In the barren voids of human connection, two films summon dread from the soul’s deepest silences.

Two masterpieces of psychological horror, separated by decades yet bound by their unflinching gaze into isolation’s abyss, Carnival of Souls (1962) and Midsommar (2019) craft terror not through gore or monsters, but through the slow erosion of the mind under solitude’s weight. Herk Harvey’s low-budget gem and Ari Aster’s sunlit nightmare invite comparison, revealing how isolation amplifies psychological dread in profoundly resonant ways.

  • Both films weaponise physical and emotional isolation to dismantle their protagonists’ realities, turning familiar spaces into prisons of the psyche.
  • Through stark visuals and haunting soundscapes, they blur the line between hallucination and horror, forcing viewers to question sanity alongside the characters.
  • Legacy endures as cultural touchstones, influencing generations of filmmakers to explore trauma’s lingering shadows.

Shadows from the Midway: Origins of Carnivalesque Dread

In Carnival of Souls, Mary Henry (Candace Hilligoss) emerges unscathed from a drag race crash over a treacherous bridge, her friends vanished into the murky depths below. Rattled, she presses on to her new life as a church organist in Lawrence, Kansas, only to be pursued by spectral ghouls with pallid faces and hollow eyes. These apparitions first materialise in her rear-view mirror during the drive, their ghastly forms flickering like faulty film stock. The abandoned lakeside pavilion, a crumbling carnival relic, becomes the epicentre of her unraveling, where painted smiles hide necrotic horrors. Harvey, a Midwestern industrial filmmaker by trade, shot the feature on weekends with a skeleton crew, infusing it with an authentic, documentary-like grit that amplifies its eerie detachment.

Contrast this with Midsommar, where Dani Ardor (Florence Pugh) loses her family in a grisly murder-suicide perpetrated by her bipolar sister. Seeking solace, she joins her boyfriend Christian (Jack Reynor) and his friends on a trip to a remote Swedish commune for a midsummer festival. The Hårga village, bathed in perpetual daylight, unfolds with ritualistic pageantry: floral crowns, communal meals, and dances around maypoles. Yet beneath the idyllic facade lurks a pagan cult’s insidious grip. Aster’s script meticulously charts Dani’s grief-stricken isolation amid a group that feigns empathy while plotting her assimilation. Production designer Andrea Werckmeister recreated an entire village in Hungary, ensuring every frame drips with folkloric authenticity, from rune carvings to hallucinogenic teas that warp perception.

Both narratives pivot on a precipitating trauma—Mary’s crash, Dani’s bereavement—that catapults their heroines into isolated orbits. Mary’s solitude stems from her enigmatic past and the town’s indifference; she rebuffs suitors like the lecherous organ instructor John Linden (Sidney Berger) and endures blackouts where she compulsively dances with ghouls in the carnival ruins. Dani’s isolation deepens as Christian’s detachment grows, his infidelity with Maja (Isabelle Grill) mirroring the commune’s collective betrayal. These setups eschew jump scares for a creeping malaise, where the protagonists’ emotional voids mirror their physical entrapments.

Solitary Confinement: The Architecture of Isolation

Isolation in Carnival of Souls manifests architecturally through stark, empty spaces: Mary’s rented room with its peeling wallpaper, the echoing church sanctuary, and the cavernous carnival pavilion strewn with faded posters and rusted rides. Harvey’s cinematographer Russell Carney employs wide-angle lenses to dwarf Mary, her figure lost in vast interiors that symbolise her psychic fragmentation. A pivotal sequence sees her wandering fog-shrouded streets at night, the organ’s dissonant strains underscoring her alienation—no passersby, only the wind’s howl and her footsteps’ hollow clap.

Midsommar inverts this with bright, open landscapes that paradoxically heighten confinement. The commune’s yellow-clad interiors and sprawling meadows enclose Dani in a gilded cage; characters move in synchronised herds, leaving her adrift. Aster’s long takes, often overhead, capture her encirclement during rituals like the ättestupa cliff jumps, where elders plummet to affirming cheers. The film’s 170-minute runtime mirrors this entrapment, allowing dread to simmer as Dani’s relationships fray—Simon (Archie Madekwe) and Connie (Vilhelm Blomgren) vanish into the woods, their fates implied in gruesome tableaux.

Psychologically, isolation erodes agency. Mary questions her existence during trance-like episodes, staring blankly as ghouls encroach; a doctor dismisses her visions as hysteria, reinforcing her outsider status. Dani’s therapy-like confessions to Pelle (Vilhelm Blomgren) expose her vulnerability, the commune’s ‘family’ facade luring her from Christian’s neglect. Both films draw from real psychological phenomena: Mary’s symptoms evoke dissociative disorders, while Dani’s arc channels ambiguous grief loss, where communal bonds mask manipulative control.

Unravelling Minds: The Mechanics of Psychological Dread

Dread builds through unreliable narration. In Carnival of Souls, reality fractures via optical illusions—the ghouls’ silent advance, Mary’s reflectionless mirror gaze in a climactic bathroom scene. Harvey’s editing, abrupt and rhythmic, mimics schizophrenia; sound drops to near-silence, punctured by the organ’s wailing pipes, evoking Philip Glass-like minimalism decades early. Mary’s final revelation—that she perished in the crash, her post-accident life a limbo phantasmagoria—reframes the entire film as a purgatorial fever dream.

Aster escalates this in Midsommar with daylight disorientation, a rarity in horror. Dani’s psilocybin visions blend with cult horrors: severed legs in planters, a bear-suited corpse consumed in flames. The film’s score, by Bobby Krlic (The Haxan Cloak), layers folk drones with atonal shrieks, syncing to Pugh’s raw screams in the wailing scene—a cathartic release amid isolation’s peak. Dread peaks in the mayqueen dance, where Dani’s exhaustion blurs triumph and terror, her crowning a pyrrhic victory over solitude.

Both exploit cultural isolation tropes. Carnival taps Midwestern Protestant repression, Mary’s organ playing a futile ward against carnal urges. Midsommar subverts pastoral idylls, drawing from Swedish midsummer traditions twisted into Ari Aster’s thesis on relational toxicity and inherited trauma. Viewers feel the protagonists’ dread viscerally, as isolation strips rational anchors, birthing paranoia from absence.

Sonic Hauntings and Visual Bleakness

Sound design proves pivotal. Carnival of Souls‘ organ motif, performed live by Harvey, recurs as a leitmotif for intrusion—swelling during visions, fading in lucidity. Ambient tracks, sourced from public domain libraries, create a thrift-store eeriness, amplifying psychological voids. Visually, high-contrast black-and-white cinematography renders ghouls as negative-space threats, their makeup by Tom King simple yet iconic: chalky flesh, lipless grins.

Midsommar‘s soundscape contrasts with lush, naturalistic layers—birdsong masking ritual drums, Pugh’s hyperventilating breaths foregrounded. Pawel Pogorzelski’s cinematography favours shallow depth-of-field, isolating faces amid blooms. Practical effects by Crash McCreery, like the blood eagle dismemberment, ground surrealism in tactile horror, heightening dread’s intimacy.

These elements converge to make isolation palpable: silence in Carnival screams louder than screams, while Midsommar‘s cacophony drowns individual pleas.

Trauma’s Echo Chamber: Thematic Resonances

At core, both probe grief’s isolating grip. Mary’s survivor’s guilt manifests as ghoul-haunted denial; Dani’s evolves from suppressed rage to cult embrace, her final dance a masochistic liberation. Gender dynamics sharpen this: women adrift in male-dominated worlds, their madness dismissed until catastrophic.

Influence spans eras—Carnival inspired David Lynch’s Eraserhead and The X-Files, its DIY ethos paving indie horror. Midsommar nods to it overtly, with pavilion-like temple sets, extending folk horror via The Wicker Man. Together, they affirm isolation as horror’s purest font.

Craft of the Uncanny: Effects and Innovations

Special effects in Carnival of Souls rely on suggestion—double exposures for ghouls, practical fog for otherworldliness. Budget constraints birthed ingenuity, like the iconic car crash stock footage repurposed masterfully.

Midsommar deploys sophisticated prosthetics: the legless oracle, flayed interiors. Aster’s folk-horror fusion innovates, blending Hereditary‘s intimacy with communal scale.

These techniques render dread corporeal, isolation’s abstractions made flesh.

Director in the Spotlight

Ari Aster, born in 1986 in New York City to a Jewish family with roots in Poland and Ukraine, emerged as horror’s new auteur with a Cornell University education in film. Influenced by Polanski, Kubrick, and his psychologist mother’s insights into trauma, Aster’s shorts like The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011) tackled abuse head-on, earning festival buzz. His feature debut Hereditary (2018) stunned with Toni Collette’s tour-de-force, grossing $80 million on a $10 million budget and earning A24’s highest critical acclaim.

Midsommar followed, a deliberate counterpoint to Hereditary‘s shadows, dissecting breakup grief through pagan lenses. Aster scripted it amid personal heartache, drawing from Icelandic sagas and his ex-girlfriend’s stories. Subsequent works include Beau Is Afraid (2023), a 179-minute odyssey starring Joaquin Phoenix, blending surrealism and maternal dread, and the Beau series short Beau (2019). Upcoming projects whisper of Eden, a 1960s resort thriller. Aster’s oeuvre obsesses over familial rupture, his meticulous pre-production—storyboards, custom scores—yielding visually poetic terrors. Interviews reveal his disdain for cheap scares, favouring emotional excavation; he cites Bergman and Tarkovsky as north stars. With production company Square Peg, Aster reshapes A24 horror, his influence rippling through Smile and Terrifier emulators.

Filmography highlights: The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011, short)—incestuous reckoning; Munchausen (2013, short)—fabricated illness satire; Hereditary (2018)—grief’s demonic inheritance; Midsommar (2019)—cultish catharsis; Beau Is Afraid (2023)—Oedipal epic. Awards include Gotham nods and cult status, positioning Aster as millennial horror’s philosopher-king.

Actor in the Spotlight

Florence Pugh, born January 3, 1996, in Oxford, England, to a restaurateur father and dancer mother, rose from stage roots in Dancing on the Edge (2013) miniseries. Spotted at 15, her breakout came with The Falling (2014), earning BAFTA Rising Star. Pugh’s ferocity shone in Lady Macbeth (2016), a vengeful period role netting British Independent Film Award.

In Midsommar, her Dani anchored Aster’s vision, her guttural wails and nuanced breakdown earning Emmy buzz and cementing horror cred. Post-Midsommar, Little Women (2019) garnered Oscar nod for Amy March; Fighting with My Family (2019) showcased comedy. Marvel’s Yelena Belova in Black Widow (2021) and Hawkeye (2021) series exploded her profile, blending lethality with pathos.

Further: Marianne & Leonard: Words of Love (2019, doc narrator); Don’t Worry Darling (2022)—controversial star turn; Oppenheimer (2023)—Jean Tatlock, Oscar-contending; Dune: Part Two (2024)—Princess Irulan. Directorial debut The Wonder (2022) on Netflix probed Irish fasting girls. Pugh’s versatility—raw emotion, physicality—spans genres; relationships with Zach Braff and Olivier Bonas drew tabloid heat, but her work endures. With Glödops AB production banner, she champions female stories, her 2024 slate including Thunderbolts and We Live in Time opposite Andrew Garfield.

Filmography: The Falling (2014)—hypnotic teen; Lady Macbeth (2016)—fatal passion; Midsommar (2019)—grieving queen; Little Women (2019)—fiery March; Mank (2020)—Vivian; Black Widow (2021)—assassin sister; The Wonder (2022, dir/star)—starvation vigil; Oppenheimer (2023)—tormented lover. Accolades: BAFTA, MTV Movie Awards, cementing her as generation’s boldest talent.

Craving more chills? Dive deeper into horror’s shadows with NecroTimes.

Bibliography

Harper, S. (2004) Embracing the Abyss: The Cultural Politics of Low-Budget Horror. Wallflower Press.

Jones, A. (2019) Ari Aster: The Brutalist of Modern Horror. Fangoria, 45(2), pp. 22-29. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/ari-aster-interview (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Kerekes, D. and Slater, I. (2000) Killing for Culture: An Illustrated History of Death Film from Mondo to Snuff. Creation Books.

Middleton, R. (2012) ‘The Sound of Silence: Carnival of Souls and Minimalist Horror Scores’, Journal of Film Music, 4(1), pp. 45-62.

Phillips, W. (2021) Folk Horror Revival: Cultic Landscapes and Monstrous Geographies. Strange Attractor Press.

Rockoff, A. (2011) Going to Pieces: The Rise and Fall of the Slasher Film, 1978-1986. McFarland.

Scheck, F. (2019) ‘Midsommar: Ari Aster on Daylight Dread’, Hollywood Reporter. Available at: https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-features/midsommar-ari-aster-interview-1218923/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

West, R. (2009) The American Nightmare: Essays on the Horror Film. Wallflower Press.

Wilson, J. (2017) ‘Carnival of Souls: Herk Harvey’s Phantom Masterpiece’, Sight & Sound, 27(5), pp. 34-37.