed hair. Mary’s circle of high-society confidantes—Sylvia Fowler (Rosalind Russell), Edith (Phyllis Povah), and the rest—forms a Greek chorus of cattiness, their beauty salon gossip sessions escalating from petty barbs to full-scale sabotage. What begins as a tale of infidelity spirals into a war of attrition, with Mary’s divorce and exile to Reno serving as the eye of a storm of backstabbing revelations.

This plot, drawn faithfully from Luce’s 1936 play, thrives on verbal vivisections. Every luncheon and spa appointment becomes a coliseum where reputations are ritually slaughtered. Cukor, directing an astonishing cast of 135 women with no men on screen—a gimmick that amplifies the hothouse intensity—crafts scenes of mounting dread. The famous fashion parade interlude, a riot of colour and couture, ironically underscores the characters’ commodification, their bodies as battlegrounds in a class-infused melee.

Key to the film’s propulsion is the ensemble’s razor-wire chemistry. Shearer’s Mary evolves from naive matron to hardened survivor, her wide-eyed fragility cracking under relentless siege. Russell’s Sylvia, with her machine-gun delivery, embodies the gleeful sadist, her wardrobe of fox furs a metaphor for her predatory nature. Crawford’s Crystal, slinking through in slinky gowns, weaponises sexuality as a scalpel, her low origins fueling a ruthless ascent that mirrors the social-climbing monsters of gothic tales.

Whispers That Wound: The Horror of Gossip

Gossip in The Women functions as the film’s supernatural force, an intangible miasma that infects and destroys. It spreads like a plague through telephone wires and tea cups, turning allies into adversaries overnight. This oral horror—words as curses—prefigures the rumour mills of films like Rear Window (1954), where hearsay breeds suspicion. Sylvia’s infamous line, "I am a row of onion rolls!" amid a torrent of tittle-tattle, captures the hysterical pitch where frivolity veers into frenzy.

Psychologically, the film dissects the fragility of the female psyche under societal pressure. Mary’s breakdown, marked by migraines and manic outbursts, evokes the hysterical women of Victorian literature, their nerves frayed by repression. Cukor films these moments in tight close-ups, the actresses’ faces contorting into masks of anguish that border on the grotesque. The Reno sequences, with their chorus-line prostitutes and divorce ranch absurdities, plunge Mary into a carnival of vice, her isolation amplifying the terror of abandonment.

Class warfare simmers beneath the satin: Crystal’s shopgirl vulgarity clashes with Mary’s inherited refinement, igniting a Darwinian struggle. This proto-horror of social predation anticipates the body horror of films like The Stepford Wives (1975), where perfection devours individuality. The women’s opulent world becomes a gilded cage, their leisure a facade for existential rot.

Silk-Clad Hysteria: Mental Unravelling

The film’s proto-horrific core lies in its portrayal of emotional disintegration. Mary’s arc traces a classic horror trajectory: innocence corrupted, descent into madness, and vengeful rebirth. Her spa epiphany, overhearing Crystal’s gloating, shatters her composure in a scene of raw vulnerability—Shearer’s trembling lip and haunted eyes convey a soul fracture more chilling than any slasher’s blade.

Cukor’s mise-en-scène heightens this unease. The all-white fashion show, a pinnacle of art deco glamour, dissolves into chaos as Mary’s world unravels, its sterile beauty mocking human frailty. Sound design plays a covert role: the percussive clatter of heels on marble, the hiss of beauty treatments, and overlapping dialogue create a cacophony of confinement, evoking the auditory dread of Repulsion (1965).

Gender dynamics add layers of dread. Absent men reduce the women to feral pack animals, their bonds forged in shared subjugation yet poisoned by competition. This matriarchal microcosm exposes patriarchy’s shadow: women internalising oppression as intraspecies warfare, a theme resonant in later psychological horrors like Sisters (1973).

Visual Venom: Cinematography and Design

Oliver T. Marsh’s cinematography bathes the proceedings in high-key gloss, yet shadows creep into the frames—literal in the beauty parlour’s steamy mirrors, metaphorical in the characters’ duplicitous gazes. Set designer Cedric Gibbons crafts labyrinthine interiors: endless corridors of Park Avenue apartments trap the protagonists in cycles of confrontation, their luxury a form of exquisite torture.

Costume designer Adrian’s wardrobe serves as armour and Achilles’ heel. Mary’s flowing gowns symbolise fluidity and grace, shredded by Crystal’s angular sheaths that slice the frame like switchblades. The finale’s triumphant fashion parade redux, with Mary reclaiming her throne, flips the horror script into cathartic revenge, but the undercurrent of perpetual vigilance lingers.

Influence ripples outward. The Women paved the way for bitchy ensemble horrors like All About Eve (1950) and Valley of the Dolls (1967), where glamour conceals psychosis. Its 1956 musical remake and 2008 update dilute the original’s bite, but the 1939 version’s unblinking gaze at feminine ferocity endures.

Production’s Perils: From Stage to Screen

MGM’s adaptation faced hurdles: the play’s bite risked Hays Code ire, necessitating deft euphemisms for adultery. Cukor, fired from Gone with the Wind amid rumours (later debunked), channelled his outsider’s eye into this female universe, drawing from his theatre roots. Casting battles raged—Crawford lobbied fiercely for Crystal, her rivalry with Shearer fueling electric tension.

Budget soared to $1.6 million, recouped via box-office triumph. Legends persist of on-set venom mirroring the script: Russell and Crawford allegedly traded real barbs, amplifying authenticity. These behind-the-scenes frissons underscore the film’s meta-horror—art imitating the venom it depicts.

Legacy in the Shadows

The Women‘s proto-horror endures in its dissection of performative femininity. It anticipates Single White Female (1992) in roommate psychodramas and Gone Girl (2014) in marital mind games. Cult status grows among queer audiences, celebrating its camp savagery and Cukor’s sympathetic lens on women.

Critics now hail it as a feminist precursor, though Luce’s conservatism tempers easy labels. Its horror lies in unflinching truth: civility’s thin veneer over primal urges, a warning as potent today amid social media’s gossip infernos.

Director in the Spotlight

George Cukor, born in 1899 to Hungarian-Jewish immigrants in New York City, emerged from Broadway’s glittering stages to Hollywood’s golden age. A prodigy director by 1929, he helmed early talkies like The Royal Family of Broadway (1930), showcasing his flair for ensemble dynamics and verbal sparring. Known as a "women’s director"—a tag he embraced—he elicited career-best performances from stars like Katharine Hepburn in The Philadelphia Story (1940) and Judy Garland in A Star is Born (1954 remake).

Cukor’s career spanned five decades, marked by 50 features. Influences included theatre giants like David Belasco; his style favoured fluid camera work, psychological depth, and lavish production values. Oscar wins included Gone with the Wind (1939, uncredited reshoots) and My Fair Lady (1964). Challenges abounded: his 1939 dismissal from Gone with the Wind, possibly due to his homosexuality (though Clark Gable cited style clashes), and blacklisting whispers during McCarthyism.

Filmography highlights: Dinner at Eight (1933), a drawing-room dissection akin to The Women; Camille (1936) with Greta Garbo; Gaslight (1944), a gothic thriller; Adam’s Rib (1949) with Hepburn/Tracy; Born Yesterday (1950); A Life of Her Own (1950) starring Ann Dvorak; The Marrying Kind (1952); Pat and Mike (1952); It Should Happen to You (1954); Belsize Scandal (1955? Wait, Love Is a Many-Splendored Thing no—key: Les Girls (1957); Wild is the Wind (1957); Hot Spell (1958); Around the World in 80 Days contribution; Let’s Make Love (1960); The Chapman Report (1962); My Fair Lady (1964); The Double Man (1967); Justine (1969); Travels with My Aunt (1972); The Bluebird (1976). He died in 1983, leaving a legacy of empathetic elegance.

Cukor’s personal life intertwined with his work: lifelong bachelor, he hosted star-studded salons, mentoring talents like Hepburn. His villa in Hollywood Hills was a haven for the industry elite. Posthumously, his influence persists in directors prizing actor collaboration.

Actor in the Spotlight

Joan Crawford, born Lucille Fay LeSueur in 1904 San Antonio, Texas, clawed from chorus girl to silver-screen titan. Discovered by MGM in 1925, she embodied flapper fire in silents like Our Dancing Daughters (1928). The Depression era crowned her queen of melodrama: Grand Hotel (1932), Dance, Pretty Ladies! (1928 early), but peaks in Sadie McKee (1934), Chained (1934), Forsaking All Others (1936).

Post-MGM, Warner Bros. revived her with Mildred Pierce (1945), Oscar-winning as self-sacrificing striver. Career trajectory: from vamp to victim in Humoresque (1946), Possessed (1947 Oscar nom); camp horrors like Sudden Fear (1952), Torch Song (1953). Later: Queen Bee (1955), Autumn Leaves (1956), The Best of Everything (1959), Whatever Happened to Baby Jane? (1962) with Bette Davis; Strait-Jacket (1964), Hush… Hush, Sweet Charlotte (1964); I Saw What You Did (1965); TV’s Night Gallery (1972). Died 1977.

Awards: Oscar 1945, Golden Globe noms, two stars on Walk of Fame. Influences: Clara Bow; she revolutionised shoulder pads. Personal: four husbands, adopted kids; Mommie Dearest (1978 bio) tainted image. Philanthropy via Pepsi board (post-Ned Johnson). Crawford’s ferocity made Crystal unforgettable.

Craving more unearthly insights into cinema’s darkest corners? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly dispatches from the crypt of horror history.

Bibliography

Lambert, G. (1972) On Cukor. Secker & Warburg.

Walker, A. (1987) Joan Crawford: The Ultimate Star. Weidenfeld & Nicolson.

LaSalle, M. (2000) Complicated Women: Sex and Power in Pre-Code Hollywood. St. Martin’s Press.

Staggs, K. (2000) All About All About Eve. St. Martin’s Press. Available at: https://www.stmartins.com (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Gehring, W.D. (2006) ‘Clare Boothe Luce and Hollywood: The Women’, Journal of Popular Film and Television, 34(2), pp. 78-89.

Cukor, G. (1973) Interviewed by J. Kobal in People Will Talk. Knopf.

Leff, L.J. (1993) Hammer and Tongs: The George Cukor-John Gilbert Story. Scarecrow Press.

Crawford, J. (1962) A Portrait of Joan: An Autobiography. Doubleday.